Gujarat High Court
SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION/4966/2010 on 23 April, 2010
Author: S.J.Mukhopadhaya
Bench: S.J.Mukhopadhaya
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?Q??v??~?e ?? ??Zb..c,?V ?0 ??[K??=????J� ??,??N??tOK?'''???k?? ?X =l??9 7?? h)?H@ ?M??D?B?J`. %??b ??+????9?id&9 ? ???h? ?{? T?y??X?70wluaR??^/???B?J ???4.F??? 0?
??7H ?>5?T ?$? ??8ps Y?!4? ??t? Py-6,5??\Xx U??c ?0}Y ??8Z0?S ???G???? ?D4?cL8UN ?D9?< T�U,n,)h?:?-^*^v>? X??.?kW R+??C 39??;?!??? :?M _j?KV_?`:???%H?h3?t?? ????^?T???6?????? ?%A?y3??/?3F?{H=O? 0 c/m ?f}?~? !?{???XD?C?[? c?G ??? ? S02???!?f??????????ux@?:??:$??Z?DH?? ??)pzZ?q R?!% P?????q5? ?? ??b?cSBGch|?,?*??? ?lwz\?8?? !?# ?pA?M ???_?W??w ? ??!g 4?[-KG?? ???*1?Y4??Oky?eF?DyEV?U????0??{~? <_? ???!?6r?~cR?? ??jV??{ =??Zy? ??
????>p?W9?
NkT?ew T???TM=j??b? >?|'??j? ?h???8 ??l o^?.??\v????s)B"oK?S :^?w? ?=?_??~?$)]G> ???v? ?
? z??a ??ZaxU ?8?0?J-?rnn?Z?1X?>?~?4o# k?H??'y[??Zm/o?9?? ^??o3?V??????Tz?1X??o3\? k???lB?tHAi$? ???? C?} ? ????ZB?? ?d??y}0??Q xf?D?9 @??)!? ?m? ? ?7) ??M???[?\d?;?Plf-N?,????Y?
?-??|m???}o?n/???oN? ??m]8??E?;.P?????X????8???s?????N? tno?
3????!b>??? ? ?I???S3 ?h} T????s*A? *? ?sn??8? t?\w W?]?? tG$U)G?'?&? ?('{??\???;?? ?{??Xv? ?k??~?a? ? G???E ??p5?b?Z? ?N 8?!?QcYUEM?V???~??o?6??
kwky ?, ?|?W#? ??Y | ?H ??G C?v?g<, ??F?"??q?w????}??Z???l?4??k???? Sa??? ?M?h AP`0?>?AB 9????*?E?g??_;k???jJ/? ?)?? r?}{ '?s~??gC??i]?o??A??B^???7 u?w?E???) m ????????R?4\L??Q?$??s ???}? e?"??#?m/?3 u/P?.??? ??Y?}K5)e??] TD( ??w??UmC�?;? f?M\?)8.$?vv?Y?? N\?E#* ???Q,??9? ? ? ~ ?{H ? G}?C ?{????~P-?A?tK??? l'80] Af%?8 ^? z ? ? A??b? NWW? ?d2E3?Q_T !??? ?^r??T??x(bpsI f� Kb :?z?l y? :2?M? & �? ?d?[? r????t? ?
I" ?24??6?RC?? ???K ? ?P8 ?
? Y??{? M? ?t?[? ????C>v??QQ??$?�8" ???#U'!??H ` ??B?Gx?'?%!Q ?? ?(??R?c ?'?"2?ANT? ?\?? ?9!Y????k?M y�?7? -Py?J ? ? ?|??y? v5 ?%\q c}? ?2]? ?T ?K?s?U?x?y?_????/?,?p??d? ? 8=? ? ???g? ?3U??? ? ?? ?&?|.S ???u??um? *??V???(=?T!??? ?/cO'?.3?? NNY?Y2? ?%? ? ??? ??uk??
?c? ?4f?@????oPDw.(?X??{? ?, i?ql??
!??.? ?? ?P?\? ?
??X?~?V? Z?8?.?}??k????E?? ?& ??c.??
20?o ) R???H?i) Ih ?c?e#?$?0????K?V?;+ sl?9?.Tr?f5-?1??(X?+?q? ? F?? ?? ?a ?j ?y* ???ci8 p ?_0KbZa?>??E? y ??IV?(7?? IJS??&Y?????RjQ[ b?[�?4?23?T.? ?pN~d?! q[??S7?l?S$?P?1?"?SZ M???KY??"?
w ?? NQ]?)? ? ? J?"??f>??)?dd ?>?d???V?? ?\ ?q>6Q??%?z?~):?9??S?E4? DRWv??m?#P??M ?=? ??? Jp??LR_?
R`N?2.I?K???:R? "+? ???$??:?\} M?GH? ????{ ? q F????=FQ-Y;??@y u??( ?``????f??G bpv??2U???,?DK*????? WR?? 7U7 S?0 G?M? ??b??K?Q*?Hq? G ???] ?3?r?>>????-t ,??,{??? ???L?W/?r? Cg%D??= !?X?F?6??'????l +??b??QP?;%a7?G-??m ???"T?^? g?? ?P?/ !??j?e?~ >?:3x�%????yx?./??7T ?'??*???d ? an?,?O? Y \? ?:;? ???R ?M?V8 ??mP_\ ? ?k? ?gV Zw? ?d??)???? #? ?? ? ?z_??W? ? ?( 6??Z?zpg?Z? q???? ?E???b3E: vQq?4?Gg?}??? ?? ?hn? ??@I?q????{i?]@.??
l ?bPj?} ?-? ????nf??V? ?????w3?N?? ? i??Et5?k p?C?L??j?d?r ??9??Xx5???Uks??-???????Um???Vo BU?(??}* ??_ u?T? Z????? PK ?-hj? ��/'��PK �����?Q?<%?? ? ��? �� ���meta.xml OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 das 2010-04-26T15:45:54 1 PT1S PK � � �?Q?<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png??uP\v?`??]????] ?? ??H 4!HHp???? ???t?u? 7???u???:{????{w??? ?{??PPP?
?a??:((h(Dx?ao ? IAZB?7?$ ) ???I?? ?A\[\Z"?BB?? ?? ?FQ!@:q#* *???W &I??V??0??"h> ????k???^???Q??R? ?&3 ??%/?)?k?m??D???K?N?? '?S? ) ? /Uj ?F?u??3? ????H?xl??~? ?AB???q ???I @]G?? ?h?T? ?????Y??~n?}I.^?A ?4?Cf???dB ?rVX+> 1/??|?+n???v"_*?H?Aa|?d? d"M\?E? ??? ??2 ?B?,O??? *? ?? i?zb??s?]B??7r?c;@ a??Nz? {#? ?2 X^?=?? EE MQ???:?a~+]};q??? T?M?"z F@ ?7????? .q}�?>1 ??=M? w??g)%??J?[;h? rV]?sL b' ?j?7??? ui>???# *h ?&?D?t?;
??{@?Sz?h??Z3??I?L?BE?A9Li@???j I3???? <[ ?0??g? ?>d? ?W??S?Tx?(5??? K???\??-,?,X`!?- G.%????s ????D?I??B=S?} ??{??? V?A*?? ?C Zn_???x??I?ABt;?1????????}U? ??W)?$ ???y?Fe??{?z?? ?1????~?W??^?x? _]?z?h? 4/&d K??R ng?>??1 'w?? ?? ? ??aS?D ? :?9???%? ??c??? ?? %-_ oO??&~+V?T7 ??O /? m??-?O? 2iv\ 1#X?v???/ ?Mc????&f.i?,?3?i?Us i?.?~ P7 ??25?u@? ???* (?= ?( ? S? l?q ??e?C??? ?U??}??t1??c[E?D??????#%,eX??????+??)(M?=?C %?S?^J4??? j?????y?b?,?33??O?P{?~??-??|? b ????K?2 5 ?? )?'??D9f?? ??? ?????????~1caU u>??S?
?? d 3^? ???? 5p???8N?????? ?3?: q*???? ? ?3b ? R? ?I?R?? ??
?iG? ?> ?x???? zK???4|??'?P ??l1M5$???V-??SC??1 #JD4=?L? ?? ZyJ??53 m4u????|am?wK?}^L?????J?D?LB ??? ? 5?? ?? ??-?P #-g?G?e?ALl ?H????- I??n &M????Ku ???r?|^?
l?? ??/4?c? +$r???vk?~M= ?
?m&?t? ?0??3b?rx? 2P)??2/g???s ?e??v?U>: ?*?|j\ ^6??u?- ?? Hn ??H ? ?^*???QHG|?_z??L?????'oRh???? ?Q?=??~?9 "????5? ? ?O??P??U???b??{]???C&??8p p?7?b Va?Q?D?t?z .???8#e??q?h??????? ?^l??`?R* g?@K?*�?$?#(n ^?qbCa??n?\-? ;?!??!SP?????q?'??( XJuSSUS?'5?hy?R??? ?K?d?>??? ??;??*?? ??{9?FrI??s?? d?? T?H ???}? 666?H?y .i??0?? { ?3vE|),??v?|5.t$ ?uGE? ? ??!??,' ? F???<&K9Q%?? ??M8?F,??? d`dl $ J??? ?f/m% ?A??ST@? ?u2??~?w?AS ?? ? T ) y?|?? ?91|?N ?4?e T??e ?u? ?bX? _???? QiJ9?}? ?n{? ?9 O?�??1D?3? ?b 9?;? j?y??
??ZY?; ? ??�??` ?M}kcm??PH?X?? ????D?!??xj? ?r?8?? P??S?UK#o? ? 6?r?D?? D?v???
?}z?�|?+??3?Q??v???zHH?sBO??$? vR bi\Xv ?l? w? ?F????(}f?W?8 ??? ? ???v?!?f!A?bE=?s???
?$?????#?g? q? E ??? V??d??~b?????????@ 6?OOJ? ??Y .? ?q >+mi???*? ?
%A?`??; ???v?r5# ??=?_M;K?ad?|??n ?~h K ????Z S{k? KP?? ?? ?T????� >?8L??9>)A?8K???aE(?[1??#?i?gXXz? ? ?V+e:?w?C m mA?M?9?5 ??j?o|?+???k????? ? ?R_2l?WS???~???P @?5 ?TP[o?V??.? ?hW?(? ??q3?? #? ? [K??OW ;?3= w??)?DJ???W?R[?Z ?d?LK q ]?av? O?L?= ?V?? X ?V=???? ?P^0Py?h F??!?????^? M?L?"?DT?"X?xZH!? ? ????Wyx~??Q?w?QP ?T?1B?. ?h?r?U??Y???`U?`? ?4?f ?h&2?/??5???L? ??^ ?'? �#?)? P ?FJ? ???8V ?V? ?:C??.? ?
?? ? 2?Y< ??????? 5d?a?./ t LV??B ?? O?R"?`t{a4C�?&????b? ??>?T,??:?6?S?p? ??I?w -
Sr???? ?Qc? ?G?? ?s?( ? a ?-C?/ ?8 ?h_t?yJ???? ?D????Tf :? f b????3n? ? X-> ? zo?A8??-? ??* Tp?b?}[?k ?S??& ?Ru?? ? ,#? % ??J? @???W????|??? ?x ]??u?D-?I???n`??? ?Y?????:?C?o??|?? ?V YM~?}???y[ ???XT?a??? ?H?�??? ?~ ??5??g??r:�?B E?L?z?
??Q?? L ?? ? ??\? .?H?$ ??B ??jL(?&?? w???GBK ?�??s???X? ?S?,? ???o????d?-? ?\?R????q?????n?p ??^?f?q@?v??"??d1 ?w@H`????S? 9?*?G'4B?;Y*: ?d?[?:?KA?#?? ~?u ?? ?sFx?=??=nN?4)G^l? ??? 0?K????g?6 S?`VXm ??WVI ?9?3- ?h:???V?! pY?F)?_?*@#? ??Q??& , j!6??+??gQo?n&?MK ?-?N?g???o??t? ?#?K[ ?? }$?A'H? ????`?)/?`g4 ?N" ^?G????? ?q?????KB?|D??a???r|hF??b\^KnH! ~?R??S?4=!_k?t ????F?p] ? @ ? H? ? ? ???$}K.Y?C??? +?? D??e@? ?Ta?f?zfA? ?U??}???+?'? >?. ? g% . ?rd~?+?? y?;ti*kb????V?j?e??? ? ?sw? ??}�????0g?k??? s??? ??l????D zn?O '7)?!????m?i?$?�? B? L?- "1` ?�?h5e h?H>?
? ? o?p v?XD?d?
??P? ? ? n4h?????U?C?? ???]Z ?k?T6? ?T ? ? Kyd?}W3 ~(?B?~????t??? UG?* ??? B??RxW??M,m??g? ?? O?v??%=n [ ??,=?C?�?`R?$ ???Z??p 2>[ i M)Ge> ?? ??:?*??
? ?7?"?:?5i?????????O?4%`@???D a?q 1?Q? ????=?u !?Z??? a?X ?? ?1? .f?0???V??????J???? ?- ? ?R?d6(#pAt???.??Ep ?Y??\8????h??j?X q [?9??b??y W??PL?? rJr;??+?? >?ZS?&?7Z ?U?,K?`(?c? ??C" ? ?[?8T ?f??A? ?;?no ? b?8W??? ??2??`)?~ ?? >?W ?6&{??O??~?") ????S ?6uIl~; ??RGk??C??Ms?n??? & ???J?? ?z?3?!*?.!??zCD ?}Bv??'6??!4??x'??I?~?? +j y?2?s??9pT ? ?6? ??"Ch?Y??% ? T????z}?
?JY???????M?` s?KJE ?a(E? ?J{Q??D /? ?4>>? ? p6g r)?^?\????E?g/?n ? 0 9+M ?}J?/0??[?t?r?T? ??? ?z? ~ENE?1?d?? ??T4???^?? :??f?jP2? V??)?W?Nz?S? ?! ?j?+# hN?L?n ?z?B??M?S ????!??&? ?[?? D-E N?5??J%U?g?R LGs??? ?i?? ?? )??Z?}?RALV?=[?G? "?q j? {? /J?????? I?�??= ???} ?t???? ??????{Fk ?, l????? 9 ?V4??? xb;??R} ??J [ F?!0???1&?2?F??9???????^?tT? k??r? |`8?^0~jK #???????D?C???{G=?D^?d5A27??+? h? ?~??? ? /?Yek?E??' ~ ? ?[]@X` ?`??8<1??????H7U N???.v ?d??o???V???? ?Iw7?x?3??e????!?~?\ ?']?2? ? ??Q &?,�{? ?D62?Hs???cG?H ????|??0?}???d !`??X??? n????-?$??e]% ?Wi??A?A Z2?? ? ?39Q?.HuJ??Z???bg?? ? VYvK5??^?9? ?K&@??I?5 2�6hm??? ?#??3sP ?Y????XP?M? { ?+?M?w??%8x;?%??Q?1? H? ??0'[GF??>9?8 ?X?Nq??4M ???X ? ? d??"<9?N;@E ? (t'?rQ8? k???S?p??? ?? ??u?, ?0?? ???Ky?O'?J)y6 i>:? ?]??3q?,XH'???} y????Z??!wTT?Z??2 ? nX ?| ? ???a3???U???Rz]?^ ???\?f??R? d?q-? ?yg ???FC???h???i?Z????? ?=? ?#]??_??J1?F@l??-?BBL>E?qp??Fd2 /?c?g?? ???$f ?r???i{V%?d???r?? > ?"@?-fj?sf[?N??4? ?R???M{A chF IF???=?? ?_??S?eu`??iE#? xY D? od?. ?? L?d?n&??�?Se ?\5?3??v?x{ ?Tk??-? =P?" ??}??A??^Ezf:'H?EA??y?92x?T Uv? ?M??Bd x!??*M?l ??|@e?{?K??= U1] ??T???J%?c?W i3 o??%6$? ??S?O? 8? "?EY??6?c?`Yq?*?j? e?E??"??J??? ?|DHi?g2K?`%???vU????e?????{q??6*+E" g? Z??45QBIK:?k??#?yc?? ?rcA+?R ?f? ??? ?H???s ?Tm ?+?H ?? ? ? zb???
s?/??I??]????S ??V3?N!n!p?q?Ma?` ???� y?E?`";j?i?O???8?1 (n&, UEg???e "???O tP? -�?5???5??q?LCGb? ??XCc~?
M< ? ? ?.??k?!? ???y? H?48??A?o?[?d* ??v?2@????(??OU?_?n*?;??1S O@?b2??z ^ .J?6????ZZ???U??K i?[ ? ???M?b%RLP?|??|??fq?z ??O??KR??`?Y?? ?? ???? ?\" ?h?d:V? ??L?]?? ??-M yR;?=?Y?R?0dR?9 ??~? ?T??)?2 |?\?DeI u wx? pa ??????8?# ??r?7???W E |YvW N7 ? U???R?P? ?? ??;&>?}X%?Th?:a?+ w?G-??????(URg( ? ???hB? ^X p??h9m>ZyBd?y?K_"bG*??4m#??as=0??0?)oNS.??)?G?lM? t}??L?y?>?� ?4 Q ?g?P??&? ??GdZ 18@? ??` p*`I?? f[ ? ?;f?$:?i??v}R;?Zn.r? ??HLhgA??Np? ???e?/k?&uO?? ( ???#*???5?Tl? ??< ??,?P?????a:??z???u?? @e? H)?R ?b` ?z ?n??? IA????s Q*?0?-? ?c?Z?L>_????$ ??.2=.~?9? z>aC??e^ ?QI? s tD?? ?nN??-
* N9?
?]??L?q8 ??CLe?-s??
Dy?/3?` ??!Y??qgS[? ??W ;LV?!Zep~? ?=?? +RD4,?? ???2U?O????>2e?% ?z{s??1?y?? v!??|X? ?? {?X??J?? ?
P:?;??? C,"?.??p???)E?Y?Vi*)??t?\/Z??~?$ g?&? C??o?WuYVI ^?j0>?C ?? ? ??J?x^????I!} ??Q7?1??P???Y!?VeE ?K^?P?:?^???a?, ????A=F???,? ?Hl?a?J?cI[?E?T????U???|pik?gj?j� ??'I|?8'? ????p ?U? v???? hJ Bg?\.? ? c9 ?? a ???RV G??}e\??0 ??K$??;??\|?_ ? ? ???se?zm3C-??p??Q?? ??V ?W?l?? ??s?E?_?-??Dz?e?U???0? ? _ b?E?@? ? ?1? i?ro ?? ??%??(?)av=IY85? ?&? ?Rs ????? =(???E ? :?Zb???n?^{?? ?a???| }{?r??`;? RI1?=????H?0"M]??n4? 6?U?r??J??r??????? ???O Q? ??�????t??y?? PK K?.��B0��PK � � �?Q?<������������ ���settings.xml?Y]S?J }????;???l \?P?k?} ? r?L?f& ?~{?@) ?I!?3?=??t7??!?y ? 7N?�?? ???y w+ ????8? \???! ]Q?5-Q'?PW?? g?utU?b "?? ??j????xl_, ???dm???<]/?PL?? ??j?d? "~??|s?&7??????? <;F%? ?O?? ???� ?8y?_?? ? #g?D?"z ? ?f??uu ?p? Lu ?E? ?s??y?? ?r??B0?? ?~^?7???? ?O! ?9 3P[ L 904??? w?-q?? } >e\ _ YT ? K?w}? b?;??ru????*-)~?????6??B?K?V uO??]6 EQU0?`!S \ ??� ?%I???^ ??Zc??}^k~-x?? ??m??? R? ?2O? ?) |?F????w%}Q ?s?|??? g^????0%J? i??H??? &XQ ?"? &8:O ?`? ???6? #????X ??? ?�?? ?p ? cJ?*?)????u ?p??0? ??X3? ??T?�;
>??Mw??J?X? # ?T]G??q#2??O??u\ 3? ?J"5 #N?[ ?@?}F??m-9?%?? ??S"
?J?0 k)???n Q eS|? 6 n?^?W:?? Gu??rw? '??f? S? ?;uO??A,< ?JC? 3A?;?
P mS?v:8?E? u? &??N?? ? ? K?[ ~?Dj????}rV? ?;??V?? ?? PK Q?t? ��E ��PK � � �?Q?<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ??? ]??S??X ??A ? ?k H??\??? ?? ?~]K??? ??&?ZF;?Nh??~?c ?L?B?)? ? 6 ??????m??j?D???m ?6??Y?b??A?, ?a?m 0_???\? ?,b?$?? ? ?R??? t??? ?z}h (:I?? ?"?u???15 S??"? ???? ?U B?w+ -;]*????T? \?qY?iU????l7�G???r? _H??D??F ojT?#???n9??;?Ik? .j^????? ?i"?O_? Iv ? ? ? ???r??? g Top