Karnataka High Court
M/S Jnana Sarovara Educational ... vs The Housing And Urban Development ... on 10 March, 2010
Author: N.Ananda
Bench: N.Ananda
V ' _ " gay Sri, <;.»a§~§m§a%T2§: 31%-*2' a§2v0<:9;?€; IN TI-{E HIGH CGGRT G2?' KAR3.'iA"i'.5s.KA AT £}ATE1I"j)"1'HES 'mg: mth {JAY GE?' ;\.smR<:§«:' igifrsiié ' jj . BEFQRE TE-EE: HON'BL€L MR. Jiigrzégja r;....T$g§?:;;%;:ss.£i:§é; H C:a2:M£N;aL P:~:?:*1*r::3sa; :~:1;m::<:. ::::£e' 2g«:;;§%A "
EETwE§;
E. %~azg$w JNAEQA SA§%{}'2_;8%£?A £1E3E}Cfi;'FE€;)§'§'fiL TRHSE {JS--;'§f§"'?;., ; ?~I),580; 25% Mam, '- _ i :1 STAGE:, i{P':§LLA :s:;'::3";4:;2.§;,§A:,+.'."'+.._ :1 P. §»:AGz;;;z;'~«:>q:?SG::_QE;~5~?'G 'e§<}8.1.."».__._,1 §2i%::3i€E:S;E:i«-§TE?':} BY' Ef"E'S 1:::2=;.A_?.;§?;j:g:A1'»:, gm s;{,:i'"';:-':;r;+;':s:,,s;a¥E% '§%§§§E3"§7'}*§';' V €22; '_§5§§'§gf§¥§§i;f';ffvS§--l.E§}V'f'Yf, }3:""§ Yfififéfi.
:'$R".§ S2s.::3HA:<;%3§?"$H'E:?§?¥, -- .
S; {fix s:;§_:x:;::€;§::?."$.§{T§:r:**:*3f,' g€;€§;V..55.3'E;;aES;,'* _ ' hé&§zA{2:--.rg'§s '"E"R"£j%';'ij§: E..§~EPR ass: :3 Riff, Jgwjgg S;%E?t§}i?;=§F?A 'E:§U{Z'f&TI¢:'}NfiL "'E'*§€iJ7ST__, ;*~i:;£;x5$<':>, i2€:'fH"'E%.«€A1_?-Ev, 3 gm SFAQE, A '~:<i~:z.--:;i,A"~rgiaHALm} J, Ex Nfisfififi, = --. E%.a'§'::'j$iT}.f<5*E~i«S§7Z{} G08, §\..i 3, ~. ' --$MT; €'§LE_K2'§.§;A'1'A S§~iEfFT':*', ' .__ié»'j€}_ S?;f%',.s:%§~Eg%.§<ZAR gaarzw, ;mE::> 33' yaéfia 'E'E~%?j§TE'EEj S€:{:RE'E2%RY3 .. , ,,s:*4;;§=;,a Sfi§€C?V2%RA §;;">:;::AT::::;m:, !§*:2::$':; _ rs:«s;3.58@,, ::2efI*§ §%.ri.figEE=§, 11%: §"'E:%,<f§Ei, §€;'E£EE.,LA Mzf;H;%:,:,za§ a. R NASAR, ?ss1YSG§€E~5'?8 gas, §3ET'E'§'§ €17} §'%'E*3§3§§ §.I'§§:
THE :~:{>:..:s;:NG ANIE LERBAEQ §.Z}E¥Z.'.§E:LOPIsrE'£§§'»i'§" <:.{::§%?<32%;1'§'s ma :..:'§§3v, A C£}Z:r§?.i§P~§'{ §§'ai{i{}¥<':§3€"}R,-%''I'E§!§ &, ; §2§:<3::). i.§1'~§DEE€ TEE PR<:3v1S§§};§i'$"::T:s;*.
'mI:: CO?v§P'm;'éEEiS A<"::T 39:36, _ i A 1 H?£VI§"~3{} mg: REGEE; €}¥"'¥'i(?:E m ".§~§32.§£§€3.€i§ BE-L%i§fi;N'1 * iésiéza i-+ZAE§§"i"E';'i" {ZTSN'E'RE *Z:{T}§§£?§._PLE=;'><i; ' L£}{}E~§E RCEAE), zmw :">§:Li~«:z ~';:.1_fi C§{}Z§.
$55 LQQAL R,EG§{3I€;%,L <3§«*§*:c§: §:fT_ 'V §~¢EA£'€EP§%.L CENTRE,' _:§~:<;:-?a_§%T:;%: B1g:z¢::,j.;§, WE ¥'L{}{§P%? Bi%£~E{§fi;i;{}E€E1 »-"::E~":€:;3:.s:::i:?'=::i:;;;;,..b REEPTD, BY ETEE Mgnasm, ' . * 'V RE';8§3éZ)N'i}E?é"i"' £83: an. 3 :3 ;x€:HAf§é:§:_,;x, ;§t:::;§1~;.:1:¢:>:2._'s:;::i:::'¥:éé;*§*E:; 'rz-:Vfi:?'s.,J:%§?<:.;sf«i;:i:1;g.V_L_p§:":%?':a:::";«:__:_s is': 1,519 :51 Sx--'§82i2} €:;e::E">,{T; :33? *'E*z««iE2:: 5:3v{;+s::T;<2i:'£é: §%f<j}E€ "i'.Ej§E P£~::':'-i*':':s£33*~:.£<:R$ PR;='~'i'2"E!'%G "I'%--EA'E"
'TH§:?§ %:<3_:~z*::%:;.:§. £"f'.£i:?'sZ§-.%§?"£'._M;fa§7"'--BE?:' ?LEiA$Ei§} -3:3 Qzsmfi *"§'HE:
<':<>:~;::4?;,A:':=a:i:"§:é {:,.;{;:;' .;$.;;f>.':%::3{':s;.:?;r'; 2008 am *m;z: §«'::,.%: 32%? xiv ;::?:>§3:,., {'f;HE§:i¥?' §'yEvEE?E'£%{}E?{§§¥§;>,§fiE'*§%§'4 _§¥§gc2:$?::as;?§:, §vEA%'{} ;~;z=::.:,, :2;mé<.";«;:,;;;€_;1§e2: A3, §3§s:w;%: £?§?\3E:}{é3REZ=»¥.
= ' V 'FE2i7'sl< {,7§:§_;:§§:3a£ §3é§"£iti<::::.2 comiizg an E9: a:§mis§;é<i::: £31233 ' flag?' 1' jfaicazsis 33:3: 'f0EL:>w7i_:i:g:
QRBEE '§'Z§'3s:'s'; §}€§éEi--i}fl€I'$ 931% '§:Izs:::i§3g ma: fig? 3:; §}§§€:"§{?€'f A *:':§}§i§"§K}:§§7'§3:駥C2EEi Tamziaz' §§€i€?'§ii@§} Z38 Qf E125 .§'§eg;{:«::}:3.fi§e {:*:$:§':;.m.g:r§,£$ E883 gfey fihfififi 'Ehe 57%::f:§ in (Iii. ?€{3.3€3{§§é§5f2€}€2é§ an 336 u of X3'? §x,{Z§¥EE*&, Eixiaygz E233}. Bmzgaégzrss _.»'\.
L .z' ;
§'~J° . 1 ~.-(£1 ..L% \ 1?; . 'T§':f,'§-* Ezzfiwé ifiirjszi fi3:':*s }')€f€i§i{)I1 is {;:;.:'--:§;i1__.__£.Es::
}:'c2<:er.::..' , ' K, . 5 ' " 4 if *'§1Z1g'§ ???f'*'?" azfza €'{}E§"££Z}€§2E1§g rim: 131$ }:«;E1§::'2=:;: 3*? pmctaedimgg zzgzgisz' Seatiiimi "ii-7§E§ s:>{ 1;:':3&3 Agra £?§§§.n"if:':g f pE3."1€§€31'E{?:g-" ('sf at:>3':ai:£t:rat_3;::sr; sf r::&;f1"uc£1:m :3? §.C§:3f:;"iV:S '%}:'a=:;§_ 3:2 ' " E3353; tjéizé gzsmaszseaiizzgats arr: i:3i'i:ia1.:3d Eztzfom 4the?_.{}é?22£.__f€e§;<;:2é%fg; ?':*§§m.m:§; '€135 irormggiaigzatzi E:avi12.g ':'1?1.5e_-. ;'Z)"1;fi§4;€?f'§§€§§'¥v; " f:é:':s {:3}: rfiaclzeéuiillg $533 Egan -gféfiignai yrgsaagi "the §3e*:"éiiaz:£i§'S; 31$ patimlengrs hav;e:;___V§3£1i:;iV._»5a Suztyggf R53.'?"i2.Q{} 13}{}:1§§ an a:sSur.a::1c.€ fi1:é%,3T..'%{)Zi1§iér1§;173§13~'€. 'E?i}"§.§,'1"€8fI'u{':fE.§I'€ the 10331 zmci assiil 7e:1=:3% iziiiiatfi ti}:
ggréééfiidéxigé' 'E(1E§'_»£€i.%.'Vii' S€c~'£i0H 138 cf the fiat.» ' ' ' V ' " V T115: iV§:€%_':f§:a~§:<i.;;%{;>a;§i*;:§§:i _f3£)_'? ;3&i.i?;isn$rrs re§?:.§:1'a€.i:1g '£315 grzyzmgia 2:?-sgésiin' éigé '-:i1<%m§i;::;:eii' §}E,t:2;zi{::1: 2x?{mEci SiEbI"fi,'i§' iézzet. the f{3Z'{}§.}Q§3:~}<3. for :~éct.):1$%.=ru<t§:<:z1}' :'€:.9«.:>:.:sE1?tz,i£;§{3:3. scssf' $031; is ggsangiixzg ' af3{):¥'z§'i'§Tii€E':£i:'i?:()}fi %3ei?'aV:9ém 'V {ha §"{€%3.€§ Gffissfi 0f HE§§C:{} igiérfifiiaifggggiifi E3;g§;'$§i>r€, {he raspandani shank}. £1611 Ezasya ggfiéétéjsfiizzga maiiiii' E§t:T:C'£i9:: 1:38 Qf €325 Act": 45; E25: E€a,m§,€& <Z':0U.3lS€§ £03" gtx€"§iE:§;z:§1&m §>';=°0u§é f11r§.E:£r V ':*:§':"'2_'.é,'§T}§Z1'§.§°_ {hat file peizificgrifzfirs haw: mafia at pa3im€:1t 9? Rs. Efiéifi ' C1*§:21f*§é:"~; E0 the §'€s§3:'m{§E::t; :"e$§;m:1é€z:'£ canngi. gkffiiffifié agaifigi 3'\\_'} . f;/L«'w-«5€'»--- ;
€.§.:<.=. §:;€:E.i§.i<;::f::rS E3031 bgfora the £}3?¥;):.s E44%€<:.<<§v€:}=* Tfrib {ma}: anti 3130 béifcraréé €315: Ciriazzinal C0m"'i.$ mom pa§€:;i:::u3ar.Ejg, when {.115 §:'::3g}{:ssa§ fin? .E'£€.TG31S{§.!:'£1£?'fi{}1'i ,3 ;:ea::0:1.$Z:ii1;ii<:I1 01? '£16 §r::z%;r;3 71$ pctmiinga
5. The ifimixaii armznsci fiztar Yhff rfisp€31'id_é:m','=i§;5€>z:Ed._f :.'efu§.r: fhtt Submission that tiasé prQ{:€;i§3~--:2f X23692';s;i'1=2'1Cti<:ri§ if reztgmsiimztizkzi sf {Em Efiaxz is pemiiztxg {.'::e:1'::.i{i%3:'2ai:i:;::;L --. , E3, fiassstiméxzg 'mat. the-v.,p£:3:§ti01:€:1°$ Vzlgggfiiiztézfizégéfi fer :'€:<:<>'::si:"11(:f:im1 ,3 I'€f(?€§4iEf1S'£ZF:'i?E.§.fi{}}"':VA*2}?f: i?i£:- 35:31: is j§:i$11<:§.i*-3;: béiferzi £313 Eéaad '€3§fzs::s, mat. :::.éié3";i::'$: "E7;-F1' ks) iguagh 'fhfi:
j;}f{}Cff{f{ii%E1gS §{3:«€"§,:1~Z=i*E}:'£'3_a§iA§.€ {§'Q'a;:_fi. E 385: fr-am €135 gmzgmség EEi'g§{§. in :?";€:"(1=:r1::zi:iai' 'E3é:4i':§:.*:;_§'<':e'::';' whiazréa are ;:€--"§;é:ara%:E{§ ifs}; fizz:
§€'Z--i3"BE{§.CO'§.E§1S€,i§,_fGi"~fi1€ patiéiazzerg, that :1-mm {sf €113 gromxiisa °{':1f:"iI§. "7E3£:5' '§;.-';3.«;.m:z $1110 éééiisfigieraiéen ta quash the §mcead§:1gg §§€'i'%3:fé':%§£:< "§"E::€3:€fcsre, E {ii} 39% §i1*;.€§ any maxi: "E31 iizifi. p:§::tia?o511i§ ' :$_3.{3:{f€§E'C1iEi§}.};"§ it is ziismigseda 5 333%: