Karnataka High Court
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co Ltd vs Smt Suguna W/O Late Naveen Kumar on 11 July, 2011
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, H.S.Kempanna
3% '"'§"%%§ *Q§%}§f%" $§ §§§i§.?%%fi{§'}%.%§ $5? §é§%§€.'%§:§i}i§:§ E}§§?E§ "'%"§--§E$ *:":-%§ :2?" §$%._'*§ *3? 31%;: 2%:
?§E§§?%""§ "§"°:=§§ %«§{;;:§*%:E §<r'%§,§i§$"E'"§i":§ :<;m»='§;;2 §3:;r:§§.§;f::ié~;§"--T.[[ g%?%é§ *%"'%%§. %~*§%;°;":»?%§"'%¥E §¥E%a §i;§:§§::fE %*%_;i.E%;§'€*2'%§?§g§%§'§%E§5§:'V é T $5:2gag,;§§;:k??*T2;;z;i;2;§§§%§%«;§:: - A % §§?%"§§§§€: < gag é%,..'§.E§§*éiZ :;$;§g#2a§§§};%;:;§:%§§%%:+::;§s;§:s§%i§ ;;'=;':r; §a:§,§s:§§g$ :"':§§§;gM.Ms?%§:§:;<;§g, :31? "§'?T.%_;=%i;i»%§ 23%; §E;§E§%?*é€'§ §$§§;§T'3;~...* * .
g§3a;§a;a;.§§,% §§§:%;;:.% §=w*%§ §%*?:;«'%§%§§«a:i§%§'ii. % % * f @j;"§'%=;*%§§E.i§%§'?
§§%;° figé : 5:: f"-"E§;§%§'g§""'§; "
§:?€§? §£§§i§§*é& is??? va,_§§":§; $3 §:§%«*§&§ ggga §§§i*.:§;%=§.:§ figgg % #§%§§';s§§,5%:';%;§.§;ré'%rai:5§2¢%;é§;.% MMMMM §éi'?;E'=;Z'?. 22::
§.z£§-agifiig «2;*V§§::s§5a€f:::§;a~es;a1:s@;§ '§::§§;* as agaasaaafgé agggg 2;? *:<E§a§:g;§§,@ %;,§§§§§§:a.§§a ggzzgggg ;%§;.;»» §§;%;»:%j~§" ééifxgzéx :",?§%~§ a: %§§%:§§§:€§~§ gafisag §«: E %i:§'}§W€E?§*?',..':¥§@§§g§¥E§§§§g%§fi A' %g§%:%§§t;;a:;5§§§ %§£% aga _:;v:s§%§§§§;§;
_ 35% "§"' R %§?§%€_§§g%;k€ $53 :§2g;§"§~§ fimgg ?;.:";9é;'§£§3*a§a%.'z'1% %;;%§*é€".%§a§m§;§,§' §§§ %Z§ §§§?$§%§$§§§"?§ aigémgszisg :§%<:%§§@ @633 & §§%§§§§E §""§§%§' Q? %é"%§'3i§£§§ §§&%'%§§§ éégéifig 3%: 25% §§?§ 352$ E? sésagé §%§$§ §:§§§:% $3; :§§§§%§:&§§7'*€§:_§éa%. §§§§as§:§&§§i §as?$§"a §?§§ '§":"'%§:§§§a§. zfafiéfiggé %:a;;§.""§'§*§§;§;%;g%~§ izég 's§§§'i§§§§ wéih "3";§"%%§ §§§%%%g§:%~«E§zs:§m§§£:§ £:,;%m;«:%§a§:":aV%;;,'-.:' $3; é3%:i%i§§'*§§ 3? ;?;%§ gaaiw am §'%%§§§§%§é'§: fié%é=:g%§+a:;§..a mafia: ségfzégk §§§if%§§": %,:,§§"§':§%:* §§%.§;::§;%'; g? %E%§?'§%i§% fig i§i§§i&§%'§%§ hfifié éé §%M.;E:§%22%"§ %¥¥:%§§a&§ i:@§Ee§§é _..%g§$§%j§%&V§t,§§._ éi§;(.§$s§:>§§;Hvéggé 3:': 332% gama §.:§:§:; §?*§i}§°§_"§§¥%§ is §%§§?
;§§%§§§?§ %s§§;§%%§V%;§--.: an é.§g2§§§':
"$33 iiaazséggm-~..g&::::-£?;1".;§§és§' §§!=%;§%;,£; ggiagaég, iéa figé gag: mag} mgaggiéfilivv §a.:::€;:*é§'§.';::V§§V_::e%i%':%é:%a%%fi;§§%; Ezg wag %§%'§'s§'§FE§ % E33??? :2? E§;§,$§§§;*~".a5 m%*§:%é$§vv3;.:rz.:=;% fiéei $3' §i§"2% méigg a::§§§%, Eéaéiagaé 9s.:_é%aaé ;%é{:£:_ s;;a:§§;'§;s;§V%°_§£**:.a itaga, .. 'aw ??%""§é§v <駧eE§?§§§*§'%:--E§**:%;.i§.,§§"g§*§£e iamgagyg amiagégiéfif $33: '.a;a;%se%§=:s ';~'=i:2m§§r fié mi fiéa avg: §€€%a§fiE §'% 3% magi %:§*gf§§a _ %€i€';%*€§%§§'2§; ggéé $23: fifié '=:;&E:%%a§$ sf': §é§%$§§%§'2 ?§§§ mi 32%: %%§§§§'§ aaaééagzi. :%£€::€:s§'§§?'§§ :3 éfiifiég ;%%§ flaw gm aamasgai a?" ééws 7:};
aaagzséi 3%?' 3% :§%":%<.§*:=:=;%g:§:*: ggggagézk "§"%§§§"§%§§%,, §:%"'§% E?:$§.§;?'§§"é%f:§ _~.
ffiviéfi §;.:~.?" iv T §?'§% €§':gaé'§ &§2<§»'§5-;g§'_§§%g?%g;:§% A $9 '%"?§@a:§?: 3% §;§=§a§§:a§:§;~§§:$a;§'§§@£% §$§:'2¢§a§*;3; éégg §;:.:as%3%%§?2§§ 33%}: mi'? %:%e% §§%"%$§§%;§,§«. fig"? ééwg Qsaéfiiififi-'--___§§ §'&&§§§§§§":€fi aw Eiaézééééég $3: §§§§ iééé Qasggaiégmt §as§§'§é:5g§'-§té*::{a§'»v.4 £:€}s,.§§§$ fif §§"§i§§§""§§?1'§; $33 Eaaméfi aazmggé fa iéaé::§§e§é§%é"%§:T '_"'_'T "
«- E§"§§%.,%§"§§'§€fi £§:¥§"%§§?s§,§ %:%§ §::?§§;:%i§ja:§" '§:?:;3§ 7_4%§%_,4§:%:§v§.';§:§V' €33:
gmgg 32% flgiéfiiiiiéfié :3? :@§:2§%%:2§§%i'é::sz'«._§'%;¥§?§§é-iégé ?:'§§:2:,;:°:§§: "?%:§§§§§:"aa, wmt $3 §°%':f§_;i'£§~:i:&§ ié fig' rt'*;;V§s*:;§§%",§-;£»*'..e§';?*'es::§ "9%3'*g 13$ £32: fiééa aggeaé égz "'tgs;%3§€:%§@§' %§a:é'$%§: %é§;rs:$§°§§§4;%%é :53.:é;:j:*§.%§:i?i§§1.§§ gsaéégrgi as? ::$%?"* 1%, ~§?§§*;E%%i%.g}'%;;&$%*}:;iA:"--%$%§:%::%:(§ %c'i1:<:§~:":$§§ §§§ §§'é& aggggééaai €%§{§€'§?§ %§'§---:§_é'§m§' Ea: 2?; §%; gafiéag §%.§§¥'§%§§§ 2%: iéwgyg %§::__§:a:%i?§:%§';§ ;:é?§= §:éf:".$?§ :§ $?':fi%a% 32$: igaéémi wag %§§*;:§;*ag;f€;:§**:?§_:2w=éE@s* §:_=?g'5€§$ aw iézai gm égagasgé $533 a g;§§§§$?§ 'V.ié-€°§%;~=.._g:§§§."*.%%é3i %;%*;%?§é"'§?;éV :?s$i%:§§%§ 9?: §'§€§§"§ Ea §§%i%%%? fiéfii '*§*s%§2§%{ée%§:TA "§{:_é:m9&§:V"$.::$:a§§::§§ %§§§§.,§§§$§ éré iiéa mm %;§'s§f§§§ :?¢£:;§{§§§'%i. V' -;ég::c ia;;§*{駧::§ :33 §"'§%§'§"§, %?a§§'§§§'§ as fiaagagafii wag V ii;-. §§;§'§%2§*;'§ §%§%§§§€§§ £$§§§§§ %2::.:§§%?:a%; gmgaésggég E:
§§§>§.a§ the i§a£%£:§ E5: §'%§§'é is: figg fifiiéfifi g3?' $§fi§§%§"§% figgaégéi," "§§%%§*g§£;s§§ 2% §$§ia3§* wéw mg a:§§*§°§§§?t§§ '~~".;:§:£%§ fiaagggafi %§ :'§i,3§§":§"§$ ;%*§&§?§a"§§ £%:':駧%§§ §"'%@§§§'§Z'3§ 33% v._é§':%%%§"%§%:§%§ § fifiaiiifi Wfiéifié? §i?'z%§§ éisgzmaa %;:;:§:'& ?€3§§§%%§ we éf;
%:§":§ éaaaagggf %§§i';§"':%§? am §£i';Z€2i.§Z¥'§'{ Q? {fig msgsfi igaffég fiiflifiéfii 0:" §€§i'E§..§%"%§. {sf grggasaééifi §§s.e;{§§*;§ §'E§§§§E€% §a:~"=§§°:%§ §€I3€§§§'?":%?%§%?"§? %*"£§§%§"§€Z%, ha §é}§°'%§%§"§§$ iésai %% %§§§'§--as%;§~4'%jEr:T;3§'§e«V wag: ifiissgé Es:-i§:@ @3233; gag'; ifi 3% Em: éiifig ::§';*:.§_§§"2§§;% ":=;;§9§g§§."'_4'T ' gfii 332% €§§§"%§%§§§§§:§$§'§; §§£iE§"§§§'§§ %:§3'AA'?%:'§§'::,_ ;i&§;§%§¥;&%§'4%;%s$?'--%;$%"'. :%::a::::~§§:§§ 2% aetgaifierzi mg :%:é,__ 'g§§2e:§§;;:}§::g:§ég:4§g;§=. £$§*§*:;§§22:g am i;%'s§§% ia g §§"aa;§i*::.:%飧>ia§'§%%$..§?::iV:§%i§;i.:'§§'r2§ g? 232% §$§§€:}',. fig §as%%%':$;:*§:§§€:§f:V§':$V:A.§%*;§'i:'-«.!;§2& §%é§:'*-:§-§§:».%§§ mi {i€}$§§%?§§& aéséiéz iésa ezgéézzéeé wig':
%;§":% C§§§?3'%§§'§§§= %f§;;é;e égfiaagfifi %§a§ gzggigigeaé %:%;;4$' ssaéégfiig aaiggaiéy Em §"%§% §" a%f_§_§§ §§E§iE%'§§$$ '$29 ggma Ea gigs; §:§;:"§.§2i§s§*:a*i2:a:§Vé§é:.é'§§:§a§r§§'a§§ {:§§°§"s§§§""s*§2, E3': 532% §';%§"§:a:;;'§'gi§::£%§,-.:?;:;%fggggégia 'iéga :;';§:;:?§ ifi geéi agififat 3% %;%:2'-zafiagri §@§s;:>m; argfié §§§'§"§%§§§ éigg §§§§¥'%'"% ;§§?:§§§:3?:e :""'_~§?:.§:°:'"駧a%:s*§§ %%:% L%§§'§'3%§ £$E§§':§§§ fa" 2% _ §é§;é%;-:z§=;;é%§.%2v-¥:}§g%magig $§.§§§£'3?'§§§":§ fig Eésfigmgaz $5 2% vi:§;fi%'A§§:*%.§§3§§VV¥'%fi;%é%§"£§ ézifgg gzgagii ta; éégmégg iéée gggggia 9' iwigyéag éémzfi iiéé ifiéfififiéé fig? §§%% ggfiéggf §%: :3 SEQ? ééé §%5f§;%§%;§%§% imi: %;%::§ £%£%a§%§ wag gézéfiaé ta §§.3§%;§§"§ miiasgg émggiiaé 3%: 32 ii?' aimk méé §":§§§%§ 53? 2%;-'2%»« 5% §%L§§§;§§§T:§§ iagasrgj, ii; ztgséast 3% §§%§§§'?%&§ %:%§&: ':§"§% §%§%%:§§: §'§§§;r' giégfi mi ?¥'%i:&§'§§ iéégg §§'s;§i§§'¥%S §§"§ i§"§§ =§e:£§§§%§§§ ¥¥§% a:$::§§§V.%°-égzgg §§§§§%£T§$§§§ iézé §§'§:§z"§*§%€:§§ §§";f§f"§€§é':;fi $3? %% §i;§§%§';-%:3§f€§%~.. §%"'§$£.i?%%'§§$$ figrygggfig ;§?§v§é%§§ '%£§§§%g§§ %;§§§ ' M §§€§&§fi§ ?a§§%z&%:r: Kama? gérgééiiaéé"%§'--«%:.%:é__%%:€;:§:§.§ gigéf v--.%%§§~V4 §'§§*%£% wag: §:§"§§ ?§*=% Eégafifl Egg %*:a%;é;§§%;;_§$§§;:;': .£:;%*g:€§ §§£:::§§m:§;é"' maéfiiaéfiaé mg gaggg ;%§$%§@ ;:é:g§s;.%§:g§ %g;;§%;%::%§g%%gsgmgag ifiaéfié $3 §§,§§ ifi §§"'§§i,§§"§§$ gaggiaigzaé --§§§:f§'--§ '§'**3§§ §:*;a€%"f§€ ~:a§§£%§%;r:§, immafiégigig gag: iféa é§:::;g%::é§%%¥;~¢:§s: _1§L;%::~rg:'z§§ Ea §:.§§e;::*g ifiéfiéififié C$§§§§% " §%§"~':§§'§%§§§ §':§¥% gag:
5 §%§§:r*i ifi;:%g%§_u._§<§§s:*§;%':'§%§iaVg*§e_§§':«%VEfifiéé-%:f;'§V§%g§%§§: gr: fig aging flay, '§:§:'§}'§'§i?f%"_'__ é.:%;f§:%e%~. g;a%7:%.<:gg§a§ Efifi §$§§%§ ggmiéggs' c$§':*a§§5§§%§%? .j_§?§ _3"* 'légéé haggé fig ifié gamég iééaa %§§£§§'§:§;%;:& g;;5§'<t2.%;§5%§§'§§"1;%;%%;§: '§§§% §'?"?§§§€E%Z E53 géé §§§§?;§§§§ éi &"§'§:§§'%"f@§E*%:{%*:§"§§§§§& $5 §§:%§%§%:§§§:& éha fééfiiifiif E§2*':§§'2%§%§ai§§§§ :;%§§§f%" §*%%.i§i§?: Vfi::»-§f~':%§§ §§'E§'§§§'fi"%%%§§?E §'§"£";?:"2 $i=§§%2§z"'§ §'?§E%§§€§§ £§%§&§§ §§_'f:»$'$§§.§$§* "E°§*:s% éwgagéfi §€%%§ $3; éwéifiéfifiyé ma 2% K '"--.. '::§§§%§%é%:%§%sa§ §§§§%§ fig §§'E§ %"ai§*:%§ wag %a%?§§'§ fiig égaiéx étéaiggzfisé éézaaa Ea g fgééasgrg gm §%'§% §%?§ £1??? 33% %%§§% u 7%? %§%%;&$%:§§§§§,§2:g 3% mafia §§%¥§§°¥"'§§§§§§'§:€§§§f afigg' ggaaigi g?
V' %.";2:"3§§"§§§$§§'E§L f:**$§*:: $:,§$%*;§%"'$ ééaééaa-E ififiaga §%%3§§E§§§ $5 asa iéza §$;f§"%§§§§§'%§; §€€§§§%§ fig iifie ?§§§":%§ $2'; Ezmg 2%§§£§ 53:: fifi 3;} gtégagfii £3? iiég figiag ifi éaégéag 3 agmgéaéfiig ifia wag $3? %%:':a& §?%§%,§§'%§"'§§& £§§'%"g;§§§%*g fifififiéfii % §£€§§i%§§ Qaaaasgga §?'§i '?5§§§ §1§§"&§§.L§*§' %:§%i%2%§*: Eéaa §€§*é$%%?§%fiE¥§§ 9% tag K$%'§§%'§§§'%§3;.$§§§;~:T §S§§§%.,.§§ fie %;%'§'.:%€é§€§:.z . §§§§§§.:a: V. :3" %E5'§2%§": gag éggfigsgzgé ';¥s:'«;s::§:%;_ §%£§1%C§§i:_;%;§j"'A%}'%2é". mag §"§§%$%§§°°:a:§ aegaégegi fiim 55 §§é?.§%é':;, mi »§v_§§§f§*:2%a§':.é:'%:.;§'~ %£€§§%a?';§ 3% iémi fie §&§§§§ée$-a§, :'%€.§§ é*§3~ .;§%§%§»§§'§E séi §§ V §'§€3%i swag": fé? fiéé a;§§§§;.§§;*:%_:~§';2%;:b§5%a5*;*§::%;;;§ :l€::%s§?'§§a§é%§"'%iisa! %.'.Z§?§i§§'%%§ égfgaé', '%£§§§y§%% gag si§§§:§§§e§I.é§%;§%;1§2 3:%é&§§a:%§j§§§§:§$ §%:&a§e gm ;:'3*:§z%§*%a§ ég §%§;:é;=:'::§._é§f:-- :§'2%;% §";&§;:§%.;:*§«.. "'?E%j§:%;:fi*;' §%j'i%'%:& §:r'§;§§*§ gfiagge fiéééi wag ;%%f§§3g?;"':%%§§s2>s';":§._§%--%§§§f:%"§%:g2s%°$r:£% €§;r§§§§§':*g ég $3? 2% §;::%§5':f_:§e§: -§:%'A§V§i%;"%§§;§'§v%:;2%§«%2%:i;_ézaééaségé Esgéiéz: §§"§§ céaémgfiigf éi wag §§é%z<.:f':>§°% ifié §§fEf"'§§%§°%§? ig §;%==;§§§§§&§$ Em .;r:"2§::g§%:";:j; $ir;g';<:::;;_§:é{§§ § _;§§§%?§':% §%§§€§§'zs§§ :%%':§£§ i:%:§*§g ésaiga ::*3<:sé:_"§¥:%;§*%'é;é §%"§.;'; afz $?§%€%%' Q? iégé §fi$?;§§"§§"§€§ Cf§§'§3§%§'z"§ fiéag L'§"%.§'€;.-¢'.%<:°2§%;:é:"%i:§§_% §7§~§:*i$ $2? 25% £§§§ §§§"§e:*;a§§%ga 2% .i§;"é:;*:% £i%'"€%.§§'§"§§i$?§%;"%§§ §£§§ *:§?%§'5§§ igaa 3 §§§%§'%;%"'E'§ ééégféé 3% ma: §§§§é§i§'% §%g ifié "§a'§§:§§*:§§ 3": §'€§§§*§§ 3% §*:.«§§i§:§g§&§:§& afié £§:§3§§*§§ Q? aw §§§§§§%§ Q? %§';% §a%%a§§§, " "§3ai:,%§;§§§§*2:§%3s; éféfi gfigvggs 253% %§§%$?;§$¥E faigefi $3 $5 $52 %,§§§:i% a;2§%§% §%§E§§"¥$*iZ ifgfi aggééiggiwigzgaggfiag §é3§fi§§?§*§', gae-mm .._m_w.
'"r"
:53 §g:::3:§%§§§§3i, étéaa agggai Sgt fiifimififiéfis Qgg §§?"駧§§"§§, i? am is: §%§§§%% ég $:'§a§°'§$ 3% fig 3&2? ifi am ""§'"§§%:,s 21%?' $15 1%-A5;