Karnataka High Court
Gowramma vs The Special Deputy Commissioner on 16 September, 2008
Author: N.Kumar
Bench: N.Kumar
1!-0!-IWECI twrqm axowfififia V
.1-:;t£0§as_tuIuI0:_) £;1,nCi(3§1VfB§:7Qdf§'3(;",_g;_'v' 1" _
(mmonpv 'imimsag Buezfsaxgfl w d.
10; awaonpv -i0FFi9S '£91193 BpII'H.ftIBM $13 KL')
§.)[E1'{E3fj,_I[3..I(§M 91019331251
V "Iif&0}!B>ITf'3"*LIBI9}.
13 3V."£)?5'9&
g z;=.1e:2:;u_z_§.«g3;. moqe pagy
V_'3d"1'"'~'Ef3H I-IS 0/AA
' E*III'lI1"¥L~2.ImO{} umg
muoggad " '
I _ % ='"'ni:a3"'m' 71.'""::1a""
* % {E~'.'§'a1ii%.i:!f:1:»I..l_$qé?t':'__3<i 12.383 'OM t'w;r:;'4=a mm
(sg2:1--a'1§1;% 1§¥fi£'.'€1".J°A0S€{}€ 'om Hogym mm
10 uzez 'UN U30?i1.[l9d mm
" . V ;~:%T1'ioI.z.anr um mam):-I am
V % caaoaaa
if" jémz 'mqmaidas .10 1489 am am srtn puma
t-mm'%9Hva LV vxvmvnuvx 410 131100 I-I'D!!! mu. m
V 1"?"
Q1? .
fiflag
ff
egaa
3'/'fig
glory
11""
'L 'E
ifigifg
1:11
/V( 1; 919
// j
-.j;};3" .
/jg, ._ d _V
Q?"
gflflfi '
3135'
9113
f'
130
"P5
113
3:0
'17
flgfifiaii
ii';
gig
,; '11si?'3ij,?" Z' 74
M ~ § 1;t!».i_ A
flaigfi .
;3 ¢,;:aiF V
5 50
' 6 f
991:,
96
flflfi
0 96
.,;,L9!-'
511*'
% 9"
gag?
(73
9i1$*"' '
3.13.436" «.
J0 " « 2; 97"' flgg( '_;9a0' I -3»?
£63 901 9 25¢?"
49,,;2fJ /W V 36??
541" -;?11'''' = 1 95 6?q.,__ g f Jraflfgfiafig .. 'E: fitfljflifiggxffi 9156 3,101"! £3?' , 9" ' gig"
. {I 1 2 '1 '9 301 fi""" "* Qua 15";/$97 a}g.fi9a'£ V 1147 5%"
W 421 W ' gazff"
;~1_ ':,3,4;g;{h gxfl, {find ' fig" 3 _ :5: WI'; ~ ._ .9117 ii'; % «jfi gs "'3 3é%?'5 ya?"
ggggifl '£6 gfifiv' " . "
4791 4 ' lg!' 1?' 47 919 am"
51*' gfiigiivi' 0239 .1?"
"mat?
A4 w.1'§~"@\*. ' Vflgd ._
-ap?*' .
63:6 @110 fig?
ad' 00 72%"
Qfifiti 9?!) ggfla awyogoigm ;, ' :3 . ct?' ' gig.
oz?
fitflfi " Q1147 " £573 0 s 6 Vogégféaiv £41 gag' 066 a1a"{d,L {,1 {£19. 9'.
:19? 0 .{.I1'5 , +9?" ¥:3??I;1;1!3 V' 9 ti 11 ' gflafljttgflfigfifi 6?
. ,('¢" 0 d ' :11' 199% "u.:I",fi 2/ 3-ti?' 5?';
0 $31 4 _; ,I'9?1 Qflé J . $9 9 J' E1 3 :1 ('fig yd"
git?' $3 . £3793:
Wag) I6?
3
gjgofggfig 6 g.,o1"j1 9951' J; qfijggfigafi , :6 21*' :1 f %%%;:v?""'1 pmsszuoo pave Kpotystto zaq :1; amm qagqm Smgmmmp ;__ aqjs 9'.-mo _I3q;;o atp, tat; 933301: sq; pangcmm aqs ti9t31§§"';j;L¥_§;:z_ mi" "33? 5-'Qfifiti 9A§9<xa1 101;); pgp Jauoggad 9:3; :1 P919' "°9?4'="d 1?-Im MI: 30 my arm u:kéa;;;:oq§mg"g-:1; 1§li:1f:§t;;.Q[r§2:!§ Pug 3~'93*'31T.m ml"; J0 9'~3T1E'19"U3! 1-NI; $3 9&5"
"*3 9*" mam PWIQOHOO '5! 19fi%?§i's19d*'_V§t{%'wA$"é ltfll "I 3? H 'sfiusmmmd 11?3BzZ1.m3F_%§I§i;%:a,1té' p§;q"§§g§;:;~:q1na mg mg pgsgmlsw 935' E99996' Qifii. [.}iTB8'§.IO_.fE mp go t:):0_E1Bd1'1::x)o pm: mauouuad '-3131 3'5'3--"¥339 u uogefigq wmagm Dflqnd 5' P91? '.I9I:IO}i1}:;:ad sq; Jo amen am 'I? WC' 993"] "39':i i7'7'=?'I-- "I1 50 ICDQCISEII U1 manna tIcJ}1tf$I3iII amfié "3[I§[i':?90[iOO pm; S'..I$§I3E'[{[A tag; 9;; s3u0f?§i _ fingugugdmoa Iauogssgmtaog xmdgq 'T4.m".§*.':1'§'7'3i'f{'3'31E«(7';--V"'L:?V..'§"5V'3P0I 'é-'~I93B"[[g;A BILL *9 para 3' salttxatztrv _ H.993" SV3?-I3"? H9?!'-'flflfll 9111 'fiffitltgiptoiyay *p;r.;p ares '-3111, 36" Sysfiq 91:11 no amen 191;; :J;r3;11uI 0; uoueaqddg mil. 'P9913 3133 311:1 J0 Emm; 1:13". t[0§S€.i3S'SDEI . 0919 S835 Jauoggzwd sq; 'mane; Jggzg 11; gpggp ares ,,,,1+, é"%1.'4®1Ti39X9 11393 3111 '93I3'9p mg 50 suxra; II; ptng pggga-(1 ggm %...~w«/"W1 .3_;n0{) sgqt; mopq Q: 3 am 'swim an $61 WA9F~I33V '11?I9'3I€11T-?*1'i43*{). ériéfl A {ID sinus 9131 go uogenmsard :..::;1:11st:::v pEIB ti; snjires sq; ;o II£)§1{§S9'S§§-'GCI I1; J:QA90SI.iI(§q;§& ssttdaxad. 9:15;.' Kfnp Xq Z},"£I9ll1"EI.I9A0{ij sq; _;:c> _;:{E-qgq no _§3tf; 951%: 0: mpnsqex mt: _ 9?" & 'mumufio 39 so Iséptmwi 9*'-1 IIWI5 SPfIW9{~i~$ifl 5:?33§ 'Sm "11 'em 1:1; pmmodrcmug 0311:: 9t[ {Isms Jsuoggad Qtfi, gig; sq; pagaauvro 19"°¥99?'I1'17i0"J._ 353#id9fi'._«3'i% ayes 9:11 3:0 S;-seq 9I;[:}, no $3;m13v g1;' 1;/g; *0" '.53 _;ca wadsat ug sprang: 6:; sq; go amen sq; 3:;t_t;B:mtt1 1:II_r:,f'i' }ira:,_..L :1;g;;g;u:{fi€jd"'"'£:bg;.I0t;;ne .r;mo[ sq; '9.IO}$).i9t[; S; PW! FEES mu fizmdoxti mu 01 am; on: sq; fiugpngotq 1,/ggogq ufig 3[if.IB:9q puts; _ JG are eqm suomad sq; 13:11 IIO_ISI1{OlICir£} sq), 0:; 'atfgi [[3 Sugmaq 13352 'gixmhtta xsge mtrogssguzrmog M 'gamma ucogtmmm sq: 3:0 uagigtraggirzm . qp; ';;::§§,fV'§q; go (9)991; uagaaag Japan Jguogssgmmog; Kjndaq my Stztgtparaocud B Siam. Btrgpasixud pass 91;; 'L '.I9},'J,BUI 91;; %.%.x/"W m:>g1:3;ps§.m_f seq mttogssgwmog Kutdaq am ryeq; 3tt;mt1_s;§12 ' agjogmaq; ~1:a1sg:89.:: t1s:Ig::;Bgu11II my tr; p9.Ia3_:t;;. gpuaaéw Jzmogjqsd 9:11 30 .mo;s33: my pQ';i1CT£§X9 psap §ges;'pm'a;§_:3?9:; ;,E§¢fi':
Qgstaq any rm 2;; :11 "9951 .1995 911:; !ZEI"iT(Z-Tl:;.'f'.'3_'.§31S_I3fii. lZV'It..§'f".ViI£¥;'i'1:l.j.!.;IA~~Q:J[.111,,,['.".I-V; Immvqs 3; Kzmrdoad my 01 91:13:; tngefo Qqgé #11131: sq; :x::;'u0gg:;9d 9:13 go .mom-33: sq; pm?
pr€ra.Ii)'.;}'p stem :p,g:11s; sq; -;;vs§a;:_1¢:1:ci1;1:1'§uI.;7..§s_t:fi. 1.;-éézgmmdmoa B sum azxxatu 's1p":_§' ;1E.I'J'€HQ3.IgE :19 1:99:11! [Rm 032:' 12:3 0195.' pamqua swat; 9; 31 'SE1I'£I"i3 33;
game I 01 gsmd ~»r;j:;i39 ptm SQA[9SIIIi§fli{".'; 3IIOIIIt&§ fiuadazd 912;? ;{;;.*Ig';. 913499 9:11 01 papmzyotts 3d?$i3iEA 9£i%1w¥?dd§" E-'m 'I399? 9% viesareje 3:11 '' Vpti":'+3{:_ 'ifisaqoltld oqm nomad {pus 9:10 5;; paap ages pqmgsgfiax B mptm suamad Ca'; sq; pfcrs BtIu"3q;3q's amdsgp II; 1011 9;
"'9';I1d'sgp :1; 30:1 3; ziuadmd am"; 0"; mittitgqaqg gt) 3[;_u gimp 3 Stem uogsgnb II; pI'.lTB{ 91:3 'gwqz; papnzmuaa V ..I9pi<§V: mffitifitltiffilg 311;: Sugjmsse 'xauoggad sq; .103: Btrgxeatide fafizfinoo xomas pammg am 'fippza E'pEIl't_fiIBN gig; *5; 10; 1tI3uI:I.I::am:){) sq; Kq msqj, ;su_rta3e pr.9m;:J,;tI_{ 91:3 ,, flue _;_{ 10 1o:['3g'.I .I_EQl".[1 0.1103113 01 in Kam uaqm pm: gg ' am :0 Lisaimm 991 WJJB pitwm Slim-"vita V*+3j""tr-"Is aq 01; zgmeq §§é3];.IZ;t'1"9 sq; ':11::1_;9.Im:1:; 'pE{[33'A:"Vpf;iIf,§[A. J E' sg uogsatib (1; pure; aoq; ';uU;;; s9f.;.Ivac{ .Qi:;[}..: sq; apgaqp 0:; t1o§:);psy:.In§." on $§i3i;{.1QU0§ffS$~§1;IAf€§}IC)';\";*C1I'E.€£[§{jvvC}I{}~:;3i)V sq: _.;0 (9)931: uo;;:x:;3 Japmz gf:'"sv.'::§3Z)'_(V1'¥§;;SIII'£1CZ).I§{) zassm .IQ'ptIn -Emma): 'Z,l¢:.'?E1 ::;:_:' agasq azmq sdzaasz .I9f.[1O 331%; passymsgp sq 01 games Hfifififigi' p2)3II9'{{BI{i) per;
sq mpxo qfifqi-ks :,.mg_:39.I 1:3} uogwaggdée {IE mp.-2111 pjip Si3Is§Tl§,¥3AT;.'1I;§f'If§:?1'I(f{£.§.i'.i'T§1';%;;:1V.%}EI{) 13:11 2o::£;;rpy:A:; QEIIGS :;»q 01 sgmadde :m11;;q1_ put3T §;aQ51' ':;:)§f uéggfoqv surtatq (Si10QtI¥€['['E¥'.)'S:£IIs[ pits} ;35'f{q3{j;I3}'£ """ Hétp yo suoysgiscxid sq; 19pun' . 1u2)miiJ91i£_s{;§' 93311;}; "gpop I; 3t:r_{:3q uogssnb LiI§3"'{JE{T:3'{ mm 91.; '$1395 ()3, 3:0 asdei 2 Jaye . qans ';(3_ as;:a.I9xa liq p9{:;19stIn sq ';0uIn»3:) p'9[119E fiam V' sq; go s:1q3;.: 91;; asyausma 'snip; QIQEUOSQQJ V. p9s:;3.Ia:x9 sq pyttoqs mmod E{;')E1S 122111 3131 pamas ;':~,:)V mg 50 (3)9131 n:r;:>;;:39s;; Japan S9§.I1tI9 939:1; maps: 03 'é§31§"['J}C7B Hogzafi E' ssafull my am 30 551 pm; 931" ' « SE &1.1:;cE0.1c'i am 0"; afm .191; qsgfqmsa 0; ;m{;_:=:_;..SE:{ 5&1 :11"-312p, 3m_:p{-:31; 1:27; p9ggs11_€ gem .I9EIO§CS'Si'LUIII10"Cv:)-;'1§';I;iCI;':£] 7* ' ;tat{.; ti; Sf." 1; *1t:{3g;I 01:: S198 aqs '.I(l)lZI0§f,1V.V"f)'é'-.é'li_IV atfigo 9}}:-s sq'; ~s9";1i:3c:x9 pm; mxsap ':1-33UZB.E3 '..')*s11xi=f.;*;:r;:a¢:{ zigaxam 'amt; or: 831]" oqzss Q; .;tmm9:u:8u ma 0111'; p'aI§;1:I9 seq 19t;g)§:;;;3dAA9Ii;f.'¥{_ 3%; 13313111; firm seam; mu op 5&3 'p;;};1EIE.I3'.;%I 101:: 3; [}"(1H[ 91:}, _;1 9;: 19910 3,u'i-31823,; mi V£{Vp91:;;mpV: ' £§1[tBd11i1')C) go s"J,q3g;1 mp, :31 1::r9_fq11§ --3@Sut§.:qt§;§t{§§x:éi am} 1I.TtZQIt[Ef.I9AO{) sq; mzm mama 1: safieliiir 5:541' 'i796{ 'wv tromroqv mm:
cs:1mwumiw "arasfiw an 370 fitiiwed air; tmm 1tI:;111§tz1§:Av:$§.j;' gqgé _;:j-;;:g.s9n. 31 'urea; gpop 13 S; uagsattb ti; f)II'8[ '§ a.:;,1_wq:E:1r:iii's;P_'F~1?}'3*éfi S: 1; 'S138; presaroge 9:14 wow *9 ".I3pIC> pafindmg sq; gncagxoddtm 'gnzfixmraaog fegasdg paumaf sq: 'alimoo 19,5 =17 mpgse 19% -.3q 0:; Ii3];1IO 311; 311133;; at; 330933: pgesaiczga mg .103 *u6}:;:);A3 e@P"[ ' ' ' ' " M % gmgxp age gnaw; '%i'13mI1I0<I>V vosfiad W at mam my 393 'gm 43;: i4¢"»¥é%i:;2?'3'tzt f:i:tt1 50 Mia mm H! W0 SW » 5 M 5 » ; 13:; 311101.) airs 5: am: ,,::/N 3FfFiE9FI€1b"3'5?.__H".'?"I0:£'P19d gm 5° W' N I' T3 11}:un Iii'-Iifllli lttiatrrtrxamié) ''3 9'; 11? W"I3 flflgeflggqfi jotrxf , V ' . Q13 qggqm EIi0_t,1l:i:91II€x) sun PR3 gut' ()1 QEQBEBAB , V. ._ I % - * zzrqs Runs 1!'? '$119; '3,-iF'<i~.=*::3» 1:5?! 01 HJC10 3? 1? PW Figs" 961 am' 11