Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 1, Cited by 3]

Karnataka High Court

B S Girish vs The Managing Director B M T C on 28 October, 2009

Author: N.K.Patil

Bench: N.K.Patil

EN ':"1----11-<3 I---IiGI§ COURT cw KAR§\'A'I'AKA AT   %
£O)A'E'E1T) 'I'I~~£IS '11--1:4'-: 28'?" ram' 01--* oc'1"c>z;3I§RV:;;at59'" =  O
PRESIf:NT'i'    
"1"HI£ HON'-B1,E Mm}  . I}§..1§A9I*1--1.'  Of-L  ; 7

Tr-~19: 1«v10m3L£s: Mr2.JLJs*1'1'£:§:~~§:.N.Ka:sr-i;zavA:§m5éAYANA 1'

M.F.g\.N0.757§'»,/_20_Q6 (ix/1v1.O_ 
BE3'1'\-VIEEN: V V O

.B.S.GERIS1---I s/0 S£ZI3.i'i1°x~§".¥?)'\   ' ''
AGEEEZ)      
R/AT .NO.,20_23;*'1"I._}*LO()I'Zi. 7W. z\;m1w. 
11)~BLOCI:{, 11»_'s'mG.1::. I%2_g?a..JAJ__EN:\(3/':12L
i:3ANGAI,O_Ri£. ;j_ '   2  API'F£I.LAI\ET
{By 33121,9.OS'.'SRx.1'§1a-1OAR.{_}m_v.. ) j

ANI): '

'1f:~-_i(Ei MANAG :)1REC'roR.
B.:v:T:;: ,1) wow, s'1T'rTm_1\z*rr~1INAGAR

O *.£<:.':é_RQA{);~--..,
 _r3zaNc>4§Lr)%I2:_1~f«:'* 5 27. . . . RESPOND BENT

O A {E3}, E31-{.I§}'§'}_.I'5I.M(}'§'I(}§. Am-'.)

~~ O"'{HIS MFA IE5 FI§.EI[) U/SK I 73(1) OF I\/IX?' ACT AGAINST

=  .. TI:-{}:T[Li'U'{)GE\/EE)I\§'1.' $1 AWA.RI) I.)/\'I'F:="ZD 13/ 2/12008 PASSED IN'
 V MVC 3236/O5 ON THE FELE OF THE VI ADDL. SCJ'
 '.?vf--EI.ME3EER, E\e'E.f\C'E', ME'F'ROPOIn,I'I'A.I\E ARISA. £3/r\NGA.1,0Rfi,

g (SCC}"I'~2}. PAR"I'I.Y AI,LO\2'v'ING TI-'-{Iii CILAIM PETITION 1*'OR

O COMPENSf~\'I'ION 82 SEEKING E:'§NHANCE§\/'IFfNT OF

COMPEZNSATIOE\§.

  
  
 

THIS M.F.A. CO INC} ON FOR HEARING THIS DAY.
N.I'{.}-"ATI.l.. J., I.:)I%ZI.,I'V QICI) 'I'I'"II§Z I'([)I...i,C_)WEN(}:



'.J 1

  

E't':?£'t.'"1'{)1l.'c1b1(.' 2.11%} (',()}i1(-'11{'i(:C1 that. {he .~s:m1c is pug :'e.aji'=2-}1"E(>1'

('me ('.011SiC1tii'£.i{',i(.)]'i of 11w 1'1T1z':11&?1"ie;t1 (.)1'i)' --1'L?LfG!f'C.}- : :'.--1-1'aL'.§

t1']€i1'(>i"L1);"('. it ('1<)es; rm! (fail for i;1:€1t:*1'1?:1'('1ICC  {:§)11'1f1.. V'

 We }"az:wc'-é 1161*}-11"CIiV»'i"'E")'_(? }c2ii'.r_1(é.t.1 (r()1,.1':'1-sa.'i:1: £31}.)}:9t?&.i}'i}'"i}-,',

on b01'.]'1 sides.

7. After c21rcf1.1'iV§:'<31is.iéic3'}'21t_iinj».VQ'i'--1119 s1.:bmiSsi(";11s

of 'f,I"l(:' }t".I'}]"1'}'ii"C1 (.?r.:)1..1}'iLse} Q19: bQ'!*.~1:1'_'+g;Vi(l<§&ss anti 2:1'i'£('é;* i:1'1<.)I'o11_s_gh
ca .r21.}11e1£.iic':)i) ,('3--f't1i"i:é:_ ("Jr-i.giV1'ié-1}.__"1j(?£E:):'ri$ 2':v'(1i}aI';)1c on file. 1111:'.

()1'11yV..'1:)0i 1*: i V 1T.151;i1'ii' -»:e;1Li'i$CV " --fg)i." ~ £51.11" ('O11si(}C}'2:1E.i()}'1 is.

 VA .H!'I'1<2>Ii'iAé_21"  ("OIIl{I)£.'!1S(1If()!'I =:.u1>cu'ci.c?d }")_;.,I
z!i'1.(-,> Tf'1'.b._lV.IVI"IClt' i;..sja.a.s'i arld r'c..>a.«;<m.a}J(<3?
  I101: in c:i.i$p1.I.1c: t:I'"1z1iT on ac(~01.mi' the

';{a(':{'?i<.i('::'ii:Q; t'1'ac=' 211:)p(>1i;11'n .<-;1.1st.z.1§m:>(i thc: 2-1{"(.)r€*.$z1i(_'i 1'n_}1s;'ics

21I'1é1_\%;%21s iI'!~}')E'1E.I'('.'.E.'i'£i for 10 cialys. "l'hc;=. '1"rib1.1m11 c)1,1g2jE1i to

 ';2'1}{t:1.'1 film <'<)1"£sidC1'211ion. E.1'1€t ].)2.'u'.11. 2"11id S1t'ffea'i:'1g..e3

1.

11"1d0rg"()1"1<? by the e11.)pc=>1I21n1 <:'1:1c> En [lac i1":j1.11*i<>s st:-S»'i;;1i1'atjrL1 13_\,-" him 2.u"1.(:i also {J10 d1.tr211.i<)1'1 0'!' '.'1'36r i1'€'.2'5=1.11':1c*}.']f". 'i'a1.}«;i1'1;._{ irgm) L_*<.):'1.~_;i(1v1*;1iion T.I'1.t':.'.'.§(..' ;2=1$pc("£.s. \w (3 c1£?@n1 it fit to z-m»'211'ci Rs.25.0()O/-- 10\.va1'c1.€s pélijfl and s1.:iTe..1'i:1,s::s 21:3 a.g;§a1i11st Rs:s.15.()OO/ --« 2T1\var(%'v(E1 by the "]"ri}.')t 1 11211 .

9. F'1.1r1.hc-tr 1.110 'E'1'i':.3u1'1221.i"he"-25;' c::.j;1111ii'%."{§.c{c'1x<?3_':i7()i*v..i:1'5 . a1w21rcii1'1g Rs.2,000/+ 1.0wa1"c1s"«c(m\5eyam:e.»_1:.(>t;.g*1231ii:1g food zmd att.endam. (ii1z1rge.sj'."'~..fI'akir1g '1:1i.(")_. (.'.'V("";'v1'1V.'$'V'§iVC'§"C'I'.'cH.i()VEV1 Hits.' 1'":2'1.i,1.1r(> of i.:1'j1..11fic'-:e.s:_ 2;11'1c1A"{f'1r>_:(.3s1i*afi011 Of":r€fa1n1c:'1!:, we df:?('.fH it. fit to award -'RS.5v.'OO0:ff 'f._U\2§'£i_I'C1S <'t()11\-'c:y2i;1I1c.re, :1(')1.1 ris.:a11ijigfj,f"(.)()'iE e:1.:"1'd_' 21':',E"as'*1'1c!z.».1m: (..r}'121rgcts 2:15-1 21;gai1'1s1. Rs; . 2. (;'O(Ii / -- 2'1'.,:\.;'é;' gt/.('.i'c-'.(Vi' 'E 'i'}(' T1"i1i)1.u 12-11. _ 1'f)V. F11h1"f.hC.1_"__.';]'1&1Vi}'1§_{ regard {.0 n21l.1,:re 0!" i.1'1_}'1.,1:'ie.e;. . '1".}'»1.(;r '£f_) (f)<.ft0r 'has 213888-S€('i lhc disability of their 221p;)t:21iaI'11 .' Aaif 2'1%' 'ii.(;) the wh(')l.e body wh.Ec}.1 p@r'mar1€;>1:1l in .:'1al"1,1re and {he appellzimi has !.0 (¥I"ld1..H"C. this (.iisabEii{.y dLzri:'1gg _1 1""1<_.* rest. 01' his life. 2«m.d it. ("(')n'1(.*s in lhe \v2.1}«-' of c1isc:}'k21.;';gi1'1g his ci221},h1,0Ac12;1y xx--'()1"1<;. Kc?c=r13i1'1g in Vf(':'\V t"hi$ we cEvc.m it". fit E0 awa.1'c,i £1Sp(T(?l of 1.1%.' n1211.t.c..

. "l'(..)wz1rd.s pziin mlctl :.s1.:.i:'f@1'i1'1g;§s~s Rs. . 'i'<)\v221.r('1s 1.11c=.'di<ée..aI (.'xpc1'1.so>s = 13., (.3. '"l'(.)w;1rds ('.011v('yz'111("'@. £I(.)i11'iSl'1§1"Ig E'0(..)('§ 8: 2mm1(:12-1111 ("11e.i1"gc-as "B33.C(.)'Q;()V(.1 wax.

(3<1<>~()<>. ~

4. '1'(')warcE.e.s 1(:)sss; 01'c.2u'111'ng_.§ (T1111'i'i1g A' ' » _ _ 1:.i1i('1 L11") porioczl I"{.g;;.. »u£}'>.Q.()()(;)--()()

5. 'i'<)wa11'cIs fm1.11'c mcdicati'r::§{j.)€:11sés._ 25V[O'O3()-()0 V

6. '1'c')w::1rds5 c1'i$a}:Ji1ii;\I and L' u 'I loss of 21n1(%:"1it'i€?f-5' * RS."-A 2"(),()OOvOO :*fhfiai,*J%"a RsJ-08LxK»o0 'i'hc'\ 1*-_:~,s;'.)(')1'}clétit' * 'C«.(i)"£T{3{')15t:11.jd'1'1 di1'c(éted 1.0 dc1.)<')siE" "é"."1"r'.':' 5~--<i;"..1.'j1'.¥1£11.1c_g%iE, c~.'.01:::'1pc.11.s->2-1Hon with i111.(r1'<=..si E1}1c?1"vt;"<.3'1'1'.--.xi-'itI1ifif:.;2a~ p'<:31fi'<..>c1 r5£"'f<~'3111f wmks fmrn the (ism-2 of re C' e i"p1" '<:)_f (..?<..);;)3,v~ ,c")"i7. 1'i"}.(f tign1m 11.. (")1'i'..cic*'i)Q9§'{: or S--i:.("1'1 s1..m1 19}-' 1.110 C<)1'}':)01"z=11ion. H1:-3 ._.,;~;La;.1-19,...» slrlali 133'..v~--.-~:*C]c-%e;1seci. in f£;i\.='()L11' of t.1'1o 2.1ppel1'c11'1'i', i_1§"1mi('7«(i.iz;v1't.(".1y} is c1i1'(.=<r1c(i E0 CI 1"zi1\v 1.1.19, e1we=11'd a(*(..'(..)1'£iingly. Sd/-

JUDGE Sd/--

FUDGE R.'3'i"'