Karnataka High Court
Commissioner Of Income Tax-Iii , vs M/S Misys Software Solution(India)P. ... on 3 November, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
= ..':%g;-§';="g; ._®§§SY'S S{§§K::a?A;2%: ;§<3m:':':®zx: ::_r~§z;};.A}:-'a 2;;':':3.. 72:;-?%:'§:5;§':':;g; %:':--,jm§3~ €12? {}';re:E<?:° {E;2é':,é;%::i 2€%~€}2-i2{}£.E pz'z.:~'ss;&zd is: 1'"§1!E V' '§?§Zs;>§'§§vT?é/§f%;=::':g;;;"2{}H312 i}::»§" Eiizéf "':'ea:.' i3{}%{}¢E----85Lx }"éi'i_;;'s§§§,E'§ 'i'.h;':§. 'é}'l§.:~T=s §i{3:'1":";Ee:% *{I€I3':.22'§. 23222;! Ems? _§I}§é"fE.Ef:§{'f{§ mi 'E"§"§'E5 §§i.{}E"'§ {if€}§,§E:{'?' GE' E{;§§{?\.?;E'§?%E{f% E32'-'-'s ?'=§{}z'-':E,{}§€E=Z Zj}:'¥E'EiE.} ':':§««§:$ *;'mé;: eA3:;%%-2--> _:__>;v:' 9:: :x§<';v§:::»r§;§:§§<: :20: E yggggm?
ma E-§()_F'€"BE.E E'v'§R.JUS'Hi'§iE R' KU?vLf§£¥{ A_§*=J'£} ma H€}f\£'BLEZ §\:ER.JE£S'i'Z{ZE<: mfg: MA;...::2é:;é.f:f:E:ff :
§waNGg2?©F2é;L»f E3 ES'§"s?'v'£CE*Z;'\3 2: c@:xx:§x:1;S$:0N:<:E_% QR' i r~é:{:a:s}F»z *<§?s:.;§§w:::
REV %:;r\m<: s§3u'r1%..:):.N:;;§,% g;;E,§ 2223345--- §.%{@.£%iI}, " » "K EIVCGMEE3'E§§§;QE'E?°E{3{§R~,»."_' ._ 3, WAR;i3=»€ 221%' El E3;*:;,f'£G;2%.gii3}{E:, ' '- V V V - . APPES-E-LAN'FS {E-W SR? ;2:j;:;:z,K§N:3;:2x:T§<2§M;2§§$T'T3§§..{:{}LJN3::§,, §~"{}R 3m'. :3 E swam E%fiA'"§"EiE;~:&{3R?{)C;!§'§"%Li} _ " ' EENE} V' £;€§:;13{,:::s:§ §*Z?vE§{%2§SS':' {}{,}LEL> EJENKQ §:'.:'§§%§§§ §C}§5? E?'»E'"i"Ei§~E.§Ts/EE%§§j}£f3.'?§'%: R.EE¥§{} #;}::(};i1'a_ . j E-L3Al's3飧AL€}E?;E%:~§69('3'E' 3 1 V V RES-;€%P{}f'€§.}E§?aT'E.' ""§."§'3§:+:: i"E";"£ f'},§<:<§ {§:':s:§s':§' §a":<?r_2{i;G--?: :1}? Ef.E:.;":{i'§.3 E§5§ L §{::»r:':22..2E;i:§.s é'E"::§=, §;::§');s;?'.§"s;'2i.£;::=.§ {gm-::»;§..%.{:§"§:3; :;>§;' E2;-2.1%; .%«3§{§."§.{'.:f§ €.§'%_<';7-:1-::§':":..
% . "--{_i.€;':,:_:'E, ;?_:':_"<éi'Eé<-'r {ZEEEEEEE 5}? €Q§?'i§?Z§§$§§§"£€§' fif Efiaamé '§'ax .;:§;-,_; §g--*'§%.§'a:& ELXSE Efidm Es: Eff; Z'?§;'2§§§ azgzéi <>i:E'2a=-tr '1:/.:*:f:-:33":é3<:'%;.£:5§ :m;§§;fi:é3.':"ss_«; {§.§:'§§§{}§%§f£"i £33?" 02:. §.§{}¥{}é?:"3;2i{§E E zmati §"i'1§:
-:&.:;.:§§{'ET §&}%S:.Ef: §'§.<1%E.»:§ £3: §Z2=,:w}z.:*s" 52:" E':E':<3 2 ii. saei, 2%-i{§:;> E319 z;'{_>:z1::2<;}:2 ;2.§"_:}§;.:=s;%§i;::€4s:? :"):"<.§$r (3.:-zieci 2f';"é§}2,.f2{}§E ;>::s::5;c;%d 'by :':E'::'% E"§'fi'E'. 'E-E' ;E-3€:1e:%Z%.:; B2-:.r1.§,;z2§<m:: in a;}pe:°:§ §:>:'<}£:a<:?a:§§§':gj§s52 fix": N7':}.§}?ri,i§E%21§::gj28}£} ii;-3.i.e":<i 2.8~{}242€}E E? in E.h23--'"-. i:«2é;s1*e:a'§. {;s£"§a:::=:+%.:£:::~. zuxci e<;,;z,2:§é,y, 'T "§.'his:; g-::g3§;€;».1E {3()E'E1§I'1§»§ 0:: far a€i:'1:és;ss;§<>n g.,%}§$:'%:'駧7;V_ "J.§g_ ' Kumar J :§é3EE'4.,-*::*1.°<::u:i f;,h.€: f<)E.E02a.7i:':gE§: " L' T JUI)GMEE\TT"£' '§."%1"ES z»2p;:=€:é21§ is by tile §§é;sv§;=,ri:'.;§é '{".:ha1i§é::*;g;__§i:égi; '~th::{' {'>§*{i€r pasgerii %}y ':.§";.€: '§":'§%}2_:':'s;~g;VE";'~. '_E'}1%:._ :~;:L:b$§:};g:1€'i21§ :§2z@s5E:i<>:1 0f .Ez,s,:.x.r which a.1;j_§sk::s;;V §:,i_f {:oI--":";<3i:ié:1fa§}i{}:r1 in §:§3§§_=;
:a2_p;}<:ai "WThei:E1\3r 7._t';fi§': '1':i?3i:Ii%;:.'§ "%.i:?21Sg {f(}'E"E"€;".{.'i if} h<::§ci1?11g 'é=;Ef';}=::. w"f1i§é:4{,:<;%i31§3ui1'§Eég :"€§i<:<f L1:":£ie:° ;Se:$:z:;;:<:'::_ ;e:}A' 'EEK Am 2951, "aims: 2}ii:",1_4{}'a.:gEfi: fine <:E:21r§§€S and '.:i:;:42"i'w;3.ii:2§.;§ s;sE':m4:i{i Ex: <;2><é:iL;»:i<3:'§ '-vL.{::<::§2§'A $25517"t{}i:aiVafi;;;I':1.€;x,>;3r§ if §,E'§g=: Sgzgzzzer 22.1% _ é:'::<it§§f{~>:§"'f§"?::%:}1 <:};§>:'3rE: €:'r_:;:*:':<}ve:° 29"' .f~:s3.§:£ <;:4:::%s'é'1.i{;}1"2. w2:$ <t0':3::%%;:%;€:§.*é%::E. 'E35; €.E";.E.:€~; i sgéazt :3": {E 2;:.§{:s: E3": 555%: E; E": if §3%3<=%"2.?{'5?":."; 1; at (_§'E':f': '.' 'V V \.a~J ii E?'<>§E{}::1r§.:1§;; E_:hé;: af?:Tm:sI:;;:1i<;i _;§2,.:_{§§2;§";";::%:'1é am? fm" $'§':é:\:; :'{'-?:::-ssasems; ::;%.'.a:i'{.{:%€.E in {Eng Szaézi cimiatzz §:§"1§:'<-".4 :_»2p;g~>@.;:._§ a'fis:s-mi:-i--;s'sc~.:iE zmszi {E19 :%142'§3saz:2'1:'1E,i.aE Qzm::%;£;§@E:...<j>vf"--w.E;:*;¥$:" :14:-9; a:ns~1«;ws:re£i in §'at-*01:::" {Ef file: :1ss;c?=$é.;;£;3{% ».8.~:'§s;f?; -.7é:h§-;€ A f §€e2;€%:2 2:: 3 ,