State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
National Ins vs Ilaben K Shah on 23 July, 2008
cwa aka m tit 31. ailactrtl. 2331 Iitquélvtt run;-u " zlénfiava M3 " isafl fétcLta'l%'L gcvsqqi, v 9;°6'12;Z'1.3£ 2:u%:;L 2>tLLLom{'L zswl £3» 3: ML gsuvtl 'J.Hl.'§l1ct visa uatsm,-'1 [5trtL°1@53t vimsail email. .
2>{L3;!sts?L2>mru1.2s.xa.2c:o:: vu aka 1;t;.c<1'l 2:taLx:1nH1°aL-E2 aft. 'W44 » ( '3{'L(°b'1.-it-{K ) V . "'V "*l';j,~"i-
( tc+"l#1L&vw1. 'e2u2S ) aoLt:3.a.'I aimélul swla. £123': 2{Z¢t'Li3,3~':£ ziimszvfl d.%'C'fl$ W5 28; wig; %LL_3>{~'31;fll Q29 '3-'v,tLEliQ~<g<t 'i,2L<'4.L 3 d€»fl0l'1'%.lL[T§,r% =wua"L Met 235; am «L211. Ptzfl [P+==,LLe'L~u T[?+..cc.-->1:."l«1'L =3LcL'1 2'§MLd £9 E *$'?.r]&[[%r]. €t«tL 'v;*L2<{L'5,2:('L 2S:»§Lm.«1'1 nsetlgg zziél
--w1$Laé't2Sn iilszflzii émi uésetl "cs'li§[riL. am Ml ?.'f<_Q»{lcl wk vuvq ?.l"{.dl~1?«l'l.
[?¢cLLe'[s-u F¢{.q.a1'1»{1 =:Ht2'l emu Mvq 2?Lq'l 2~°g:2>u:1 2§ E: [3l..'£r'L%.-91, ¢°.'1qLa.-it amvcl 6?: 2__mL,*1«3,e~a7r,l- 3;s»=1c1L~1'L gs». siet 2% $1 aim M51 -*m{'l vmfl 3£'i5°L E :fl2+ts'--l~fl ?u§[sc§;2Si1 vinahil 53¢ i§L..1{O,OO0/-- rfl era 2%. >»u9L-:u qa cmlati c't.v{{ bu Iitc-flailwii 215 sénzfa 33161 rt €129 ci19Lw.r'i g1.2,uocz:-- Vfl'-;'rC3l23'L <>i'L»m' M7133» Hiha 23: alien} 2: r:.\.2;m *1.oIL sit c1L.:m.a =1,..c>--e wit t€Ljefl.a<.'12tI°z?L cflimzéu, Etvfl ?{£Is€¢s3H IiL.c»I."L2«t'1 aide': °a?L SMS 2541 mczmm am cit 31 gL.u'-moo/-- °6 vwfl at; c's.«LLa'L amt? Mi 2431 Etvwivil zégwuwt zmeivmi &.2»i'L£x a»mL2'1 mat Vqlfizmadl cu.22.<1¢1.o~4.T efl cu3.<1.=t=1M.oe[ vfl cam 1L'u;a'12fl avg site. 59 £1 '*3-l.,L:.l étcni. [?1.£'m'1 % 3.1l.--'t,'t~'i,E=8X.,'f---- 42£1LL5l eL Ga Emi 0§:L_ Q6 [§L°LLE51*1Li3l.'¢L..>3Lrl'i'1 1>LL'§',§2>tLr'{ Hm uummi 2>uE'.L 93:, Na fattvflscx é.a'ls<13z W3; émi ML [3L<'-Lta 2»'LszLct: figa §:?.¢Ll1lt?i am £9. Evefl "(I-'*1 gm saqtui M51, £32.
Ifiiqxa zsiw: vitgz 3v.qLH.i we'; :3». Fctouél aim §u+t'1:3t 1:1 silatsl-'t EH1 Mlzééa u'La'hfl bial 2$L.'1,'t8-,€3'6'/-- ru. <~ra€t 3_'L.'{Q.,'{OO,f--- ( gfiuu oucm «g.=m uilaml ) «'."2rl".|.E.~".Lri cm'1t»t2fl mime gang am cql zyft <5 2&1-'ti. cw; 221%: «mu .§sxm'1 ,cLLflM2L'1 2 '?:{3€LL31HLHi 3;--,a»qcL1. f3t<umL mi M51 Av? g.3=u:2¢LL=e1i zmctcit vtzfl.
Excuefl ML [Ems ma W'4[L~il M3,. _?5L,'€O_,OOO_l-- ML s2Lc'L<t~{ C9 .901 °ae1tcLcm-§LtS, <1 2334. 'mu em 2?ia'm'1 ztstaefll vuvfl :'xi£i61.1*a «Ht (am. 5?: alz?
4défiléfl 1+'1:.1<u eat 24-? é':L%."~4|:l.8:6i<{.l."ll'7~"'-:1 €1?>?L'{l_ mg. gqtal bu wléi-g =2»'L.ss 2.-{cm ztaiéfléa dL.'l~3.®.OE -1L im Mtita Q, '13: bu-"1 at? [EL.§m'L 5:' gsx aim 2% E1 thou MR «mil £9; €mE%~1'1L raw zzagwu M123» 3; fiilséufit "4:L.C*L'12{1, éictl '{§i&fL cftm. _:}uvt"[»1a. iwsai q1%'{~at2v'z wtiia $1 >'e»i5HL 51.2? '*4 5213 :;.212ue.~u sfimi 23 aia rtafl. cwfl cilvu éwfl Eitru Ma, Salsa: --(3'>lL5t"L 23ml. :»1.[E2m>-L (Em 2»u'=u=«. 12.1351 Q9 :1 mi-$1 §L.C2==u<?{vt 2315; £23 ¥¥:L¥*'l'E.rtLfi_L'i:%i1;*{,lE;*LL sumi vg a2cu>+.'L mam wiefl am; E1 §L§a29t $'mt aw dutfia new ml. SL241 [E1;.:?n_»'{ <73' gau aia. ® 31 «riton MA rmzfl £16 an [Ema 2-a; ésQ'€l,L [€L+'LI.?1.:<'2 eL Q. 2:. [E1.cu--zrfl 2>{Lw.2"1 §{;tl5lL?{l_ --cu»t€t «£31 u&L3L2'Lvu RLcL.3fl:=»{t~{1 vftfiasr -Fm:
am ec{lt«D. uurmi cflitet £9, snmi 3.32; Lztim' 'E.Qttl3{"§l ML?-'L ~:«L'1%7L<;~L 99. c1 {3xmt'1 wu:>.L umafla Ha 2&5; we em 2% 3 :s2'Lrua'L~11c'L-u a2a.t€?see E152-$L:'5€_ =2io'1~{1 % ctsefls -en.-fl 1>t~3t Etzfl am 03* 1J:1$LdLé.ct'.I St 2451 51 {mama $w+'iaca;cuo1La?1 uéc-ti 19 mi ma mssm-ail Eivfl. "fit :_§;m"L €9c<;«Li 2 qnia4.'I ~¢21ta,La"L Iftstcu am 815:;
°2_!l3LI;'£@ aakilla mtfia :5. Hal &€lLLLa'1 Him ®<~:~Li 2 cwhl -'cu cL::<¢'I¢~a'L 1{L€L:tL eh Pig «H1 at} wig I-'URL $1-tril ictm ?L2>$Lru Wlvtet {s'L.%a2-1L m[<'=-utm Eiicuq zicfl §nsS %* mm 3; mai gmcfl Lwml amen avg szqwi =w,€m «an § '%°1i £.«:;*tauz'1 cflimz. 24.:2cLL2S'sc«. évftamil i'9c<1i 2 qwizil uflsuu «am 2:13: ML ctseflarfl ssflmsl q"D'+._e.L:a[r't '?&L'§L égrfl L=31a€¢ 3 uZ'Lr.fl2{'lv11 met ri.'K('t) uutpl 'CH3.-'!..Y:L2:l 8.-{L mqtfisa sflifmvfl c_Lsc4{1$ 2431 v°arvam21 mil mi wax °zrLL2L'1 "2?L23~"=. cflfiati EL-11 13.$1a::?t2S%t~{1 mfaal whdlzfl ?; #3: rtL.2'i..'{'i.OX vu. a'L°x cfl't'1c--L f9 9131 §uLt1c--L :3. fc'tcus'LrtL [?+.-m'L~1'1 acfla mLt§'L it n£1¥ta.R3t Cauitssn ctzmils mi 2 cusiul £94 at it aamqz ~§t2~u'1aa«u KL':-uL°a§ 5:13 Mel cu.m2.o"~L ail "{LE9'C-tl -2 cu»? auet'Ia31 (CL cu..2.=12.oa vu 21% $Q'1'»LlE.'v1~'22Ll rtsr.-fls 3»-ich '?z§L1§LctL ecu M1 ificii 3125 gztcil célm .=}u«{1wu eta-'1em'L23't [3L£?l%°i mat 2+ 'wail Mai {fitcuaru wmi 21' 3% *t%iL Ewftrxt {iv-La. itaazjj sag Q 3: sfmtafl E 3 ~rt%[1. sum, 3: a2'1=wa'HL q'1=u '-L\LC1'I%l'1'i=f£,<<'L g L.'«LC:1,'OiOD/_~» vfl Q3 :v1aé'L ?s 08L s}'uS1+§L 2:1°eE:air=1i s2'1tus1-'-1 (atL2'L§s:1§ séxsfiu =»i3L §L+Sm2L WL 3-L'5l~C{F'~LL?L am 611 P1 _y,Ho,oooi~ + _gL.a,~1.<:2e1~ -11 sc'1&§=1 oilrm flm get gL.u2,uoo/-- «lie. Q gL,a,<1a*,e«3x/- Puzfl £?:L.:s':2=H'jL Caufitaa gs:-i <;g:LmiaL été' SH 22 s.2cEL °8v5a?x.
Smirtl mual mat am zvggwun aixcil £9 3; Fcuziiaix asilmél mqxeisa éfivfunz 2»i:?Lru 95 v.i'L';=>:L2;{Lu.'1sw.L éxtt 2:191 8. axis} 9+ aamz éwflaaj. $12%u°§ 3L2 zég aviet :39 am {=Z{1*{L'E.'1 '<0 qsiail bu aaalsiaxl ufmcu édl ac; °arL3tl3tf:l Q €'m'29.:t'L ma 3 2'lzusfL ctz$2L'1uL,aa.a9.o>: vu Sm' 3% sjscuqia e§m'1a<«x '<'L2-':9l:l aw. 5L': aéisfia maize. 6 E1 vgg sum 2?: Pt mt-"1 Emi wet °a?L sqmsl 20 <'«l3>i;t_ 012,51 ®c~<+i 2 L ulsmt aim ch wax $Z'1lLlE;'l °3t ?H1.='t£|,s«:?u§vL LEL¢fl2{1 ctt.u.°m.o:r efl cLt.z=L.m.o14. §*1'j1v{l c{1?4.c-z 2?; 22191 E1 Witcflzfl r[l.3.2,'i'1;O'--I. efl <tL.2a..u.o--§ ggil eflvg az--'L<4.cmtiL vzufiea. 23 =.»=L+'t *>:?u. szlntai :.>uc1s.ef1s cu.2.a2.o.1x vu zftvzr =1 sam étexflacml otcuqcu om czufi Ft-1Le1e;1.LmL'§L €9c«a'i Q €t\i%{l 'fléldl «slat rfit. um d.LZ..'R.0'-t ru 1ui9tn~u zit cvsi :>LeL'l=3t ct'; cu.2.<12,oa am ma E é,=¢51aLts.'1:«§'m§r:-0. ='{é1a«c1éS'31 Ifteilzfl *2' <u.u.=m.o'7: ru. 'Sm citfia Q? ?t uéaial FWEL aou 2,LL=..'l['é.§'s dfififlfi?-$1 qlstctit g.;cLL niiaé E am «mils ?+§is.é'¢sSH 1iI.c~f12{l-fl awi Lmuéi z$L_.asaw;?L Ml met ri.x(1) uL=+u§L xii 2?mS12ala_L =>u3u21. V[&.$?'w'{ zru ;é,_éla<t 'tLuv,mi riflfia -1 £125 Guvfxad §§s,3'{ nggmicit £128 r'Lv'{ as szcit 9:?Li5?3t. E1=»1'12?{ 22131121 %lH.&i. €t=»iLrfl aicflartt %l't35.*1*{l cs.L.?ta,.e.oe ;; it amqzz éwilaagi oflog 2La'i$'L's2, ivggsam @L2,Q Pm: &=2'tm:£l~'1 s.«2cu*v;i 3'-*l{5l.(jl cLL.?.2.°n'LO'£- efl m.m.a1.o~e vfl 1-EL.e{1zL'1 2;; sia £9.
u. an &L3+.*tl_ m=+LcuU.LL =3La€1 3 art ::it=+La'lrtt £?=L.c:,afI-fl Switvfl <?t.[*3L<t ea"1c+"'L={L £141 Q."g2»tLr|. :39 E: 32'1'U.l;*a'I 20 qsieil wig ui1g@c<+'L 2 sJL~s°L2l'Lm =>J.L€;3 cl.-§7€.l?. F'l¢JJ.?.1§t &['3.13;l-1,°L°62'ld 3._L"K*JL, axmatcue. 21% [Ema vi.:e<:e 2.oo¢.
*1. til -1aLrLc+2S«azi1. gal.
é"t°es'l.2>L'i$'l2I{ ?.°z?L HLvL,§L.6vgv.d'1uéa gee '°{1'<-;§1'°L,<{lGl;£+ 2?'Ls, cL§L's;u.
9.. éziém am ztcfizilas mu. ell.
as, 2331 am, ssgt m1cIt.,~'a«:Lms Que} mu um, rtqivtgzl, «am.
my .. Etqtél éieuét-1. 3$mL%S me.
am zgsz eimmfl, %+:, with «mi, e.tc+'L.a, °a"1.1!i=£HéLa .. HfEt[3tC{LE.'l s'm,: wzala aft 2%. °zfl. m'1,u;guaz1 «$l1~'t<fl<1'].'lL.<3.d 141. $3.123, wwzfl >3'tscfl§a : [Email (£23: [EL.q.>3fl :?m;°%.2'L<1'd ulafilqtsfl «Q3 [EL.cL>2,L'l 2?m.2A=:1V.a::s2 Lgan : abut! L:-Elvu'<?1-1 Iil. %msS; zt<su.»3¢'l mzsfi ) <1. Czuitsa Fétcus {?LIi=v1ts,LeL °2s'1c<--u owes cum Ft<1l.l2EL 571211 %l'~Lv3i gum 2L'1a <s:fl.=+La «{.ax~<:e/o 5 vu zsuniui m.u.1L.2ooe vu in; 281:4. gauztl «um: M 91; am~u2u=uc1w1L2&€L aitaét Er vhma z¥+2aL'1. g;1.cfl.. :€m==z: Szzlézn Qieet mil-alasak 336:1. 99.
2. <:2'lzue.~{1 agmi 'es'1'scLv2?u:fl :3 3 .%2'tqLzi1:9¢ %{LHLClL."1L -lama 5+2zEL..:g.a'1. utmil 2-is Mlséméa u'L<flo.{l gL.LLtoV,ooo/V-- -fl m.2m<1.cx an rLt.2'l.'1'1.0"i 2_;Lt{'[~1'1 c--fit'1.c»s.. mu ~$L<+1aI, cL[.2Q.'i~'1.OT1 2&1 d.l..Q'l.'i,'LO§ zyfl. 2°1-3 maqmi wcia, .aré'l2-wa'1r't <u.m2.oxL vu 91°23' 'ft iscucm émflaani 2L2cuiSsc«L &3i"L::+2 2£t"o'zvi1 mica: v.»uucu=+.i =>LL€La =»c--% azu v;51~?[ H2': 2;. a,rta,z3':-r/-- etilca. ML
2.Lsm'=¢'l ¥~u3.C4.[1 =2.~ia'Lru uziwfl Q.'$°i aluxqcu mi qwami cam §;-ruil amt s£~'Lsé§H
2. 'L%<i7l L¢t1'--*tL $11-1'113tL szltuélrit 2;s:'+2S=+ =?{qL auzqtaz mafia E $2(I?«L1E:['C§'4..?l.3d c1.3:!3:l£»';'iL3'L%L'1 ~=£17+u:~t'.l '-l'LC'fl%l"1,'C:l.cLi uéexi uutcu mu flea l~ q1=u«ihL'1«:112{L éufl qvtfi '$11'll£rl?~:t:&'{1.@1{i1.5d. §ll2(1[:l8--dS€fl§3 axis'; cilia s?1m,'1v'i, '°&I2LL31a. rim. 3:191 F1 "271-?t_ 53t§13£§t1§'~{ lftdlzil cflttt 1&4-LL-1'1 =>u E--LLfl,R£ (£55613/ilfilv »_.s3Ls-S EL q'lm.vfl sum ~i.2r(1) 'élHL?§l ziiacl 3; «£1 2¥ts.:5I.2_é1oL -;s2L.sS $'2'1?4LLE:1~3{. €t2»€LrL_: au imvfl amen: rsiririt 3125 Mai mL'L aé vzfia, "wail *§1.L'2L°6' 2129?: _';?fl?-1,L£4.,'l?3i. (3'{€l£sr1. ézfleue lEL.s'Lv;n %i*+&i 21% 53:1.
f5L:?_m'1 é'p»iLru cL1R§LH'L £13; °essm3L<1€s § Qili-liLCllUL£2;t sa.'1aua'L-'1 ?tQ'€L"EL fsuvfm aétén. aim tits:-L'L2+Z1 C:i,rti u£2c1'L~{l nsgcails 2»i=>'t-+31, sscft 212% 3: 312:1 *L.2r(~<L) wwit ul a?t3:aa"L22'l<>1 mi Pica 2:129:21-2 .a2l»u.Le".l-1'L aéufia "'Ll3i'g'2 siex E9 91 IBM 2&3. «ma rtzft stag. 3: $2Tl=4,vzfl2»'£ °?s ilazwé &.L§ my 3% Mi é'm(1ac1<=1LuxL:$"1 £s2'lzLL€l {3"Lil3'd. E<?x:--m.'124'1 2.0 quiet], lilsuu e.m iag °K'§lL3LC%. twig \us9tr1sL"1 91 °zr e'mflac¢:¢LmL2?t EL1£Lw'l («La §_{ftL~?.'1 szlqtal Cmzfum f6t'>tL2'l2fl 20 cvaizil «J22. uég; a cuieil 1't'LsLcLL eat Fit °2§tdf:i nits 2+aT¢'l3;a 9*tL'5{Ci :59 24% an uaizrléa 3214:3122. 2mucuu1L:»€L %{'H8t um 23 33:1 3 wig ¥tLHL€{LUll?5t é2'lz.u.a'l~fl (suflsn sc3{2S=1 ::z"LLL1z"L %4.Z¢{l%3!:€:t ifivfumvfl m -cnizil '+°fLsLcu eat, Em. oxefl rm-igz Tfiifl Q9 r'; 1i:L°<'-l-317:1'-§'.'**=l',i'~{'-'1-*1~%L"l9J£.*:t cilsu s;Hr{1v'1 2Qm;,=L3,§»_3'2rj~ -L:
astvu ~=?%l!.°6 2i[§;tt gaqcu gsa .ei«<1.
Guiud fJ5§LE.t%l'1 ruin»: eL2S+'t ii wtru HLHLQLULL 2§'1ac3L % r7t2l*t£<£- i3v&i4_?L.5§.C1.'1;23. 1>1lA[5L€Ll£ sic-L £9'.
3. ML ffitcwavfl aw-n'1 ggrttqkafl cmét 0&4': uatatitvu [?+.q.a[[::1 sstvxi Q. [3tcusIlrtL E3LcL.3fl-1'1 z':u;2:1Lct v~LL«'t>'L'L <{[?{c¢ €53 c'm°x :amL.cucr1H1 [3t.cx.--2flrfl .<"¢1['1"»L<t
2.c+'lcé.1 ci=+Lt2LH1efl?{c1L 23».
'A'; '[EmLs~1ru EEt.q.2;L't-{L awgvfl mat gm 'Z§%tlct ?.;iCfl £9 E ["=¢.:7'm1 $2'lzu€lv'EL ss<='tsS=~L ¢ig;v_ aft 2131. gm,<1a.,eax/-- Q>t'{t.3{EL ti St e§$m Mr': auva