Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Shankar Bhagwan Palde vs M/O Defence on 7 November, 2019
i OA No. 764/2018, 2435/2019 to
2530/2019, 3235/2019, 326/2019,
" 366/2019, 4364/2019 to 439/2019,
4497/2019 to 4354/2019,
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAI
ORIGINAL APPLICATION Nos.
7164/2018, 2485/2019
246/2019, 247/2019, 248/2019, 249/2019,
250/2019, 323/2019, 326/2019, 366/2019,
436/2019, 437/2019, 438/2019, 439/2019,
449/2019, 450/2019, 451/2019, 452/2019,
453/2019, 454/2019
Bate of decision: O7,.,11.2013
CORAM:~ R. VIGAYRUMAR, MEMBER {A}.
R.N. SINGH, MEMBER (0).
Mes. Punam Kumari
Ex-MTS, PA No. os?71-G,
widow of Late Rai Koshore
Singh, age-32 years, Occ. Service,
Presently residing at SMO P-134/3,
Air Force Station, Devlali Camp,
Nashik 422401, Maharéshtra.
, Applicant in OA No.764/2018,
Pandhari nath Sukdevy Gawande
EX-MTS, PA No. 63767
Son of Shri Gawands
Sukdeo Kalu,
Age-44 years, Occ. Service, presently -
residing at H.No.305, Shingwe
Bahula, Deviali Camp, Nashik-422401,
Maharasntra.
Applicant in OA No.245/2019.
Santosh Digambar Kshirsagar
Ex-MTS, PA No. 6S7S8-A,
Son of Shri Digambar Kshirsagar,
Age-28 years, Occ.Service, presently
residing at A/6é, NE, Panchjyoti Society,
Naviali Camp, Nashik-d22401,
2 OA No. 64/2018, 2485/2019 to"
2200/2019, 323/2019, 326/9019, .
* 366/2019, 4536/2019 to 4359/2019
449/201 to 4854/2019,
.. Applicant in OA No.246/2019.
Ganesh Trambak Patole
EX-MTS, BPA Neo. o3766-T,
Son of Shri Trambak Patole,
Age~44 Years, Occ, Service
Presently residing at Village
Shingawe Bahula, Deviali Camp,
Nashil~-422401,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.247/2019.
Shankar Bhagwan Pale
EX~MTD, PA No.45825-8, Son of
Shri Bhagwan K. Palde,
Age~40 vear QOec. Service,
r n idi a
Ambad Ganvathan, Village-
PO-Lahavit, Na asnik-422502,
Maharashtra,
-» Applicant in OA No. 248/2019.
Pravin Shivaii Gawali
EX-MYs, PA No.63760-S,
Son of Shir Shivaji Gawali,
Age 29 years, Occ. service,
Presently residing at jaily
Market, Shivaji Chowk, Lahavit,
Dist. Nashik-422502,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.249/2019.
Vinod Kumar,
EX-MTS (PH}, PA No. 63770-5,
eon of Shri Late Hazgari Lal,
Age~39 vears, Ccc.Service,
Resident of 145, Idra Colony,
Ratnada, AF Area, PO-Residency
Defence Lab, Dist-dJodhpur,
Rajasthan-342c11.
.. Applicant in OA No.250/2019.
Sachin Govind Adka
RAT Or Tm, ORK
Ex-NTs, PA No, 63759-P,
3 OA No. 764/2018, 2453/2019 to
: 2002019, 323/2019, 326/201,
* 366/2019, 436/2019 to 439/2019,
449/2019 to 454/2019,
Son of Shri Gavind Adke,
Age-28 years, Occ, Service,
Presently residing at H. No.703,
Rarkhana Road, Post-Nanegaon,
Nashik-422502,
Maharashtra.
..- Applicant in OA No.323/2019.
Namdeyvy Bhaussheb Jaras
x-Cook, PA No. 45824-N,
Ee
Son of Shri Bhausaheb Jaras,
Age028 years, Occ. Service,
Presentiy residing at H. N.1054
Lahavit, Malwadi, District-Nashik
422502, Maharashtra.
... Applicant in OA No.326/2019.,
ch
RxX> MTS, PA No. 63764-L,
S/o Pandurang Chavanke,
Age-24 years, Occ. Serv
Presently residing at
sae Ta che-Sanuae, Mandi t
ali Nashik, Dist.Nashik-422502,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in GA No.366/2019.
Rajesh Bhikari Pardhe
EX-MTS, PA Ne. 63761 ~K,
ri Pardhe,
Son of Shri Bhika
Age~3l years, Occ. Service,
Presently residing at NP-95/01
Six Chawal, 25 ED AF Station,
Deviali (Si, Nashik-422501,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.436/2013
Mano} Prabhakar Shinde
EX MPs, PA No. 63763-H,
son of Prabhakar Shinde,
Age-25 years, Gcc. Labourer,
presently residing at 124,
Maruti Gali Lahvit, Nashik,
District-Nashik-42250¢2,
2019,
sy
45/2019 to
4949/2019 to 454)
23/2019, 3526/2019,
z
ae
"
2019 to 439,2019,
ae
i
ay
OA No. 4337/2019,
50/2619, 3
O19, 43
4
e
6
OA No. 764/2018,
2
"366,
zn
4
.« Applicant
a a 933
yet rt rt
ce om o
os i] OF
nm ne, Ma
4] oy ry
ry or} <i
"i ft ait
© oO Oo
mi a wa
el, fh ra
wD
OQ 6 '@) 3 G
my wn Me
A _ 4 ood A
G4 ott
43 oo fa set 44
% cd td C BO th x
i i oO th . By ry ved ah) @ « AS
ea] t} Te TS hg G pf tt wm hf ergy
~ Oo od ned "rd of » OF toc | ~ OF Ob dt
GD ~ 1% wd we Red LOE Ey rt hd ONE a OE rf ee] i ke og
id nt 0, OO MN -rd it oy PY i Q, $B 3 ky
TS ww AD hg oy MoM US f Op i 2; OO db Py gt 4 rey AM O ty
ate 3 ee 430 Oo oO ved ri NS eet an oy eh Sort
Pa LE eh bP CD, ' M 2 da fy ba egy a) * TH 1 O ey * OD a 4
@ i OB om. " WH O rf $4 =P x wy fi fy cy . mu £5 4
ba Ag oye ° oe om OD ' "fos YD ) . sf :
PMO Oo tn Be a 43 Spot CJ * @ oP aw ry ma Sw tS
Oh I~ TF fy ct re a4 O tM vb Oy DO 4 GQ web ap whe OO O OF og
AGO bh ed ys 8 UE BE Gh wed ES od 2 MG he ad GB ) O -e
OO MO tt uy ct ad D Bo ck pp 4 rc) B44, eM a) i 0 -o
» «ns "ef 1G SP WS . 0G Om OO MH i em ted sh set
a CY os oy tm +o MG oo ord O Oe oy 6 a oct 53MM 8
Th mM @ a a + oO my oot ap 4 1 @ OS i + iy if
Hed bE kd Boe ot SB 4 ed 4d Oy de ke ag * © DO EF ww a Gow erd hy Sy
Hel be G ca Mt Ro Cope GS MH mh ky ned ee 4 Fo $a ont
© Oa 0G fay eed rt Kod OO WG a SE mre yD oa te te OP gy © 4 So) gO) tp,
x Lo Part 2 Oy oct fbb st ep ct od a WE so 1 4 es Mf GY a ed
mo 43 ay 3] Bost Bart OR nr 4 ai uo Om o 4.3
A Woo oe ~ $3 y+ ha oe oa eB OF CR rd MMe ed ot
WE O OG Wont by 4 OS OGD SM a he <4 sy hy "Aor OO. oD
a fo UF as br oat SOUP hs Sb wg ep og «Psy td QO AD fey 144
Abt SF a a A 4 WO £F ry te let OP be oy id Oo: Som @
ro O & &: wt om OM a oc O Beeb Dow GE PY OY wed eg 6G BYE OPO 4G
1 Tl 0 eG Oy 0 op st Wh Oi 3 © Bt Qos 2 B09 >. be oy et Bu fe OF ef Oy
.. Applicant in OA No.450/2019.
SGG/2019, 4436/2019 to 439/2019
§
Dinkar Ashok Patole
EX-MTS, _ No. §3765-R,
Sen of Ashok K Patole,
Age-Z6 years, Occ. Service,
Presently residing at
ponshingve, Post Shenit,
istrict Nashik 4225902,
narashtra. .
i
Ma
Pad
.. Applicant
Shubhan
2
f
x
4
ca
a
to fet
ty ong i
hy
ry
beds
*
dak SOLS PL
ot
wa ©
m o
ho
Po rh OF
oy
Hob
if
ify =
ct
Clik, ta
Gm &
ry bt
a
<4
(b
rs
@
tah
ey
iD
St
ary
hd
is. b f
on,
ma
ty
rr
His fs
£5
un td
cs tt
pa
".
Peg
zt
¥
ho
ho
me 2 FLOM
t whe
os"
a a
5
na
ha
oD
rashtra.
.. Applicant
on
ta ff ®
Q:
or
63
fA
ty
OO rR re fl
}
ny
wm
fete
43)
-
2
I
A
® ta
4
me fa pa po
8
ry 1
om ©
ea
ct
fe
(A
Suman Hos
Nashik,
At
28O1,
me
rR
ror Dt cr
4
w
4
Fo
ae
oy
A
a
E
A 2
a
=
ae
Q
im ort
ce
m ep td
rs Uy pe oD
tz
bee
£8)
$s fete
cr
w
.. Applicant
~
ay Wx %
fu
3
DB
ay
nase Sone
PA No
ee
sod
cs pp
a
5
we}
ry fo
a
[Hh
O
YY
.
>
x
i
wy
es)
r
o
cy
*
on
@
i.
"
fe
o
G
Ne
Lo
oy
~
PY
ey,
beatin
Dag
we
5
Ct
moc
iT ©
A
a
o
ry
OO
thd
~~
mf ty fF
th ct
ry oo
he
ede
we
ry tn
te
i be My
4
mM
OA No. 764/2018, 2458/2019 to
SoU/20TS, 3235/2079, 3236/2019
3
x
4490/2019 to 4534/2019.
in OA No.451/2019.
in OA No. 452/2019.
in OA No. 4583/2019.
...Applicant in OA Ne. 454/2019.
(By Advocate Shri Yogendra Pratap Singh)
(201 9 to
2019, 3826/2019,
SE/2D19, 436/2019 to 4390/2019,
wy
xt
ra
8,
eed
0
oy
ke
64
2530/2019, 32:
ms
QA No,
O19,
?
za
en
Ay
x
sf
£
S tod
cal
oa
Pa
449/201
BL
4.
ine-c
*
3
ng-
d
z
4
COmMa rnd.
:
a
oh yp
z
mS
Versus
Ly
2
7
Onman
wwe
t
os
Net
in-e¢}
ex
mo
=
ae
"&
EA Oe we
er
.
EL
Oks
Fic
ee
=
pment Depo
station,
~
~
a
iy
SAL
~
Lntbenan
Qo
is
ir
fa
®
HO
Ber
Ce
Ma
oO
3
rar
C3
ay %
i
ced
Me
5)
ei
Et oN fe
R. VIJAYKUMAR, MEMBER {a}
x
*
ORDER (OR A DL)
(By Advocate Shri R. R. Shetty) Fex vee} x6) a sod ot ay Ba 63 sed SS hd cs we 3 sed end {;
kg Q oA $5 oS the 6 "4 he fs cs act % sy} 2019, f 9 A 2 2019 to 4 y 2 y 6 019, 323/2019, 326/2019 43 OQ 2019, f y 3 366 oR £5 -
ot Oh ke GD s .
fi Oui te FG Lda Gg G3 mmf cy 4a 3 WD bp ord be oa . "4 4 ts i a ey HO ex i 4 Gy att + a 2 "4 re @ 43 ke Rp Ay Ds a : > ij tee UH GR dG % GO AD for ce vs te Oh be ow BY 4 wo crs preg OO + f%, mre 4 4 - Lf o a5 ron 5B .en " 8 fo 8 Paes ee GO o tr ot G 8 co a F " * at ¢ rts + A hes ¥ Bsa Bal Fa" oo wg fades eo & whos . : oq RO : RF en as ve 3 g. + s we Uy ry O ma He Ow a a 6 Q wa a a Oty iS af bo = * { a o our. oe ™ yee Be roa hh, So vo © ay re an a oe a) ery 2 a a if a Soe » gay OO GY Ue ety ye OD ot 4 BG cy 4 to 3 MD yy 2 FG Ho ee GH EMG "~, ay SH <4 GS sey OU my fs & mee Go ay wo ss a 80 - mh $3 fs 1 ag my oy o @ a op ed ~~ te i sore $3 4a g8n ons 3 yy eg et oy Bes 2 BEN i at Oo Ge htm PM eGo ba Oe O ® "3 Ge Be ws & ty hd teed try "CS hy "- w a 42 lng OX "Sg 43 hy Oo cm" CH 2 ~~ 3G 2 ee tty Wee OR Sg Boe 2 ee aff yy i 3 ces D oy ff ied care 6 Oo. GB 9 4 43 Sy od pM nen ae ere ; ve it on, a a8 Pa +. abs 4 > e "e.g 8 eo" ee oo ® wea Paget Be gS ehh da 2 : i 7 ho RE te CO WY kG va ky we ny, ERY DO 3 43 Ee tre! % i os 4s » 2, jy OM et kM 2 6 ab gg oy ty te 8 a
- a as gy ir Fr oe oS cy os i et 4 oS b a De Se O48 % ta on i « 1 OAS ch Gg oY a bt woo me Me fe Mt Ra, i , 5 aa @ 1 Ba 4 4 fay 4 @ 4 i af) Ma 4 eG OS i) g 4 HE fe es OG pws S Sm O BBD 4ea& 4 OM oy , a See § vege oA BARR Ns Bygo, Mu re ~ a aR Vet 2 ht . . : ned aes si A © tm «3 walk "oO ti 2, a own "4 OH Sy q +4 e Woe ni nln . wo EP i a ES ge _ Fai ** Bogs is ki fa oo s . oe Re ~ GF ot 7 OE eet oo wy uw ord dd Sty G _ S a mt i 44 & a & 2 my By TH is " oo MN Cs ; CE ag Se ® B® nh ¢ 2 Bowes uy Be Ry ny Bo om @ a @ = a a ra & e ty Ly pwr - fs 4 oh, i mY ne as ei cs 'si Es a , es "4 ns fon 3 we at cp 5 oe SyHoadg org 4 Og pe oS © * vot rj $3 23 Fy seg rg Sy Fw oS x | mt ang PO ft bE G 8 ie RM es i 7 we a m4 Gt ON Bb eg Ao auc Ger, i raj De a & ot Be ag ts. cp tp go th a : 4 BOR £ SUSseR ager as fod heGugigue ghe"" 88 g Rp fe Bes Sb tN TT : 7 5 te ee te Ray pS A NO PESSsh SHSeeSsas see Qa sunUsod "B8ag¥se © > Ue Be TE org ct 3m Pee TT LB Bp © wn "oy Uo f & wee Sm Gt a x om o MS an a Se , SOU Ee) bt hy a t 30 & Bo tre SEE cig erp thy Tp Ou ae tl wy » ek Cay ope try. *F8 te + i) YY by ' oT O TA OO Oy ley te fed ro Dard ved z fi Q eld , ef fed f2019 ta 245;
§ O18, 9 & OA No. 764 i H 386 2019 3f ae 32 202019, 3 2019, O19, 2 2 ¥2O19 to 439/ 4492019 to 454, 33 O19, i oh tf my mI Mead tp . wef 53 a ks 43 4 AY oO oe ay hy g $4 oy St 45 by ms fe j ri ey he 43 o} 3 wo vied tf ft het Ft 1s bf in 3 D red ad 3 ay} ref tenef anf "rd wer a 13 G
a) g or Ad re got chek A Ch a +f 3-3 "sd ot ea.
oO an eq net s term Ne ae ee ne @ £ § cy ita) ir .
wef a 43 019 to oN wy =] o ?
2019, :
O19, 3 i 9 to 454/2019.
i /2019, 326 Q 2019 ta 439 2 :
* a 36/ a9, 64/2018, 4 F <f "
2019, 32 66/2019, 4 i OA No _% 2 Wee HH wy Oy omy OH oD taf ad 4b ny DHE 45 Gk wD © UE at a s| QO ha t @ Ow t% GO G oh OOo Gb eM pS m4 Re AO OG Od OS GO E By He O Oe MN cE te SS EG YE ap a RL Dod ts Ry a Ry Wes Dk Ay ors ot © % Hb 2 BB Ho. 2 8 Bo ae ty a an: ba Pm Om om Bn Mi Goct oy mh a, ad MOD mH Eb yy $4} al] Gm rm Goa Oy Oa MM oop ge OO 4 oD mS & OF hs MO Ye ort Boy ym TD a Bot aS Os 4p Word gH od BB R ®t, HE gg Th te oe be OR, ka ty 4 Sr @ oy PME ga ge SS 4g OE HE 5M SON Ooo Aa os Oa & Obst gy 7 Lg 4 5 eg ge SoG oe eo eM Bm % es} 8 Me 4 ot EE z by ~ My ER cred i) aio Bayo & q G td Yor OT By & OD GRR eg s 3 ed al 1G OB a poy Ot oa 4 pe iad qd SG ope fe 4g) te a 3 45 4 n aS "4 o i o $3 th gO 1 mo oP & 43 sah ml Of ad te i) a a wa og fe & 8 GoM Sg wa ct OL fer to lor tS « Oe Loot Em mg bt ee sell ct Cy ay : St alr aah Cs 43 rt AT Se we ba KS oD ee MR td Teg Be AS Al eg ge & c OG ke My wy ity w 9, Ss a : ol at gs ° wo Ma 8 1 8 3 4a "5 0 vr Be 2 woe 2a al ol Q & & a qt 8 fy Say ord hy Bag ° BOs ~| a) O) vf ac a OS 5 @ 8 BBP Bo gf Oa ST ET o gd Bry S My ; rene ot ot oy" E 4. Ah RE $ & ut nt , HQh OS ef G) ay 3 --| LS aan ae 2° Hig ow ny L ml et | ft | OA My, BS al cs ty "
mp ed mp a Sag GH woo 1 BS a Bi ae of % bt © td we eS na . Bp 33 ; 4 oy, 4 ct . a Ge G Yabas alo} of | YN an? % 8 Ge Heeb ty Gow Ob ay Gl hed Sl dy % hy O Bo ie Nii 0 oe . el OL OF oil 9 Qo BOY are goo gS ra : 1 & ims: 43 me MD Mg ae So a Of end Sg A 4 . {tt re Ces DL try 5 et Cy DA ty, 7 ma g & uw @ os US mon te kl © Oo} Ob ah wl aap OL iri be mS * wo fel ty Me veg ved vf & tS SE YE cet wot tA sh Bi ddiaa im 7G O45 74 Sy » oo @ 43 Piped ra Sa cet OY 40) om Hl CH} we OG Ob Ww ee @ Gmi Y 2s oe om BER OO by El be EA OG a ce yt OOD GO mm Ge Oe a ob oH aD 6S Ow 6% Oo 3 Gg oS wl 6 BH OC) Of it Of .G Gian 4) oo Ge we a Goa oe G ay ky pf fe wR RG OE UP dee psp OF Of) EG] A Om mG, OD pe be OO On ds mn & @ ad rv Q 4 S4/2019.
O18, 2435/2019 to 2019 to 4 oe wn {Se "4 f 'f 449 OA No. 764 19 uf) &F3 g by a d fe " t " re hd a "s - +.
6 & 8 om TH eg ny ° EE a a a RS uj 5 , w o thd Ou & 43 Gg oO i a @ ae es ay tpn ok yi "4 ws, EME YY 4 6 4 BS "Eg ae " : 4 ont a Ne "
AO Sk tO Oo & m4 ple dogg ae J GU Sh a ye ct a ee yg i D bh ed 'sf 4s hoa oo ee by al WL at cy Pee eh hg ed ed Ce OP UE Cy ey 6 . Q 4 a ay o 43 2) Ay a Fs GPR GS Mon fe hy 43 ; $4 " $4 tr % 43 ty Ea And 6 oto tye O 8 « ae Boo OD SS go Ga My SE BG © se a nn a as Be By Hi IO Oo HH fo rippo" Boe OMe gg om Be B® » c & 8 ye "4 6 OE ; i Boo Be Got oo oy OR Oy oy : x 5 we BB bn we § Q Pr og OB ES sod gh OS Bo wg o " 43 a 64 a se » rs Me 45 8 ten hg as Cy OQ . of Heed $3. 43 a tof ~ Pa "4 aed wd 3 43 sg ity ba Oa OM ODM gg wc MG oz, KEEL ce ag as QD ™ & C3 cA 4 th og 4 tt red hd rep org DOE mo ce ke 8 si as "4 rym ae ee ty eo, ~t bese DB OB oc Ay fy boy Ly a :
Ado 4 @ RG 4 we 43 ey Oy ty AB oye! 3 tt 1 oA ad ie 4 ag be th gt ee ay & s fy al & oy 2 we qa Bh \ o i « wg 3 O O43 4 By i rf eG Web a i 4 63, % ¥ cs ms gy yt * 4d bay et ayy my ky oe Cy 8 a ty ae Ja 3 G Se ce By rd Hy PO ee BO ay a G 4 gy ' ES ay Sp ky in Be Hy BO rt oy Ml bs % c ty Ow G a iz 2 8 R Goal ge Fb oe Md ye By A Q SS a ee a :.
ty 5 Soy Ag Ging | " 4 tha o ty se 43 al be f4 " . 8 a, Mog A DY GO WoO oy Ee a Bw & Hig ' "4 a - ad O o Ba 8 OH a MF ql Aa OG © wy 2 ny ® ae Gow mt Dey ae OD bs ky te oO gl rh Dg Dag "EA ae BS Hy Ce as " e 43 = Om © u # al ea Eg Bs gy n Glo a 4 Sy % SS G mim OOS ig Ent IB hy _ o rh x 4 ih % "ty Mo og: . en feegt G2 £3, Bas eg Bg Kee wy al ce i Bo 4 OE wm & 4 $, 8 6 G te ee ty Poa Us "4 a é i iS a 5» & Bes oS Boe Um UB tw pO ej; 8 8 ct a 8 Gq Kg tot 8 B Br eg A CG " Ro! g@ 8 6 oO "oe Oe BO 8 wa o 8 Bg @ a m2 8 6 Ym Bog Gf bd eS G85 es Hoek ees sey v2 3 & Bo > * i EE ey ' - ges 3 tS Ae ys ere c - * 2 r if Si gy ag Borg 7 oy a fe gy Od 'oo ty fA a ; 4 i Ot ee ay 0 ie eS y a 6 & rd & ae a igs o OS a "s wv w te rg @ mC og & GS BAPE STE REE ou oe we Gg eS Gg @ 3 a 2 tort ay O Mo a OS e ct is 5 43 ° S 3 u Gi "4 8 bo oga So he Re + "ny + ; og 24 OG OW Wy & ' "= oe eB Gas re EE Ob y Gogh oo 8 oO eh og Bae seo MH Oa a ay Ae Ww o Pw wa OG G43 ty 2 5 3 ba vd B 8 es i Or Hart be ke og omy by ty 3 £4, ~ef a 3 e ° s Cea Ap Bet 4 BE ey i * ys ° C ~~ O ™ 3 ws i 5 sed 0 wee C a re o . a . wy a wrod "Ge rn mM @ ty y UU ' x3 by hy * &4 Q me add 8 et Oe @ Wd Lo att pat OF fr ty , Box oS my GQ 4 . , aps = is 4 43 ord a im a i wh } Pe ees maa e Hoo 6 8» 9 & oO GS ef ef ee 8 a ; Tee poe + "3 + n me 4 eek ' + r ret % 4 4% <4 ~ 4-§ a iS Ft aa ch Fs o oy on vel ey 4 5 RY on " Vi am G oi a a Q G & = i CAO c w om a yo o G ; "ot w 1 6 id * " ° 03 fod mi Fa "4 D aa] G oot ty. @ $3 ue ret oC pa Sel GRO bog 6 U6BlUm UR OS ce Reed a0 4 of fo as es Tt op Pe BH 44 & a} ® ( Oo ag v e Ci w pa , w C8 oy OF 3 G4 6 G Be ad 4 & a ey i o 4 od CG o > oy EA es poet 4 4 w ard Bh " i M vd ie, o>) * 4 Bs "3 iG se ot a @ tC Sagas OQ HM R a & od Ka ng x Hog oct Se > @ Ebay Oe £5 3 "5 HOU , oO tS © rt ® va so i 'bd "pt 43 foe oO. woe C o o "4 & bs ' a : a) a ice cc @ a o GQ 2 i of or - ) iB 3 apd Shs 2 + G4 O 20) Q a ha . mt ag ao oUy!lCUmllUM GB oe © mm 28 4 yo OO MY 3 ~ rh Fo pg) et G o a i ae ie a wey 0 oO v4 6 0 m4 at 5 Ay s 3 a iD & ee a a a a 3 a Li Re © @ my 3 a sy y *3 4 : i ss ; 43 Oe @ 8 ~ a w g a a wv he ) t © 5, © @ Bh oo es cy fe Cy, he a bef wh ha ra) - tt . co 3 ep i Qo re og oo "o a Gy iD os wg te 2 if a re at C the is > ay 4 s. hy G th 4 wo 3 a ig = et 44 oy Vv od 2 & a 4 ay 2 et G a ad h4 a) B bg a rts ' a 3 4 w * Qf, R 8 a @ 5 £ |B 8 0 6 Fo mB eo G cs ¢ 3 Soy % o if as <3 is 4 at DH Re 4 Ky eo is tS Ch » "i td 4 Ba #3 9) vt pe ; od 4 } 43 o a a ez 0 "8 tT oom 6 UE oo 6 & ned os ' - 8 2a o 2 ) 3 wed ved eS % i " "s 13 aes at a4 a ot i <r eed o os vt t ryt G © <3 a B cna : g Nef \ a MW rn ty u A a $4 ce ye ° D eS ey eB 3 @o wg roy G Ad os AS Med he si -{ g ay ed @ o iy oe G i a " "s © ui v H od os " ie '2 "3 H 8 «i ka a x a ek a bg : 3 + aee4 4 ae * me ' . "
a ao . * a @ 5 3 & fA cs ie % © m @ * o 8 + wt es B u a a3 o '4 £ 2 w 44 Bs wi 8 a 4b ; a "ey «rt ot t 4 z $2 na f ; ; a - @ C3 4 0 Seg a ao . £ @ & mod 8 @ & » BY B Y e eed ay ok ay om eee 4 « 1 me y % vs :
a oe oa § @ oo * 3g fo @ mA a 8 a 33 B we Les p '4 is os) 8 : red » » Gg CG bel iy . vl de. Pet cs a in or wy vs ht a an be 4 ve tt 4) 2 > op 7 od "8 my UW mM , SB re gy r vo », vo B a D Q ft Fg : a u a § a oe & 4 " Bs $4 rt @ oS ga a ; god & st ; 43 *, 2 ia 43 Dy GS on i CC se O 4 sot 3 "3 oO ' 403 ra 4 G ni i 4 Z 63 ad wD ot va 5 S @ 1D . AG} et rt oe ha M4 CY oh rm } ie Fa 62 iy ci 3 12 '4 2 bd % > a a ta tl "4 at y, © ty A 4 Ae r YD re) ny C he 44 ed wo bee os mm a Q G ca wi ea "A ry OUD O y ) "4 4 13 } me wh o G on mE @ ® ® i r a % a n Q don oe 7 a t i * ba phy wm res % ho t we 3 oO LJ ny, fee 4 e od $4 Feat 3 i 4 iD & @ oy ee x c y 3 4 & ai ' bet et a $4 sf 4a B wa ard $3 eed GS a 8 8 6 8 8 o ¢@ © » 8 go BR Hod 6 yom & ; = 5 on : ' 4 " wo " ih - 4 in fog 8 3 b ye gp R 2 9 8 Be ey : "4 " wD wo be t ad ws ah i hd , Ae 8 raat 4 , AA z me iy di a ec bef bt tr 43 a ot ct @ te / rd b4 7 og Rk fe Be oO 8 eB , » & 8 8 & 8 § 44 Ww Chy t~ ee] "e @ os en Me et hy ay $63 mam 43 A ; 3 B i i 4 a Se x ae 9S At oy oped 13 f ap « . au ws £3 oO M2019, 2 f2019, 326, 019 to 439/2019.
;
3/2019, O19 to 4 ZL io ae >
449) Bei aly fi cs "
3h:3
2019, 4 2019, 3 3 2350 G6! » x 12 wD ke Ad be id ¥ COU 4 B eX O g asd B a pray nee SA RAL way te BU X me fe ion :
wpe Seg 4 xy is $2, SSS ek gh 44 tp wy wD ay Mey wo iN et a cn q on in © $2 Qi ig a eee te i ot aoe us oi Oo AS wt a % » La i i ia Cr at at as Pa @ "rf LD rn) 33 4 a ved 45 ved o rt ard 43 we 43 a EN F ot aot "ny ut 44 rt tet as 43 ns Q Et SO oN, @ bi Sh 4 S 3.3 iy My " * ved G 44 G sf a ao Og a % i Oo 0 , rh ay fs BC oO BW w nS i 7: G 8 red vel ° ie goood wy tt & vt ted © f AX Se wo GG 4G ot Egy ts ft 2 oS ay v 43 ® ; oh weed rd Mt Cc ® Be Ma 3 ua 0 sae mth Rg Bg i tr Bg © Ow & a eos eed a) @ i) * g . @ o 4 im ide ® G ct @ G ca ON gt 4 Q 4 ha Oy, ae a 1 o ag m OO 7 B fs :
ee ee © of oa Oo wd i O bs 43 a hy Moo UD a fee 5 w me eS Mm bo Do OF oo Go oe & mB Be 8 GO we Re og : . : My > * "r bh aa TON "4 "3 t3 oO Gy ; hes Pe 3 ' . iN) +4 iB : ad oy Ok pst . o ' oe o if Dp , % A: 3 ce oe © c a o oO i f D @ a sa 0 © "
ai werd ry Ld Sl a of) ® Q C4 oes y p Qo a @ oe # bp oF 8 wH & wn ow a. ot ny {4 Be} oy Ce iO rr be a red 45 weed cond 43 {3 @ ord GS wD ved io oe of Oo Q, {3 ced ct 5 ce ag ag a a a o ee fs) 7 Sa re) 2 "rt om mo om = le ke - 43 :
ory GB 43 ree} mf b4 ' ' ty % ow 44 " i 43 3; 4 + St . 4 MB 8 @ @ 4 bo SM we gy oO 6 Dg 3 OG iy 5 Oy q @) co a a bg o 5 c Q 2 ni ra 6 om iS = 2 th » cs DB a Fd a G 44 "4 3 ha cs p @ @} a QO @ 3H S 5 Sed re & ved ha by ad hy non ct a a 3 a re ° os fet 4 #4 o a o @ "A bt a 2 4s 2 rt vd he i 2 es ry a vcd Ad Q SG re SE UH Eg eS eT OF i 5 ie ! Ct o - bE ged : % cs v ip 0 i. ae) 5 "E a 43 fe wd a 2 Ss 9 wD 13) th wi : : i 4 me Dp ve 42 "% at Soe me OD ne OO ea i ° go © w «2 | & we we x O m4 a aed G3 4 ~ ° ve Sd wo a of a 'B x" as Ms w Gg a 1 ® & Ge & a 3 C3 8 wi 43 ra : Ft nt "4 o % . fed wa 4 G & Ad wv ort e oO ci es 43 3 an Q ed 43 ia 7 a od ~ hE m3 ne sf nt G 4 4 eS ted Me 43 ae . "y "3 oe % a a is a 3 a = mw B 4 ord @ 44 "th a { he iN ng wy " 3 @ o a i { bs ny om vet ig wd : we be & ve rd & w i GB g ee 43 dot oO i +4 4
3 I us as hs ts a w m re 3 un w a) 4 ct hey fae a J D . rs a $.4 " ord Ya ay we + wens on D - « at 4d + ih a4 oF by 3 tg uf kt swt ret on rs) of und ae _ as o @ Tas 2 44 3 4 ny Fd, a a6) fia . wo be wher 4d 'et ae) ty. el c ana wy ra « " ca ad o go et nS iy G Gk ve aed O a ot 5 o ie) i B 2 ved ae My 4 4 it w i a o a wo n a i rl 43 BoM ws 1 og ae a nn ® a x 3 Oo as 4a sod w i 0 J 4.4 Sb qs i} by ag 4 43 i Cy w Q G Mv w , W w & & a oS us th in * 44 w 3) i hg Cc 14 ka * od ce) eg + Bed i 2 vet 4 @ i "ef oO Q 43 } $4 4 a G gi ha om th w ti xg mH o « a vt & HH @ ed et Yq n $4 644 y oO "3 ord or} rd G n w $3 rd "ed a i of us al , 2018, 2435/2019 to e 0.763 ¥ :
Ey OA so Feet OK wy i ws ij 31 rn) a vps a 22 S mm +4 bf Q 3 i e os if wv Ct S g 4 ie nj ob wd s SO % ref a ef O 3 a td 4 im B q Me C3 a ord y on bed a 3 cs ca ge £ « ef "4 ny % y 63 "tS ~ wi a a o G vd 4 gM fa --E Ao es 3 9) 5 a Pe G - he © Bat en id ae wed a 4 ea ee ff eo of at SS Pos gy " } 5 + in Bh 6 tty " wy Cr + @ & G u 2 a 8 44 u 6 Oo & tA) ~o @ *t , c fy vd OG ® @ % Be 6 go on Dm a ro a k n oy ped x po rf © a 73) a we re chy fet wR 3 AS +H @e ey 7 ay ; $4 if i bed aI ' ws oA xn 3 poet " ha * od +3 g "s 0 5 43 noe Mt 3 4 ¢ tp ray a v4 5 t oo om "+ 7 hd so a ct Bed. iy vs '. 'vy tS he D an eS oy @ 43 re ay re) i @ SG eg i % in a G & 0 SBR 4 5 8 4 oy 4 eo 5 f & e fof B 9 2 8 ' ~ <p cod QD "4d 25 G me 4 $ rhea ri fe a oS | fe eS & " Os By gE i ob St Oo or Oo 7 7 4S 8 w em 4 us ne oo ie "cd ye eS es ee ae 4 wD KO t ; bet Sng 4h WO 3 w 3 A gees 3 vba fy iw a" sy wef 13 ao eh iy 0 mr 4 @ weed caf cy i ft aa ' mee ae i Bea ot. ary at iS & 4 se i a " i ie @ o ba ' us i res oO t4 D fe & me OU bY) a o 8 8 a & Pe 4 ay we 3 v3 Ss wD MM 4 3 Qo ord 5 p "es ci BD 4 C . ag On wd a BE xed fs B eh oe ee w i ® oe "4 QO 43 w eon Os a i ob, TA Oo » o mt Pa! v4 . oe AS tas ak "* wt 4 3 ws ee As 4 -
"a 8 ® ». pb #8 nag a Mg He ® 4 5 we Oh, a dt Ja vd ne sd - $4 ved 15 3 ed i 3 ve a3 fe 4 sd O » 3 oad b4 - DD ; aw a i as W w Mt cA & 3 o C3 a rf i a c i a 4 ah . 43 4d C as rt ° el a YD ce; ' xD Ph iy ; i BS ai t ty mt e as 3 o a 4 re iG 43 J wo fe-4 a oe he Th 3 + Bd 13 ® oO © 44 3 oy i pe 2 bed . § if T wD o ° rt t 2 ws Fy BG $3 % B a . 2 8 2 O gy © B go fl *¢: £ tes ~ oa . . = te t. Oo f 2 ws oO " ; a sh re) oD a 5 " Wl 8 a CG C O 4 a) 4 'tg * ne -- ' on / o r a4 al + . ° 4 ® ng wD m a & ms od in % CO n L cS é 6 etek or : 4 i. 1 at el rm {3 © goret 4 ' hy 3 My Boog 2 6 8 HG Ho» 8 @ Bg RP 2B cg BY © 5 © « Bh wD » t 4 Goo 'i e a i 1 wn @ a vd . : ri : @ * £3, | o a Q $4 ; ye 4 , at od fw a a end a rm i be ° iB Md " " ' @} a &> . wc o @ j " ka » i as Ss & & Ci a vd 4 fs 3 . ' 4 ' ea ; vd x oe % a @ " EA ts : g «S O e Osh ro) 43] $4 @ % Ch = hit 3 ae '. in RQ * @ 4 ao 8 2 RB i © ogy gO Og © hd 3 £3 , . aS a ft wa $4 o vo a a o teas ba mo a a ot wn mt 4 43 ts 3 bs 4 4 © 4 a rh, a4 6 o € cs ' % gp om w oh a 44 re BR Me gO on mG . wi Ob fg vet o ua "03 a3 i 4 . 4 a "s " ert 4.4 ip "p ¢ i : oes 4 i " 1 43 th w oh - 4 . a fa a4 © bo th "OS mG 7 OR 4 ae Om RR Eg wee oy 4 , 3 a » mv m4 GB BS os uo G6 « &
4) a @ a) a t , bea it C3 5 @ "rf : wet 6 Me eg i «sed o fs 3 @ 3 mS 4 ne ht ie ut a e. el "rd 3 a ee } ne a * oH " r ' : 4 ba os
5 ff « §& & € S$ © @ 8B Mm © & a @¢ % 8 @ & & w , ; SO 3 Set Pm -@ OQ HD G $4 *g mw i a @ 6s oO « Aad choy 43 Oo hd 4) rt S/2019, 26/2019, 5/2019 to oe +4 O19 to 4542019, Z. om ee i ' 6/2019 t 449 2, 2019, 323/2019 é é 0 OA No. 764/201 8, 24 Q "y 366, eg AY oi a w a So . ¢ o ay moo cy 43 & @ C 2 7 a 4.9 43 co ce) is i 43 4 Ba ray al RS * ig re . " A tS ts 3 M ted 3 bd 65 od cm Fa "€ Cl at, a FS BS #8 & ee A aw - 4 Che 4 bd Sag or O Pe 44 arf wi it $4 owt Go a 9 95) fg wD wf a % wD 4 \ P werd cd ® ft wy Q a Ho o 2 } Ff € O Q o ; 2 fog 8 9 8 fg 2B PNG 4-4 ot Sea yt : "¢ af MG) ; s 3 Oy Go a 5 a mp GG g ny Gg DB H m% % esd 43 Q gt 3 43 QO ~ 4 . ' , CO . ie $4 a a wy 9 fe oo Foy a # : # mG a a | 2 3) iw oO 4 ad beet bd DB fs 4 ar} iB 3 My € i iw np oe rs Sp gk i se) xy b4 @ @ gy Oo ies & Fo ay vet eg 4 ha 4 ce & "CS / ft tT it £4 o 3 . it ved Bp . & 8 os Bg e " fori a ow 33 4 ha 5 EE) a a e 2 od G 43 a ol a ° 8 uy g i At uy oa " : ha oO 3 ea " o & $ 4 o) os my ord " #1 ef os + ct te CI Sch * fa eo GC @ Hw 2» G 6 , | Bt re Bb et ® a ut zs St * % wy 3 wy i * - 2. " £ -
@ a D QO oO ie BO ni ~ je 1 ty eS 6 bs ro ~ i a 5 Bo EE eh hUulCU SR oh a 54 4 O oO i M ms oD 2 gc a np oe x 4 :
Qo w rt o wy ra an " ai "rf ~ cet a 4 n a 4 wm ee) SS ved 5 i a ved ii 9 wn he w at n - " 3 .
ef heh BG i © SG & me & i od wed G $4 43 a a GQ @) g 5 * Go & © RB OS 6 OF DG . : a 3 ae sf Ss et a2 a od O 4 wt mG ' o re re "ed 6 43 BA 4 ae Q 4 oad ior SSS SATII Ii ETI gt ga dene deed wene eee .