Maruti S/O Hanumant Dodanni vs The State Of Karnataka on 10 June, 2010

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Maruti S/O Hanumant Dodanni vs The State Of Karnataka on 10 June, 2010

   ..... 

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA. 
CIRCUXT BENCH AT GULBARGA ' '

mrmza THIS TI-IE zmm DAY 09 JUNE;;"'2§'3.;i. (}i    _

THE HONBLE MR. JUSj'I'I€§E B %;zi$1:~z<r{;';:w-%%_%__% '  T

CRLA. NCL848 6141*  2006  '  
BETWEEN '   V %_   

1.

':\/£ARU'I_'I, S,/O HANUMEXN1'E_)(;)';3ANE\T'L _ .. .

AGED ABOUT 25 YEAIESQA '-- I ' occ. AC§RiCUI_.'I'URE,H H "

R,/ATGumyuzfz'a3Ii,,:,{AGE;;; % _ TQ. BASA¥7£§KRg§;,?fA.N:;.

DESI: BIE?£%3E<;... " T " A

2. GLEJJA13£3+E, W'/' Oi_HAN_ U':"\é"£_A§S3' :)C1f}AN3'€ I;

AGED: A£340:mA;raS";' 3 GCC' H€_§E3?SEHOt;VE:), 4' "

R/AT CxLEEJ1){;§R '£i£;§,.A~:T»~'§E"L TQ 'm;sA\rAKA'{,YAré;

' ' ...APPELLANTS =§i3}*at:* sm'%SA§:*rQsH Bmmzm, Amxz, FGR " ._ {says "B.";::;w1§::§3§APPA AXS, A.mr.,;

Azém ' % AA'§':%;%;E: ;<:§':'A'i'%: {E3 Eis?x§€E'JA'1',«~'¥&{A; _ '.§7f§A'£E'%E{>{,§{T§'E=--E "§_'E*§E<;": :v:;;>;%r*x:':§_';x:ga :»><.':m_:::a E ,, '~ a,:':€i§:.<':§"j;f:e§.=§,y In é'E.:r«:?§;._.%,«:'; Imam V' T. V' * _<§_;::Se 3:' the pm:A:<;%<t1,:t:i<.>z': :10 ihga taﬁkreéi i.haE:

AE',,'§2'¥.?'€} :j»_2v«:é_;'i{§*5;~s. pI:*_£{_}2*' ':13 "§4§.é%,i€:{>€}3 211116: E:§1:2'ra=:;:2'ETEf:_{;%':' w%1.iE€? ihsay 1-',3 5s*rm*1 ow, TQ. :;3AsAvAKA_1';m.N. DIST', BEDAR, zszgpv 1&3'; 'my: S'E'A'I'E PUBLIC PRQSEI1(3U'1'C)R, €;)I~='F'ICE.i OF 'jF}:"IE AD\?€)CA'i'E: GENEERAIX.

man caum' £mL1i)1r~s@. . V BANCEALORE W 523:) 003.. .,.RESPo*r€;13I:;:%2*3§"

(BY Sm SHARANABASSAPPA ricrgpy: " k 'V THIS CRLA. ES E'IE;.EI3--~._UE\II3E3R SE{Z'I"'I{}NVVVf%174('1}.V"

CR.P.C. AGAINST THE) JUI3G.MEN'I'"'I}'E':»i238/'29.,3.2OG6 PASSED BY THE) ADIDL. D1__ST; _é<;u_»S.J 'B.II_)AE'§., EN SC. NO.E38/'OiIL AND EZ'}f'CQ§ " " ' 'A "

Tms CRLA, CO1\§'1i§EC§."_ Q18: H£;AR:_1\§cn THIS BAY TH2;*c0U:_2*1*:;:»§:;L,I_v1§:;;2;g::s i:j14%:E: FOLE,-SWING:

,'T£--"--h«i-*5jV'appé1;2A.i Eiiitéd' 'by... $16 21§}pEf§§2"iI1'{S wh<> aria §msbém.€i ' 'a;:i~:§.V:"' V;:::;§i.[%.}%i1"--.ix'i~isms' :3? iiiw d;e<?::=.a,s5€(§ A_I3r1;1p§1:'é':.:;; wEf:0_ <ﬁs:€i'«;"§:':-a 22 §"€S§.,E§§ , <3? zﬁicggetai §"12;:.;{3.sssrne:3_£", t'ie::s;:ez;:.:+:{;:d_ AA.f%l§;1Z1&E.:p1.i£31.21 was n1;m°i<=:::i ix; %.he '£E_:*sssi: ;1p§}<:}_§21:'1%:. "i'§1£3: ::it2f<3,r1<:te <)f1;.}1€ zzippeiiams bei;z'1g (ms: of iota} dcssnial, thfff '1em':'1<§>£.§ Se.s::iC3t'3s-»2. Judggje. re<:01'"<:1€ci $1116 .'$3"E.E}.f'.€;'i1(;'.I'1i1 0f the a'pp<::1ia.:':i:s;s 1m<:ier E§ec::é:i<>::1 SE3 Cr,P.{§. e?;t:u3{;i._jé:zj,"[.<3:' h€3z1ri:r1g;; the: pr<:>sse3c:'1.:t:i<}:1 211115} 1:.hc:>. E-E,pI;3<3'1}£3{}'1{'.S:_.éC'E'1wi';'f&§'E :}_~;y= _ '§Li€i§§II1®11i. daietrgi 28.8.2008 <'::):':vig:f.Vt,ec:§ t.E3\.<{%"a;p§j:s$IE'z?s.;§1_i.$ f7§:;1*"'V {>i'£¥3.n(:€és Lmciel' Secztion 498A 211118 g3QF3 rjw. S{?t{?"i':i:{}1_'1 {PC and :es<;*,1;':t12:1<:7:(3(.i =='}"1'é--'<.r_I3 1.9 2 sz,1:'f'é,'£;{ '...,;"ig:C§r0i.1;',=; ' im.prisonmr3rm: far 011$ year ~§§':P?i¥' <3f:f5RS'500/~ each and .1211 ci@f2:u.11t.V '4(3fL'vv:é';1§:'3f1€;%, ;1't':2:ii 3:10 u:'":c1<:z'gG RX. for Ewe 11a§:':;§}1$ f0'r" ';;?}:j:::% '_ Sec.'{.i0:1 498A rfw 8e<:i.:1i:>:1§t.». f'."._ﬁ;i'f'1".v.E"'t§'<*~,'>:;":'"$§¥:*.1'1te?::1<:<2::i i:hc3..r1':. ti: S!,1ffE3i'f_.R._E_ fjgg:-;;f:f_i:(;»{_i .' each and 'i,{} pay 21 ﬁne ¥~Z:%;-'£ :E€§f27a;.;§"?:. (3? ;:»2+gm1<-:z'1t. 01' fine and £19 5;»z":i"£'a=~::":"i7;:u1;:"{'4E1éV:'* %:::Vg::»e:"£»:T>d (sf gix m<}:1%:hs {;':::§.{I§'1 fez"

?.h,»kT~3":{)fvf:€;'Y'E?£1€ mi');E£&é;f___§§€<:i;i{3:1 3&6 3"/'W 5§€;'{3§ji§.()E'¥. 3% §F'C.. E3; is ' ,'g§"§i:?-3 '§v§ii{Ef:§EE1€:§E"J_, cf (,'.€,)=ﬂ's,--?'§{§§]i{',)E'} 231:2? ss;€§}¥;€::";(:::é, w§'1i«:':h £5 é.::'*:d1e%r zip-:3';-éaiii in '§'.h.i§3 (321339.

}"1(}me;té and '{.}'1(3I'€T£i.f{"€I" 2:1 ;;32111c:E12.:yz:_t.}"; was-:5 hcid. ..-5"'%.f3'.£f._r thz:-'r ;>e11'1<:h21yat'I'1 first 3.ppet1Ia.r1i: {..O{)}.°§; t:}i"ae t::ie:e:;:v::as&ses€i""1T}i:s- i:§$ hcms;e.. Abimt. four to fiV€ff (iay.s 'L'hf;?1.'t":*c,'iff{;'.fI." ~f. Irti.<': }:ié:f:%(}é1s;é:%{1 had E'a1Ee:1 mm i;.11s:: \x.«-'€11 emrci I:121gi'6ié:%i:i. 'fT'r1i._=:s. $§fvi'i.:2<;éss:e;::".«11éé;:;3 been crass examined by the. ciei1:%:?;_<:%::_V23'::'1c1 it-.is' than 3. falssa C2'1S€ filed 21.i:i'i»z3.é'{, tile 21*} V 'e~}Eémt.é;é eiiid fzhai; V ., V' .1 _' . :

her r:1aL1ghte:2r had f:»£};}::::1 iz1 "t§,I'1e:4:,1:4é1}._ wjthé)i;1t.""t01er21i:ir1g the 53t<>rm1C}:1 pain wh1's:::h1£;sL1ggé:é;t::i+::>.1§."h;a8_'7:3<:%s::':1 ezienied by PVW 2.

6. é13'..:§igr1.;n:§'1*yj"i0V"E3X.P«2 p21:1i1<:haI121'm:c1 and EXPVEQ éi:'£2::;i.::re @311';£:'}f:~2§:1121n":;i§'"" ?PW,4 is ma: sig?r1ate:)y5; ':10:

the ii1--qt1s%st. .:*€'pt§v:7tf;'~_ 'E¥W,5 is iiicsc iiocttmzz who 'K2215; {:<mC¥f§1{:€.e:f'~;:g{§:§-$:_:7:":{}f:ii:e3ni eXa,miz13J;i{>n an {fie zieaxi bad}; 211:3' i<x;a;s '~-ss;t.21t.(:%<§AV"'t;7f};:l:f£; the deaih is due '£53 1"<;*.sp'§rz1f0Iy 'E%~:t>.i.LEV:;:::,é_5"iitxvzé' §;e.:> ';;i :'<>w:'1i11g, P'.-'\?'.S iiiléf '§'21h::;§Ed;¢1r w%:<> has-'3 é{:.:3e:i:,:<,T::,e2_:£f..-- i£r1qu&=$é;. p21:':{.:h.21§1a:z1a E§X,R4§ PW'? is 27: Améérzibgzf <3? €116: pa.:T:<EE.1a3;z3;iiEf:, wim hgfss heﬂci {E5162 ;3;%.:5:;'{t}"zagrszﬂl in S2-:§s':'h2?:.;:}1.zr 81.:.':':g;E<m: azzzri ;«r:ﬁ;e2' E'.h.§;3 E }")§""

M. K pa..:'1c:1'1ay2.:{:}': her 1'12;n:i 21civ.i:'s3ec§ £",E"1_e°: 2-1<?c;_%1.1s<3::i to iiake é\z'1z1z1}':«1.:rn:¢: hawk ix) hiss h<'n.1s<::. P'\?\?.8 its 22115.9(.) :§__r'_i0t:}':e1" par'1<:}'1z1yaa:th §E1i"f1'j1'}'{)€E", P1369 is $112'? V.I':f1_:i¥% rr3g;_i$i:e;'céci Ether zmc:'§ §;1.'we53t:ig21teci f'.§:"1<': '"£Ij.é:1;'§'i:i'i;",I."_ .:1:éti.u ' arr&:+:.i:ed iihe app<31ia.1'1t.ss,

7. 'I'h€é appe1£a.:£'1t"ss I121v::{"C1r:1'1_ir:>€iV..t.h.e.i:"_:%(5mf§Iﬁ£c§i't,y iI'E the 3.13 st',21i.em::3;1t,V :';i<:€:(>rci;e'éi Vihfia 1ee1:"':'1€z:i Sesssions Judge. There>21.fter a1ftc31'.T_hcéé1-rihg t,_¥.f;é§--gjrgisfzctaliiiolz and the defericte 'ii}1f;¥:.§{;'?1.1fI"1=(*:{i §.S€s§;€_,{.j:1$.VJ:i_§i.g§§ @213 p'1ease::i to pass the jL,1d§in"1(~3_.:r"'i1' ""éiiis , and to 3:-s<:*11t:<3'r1{%e: the 21p;3ej?V1é1:':§#;.sTA §"zt:f':!:;§:&V';i.';S}_§.§i"~»'f{'3r3"f;', m_iéf:'"1ﬁ:i0';:}€d.

8."'-Ei1.eiz1:'c}CSri;S211i";»:}s:;}T1 Bi.r21dam Eearzzed {?{)I.,£}'"1.S€_1 fez.' a.p'pe;é1E2m[t.'::...and Sri Sharana1b21:-assmppzz K B;1bshet.1:;y§ » §.e3.2,r13 cc?

Q; "_'f{T'h«?::,. :e~.a.r':2e& caa:mss;<:'i ibr €..'m2: appe§ia1.':zt:s smE)§1"1i%. *{.§14:*1f4 ii: <i E*:":';5s {T3388 s%x<':@;:}f. §s2;1y§z'1g; 1:.h;3.€. Shfﬁ <:i<3es5 méi: E-»:::<)i.x.r A' E"1{>i;:£ i;V.?;;> p:,°s:=:§3é:zE"<1% €'{.>:i>€: afamé i'.E"22:ai tam" p:":%&e;e:'1<:{% is; 319%

2. t\' "6? vi §§'1v€i§:§fI31C§111'~--A.(}§' ::<}§i£?'i'€>i:i<)r1 amgi Sf:%I'ii',f;'.3'{"1{?€ dams amt; {:31} ibr i',I'€:'£1i,£'Dl';?I'1f. <32' E§.2;11*2:1s"-;s:;m@r?:t'. far fe£:(:}1<;:d. E§:'2<1 ;j%':' 1'.h<:

(:i.£'(,?i-»¥H}$t»€&.£'1{?€E'$g htsz E"%1,1bfI}..i'£if?3 IE:)E":.21i: ijE_'1<:": a;);;)<:§1aj;'1§'§-;»_V*a;§*€ «s3:1'1ii..1Z1i£€::,'1 fez.' am ::):':i<';=r1" {'Z%f.~&1{*.q1.1ii'1fl::';'L§. ' V 103 Sri Shz11*am21i3a1.sss23.pp§12 ECG? ssubxnms E:':i12-".21. iiéae t.<>ta1ity goes to ghow iillaii .{"1f;':{f£',;c{£-,3€'._C.i tit)' i1I~'tr€:a"{.II1<3I1i; and V .'k.j:21r21:~:VS'f3:%§§4{:V "n_;13'1d"«"i;h&: 3 S:,1i(:id€t c:::)mm1'ti',ed by hm: VA .;§. ":'!é:iA(;fifSfé{ﬁ..i€fIICC of ssu<;:h.

h21r2:ssn1t3r1t.§,.. piace in the house <)i'i'€,h;:"'* ";":7.i:.:r"::a3--'::' appeilemt: bczingg; t:h_e3 iltisbeiilki "E';.E3}_4~., §C21,ié§'{Vvi€%I'}'{".i:V;':§' on §ii'i':1 tit} E§hO'W as his Emw his wife €.','§':':'»)H'};{}"}._iI',f€.',f{Ti* ..-2111:} the husband hag 3f1()i', diS§?hE1§g€¥Eij' V§ 1.iS?'s_ ¥7}I,1.iT€iéii.i,1 H&?1'E(:f:-3 he sub§11.i€.s thszi: me LL V it is helci by :mr Eiigﬁi Ccmzfi, in 2;; 1'f:%pUi"E',é:';{3; AA giigi g§n.f:e;'1§, §':haE., §:'i..§'¥.'}7 £1§§,€E'{T:&?i€i{}i'1S mi qL.zz;2;;;*::°eE §*:=::g:;zr€§i:;":g E:.§':e fd.:«:-;ﬁj;,J €é:E':<3:*§-t-25;; 3:': 33:26 E':<}:,:§§;a=: {i{f>€;?*E:§ ::'3<":E". ;?:m::::;::':.i: iii'; 1"EE1i"£:}.§f~3S§1'1':<:'.1'1'{., in {hiss (?'2ilS<:': 6;-"f.XC£;?§}Ei :;a_yi1'1g {E1311 sh_<1%_:"1«:><;=:s.~; not ¥,~:n<>w haw {{7} <_%<){:»i«:; pr<}pc%rIy, {Them is ":"i{_;. '<:}j{511§%1"

211.Eegz1,i.i<3:'1 {if ab°:41s:~;e or phys-:«ic':2.11 1'1ar21:4's:sm<-:?n€--'..';:*:{::.-ed!'?<T§i.;§ %.'0 the sic"-:»:;:e,~.a.<-;r;é<i. I+'mr€;i1<:'1" it 3.53 55-e:é%'i'1"--If:h21*§. i_§.*1 §%"~zéé;p ;3<3.'--1§!:1:'i(2g Ezzxws éakeszl 't)a.+:;:}§; ii}'1t','. {ie<_re21se:ci'«:0"~t?1cir .E';m':1s;:e. $1-?i:':;:.:' a_ pa11(:'hayath heid. It 'M31; {;:1:%:»1;°Vt.i3v hbw the dec::::=;21s3e:d was; 1"{;'.S}:(iE::7};_§ in zj::'a"i_é 'i':.:')::sé'{2.._of P\?V:+:'. zinzti 2 for abami (3219 year" prior 31c} i",Er:é;'é5 h_:).Il;:'iiA£1§g",' pi" pa1:1{the1j;at.}1. Fiiffhﬁi' ii: that t§r1€§.'<:i<:sf:f}%5e;i.;<._3'::%Vci_ @213 {he £56-%{:{>1'§c1 wife <}ft'.I16 f'Liu1'éi: 2:_y3°p§é1fei:':i; 2 é11j--e <3!' P\-'s/';<3. .1 and 2 '{;i12-ti:

far 'ism; _i;h§(~"{V v2:ppc;IE2:I1tT$ éiiﬂn (1 both 'i':'h<-3 wix-*esT; of first. exppzaliémi.'-xazeréj.Ei*i§i:1g'--~;1ﬁ»«f'E'1e $211718 house and it is only £1§'3lZ'/3%' .§Zh€;"f _f.'§'_4:"':':»,:§,V 21pp€:1Ea:1if's E'irst; wife 'be€:arr1<;% ;)[email protected] 'i;}.1a1i: . Anéiﬁ:,z:31{ia::=:r'&=:i}zmdizlgfgi21:"i:e(i in t',1":e E"3_<31.1sae. This {fE'£E"3U()E', ha I %:<:rfr§.<.-::§'-.23.§ €:gt;v:.}t.y or 'hamSsII1enf;. wit:_h§:': 'H1:-2 m<3:21:2iz1g{ of S€r::i,i<> n*4 '§%»é§{E'i} EPC' E2"; "£':}:'13;'i, 2,-fiexaf {>5 %'h§:=; mai;'£.cr, §,§":{§§"€:% nb:ii':1g__§*,§:;_€3 «:3"é:E1e:.:"::* .i.2':.{icepe:'1dent wii.:'1<3:--:;&;c2s-3 ai:»'{:h<3:' f:}1e,2.:': PW$.2 ' 2: "W§i{3 {E18 ;32gr{?m.:<:a <3? ézzim d;s:2€::&.2;i§:~;€={L E em: 0f the .--.%_}p§.:";.i.<'2:.'*2 i'.E':.2:§} 'é'E3§r: pm5:s::<_.%':..ziiésm 'E12:.:%.§ 1'13?' §_§E'€}'%;"E?f:'.i z?".E'::.=. <:§'f'@-§2:'.{:"=. ' L1:'1{.¥€::' S€:»:71;'.i031 »4~£»38{z'~X) '£::<:2y(3z.1ci r<::*2153::3:'121.bI€: <:10:,:bi.. In t:E':2'1'E. View 01' E116 n:12.%:tt:€:1"., i"1:1c~s 21ppeI1z2m_£..s+: c.:-m:'1<>i béf i"1<t1:i"~.;g1.:iIi.y $03' t'.E";<3: <>§'feI'::;:&: %_.11:1cier Sc'-%<::¥;im:': 306 {PC 2133:'; aj*g:j:'7ci }';»:§1'1<}%;% I am} of the: apiniozz 1':ha1';: {he-% E1§}p(;?}1E1I'1'{.E§ c§i";%_:s:?:2f*g:'@; L'i'r:5' Be: 3CijL.Ei'{.{i€.C.1 of that <3i'f¥;é':'1ce53 c:E3.211'gé(i éi§;;2::in«$st. ~;i'h.§_.="rm, Ei«::%1'1té':»r: the 1'<)i1<_>W£ngg Gfdﬁi'.

O R Agapzzai is e1i3c)f2i§fe(i§ vj€,1._V':;1' \§:Af;c:e.r;1eer1t: <§f V vc::e:>r1viciT.i<)1'1 and s;c::1":,<;2nc:7e far <)ffe:"3.c:e:

under    39:: aside, The
app€ti1z1I1t:3VV.    {2}}<;'§3ifk§r:.e::<;>s }.r:ve3§1e,& 21;,;{z=:i:';st.
1"}1E33'I'}.._;    by ihfirxa iss <é3_z:<:eEie«:1.

"Fine ;A:7r:1;<)'i.:;1t" "is: orde3ra:;=:d :12') be refhnded ii} iii €;11';';, _

-. ' $3 §§$3i \ 4 at 'oi 'i\*1*%x'<

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

Maruti S/O Hanumant Dodanni vs The State Of Karnataka on 10 June, 2010