Karnataka High Court
The State Of Karnataka vs Fisheries Welfare Co-Operative ... on 12 April, 2012
Equivalent citations: AIR 2012 KARNATAKA 132, 2012 (3) AIR KAR R 485, (2012) 2 KCCR 1341, 2012 (4) KLT SN 33 (KAR)
Bench: Chief Justice, S.Abdul Nazeer, A.S.Bopanna
V' =..§?§1,:r%: £%a:::: E; $6 3 U41 The Siaéie sf Karriaiaka Rép. '$5; is $€Cf€§afy, Qeparimerzt ef Fisheféegg i\+E.S.B:,:§iding, Bangaiars.
N
3. Shiizaéurga Zfila Panfiizajgatiz, Chétfadufga Eistziétg Chitraéurga, I Qep. by ifs Chief EX€C:},€ii7€ Qff§<::§:". «_
4. The Assistant Dirsctor sf Fisheries} {Grade«2} J.,€Z¢Re Extensiaag' ' . _ cm'::adm-ga. }?;ESP§)NDEN?S {By Sri BeKsfvia:'1j12n&th €31" v'£€~'~~~3_§ ' Sri K$§«i.Nat;3§a3} Add: A:::3.T%4 L . _ anfi; Sri Bfifeerappa? ASA fat' R---f2 4-}";~ 1 ., These z'%p§'&%:E..3;%¢ajzé 3. 4 0f the Karnaiaka High Céuri figcé: ta" sf::"a'Lsi;ci'e"ihé§ arder pas$eé fir: the Writ Fetitisfi Ne,2.@93_$;'~%2a ggiszgaggg %-gazed Q1 .G§.2{}1G. '?hé5se heami and; :"::*s€rved fer' §2:s:*:e::1':«::e:z1€:';?:_ 'af j::dg:¢;$1éf._,»LV":h§3 fig}; the Qhief Jazgtica fiefiéveéefi Ehe :"@1i<:.§r»7i:ag : ' "
Z ..... ..«J:g§§§;,fgg\§T :§f§?§}S"w§i€«Eifffi'€9f§§;€"--1./Efifldfii' Séaiéan T? sf 'size Eiarnaiiaka High 5;$ %::§€:: :*e§€§¥€§ in i§'1§S€ C§r€i£H1S§aIEC€S. 1% __E:3a:::»§§ Siiagiéi. ézgége faiiszasiagi SE5; K§"§S§:I':& §i§§':§f§fi3.§£ Ce- ".{§§.m"2%:;::§ §'4::2§:%&§j,: iimiigé ~i?$~ giais sf %{&m&ia}:3::, :%$:p:'$s§:3'%:££% Sesratazyg Eiaggarimegzi sf Afiimaé §§u3%&:{:d:*§ a:3&
5 ELK 2399 Eifizfi 189} Erzagi an :::n_@9,2:;>i:£: issuaa 3 . M Jim mgzzéammg is Ehs effsct that fishing righis £1": ihs Siaie 33335:: $33 §}' tenéerfgsuhéic aizgtéezz with :'a§$:*&::€€ :9 {E25 {"'x§:.fé:--33;z:;er::
Q:'§€iff §8f£E:d 2é,€}2.2C3§é agé EEG? bf; grivaie ::§g::;t§5;':i§%j;2..:§__;' §@'.'.:i:
Egfipgai §'€0é3829g'2GEf} greferred by {he State a;§v§:3.;S admiétteé an a2.::2,2@:s. Er: éhe -%;ak;~::.%:%j;a;;;;;;';§,a2 * '§\E0¢2,'2=@i1 Cams :9 ae féieé E33: _shr§"zsiaha:m%g%%%'% Balakedarara Sanghs, {E} aise uthé' gas? sf '$13 Eearaed Sizigée Juége Qag afiazxfeé :0 prosecute 'aha Agggei ée$,g:j.:i€ixé_ in 316 zxfrii proseedéngsg zgfzj 2é,@7.2§: 2, :he Divésiafi Bezzshi $16 <:<>r:;:en';:§o:1 raised by Eearnsd <:01§s::vjs€__E'.A fithat iha Karnataka Enéasé §'i3he:*i€3 {€ic:2;'§As;e{:%v:a."v{i<:é':§AV? arid Reguigiéané fie: 39%} ihsgsinaftgéf' 'feffirriéfi' 'fine Fisherias ;?'is?:'§ wéuié be yeéavani afié :h%é:::fe3§'os'f;<~';y..<,sz;§g:'::t 'ac; have hséria; csi':sz:a$é;ci€:"%d1 by {is fiévéaéan B&3:cI%fa~.$§%§f;i'ci9:' ' Vf%*32?«.;G§;"T§;;.Vd'5%;;~<:£fi§d SEE Eiaéghzia figherzzzagzg Sath '7If§,§§§a§3 :$§é;::€""§§s§:§§ hsaxé; iageéhfir. Basra ihs refemiizg Qévéaion .1 fBj e::§%::T A§.§' ;Zi'.Té,.5;{i§ aiésca bear: argafié bf; {he Eéafiisé; {:Qili§:S€§ fez}: {he "§1::.§.'2;g§%;-éEai,::€;3 Eéaaéi: 333$ Karmaiakg "§'?:a::&:§§.r$::€jg' £31 ;?uf§E§§ .TfLv-..?::§?c;: %em€:1*: flea E??? {"i':"sI::3§a:e:s::,:§f fie? far 'm'€is§':"} £§i'C{i§§§f}3i§' geuéd EEQE Egava any émpaci gr: gzazéts made $3; {is Siais Ggvernmeni Whig}; ::e¥art%1$};es$} s§wz.:;E§; 3;::s'a/2'3: €V€:":§! ::'a.r:$§§.:€r2;€::; fies: @2213; ':h& guestiams ih3.:' .'5§_£s;.évv.<§Gr CQE}-Si{l{€:"8f{E:Q}'} sf 'aha E?' :13} Bench afe: :1; Whether Srig Kgishnaf, §fisi;ie;?2::a::= %perative Saciety Limited 'E'%'1s 'i:é:aV9:e. Karnataka, ssrfectiy etgifgiciateéi 'flag: 131w"? ii} Whsiier the ' A__'Kar::z.;;taji<iaVf ~ ..T_'fr a:2spar5:1€_'32 in Pijalrirgz ;P?a$ureme%:§: E.~g9'§ j'V~g_§_raerns ths grants voéfVi'£shi§;§V':§g§;:is.§::'%§é5 *'ay:~:§:e Siatés? 25 ThQVTv:é'§3%§?ai*;:__p:1<:;§?§:;i{>3?:g--...Qf .5133 Trazasparsficjg Act are:
E'€pI'¥3Ch1C€d ii:_:;I° fa1cé.ii€y jf:3fe";:*é:§:i<:é; ' "5§"L..}P%::;ci:re:I;e}21§tI'L' gther than '£3: Tenéeg Pre;h1iE.-sited Sn. and f§'SE'}': the §a:€ af ;c§':3;:.:né'§:$é;e3e::{ sf ihis Act, as Pzscuraznezzt Enfiéijg _ 1G*:§é*Gj;':ié§ 'gegds GE' Szsrviees sxaépé: £3}? éiiizéfzéng 'f€:§;:;ie:a*$§ féfiizf :%:1':,2;a§E§;'i '£ ~«.:'§j5';-:r_"-.saé{: §3.§=;_é:¥::n S péaseg am embarge an {3} awry ?_.4"p§i2ci;:&':§:§%§%:': §§;_é',;Z*ifg; {E} {mm prgsuréfigfi {6} gsgés 3? S€ra::":::8:33 {£4 'V .9 3 i:€i'i--33@_};:§T€::¥§ii::g Eendazs €53? s:;.pp§§¢: gig éfiféaafig £23. aéazggs {£2 {E jLL«-..SJ€:":é;£o:*: 2 £3? ting TE"3.§ES:38;?€§"i§Q}" flcifi §'£'¥Z}£7L3.E'€§2"3{'3}'Ei eniéigf 31363228 gang' §f?::G'az€§*z1::;1§::: Eisgarizzifina & Siaie {§£:2v€r:3:"::€::':
é ijadeftaéiing, Lesa} f%.:,:'§z:§riE§r er Bgaréfi 309%; 3:?" {§G:%g';Qé:"a:%@:: esiabiisheé '$5; 9:' ands? ax}? 23?; ami awnsé :3? c:;4:'£%.:"{>i§T!€'::§f iZ':§:r@:*:r:::n€§::§ aged 53:3: athsr Ts<3§:§;.:«::s:*..4au%:E1ari%};:. £:ié;:f:g:d7..0fj centmlieé by the Ggvsfnmsrzt and 5.3 definsé in Sesrfliégn 2 §':"~e:3i<::_"'?;.;§V«':'--"*,--::rV§'*V:"«'5:':r'.1:':.j§ 'Sr éprecuremsrat' meazzg ii.) 3-igzfchase' 'g'::";.;0:_ds, {i:§;j~ :}'§:;»tair1ing GE ssrviaes er {iii} u::der:a§<:§%ég.T_"0§' "§¥G§§{S by ihs praaurement ':"zi%:§£3E;€%s'L "§h€ file "§'rar1$par€:*1£y sic: in Ssctiéen 'gmachinerjgg IEi$iGE"
vehicles} é'§_9ii'CVi%$ sf Statignaijg texiiies raw :*naieri$fi.<;,: iT}SiI'11II3.€T'EES, Chemigals faxed grains? Gigi. _{>_f{Eseé'd§"'. @ f 9816:" cammsdiiy rsquirsci far 13;;~:§A §:': dV;V§S'tfVéb1:::i0:: by :52. gmguremani €:'1$:§':y 32:':
§§WSC:§2.5f§w¢§'é":VV€;Ei€i :§'j:'Zg'?$3 dzgiies". Seciien 2 {E} §,€3fifi€;% §s.e:'v§<:e§ 7 "fake é:~:::f:é0:2,.~e3€_ u$25:Ar%?é:1§, aiisizziiéng 1339:}; heipérag e::::° bsnefiimg a " '§§:c:<:é;2r§:ner::x€%iii::y? in Ehé CG'€.f§§'$€ af éiscézargézég étg pzgghiia éatifis '2.m:E;.23,.él€§ csnsiructian warksfi', Sgctiaa 32% {E1} defiges v"T?$:2é.s§;' as a. {@8333} C§f§€§" mafia fez" gzrgppéy sf g@§fi§ Q3' S€Y\§§{:§S ""«f%;%"i"'%%$§<3f{:s€ 55% 33: §fEi?'§§§§:3:SEE 2%? iazzéer §z2bEé$;§':§& in a "§€::'2::%§:"
Buiiséiérz".
mm;
%3 E: is in {he 'baakéyep Q? the a£%.f§{%%é' §E'£%V):S§§§":S ihat ii :3 <::<:s::%:er2.§<%:d by §§arn${§""C3--a'::1s?é'E. f';r;>:*':i%1:~;3"' Apgeéfafzig '£313.: as déspfizsai 9:' fishiéfg réghéig 9:" water bediéss §€)€S :39': :a§1tam%5_§;':g§ f:$ t§:x% ;:}r0:;:§§%f'&é_§z:«:?:3Vi*3 @fVa§s;;? 'geefis' Gr 'services' 3:' the LA§0.2§s"'t:fig:iVs§::1 serviCe§ and ihérefare, the Transparsncy? 13¢':
are not aitracteé; <3:fgc'=v__*:f%':e§:r""'d'5%:3' :f§.<;'§§_ Er:v$i{%v%i§«V:...§$"mar:{"13::<:r§l§; 8335, ::':6:icuEGu;SEy grarzting fishing fighig' W3, 3 cf E336 '§'ranspa_§:s:1cj;
Aci prescfiiées éfifxatv of the Act shali net appiy £0 grocuremerzi G§§g{}O¢'i%:§-v§;%£;'._f§§.Ei%{}iC!3S? which are inisensisient with :3;:ec.§f§édvv--é2f2.«respect sf tbs Prajecisz fuazded by $115 E:1ie;:fz;?:fi'{;i<':_2:3v..4E'7'§f:ai*:ciaE Agenaéas GE' Pmjects cavsrsé Lmdsr " V' L»-..__E:3:er:1a5':€e5iia£ §, gj;}%;¥:_:'::£:1e:2i$a 5; The fmimgfi Efissbaiédigz 331$ §?'1lsh,$§'i$$ Sscreiaréa G?
"V*,_:E;$ §éV:?é§':3{::1@:°:f: sf §r<;a:*:2a_E:ai~<:a E235 giazeéiefi fig ggééstjgggchsmé it: .__:'$;*3§e'€:éi sf éispagai af fishing yighias is: {E26 ianksg Eaka r*§::e§"s? ré%;€,%* hagifz. 833$ Sihér waiay f€S§'§_E:E"C§§ figs Gazeiis diaisé E§iE2é2@€}é§ fig E"§§$2?§:E"}?; §&3i:..:;:"€:3 E:"€§;€}; 331213: >~,,-Wm»z., er§»a§;:s, "£}©VER§'§Ex/§E§\E'E' GREEK E\E'€§, P3;%a§:/fig'1%?/MEEEEZQSSE {REF/1%?/SFM/2QG5j _ A .
ggzxsgamga wsyg 281" Jf,s:;3.a:.%§4::R%§'fi§§ ';i%;é; 0:: {ha 'fiasis Gf fiém eXAp§;3g:1a:i0i:"'V'7 greaznfie, the Oiders issue.:i"'%earEie§'._§/viii: 2V'.é:g§§*é is 321183 Em transfzsfxj {sf the 'aariks, Eakeg E'?;V€i'S,V ":?i§§er uafzzé, Qihe: Wasiter rsgeurgceg :§%i.t.'%j §z3. vgfiigfview Qf Fishes'; Be;pa3§::%:e:::§'._/ E"::o;€%si"* ::"B:'%e;*.s.a3§i:r:€::ijVifiage Panchsyaégs _ __ :§:;a§a§Eé'}§ n1eni Plan f Lake E*s"veI9g:3.:I::T;€_§:9:'§:..A_vgrit}? ;'T e LE1e:-:+., . .:»,§u;thariiies under $316 G<L2:re:;r:.;rA:i§v5e5:+§:-«§_$"'z:a#:;s:;::§i§§3a*i and arders are passefi; §ssL1ing"éEf:e" goizfiiié'i':é::*i5;§'£"'.if:Iand f§Sh€§'j§ rifles are issueé Wifi: '::7:.:::;.€dA;;aié'. effect anfi anti: fzgrihsr V Fagé; EEEE tbs Eiffififii' rsssaurces mafia? ihe 'z'f%e'::€:z:1:::§éj;<:.:'T1=i:: the Whflis <35 Efiza ;SEa{€2 is éivééeé 8,fi i: <:?£e§. s3}§'fié& as usaéezr:
V n .«_.%} '$26 First §'ar:q:ers Sfivséeggzarié; égeficiég A :3:/Yitirzézz ihfi a.é3:§:é:*:is*i:"af:§:7€ cezzirgé ef £316 E'isE2€:*is$ Qeggrfzmenzi Egaw E3381':
$§<:$€':f:?i§fE§ £16 c§:af::"a_%i§§; sgsaggrefi ssjherizzes af Gevertaraaizé 31*" Ezéia 332$ éfaiiéfil" ihé saéé pragram} 332239 fihséffi is 3'E€£€SSiE:§:" fie jggmvéais %:m§:':ér:Vg 23;: {is :r13.§aE. %:'e:%er Qf grégriiy:
?a:a 2:» 'E'§':€ §S§';%tI'}' §§g§':1%:§"§:':Aa§§. ':I;r:éé'T'::>g;¢a}:<~;§:*i'.» baéiss wiihifi $15 ;)urvi':::w 1*._F'if;31~:%f€<§S;- { fA Beparimsntg' gala Sa:n2I3.i<3§:a:1éi ._v_ 'i'1*;ja:tT;3:i 'é' gjsyg; sham bs Eimiteé is 'L%:5e"'-iégégmgg seesieiiesf assigcéafignsf pe1f.s;'5':;§_: .$ha§'§ be léésed an preferezzce. " ' V
1) Sscieties /£:g£;.i2{§ia.:i§::$ ".&f§%:g;§;§§;éfeaE under the Water i3i'a3f§3*§_%Zf1§....:€j}:rge'z:1§za*:i{§1"1.
{This }§5§js:.2€éec§ is the SG£:§e_?:'.$.s$;5}§:3_é'a&:§,éia:3:§'fegisiezfid uflder the Jaia {JSYS} are applicabés Qitiiy '£5 ,';Z*:k:~_€.r::svfé:*:=5::::_é:;3._':"'Qatar resourceg abeve 4S E-§6€f'.£are$ §€gié.n éévaleped by the Jaia s2;f:~;:ma_§§&};ana; Sanga (JSYS) under Wand . Ezagzxaici 'S?:f3j_€Ci is fsfiewing eeaéitions} 33* .E.u.{>:$é§}g*§sh€r::1ezi sf '£336 vzifiage wiiiin {he cf the Lake, shad: ha <:9mpu§sGr:§i:.z* ":"agi$1:€r€:c% as msmberg $9 $316 Tank 3.35%:
M £'e~:~@upg {we}.
'figs Cawpfiraiéve Sacéeiks af Ema:
féshsrzzzén Wiih {Em §::%:§i$ Qf the 903%'?
shag Ea gempzgfgoréijaz sngafied as memhsys is; tha fang USS? Graups fafmaé by ihfi éaisz Samvaréhazéa 33833333; Sazzga {J$"'f$}; {3} *'E';;e fisixéfig 3:€V€§G§IfI3:f:E§.§ in $125: ssgéd iasaks 3323}: 'Q5 agrréeé $33 3:21}: ihfeagi flag Eacaé fégézarrgsza mszzzbayg :.:>:':E:;*;
ii :3} ?'§% £321: éf {E16 31$': gsreféi {mm §i::h§§:ég-5:: {he said éankgf gig}: é's;::,2€é ]Z;{:§§:a§} fé$h€2:*$:;€a ;' Fésherias Cé<a0§.ér::€§v¥c5~ .S3'{:§'{..:£§3§§$;'~',,,., _ :1 T A in the saga WE2c=:2*:<;_ aE:%;a;fifg rights 35336 in the %3<3éi'ie:s""wi%h1E§; €316 purview Q5 :35 Jalé'ZSf.§:::§}é::fdha§ié."'Yé§ana Sanga {JSYS'j".:{r@ lessee Shel} he €9Q§§'1Z§_§'dv11?::€f§"£E':€:fl&:§{fi§I'}' 9f the saici :3 «i§j1€:"ds¥s1$;$:*r:e§1~€ af aid wiih ragaré its fihé.':§§§i:€,j§§'gT:'<:::.,1}ii2fir€§ éihe rifles in this " s;_}:4*é_e:*" E11163 issued by the G§'Vr=:_:f2':ma:2i:- ffem time is films ska}: 'Se . V. c:>_:I:pL:iZs::s--:*j; 'f0Bc:>w€§, 3 _ _ ;{;%,:':iata}§a Co» eperaéive Fighéréss Fe-<§€r§vi:%§.:éi'.~'A Baaéfi fiiimiéééfi, M3/sere {TEES Qf§8.§:';Zi%=f£f;Q1"E £3 §§"§'£!§§;€§ fimé prefezazzcs 11::
A%&§ S7£iEfi¥3il?;3:{}Ifi Q3? 'éhé fishery righta Eay the Fégharéss ?§'{é1e5a.:*::"::er:i:§ 3§&:": fFC%f§,£ ':?1§,s§ 'aha faiéewézxg
-~$§€:i&:i:3:s;'a3$$i:3ia:ss;'ps?'s®§2:§ Shag be gzevésieé prafereasa as 233 331% SEZEGEE Q1'; :"€$§$$five1y,§$ 3} '.T§'Er2€ géghmg QQ*G§3e'3§"§EE°V§ SQ£§§'i3:€S §':§;:%':':§g Ezéezaififirshzga gf '£336 Z:§&z*:r:a:::aE<:5. Cafipéraéivs Figherieg Ffifiaratéarz BQSS5: iixszi) §a?iys@?$ {$5 $326 fégheimeiz C3~ap§?a€§:»%: $§$§§i}; faééizzg '®J?:.i§'1§§?. this E ¥f'€§€§'€E:'EC€ agnzesfi 552:? 3 sérggis éaizézg 33:3 E'i;$3%":&3*°:*:2€§:
Ex.» C@~e§$ra§évs Sscieij; Wiéhirz 2:135: hfméis ef *:§:e:v§E_%;»2gf€% zséieye $16 pa:/25% is giéuaiéd Qféféffiéii-.i'.» The 215:5: §:r'$f€i'€fi<::€ shafi 'a4b€;"*g,i'V€§:_ j*iZfé'L:':- '°*' F§Sh€f'f1'361'1 c:::~:39era::é:fe.T' .Sacié:§_$§ h:2<;f:':*;g<_V_ £55; eyératiem ignited is Habié"'~E§*i2'eE§ 'FaLE:\2_i:"'T§-:52?€§';:a:2§ Qésérict Eevei respeszfixéeiy. «'E'1";<:5_:;:~:0i:':}3ty p::>fp1:»s'€d is obtaéiz fishing cuiiufcvéégézgsf,-.'fsiiéii$32263 obtairzxczdg HG objection £eriifica':$v--fn§;::: 'flfr: 5B駧:_:::jéfi},{' '
4) Rég£%3E.?:r%d"--. ={F'§sh€:_f:€:-e:1..._...-- 50~5§ez*£=;*;:iv€ sasieiies Véf}-ejjperative saciéty faifiztgg. E;-:%¢:E"e:§':"<ét:f€;;e....<;'§9:':*£:e$'€ fer a single :ar:}«:;;_ tbs A:?§V$.9¥72'€';',v'.f'§':v1;1'i$§3;'v.%€3:~€}§3"E§1:'8;§§V€ Seciety within iha 1inAj;if:_s" of the tank is situated Ska}? 'bs L§:*$f€r'réé. *. next prefersnse shafi be 'F19...
g£f;2':i%:ér::__{<2 :h€'";n...,hermen ::0~0§srai:ive Seciéties .A :E;a.<_;:a.g'iisfiépératieza limited ta Rabbi Eevefg Taluk E€iii_<;'?1;1€:*;§?:?:*:~v,,Di'§ii'i{:t 36%} respectively'. 5}. fifigéempifiyefi Gfaduaées fielding fiegrss :3"; the s'%;;'b§6€:t Q? fishsriss:
Vxfiiéz 3:': éaieriiiarz {<3 §:*@§€5£ fresh fish V' : :::1§.:ri::7@::$ fwd ta 'aha gensmi §Lfl5:%}:C $2? '$13 Sfiate, $3 €28;I'f}'* :32}? iéziaiiai fishézgg in 3 sciazzéiféc f{3;£f'§'Ti{}£L zixzénzgiayeé C%1'a§1.}_&§€§ £2: figizezies azzhgéci: ma}? :;§3?,aEn gas zvaéer E'éIi'$9ii§'¢:f:¥$ zéfiihém $26 éémizg {sf éhaéy é§S'{§'§€f:'i far a maximum af § }7?i3:"S 9:: 362.3% fa?
fishery fights subjgfisi $0 $333 faring 953$ sf 2:%:.:§:»E: $32333: E§:?:<:& 'aha:
§§"€f€I'€§§C€ giazsrz ta {ha %.2:":€: r:ép§.®§z.é1'd -- Céraézgataa in figheiieg :§s;...2L,':' 'ii/::€."<3'wiS" §;E.%f;;::€5'; '{:£"i€}' are uzzabie is o§:;:a_i:': f%€::.=2,.:<3& €3f'§i.S%1€fi=§3_ rights if: any @133 sf :a»*a:§:' ?
wiihézi {Em Emits @i*"§ji'ei§ éivhgzriitg. §b:ain the E5336 f;r>:~'~-- j§\i'$h'é--r}f rig}::s.. $5; the water bGd£€:s\'«..::;2}'ai§$3bZ%:' 'z1_e:Zgh'Sau:*i::g disiricés Subj §_<:;t _':::y :_aui:::5é':%é ' §;§€g'§i'd§ti@:1s. E3) T1155 Graiiuatss Eighig Shfilélfi V_.7CV><_i«""'V;'c> "0i:'5»;;%;:::_§VV:f; ./.§{:i%*:A1é3;§;%}§;a,§Vsr E15 mus: have V :e_§éé'é...§f:«.:%:3V'_'E{,a:'::a€a%:a far :10: less than 3% MS; % 5:) Vggéréad af Ease of fish V Vv A'<:I.;i€:i<}2:':i3:1___:ight$, if ihs: fishing ¢:§I'3.dE,1E,ii€$ arizpie}/'me:"1*s;3 ihe Eease sf 31.12%: 353366 :v':'€.;§?'ia>%5{£'-.§::2:>:*:ti:::,:e the 36336 zip :9 ihe 52$ (3?
'£33; f;§$§d year, In case? if £213 «§,2;f2e:2i:pie};e§ {§rad'a.3a¥:§ ceniizaazes E116 bass ever; afier €X§§;f3? {::f 'aha £5856 §®ré@d; éhe fishes}? rigbig £12 {he waisr badiw @E:;ta.§:/zaegé 33}: {ham ax: Eeasfi shafi be Senswfiéa Wéitéz ihe agparsvai sf figs cgmpeiem autimriéga :3} Sméfi? '£213 §3:*§2;'§$§:3:':$ af ihfi Eiggffiaisééa Eifégaiiazz £92; 'faha §:§{i2':&:' izsrégaziéeiz zgssrs c@~ape:"ai:':z*e Ss<:éa'€i€s;";a.E<§ Qevfiiégmefii agwcéaiiézagg' '§'a:2Z%<: 22.3833 aassaégééanag igké af 3336 'Cggvsmizzzerzé wag Ehai: 3?': haé afzzeser: z:{:iv--:<3. és::a:*i%%::e '§€1"E_f5i€E"S gr 3. fiC8f£§{}f:fS far' G'§"8wI':{£ sf éeagéz, as,...:§%e1*:»j: VW%3-:'as" :*;_:3'ezévaé ' giaiiizaritsa Ths Eearzkeé i'}0:;€.:'f:-::§fe:':":V "s'%v_§%;'r>g:a;§'V" ;j<.V:{.>T3:':%:vée::§«é::<f:15 that as €iX€?I?1?iii€}1":, as GE ifas '§ra:33parencj; 53:: had ragged: {Ef that transactiarz. In recérvdingiéfiggfits:1§ffé.§:iiA.:f:*:§é;§i:€v$.§:é>§.:1", it hafi aiready been asszzmad iha Ceuri, iihai {ha i;'1§V::;§;écii0:1. There can be :39 gaiagayéng Ac: '%&'8.S :39: aéiractefig the spiréi andé grsvésiens ef the frafisparsncy Agtt. '£i1§:rn€§th4;é4E't3~:gsL____§§%rvade 313 Government irarzsavciienafi a:i'::§V§~;":{gi'» cQ:':=.;&;::s*i:..§«..x§::=1§',:1d. hava ta be e3:3a:1fe:'::n«$§ '£5. The Qivtésien 3%§r:e%:"%.:"':*Sri K:**i._sI%}'na Fisherman relied; 3:: 'she ebsefvaiiezas in .§§agar Mserui ---'sfs» Faheem Ezieai Ex§e:€s Pvé. Efjafig 3823 §L'§ £3 ésifig 23$, 22% :{*eSp€c'stfufl5z Séaéa £35 ;?_i§?i'§§§£>:?s Bsnah fsfi éntiie gym? £2': assuméngjacaafgiifig vsithauii cansiéafaééem, {Eng}: :5: wag mandegtazgr fie aéhere :3 the §'fii'Qi?§§fiC%:1S $5 $223 'i':*&::$§&§€::{:§ AC3 Er:éi:,€$ita,'sij§.§ 323% E: baa':
cs:>:i§:€::«:§€t:§; 'file ifiariisé ééavsigmgmi édvggais Ehafi 'she saié éaézgiéie $333 $29': &§§§}' ta {E16 subjesé Ezazzsactéag ifiereim, guy 02 Eegmzad Sreiégszg weuéd have <:$:2:.«:§ée€§:t§ zine}: asgecé :3? $3? 27% {E16 5335 giaiuisé it £3 £3? {E2636 magzifald éiaéeciigs tha: we saargswez' bet}: the q:.::€s*;:§a::>:r':S in Rsfaranaa §:: the EE€ga?E§¥€. Wrié: §--':§§;$aE :"€$$,3$29;'2£}EG azzfi 25231: Ta<:v.'.};'§;%;"V«é;:i':;§§fQA:*e the Biviséen Bensh far furihsz csnsideratian.