Gujarat High Court
SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION/6476/2010 on 7 October, 2010
Author: Ravi R.Tripathi
Bench: Ravi R.Tripathi
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?YG=?19 ��� ��� ���mimetypeapplication/vnd.sun.xml.writerPK �����?YG=������������ ���Configurations2/statusbar/PK �����?YG=������������ ���Configurations2/floater/PK �����?YG=������������ ���Configurations2/popupmenu/PK �����?YG=������������ ���Configurations2/progressbar/PK �����?YG=������������ ���Configurations2/menubar/PK �����?YG=������������ ���Configurations2/toolbar/PK �����?YG=������������ ���Configurations2/images/Bitmaps/PK � � �?YG=������������ ���layout-cachecd`d(?f`` ?d``Q 1x $?R �PK ~k? ��� ���PK � � �?YG=������������ ���content.xml?\?r?H ???bk??*# ` {&?? ?5? ??{Fj??Z?n?ky???}?y?=?%~l@ ?lk???t???#????}?1????]v? ?BWx< ?+|?/? ????g1 p??z? ?+B ? ? ??d?]a?utZ*????%K?a?R.?K??B?A_Mo(f???Lj$? ????
L t?I? ?? ?@)'??5? J????[??^�??? J?? ?O?i ? E ??
?]???:???'?w?[??2?_? ?l?o?? S? ??9???zIoX?"r=1 \? ?a? ????^? QI??F?? \ ?|(??AV'}?M7k??n??:a|8? ?6 } HX?f:wY? Y??Xi>? ? ????? ?W?U?Y (??e?W?Q ?? H? ?;?VL??SLy/??}3?O??%0 T yX?"?,2O ?~? ;??n??}??H??(,????Ty/???^ti?? e?p???? >?a??r? D?>? ce ?_?S??Dz?????f?z?l?!?^(J:-??R( [ ??}<{??u?6b??/??/??_????"8????+??) ?+z~? ????!?W,[???Y? o1 ?X^r ?z?~^ ?J?~?9??k??Qi?i?Q???0???Fw ?I ?5???\?,7,2?? o ????}? n?'G?k??= ?}??}???5 ???? ?$c|??P(?%f??fOs?^LN?|:E\&??l?|?O ?r????C ") q???SBf~?!??s?h??Z??-?`?p?h??? ?n|?& ??:=r?|????8=??]7?.?s?2=;?8?p.? f???E?! ?? ??7? ??m????Q?? ???r np?\?H>?l?v?xW?=??s}?? W?? ?^y? ?:???.o?;???q???s~?"# ????u?8?Kr >???4 $2 ??f?9?? .?+?}j??b?J? " 3 D'9]6g?? ?I???'5;???? ??$?N?z?f?#????@H?G???6? ?CV?6??? ?k???N??B h ???? ??W?V??#?+??C? P??# ??HmQ ?l?v???!$ S?0??NI????H?,?t?4?????k?l??? ?k+s?q????M c"v?
?7H1yt ?? ?s?c???? v?ZbI??b???k?????|??KQYz ?? ?\???9?7W?q>~?? W??|n????4?? ?8K+ _??~???!?.???@??%?\S?'?U???V8 K ? ???E???|R8?-r I?#>???#? iJ?\?(??4-rN??d?M??lB?
??V?"mI? ?mf??'�?=*fs??( ?,????~5 =??P?s?H*?g,$?dx????|>?/\??=8K ?? ?~�?] M?x2??p??^?"�M?0d?dNM?`?Lj? ??V?5?%?U?�? Y?? b?d??S?, y 1 ?? ?j? ?R. ,??? ?�$?(9A ?5??r??Z#Q??Hx????;???T)@/�B?A ?? g ?5W????A u$??g?[ ?QB U W?S#? 6 #?{? ?e ??.?. ??L2 ?'?=Z?J??W?? ? $ ?XI?? ? pG8g??? + ??AT9>??C????Z" ??YA?El;.??}rR%of?v ???[&bH?)?f4p? Z@=?d(?? k`J?b)?+bH?(1$~?3T!( `X8?K?? %?# ?}?IC? ?`'MXb?
QW ?zv??A$X Ca?T? 1&l b?)EX ??$?R>?? ? D? �o??{J??2H-?? ?? ?&W??9H?JH? ? o ,?M?m"i?d?? ]??M? k @??/?n?b?????b ?M?Utz? 3??X? ???H$N? vE ?,?XX? `i ?%??E?/0??U?oL?? ???hp? ?u??2??F?v?? } j?m]?????_`???ts??t??X?f???t??4?? 8 d? F?50V ?-? H??$??S ? ?$!?bMZ???PMW?u5 ?'??r???c ??;s ?c? ???Pel?B!^]??{???`n?? N@%?t???6? ???Z?"Y ?q%?,????!~}?g??E?????C?? PK K?hpv ��bC��PK � � �?YG=������������ ���styles.xml?Z?o?6 ~?_ah &K???a ]?? Zlh?a??D?\%R ???_?#)?W(?N?? ?C??> ?w??T^??e?? sA ??q?0?YB????|?x{?o?{?V+ ???E???'X?`2 ?Fx?m?/?? ?1??` ?a`~?? z? ^#,\? D+@ F? ?5?? ???h �gX?U??v;?N52Z, ??w ?w?g??e? ? ??? q?? ?jT 8???"??Q`? ?h?f ?`ZdK ??$j9\?Q ?? ??`8J >? ??(?b' ?? O?n?? ?R?L?!?$?L{?Gi?A ??-!?zB XZ?::?" K`z?}?l??? ? ??&?iM?B?? [ ?CYWn??b?2(?? ?&? _a?h??�???? ??!L?@? *9???]e8?p??_0?zQ??a???#A?:???,?vf?[???`&??2?P ?,O?? ?QZI j+?Vly m ??BeF???P+ ?O q?#?J p?f?o0E ????$ oj;?u L? ?? 4??Q? 1?Op?n? ?z?O d U????d?t??98?(?5?7X ^??jAK??Q??D? Wt \???? ?N? ?8? ??jW-?&?@y!6 H??<0? G h??qE}E*8H?9)&"?.?s??I?/ ?dk,7?R??r?e ?? Q ? ?7?m?R$ ??nA??? %?d?U ???w?BA? ???hR??&??2???�/?]^?gA-Z2)U? ???j?n???T_g{N W'V u <-?? N?F??&? 2 ?0FOi_??g?????\???x ??! ?G???\?
V?)??( _.&??�X? e`7??d ? ?=?0??????s?d+???p? g ???? &M?k?j????HUB ??[?0??WQs%{ ?K ??S4l??;ah??j{P(Q??!? ?p?? Lf?? ??}??P?????fd?9?~????]?7 ?? #w ??+??? ?)??v??????>9??>??3g? ?Es???3 *?O;??i?O?? r ??? `?@??J??xc)???ll.?fn?j]>???} \^\] ?0 ??
m?K?j8?8? ?R? ?B?b??N?!?6h?????Z?S5?k? ?~??S? ?Oo?F? )Uu????? ????S?~?O??@'????n? PK ?? ��<'��PK �����?YG= ?J`? ��? �� ���meta.xml OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 ocm 2010-10-07T16:45:59 1 PT0S PK � � �?YG=������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png??eP?Q?-? N kp ?%?; ????? '??'?C??-?[?;??=?n??S??PS?t?^?{???l" ?%Q? ?P?? !?????? ?!?Rp?@AqqK? ??g?? ? ?=??>A$ ?PD??U $ E?,R ?'?0 ?`?7?O[@ �? N???B*r�?QDS?? ? ?ic?a??m????? x??}>????Q?3???[o?Y"-&?S?k?EJ^? .B? V (J?)?QX???c6?b ??P\?N1Bx \????? z??{??e ?l?? bz)C??????????f???- ? p??Z1?D rV? ? ???Qf ???c8 ?=??7???2w9?Lpm8?-?:M?l?? ?yE?xj???}9?8???K?t ?O?? L ?Q S;????P???2u???SR??:?m7Q6 p???p )?I?2??:?y3+; &p &�?]?|5?a?t??3-?.??0?k??Q?Do?h?w_??7?&?k]J] 4[??b}???L???7+?m?o???a/??@?v?uw?????u?h????+-? ??{?O? ??W?U{Q?E??C&?E?D???�?! ???A|?V [@Z?u ?YK?N????????L?`???G ??<_??Q????5??;? >?& ????"?$? 1l?? zV?z~?=?W??H??s???????o??=D->?U-T???�?t????? ? ? ??`? ??G�??? ?!????M?|?jYs???? ?{1??&? ??6?? ????!???}?s?zO??(?m? {?)?? ? hZz?G?FJL ??l( ?bk ??o>???s8z?(?AaYa !?_ ??j?&??o ??d6{V? ? ?)?a??m ?Y?6;K ?^_????CR??AI??? ?}:M[?j$?S4?D ? \?!Wd??A??? ??zm?? Hn?@l?W?nG?F?M~?-??)??Tn?W[?t?????????? *?j? u ??? ?yx ? M?2????87 c?? ??~Y? ?? ??Y z ?D^C C~C ?=m?c?-?{!=w"1??KP?P?cT(F Y{?{? q?L? ?{?$??f?? ? ?j?Y ? _Y]??mF?z?????B? s?@i7??{H"??Y??? ?8?????? ?M? >??'?? ? 9?9<<6 ? ???b?N ??G?? ?m????0 Dn??-??T?B???D'??p? ???0?h X?2?? ??&?????=??[???)??AiJ? !h2? 2w] ?l^P? ??m?????P?s??A )?O ?R???M?O %??V?? ???J2?wB?'}Qj?CPPLZ ???^> ?xiF???.
??? 0B9?a? g{% LJ ?k? J,??
? ?{9(?8??LW(?_ +??m?l?w?`4 ?m??2??5?^B??� ?X"U? %kP?U ?J??l??e?4~?\ .(c?? Lk? ???IQ o?4 5 ;?Q"?P?? ?? {? ?+l??6????V?????}H�???? + ??7S 8??=V?M'?G?,??Dy? k?B?? *?Da�?R???Z?V??Z????T?N??? j5s??? ?Ld?@? N?q?n_ a?? }?c? ?) ? ?l?{? t?]?"|!?? ???NoB?U?? ?3???L??hy?T??C?? ???l0 ?] lS??i? x???lA FXh???/???+ ?!?Vx?? N k0??N??A ??v?.h?K??&jI??G??
�?=_#????xoh ?51? ?@??j?6 ??�Q ?? ?"??q@?mL?C???j?[M?'?? ?l??? ?1??|?jQ?;? ???='?UD?me??????e 8 ???, ~?? 9 ?M?<7?? T\?}R\ ? S* ?w? ??]9? ?38 u ?d??m ??x0?+8y??-�'p? ?q??h ?|????o???x?? B?6??;?S? ? F??q?? ? ???2???? ???~5 ??1mN????| BW9??Cki0? ?U>? ???D?%?+f??w?:AD `?J|?? uT IQ ;?M?z?G vO?u???e?o?bC?B}PN?:>L`??J? ? ???O""? /?? ?. ?]f?I ??? ?l?hb?W?U??? (?'v#Z??@???9?S??3y]?
i??#????/+?4+C>2?~?0p?E??K?a??l(V????F???b ? m? ? i?d40[?1????J(K] ? i?.k?-?I??ge??0h?4" _?L?gi?g ?h}A??u??M?Q ?d??9~ a5?_i`pe???h{???-E?fa/ ?"e$66 ?L?r ??,)?v???2 8 ?wZ2 ?\? E??( ?G?e??E? g?fbq??G?]?? < ??
?(??:#?w??S?R??%??x??F:1B???1V??? 0 lY?+? M?? ?? ? ?? n??? ? ??? ?!c>#?;U?i5??lf c (P$? ?
N?w??5??}???VA??M,?]?~ <,JR? 9v\?@j .
? #R??_nO??[e??J> 1^ ??!? PM??0?e{9,wL?@? cF???D?F? ?7?e=0?l ??"-??O????N ??
}?d??xh +?=?? ?-?T???r)Y??l?? ????X*S dl$??ia "??w?_1 -<7Z??jb ???t????? ?{?Q??OV? 7 (??}S?L)fe?,1? K ???/???{??? O{ ?` B?M??+S?? 7? ???a?P??"Lq?Z??h??\8=pU4o?uH?W?~GGvz ?? =s?*F ?8o?f2?T?` ?4CDG9??"[/a??"�?F???? h? ? ?znC|?3 ?Q?x ???W? &k? [?Ct??@ Ka??? C?w ??d ?j?F?}�?Q?(?? ? 3??qX?gt?o???7????[Dv??
| ? #?? k`t?OU L^!8?? [)???No z.B??Y? /? ? ?LF?? ?&? [?]? ????? 7 ?~?- ? XY?7F7 S??zX???1~n~[??e I?SGh?<[z??z0s??$?e?ei#D ? ?|??3?-??4???kIuZ??=?G ?M ?, ?*? ?+Y _U?? ?99??n??8?2???T&> ?.? S? ? ??6?? ??^Y? ???T?|???G???\?? ?r?^ s?? LWl??.? ? ??e???V m?X?U???x?? ????F??
?!?? :??b?qJWw? ? ? - k\ ?4? ???,? ?fT?
?? yfUc ?Y/M??O= Y??0?? M????q?>??5????= c?G-~9?[? ?|?????.:? \????% d"7?? ???b ~?%X?X?_1i???6M0? t??X?hB??s???[?o???ol?I??4n? AQ ?c???&=?????J0k?JP?L?? ?w ??T?? g?`"??? ?= ????o?_A?X?u? ????1 ? ??1 ???J? ???P?:J ? ? n??6?A T?'u&iO/h?{P? *?? ?j??.??0 ,[-?}?i??? ?D? ?? ? ??'?Go_ ?z?:6?vR??h??" ? ??$ ?7$?v?$ ,X?X?\?.h ?N? i??? ??? 7???? ??3?S6/J. kNZ? ?g 6??e??= xJ;???[?Br???j8?SQ?"c??? ?i????T??u?6b?? _?*S?h???r? .
???/u ? k78????s l?i?.m K ?n ?`?K]???? JS?vhm ?}s??? ^r?`L?y??$4m?^}??L ??"-??/ ??xz?????f??'IT? ? ?8?n=Ej?p??P?Q"w? ? ???? ? ?B??y?????/?? U?? ?Z0G??;1<{???? H??H?"?(?3?? ?b??4q?Q??_T?,??K?z^ ?? E ?t?o?]???? ???xY??h?q?K}?^???_???} y????Ml R?0?> ??? ? z ?3Ea?`??"??#?? ?-?+??c? / ???`f %Ki?V ?????\E? ?~?8 ?? ??W?q???w? ?H)?Q?ZQ?8?}%???I???m?? 3B# ??? I??1N?'+_ ?sM?K?y?{ $??D t2??m g\?'? ??`v??,??9?H^`J? F? C ?-?? } ?7[??;7?@&?^[?,??.? ??o%o??S?7????? 8 : ??T?".xf7?tf ? �#?*??P?$V?AR`?? V?E?>?? Y8+??G?? ?YV? ??I?0?V?~,I_'?@3 ??y|F??fVvkCE^?6 ??? ?9?1L?Y?aSC+}???| ?????J??H???j??a DY?w'?#? ???? ? ?k 9%Q?a???O???k??;l??QX?g?? ??? ????o?9??`? ?? ??C? C?i?
???I?] ??? ?? ????
?HW ?`?fU??C?E ???? m??? ?D??&?t-X>Y?Z??0? ???A[~?N?? ?(??(oC@ F ?5 ??? *ChS:Y?Y?C?k ?o6Qm??V ??_!`??q?g?ke?(?dd(*??$gK? ?????0??X?Yz ?n ? PA?=??N?y?x|??P=]???? z???5?+?z??4???< xS?"N??Q7N}-??"% ??5H?b|?p ?"J+? ??'`??( ~ ???UA�? D?6? ?`9? G?$|}< ? e?? }? )? b?l =sj6?? ???X?#\&?#??? ??? y??>? ?????G ???/[W??9% |??) >?>?
/7U? ?>? @$ ?-H 2 ?e/????.d?? 0?2?IUxu?f ?6??
??L > ??B?0?+ ?)?M'?{ ??? Q???M' ?'a9` ???,?D )h}?%J M}??? �? ??0O?????[??< Z??[? bY??' GUZ???tcG ??? ? r?}.??(? ^??_,???vT?{??BW? ??OmZ?
u ? ?"7? 9 N?
B? ?+>?B?b/?? o??W?q7?s?G Dk?: -IDIf?? ?_?N6?V??&??t?R??|Hc M?; X?R N|???E6Z??/ n?8?4??om??*?D?]E?? N !??2L?R ? K.?????B n????q?2.?
)???*??p?? :I?4J Q?0 ??k?m?? ?? ?'??T?.i? ?/?a-$ ?
^? ?B???U???BK???E??? ?H???!g?t?8h??nZGR(???O0?9??]n?9???? z_?? %p ?j?1 ?? ??/b?JT?J6??? E????3?w? kf ??`??SN'|?f ?DR9???c?$??"? ??o??H?i? ?Ag4 ?R ? ? ?+/f -c??I& ??J ?@?? d?a? 9???%?2?�??_ XF ????A?'K??_S?xq^?? [??Q??, ,k??J???? ?+K~d?0? ?;??x?<2?Yg "u,? ?6x?(?9?& ?D? ? ???4b???P?? ?OXZ?A? v? 41`K%}?8? t?0A?? ?y?&A sR? ? J??-?f ?lG ?? RS]??{NPR??? )?d??&?�??Y`?Q??Z? x?"????? ??2???#?D?@ ??E? ?+H+ O?? K`br V?pPZGOc}q ? 6?DZ?$8??r Cm???~un&D?#?? C?ckQ?YL? 0=????[??D {w?m ?Mu???? T?0 6#c?K ???cd ?>?7@? B?~3?P???;??%??/??;?C??X?@yLU ???s????>??!?? �g3?L?k0??K D? ???? ?xWq??b ?P?}??1c?} ?]?=eZ?xQQ' E??!? ?x-??Z?d???t?? .t"????zY? r9??5u?c?) ????;?^?:?/?C ? ?f?>? ?t???u??W5??< =?C ?1#GK?:??f?M-??,?>[?4?Rs ??x??= ?? ? ?? F?Wp?? ?Rv>#? ?
7'{?????3 h9k?.Y? ?[?.?{? ?\?@4 ?h??3; ?p?hR??.@ ????1 > G?qd??b5?S?? R=?hQ?2 /?_? ??N?+=?n?:5??H?F?sR;?=H?z??i??R ??? J? ) ?{?!?0 F??[f?i?f?Y??1?F?%~$?- ?O3cQ?y ??b?{??I?9?DP} ~?B? ?7|a???#?,c??# v??V??y B4??h??Xh?(M ???y ?#? ??d B?????p8!O ?5???(?$9V?t/m?Ys ???+? ???8???????x????p?`?w=?(?bY ?8 ?~?A?K[? ???$????R@?j?? ;N>??3? ???7[ ? ?O?>?#?*? ? ??VSE ?x$????4;?~E? g9??? '? k? ?; ?Xh ??vB~?? 6? ?4L t \?v-Zp?)??=?~R? W? ?`LXM ) T 0|????? ?\ ???R?h?Od? [????4`????*Mi8^? ??N?+>I ??????c?? ??c 8 ??j?�????d6O?n? ?? ? ?LV?ZG?\o?6?Wz?GZ???fP???FI q??T?B29?f??T?? ???Gn???n??8G ??u= `vc 5?G ?+f?? W?i?s? {w# ? ?f7?? ?t$'??pIu 2} ?nAr?^'1? ?:?U?b?]??D? ? ?S? ?=?a J$?G ????d)?? c0?F???f? ?wc?]?bOn? ?e???W ?!? ???g?u?????.?? H?f? {?LR@X??????{??P ?Ke [g8 F)Och1,?>Z{S??z??9q=?;v'?a??I??? ?E?3r??gC? ?,Up?'??;?a??X? g?wD??R??Dd"?$+#^?? ?kX? !?p?}2 ?+?_? ggk ?&???53l`?=?_K"Q? ?%??? ?F? |?%?H? ? :?{?!?? ?e? ?B?%0G ,29??
Vf?`??- ??????R2 Ci?{? %6, -*?? '?cUi???|??s?)?W? ? ??a?
?????@*I?? ??.Xn???{?*?5? `-K ?mg??P?! Fo?8? ?h?~a??] Z?s??)J?? nI?xGz ?Ca???J????;qL?" < S ?\?it,?g?? ?? {F????-??K*?e ?!?ek??*?s]?/B??F??*@??C?4i%D'9nYW??M??0?e�r ??? R ?1 (ZY?? ?R?rY?j2?[Q? ???&???`Z ????S??p?Ar.K_Reqv? ???KPR?E??/?{T% ??????? ?*??i"???RSrZ?R?U?fc? ?q? ???5uKr ???? >?a???p?0Y??c??lLqL? P?b"2 ??Tw0 S5ZK~?' Oh?
l??b ??n??? ?? ???b???)t?? ? ^?? MU??: ?G ??(???A ?~ .[]} )?? ?oE?k?Z?S y?? ???72& ?p-1q??a ???we? ]peY? W?\??A???[`??j)??
Ya!?FI?@1???m?
? ? ?M ??? 4 . i??/?L?????!i?* ?? ?P??? 6??U?< 1?????`Lk11<#?D_?~g? G ?qI\??? ]U?= ??O?k????? ??I? ??CA~???jE ?/PK ?onC?5��q7��PK � � �?YG=������������ ���settings.xml?Y]s?: }????w ?N?N???nia?n??I ?2?S??? ??% ~j!?%K?H???"?Go U?? ?# ??:?N?????? '? k ?8 ?+ ??%?^ ?:}|?4???U?@?_ ??VOj?Z5??d/,x ^???????4Y[o4 ???j??b L?nW?%? ??g?d6?3??4W?? l???1*???X?}-XHv? 0_???{???_?"?F 9?'z S@h?y~Y?5n??(?#wa??+g???r?/??gy''??y9?!??r ~R??8+ >??|�> ?gLLAml0F? ??2?b{ ?9?G?a ?q?7|%dQ% >,???U~?%?Pz??~ ??7???? v?&?O????;??J??H?????eQT ?9XU ?F~' ?irurU? -? ?\O_?] ??? 6?m???k?A;??(?aB??j < ~G? ?9???y?q??? H_?S??C,?&]?,???g?? ??0b?3e?(F ??.l?O1????a?.??? ???) ? ?1??n]?T?#????m??N? ???e?+V ? ?8O?N?D }? j?C&?:?? ?:??? + L?&m?K?g?L ?$?W; ? `??7 a:???9D? c?R?N?d?ll? 1?? o?????f+ ? ??. ?d??)???:? ????CGy9u7eN2 ???R?? b?"?bAq??o?HM?_?/??Ysu?????�PK ?%8? ��I ��PK � � �?YG=������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ??? ]??S??X ??A ? ?k H??\??? ?? ?~]K??? ??&?ZF;?Nh??~?c ?L?B?)? ? 6 ??????m??j?D???m ?6??Y?b??A?, ?a?m 0_???\? ?,b?$?? ? ?R??? t??? ?z}h (:I?? ?"?u???15 S??"? ???? ?U B?w+ -;]*????T? \?qY?iU????l7�G???r? _H??D??F ojT?#???n9??;?Ik? .j^????? ?i"?O_? Iv ? ? ? ???r??? g Top