B K Mohan Kumar vs State Of Karnataka on 3 February, 2011

[Cites 2, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

B K Mohan Kumar vs State Of Karnataka on 3 February, 2011

Bench: A.S.Bopanna

IN THE} HEGH COURT OF' KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE)
.I.)A'E'ELI',) THIS THE 3"-13 DAY OF FEISREIARY 201 I
PRESENT

THE HON'I:3LI§3 MR.J.S.KHEIwLr«'XR, CHIEF 

AND  _ 
THE: HONBLE MR.JUS'.I'1.{3Efx.S.1{3OP:'h--T$§§~lA"~.: «

wnrr m:«:'rI'rIoN No. 13355/2;} 1o{:§;Mg1$::\«I:-'S.-.1§IL;V   "  _ 

C/W.

W1' Nos. 23838 / 10(GM-MMS], T.12278»1 :2--2s2/ 1G{(§M4*MMSe 1'

PIL), 12701/01'(GE§-RES~PIiL-), *_  
5672/O8(GM-MMSJPIL}, 4949,/os{GM¢MMs~9:L),
1258/08(GM-MMS-PIL), 2_804§3,(09(GM-MMS§,
18356/10(GM-M1'./I:'.3;PIL}'; 23554/1._a(GM~MMs),
6924/2009(GM~MMS-P11») .3; '303994j'--2'@O9{bGM~MMSJPIL).

WP No.13355/2€310((3y1%li:1${E1\{.E~VSrf?IfI;};§';  " 

Between :  

2. B K Mman E§sE,i.mﬂ_1' '  ..

Agéd'}fib<)L1,t 30% jg':-3211955"

S/'.0 Rg1mg1%";aa,§s',V% "  _   .

R/O Bagawadi}.Hc>séih:;1Iii Taluk
H()nn'aI11M~Ta1't1k"  .-- V 

 Dvi,-tétriitt, "  Petitzioner

may 3}:  Ramesh, Adv.)

1  " -Stia't;£:"_t_3---f K;.Z1i"r3at.21ka
A ._Re.p,by" Sec:1"et21ry {Mizms 8.: Geology]
I)e'pari:'1neni, of 1ndus':;ries S2 Cc>nm1er<:e
\,7_i"<;1_f_3'a1'1a Sc)L1c':ha_. Banga}()3"e

«     I.)irc3:c'é:0r of .EVIi.:'1£::ss & Ge(31()gy

Nc:e,49, Khainija E3I'12.1V2.ir1
I') IJev21:'2;§ Ursa Road
B2mg_ge1l£;:rc3:-- 55000 '1



3. SB. S1II"(iSh, S/0 BEiS.':1\/'al'1I'1ETt,
Aged 8.b{')Llii 41 years,
R / at A11 gel rapum,
"I'.Narasipur T a.E:..11s:, F»/E)_s,=:sc>rEt I_)isi:ri(rL

4. K..S. I)ayanar1d:»3.
S/0 KEV. Slﬁarath Kun'1a1:_
Agsd ab<)ut': .38 years,
R/' at A11garapur.21,
Ma1le1vaE1i Taiuk,
E\/Ianclya i)is'£ri(:t..

N. Cha;nd.r21sheka1* Goud,

S/0 Shadakashar Goad; 

Aged about 38 years, ' 

R/at N0. 225, 2511"' Cross, ,v 

C Block, Vijayanagalr 3"';=Siag€%, 
R/IyS01*e.   I 5 v  '

EJ1

6. Sr1'K.N.S0m[.ashei§:a;1"». :" V

S/0 Ni.?1ge'.-GQi¥'(i.21.;     '
Majqy, Rfti' I\5€f;w:,;s1axg_i13.a' 'I(.oppa111f1,
'1'K :Nar}21'sip.t,; 1"a7"Fa111'k.,. ' 
Myﬁorxs' I)is'f:*'i.€:1A:'.'%   _ 

Sri va:--;:_um Niahczsh 
Ma_§0r, 81;)' D0ddétbaIésav211'aj11,
, / 0 'Va1"L1ria=..\5'i11a,g~3,
" ~Mys'0re"--Ta1111<,V VIK/i:\?sc)1'€: I)ist;ric:i;.
.  '<3_sp£)13ci'e:nt4 Nos. 3 to 7' are
 _,i1*z1Qi'eVaciéd_\'{,'0 dated 6.8.2010)... R<~:sp0'r1der1t.s

fa]

X (isy sf; K01I<:AGA f01'IR.1 81 2,sn 33 Km,
Ad.VL"._i'<)'r R3 82 4, Sn' L.M. Chidatnzmdayya, Adv.
'  * for i11'1pIeadiI1g app3i<:am:s {A42/10]

~T _  This; Writ: Pe2'i.i't;io1': is fiiecl 1.:nde1' Articles 226 and
 w.722;;7 of 'éhc: C{)3'1stit:utZi<)n of India ;:='ra_yi11g to quash the
  i,m.p:2g:1<%d E.'i()I'i1Iﬁ"LiI3.i{Tf3.'[Zi{}f1 damd 19.03.2010, Ar1I1€x11r<:»«
 <.D iS$Ll€?d by flhif lst 1"€:+:p0I1dc":1'1t in N0. C 1 44'? MMN

" 2009 by '£1116 i:<.:~;s3:.1e GE .21 writ Qf c::<::r'f;i<)rari or :a::1y zathrsr

21ppr<>pr§a£".€: wrgit, afszxtiex' er di.r&:{:§:i::>r'2 amti <::t:<:'r.?



U:

5»

The E)ir<3.ci:c>r of Mines 81 Ge.<_)i<)gy
Khanija Bhavan.

Race CG"Ei11'S€f Road.

Ba1'1g2al0r<:é-- 560001

x.;J

The Sernior Geologist
D€p{:1I't'1'n(',I3ii of Mines & C}€¥€")10§:{}:'
(_Pv'Iir1<3s {Dix-*isi(:r1)

I).C,Offz'C:c: C<)mpc>u.11d, 2116} }7'].0a':,
Shimoga.

(By Sri R G K0118. AGAf0_;f res'1'3<)v1'éd<31'1t:;}' '7  1  V

These Vv'rit: P<~:i:it'io11s are fiIéd 1.111d<:%1f Afi;i(::i§:s 226
and 227 of the C0nst.i.~t,uf.i0I1_..of--.ff1'dié1L._prayii1gA $0 quash
A11x--A, Notiﬁ(:a'i:1'o11s all-.. 29.3;.v20*li"s~:=;ued by the R3.
Grant. stay all ﬁlrther p:for %cvc5'di:1g;sT"-- .};)V1:':~s:1;ant. to the
impugnt-3d N0t4ifi<1ati()11$.~An.x--A-dig '2[9,3 f20'1O issued by

Between : 

1. Chzlluvaraj _  V. 
S/O. P11tfTe1;~_:-w:--.1n2V}»'.  "
Aged .50 Y<;2é1"1':-3_. ' - 

'  -.S'hé:s1§.et--.'?Iai'I<A """ "

:2 »SV 1...'./1t.'cA MdaI1aika

' »Ag.(~_3d  Yéars. V V 

2;;

 3'. Kempza _.?€z1i}§"a

L S/O. I,a£;:3 Bas.21VaIinga Naika

' ' 4" -- ..  ;:'\._g<~T3::i 453..-'i7e211"s

  , 'M:m£.:::swam1y

'  SEC)' I.}c>1"z1isu«*21.n1y Nazika

  ....A;;e,d 38 Y<.=:a.r5s

" A .  Q " " N21g2;:,rz1j 2-2. N z1ii<;a

 / {.1 I'v'E:1r:ia1:12ai1~:2:

 . .. R(3Spd'1_1d%:I';'é,_s   _  _ { f



xfu
, x
R

6.

-~--.]

Aged 48 Years

SI'iCH"£E1Z'£i
S/O. Kalelilaikez.
Aged 32 Years

Na11jL111daswamy
S/O. Late Ma11'igg;()wciz:1
Aged Abou1:4 47 Years   _

A13 An-3 R/At: Bokkahal1iVi11ag<: M

Post. Chikkanaiah Ch.ai1?21 Hob}-EA '

Nar1ja11gufuTahlk. Mys'o1jé'-{)isi."' V _ V  
   V".T.;'3Petjt.io11ers

(By Sri M S Rajendra.p1fasad A::es<(:j(:i;1'fs-zs, Ad"v:s.,) 

And :

I .

!v

State: of Ke1f.,_'f1a_t.ak:.g' _ _  - 
Represe11:_ted}jh.y :'"t€;~. CE1ie"f Séc'_1*éta;13¥----VV'*
  
Mines em  --Gf-aoioggy'-.I)'e};:a ngm
M .  % '    " Vi'd.11"az1a.  dhi
B2'i.:1g.2_11<>r€é   f

Se11i&0rL 1"1cl"'S(§ieV2A:1t_'i:&'~:;*!:},»»4' J
Mines  G'c01Q-g_{y'--7{)épart1n.e1'1t

VKiiv<:m.pL'1i1ag.;a1*a Main Road
V. K ' . .- . . . . . .. '

" V _ "'I"h:{%~1;) e2.;j'L1Tiiy Commissi0r.1.e1"
._ " .fV\/1y'S()i_(?_ _D~.7.:S'f,
' Mysore'  '

D "'».3€:é.s1'eshe1.

" r /01 BasavaE.a1'ajappa

Aggezéi 3 E Years

V '  i32i\¥, H11 Eir1"t.21v1..:

N211'1ja1';.;guci1,: .



1.1:

Siddaiiiagti

S/O. Siddaiah

Aged 38 Years
Housing Board C-oI03'1;.r'
Nanjeuzgud

6. R I13<:ih2111
S / O Ramaiah
Aged 38 Years
R/At: Hejjigge   
Kempesiddana Hundi P055': '

Na1'1jangt,,1dL1 Taltlk.  I?§:¥Sf30:id(:.iq--ts _ "  T

[By Sri RG. K0115  :'or7I2.._: :9'   
Sri  K Stmasia f()~:f_R4_ R)  ' ' V

T his Writ: Petit.i.0r1_  fi.i_ed, .l,1:.I'i(f1{;',f..';!Xft.iC1€S 228 and
227 of the COHSTitLI.tiOE1H5'_)§: In.d'ia; p;*ay1'n.g-.t,0 quash the
auction pr(J(:ess__ issued.._ by 'R2 if}. ti-315-pact of sand
evactlation a11.§:t.iQ11._pr(§iceedi..ngs"ii1--.50"iizfas it relates to
I~"I0r21Ia\/e1di~BG_kk¢%;1*i_aIij_v,"-'  Bo}~;kah'a_1li"~Saragu ru and
B0kkahaE]iw;Alai_nb'urL; "-'.sf¢'._11'21gé's  15.6.2007' vide
A1'z_n_ex.A. and éL.u«:_t:i011 'prd(é.€:e(iihgs'§hteld on 16.6.2007' so
far as if: 1'€1'ClT;€ .'T-j?- i:()"*'tf%"Ie Said t.hré;L--'w:1i'ez1s vide AI}I1€X.A and
etc, '  = = 

W123' PETITION Na. 56?2 madé GM-MM-S-PIL )

Between': " V' '

 V S / O'; C}1;é2.11dr'éii$«11§%kar
' "Aged A:3Q()z.:_1>?. I }'{ears
 R/At D()d,dé1b21gi]u Moire
" " "  :I3r§iidabag1'}.:.1' Post
 ' S~{)'&3a.1'ei'' Hobii
' '1"_1\€21.i?a--:s.i1311ra 'i'21i1,2k
 __'3%\;€ys<:;rt% Ef)ist:ir<:i;



9

Hirayaur Village of'l'.Na1'a-sipxfwa Tq. Mysore .Disf.riCi: and
etc,

WRIT PETITION 370.4949/2.008 (GM~MM»S}ﬁ;g} 
Between : '4 'V .4

I, S M Rath11a1nma

W/O Shiv21.ma1Iap;)21   

Aged About 45 Years I
Occ:Agri(:uIt,u_re   *
R/O Somazlathapurel vil»1:age aniri past" _
Akkihebbai Hobii, KR. Pevtj"":E..'fc1i11k" _ V _ V
Mandya I)1"s{:ri(:t   

Ex}

P1'at.hama '   _

S/O Shivamallappa' '  "

Aged About 33 Yea::s_' 
O(3(?iAgfiC1lfF'.Z:L1i'.€   _   
R/' O Sam;iI1a§1i:;l*:§1pL1i'--1fa€ViE1agé3.a_r1d '1:->«a'st
Akkihe:b'b;§_}4.. K,-R"."Pet"fI'21IuVL:'

Mandyé1..VDi:sf;:§i(:t." '   -

'..)J

CIi'an.c_i:'21}j;'3--3,--~._ "a  --

8/ C}.S}1.ivé1m21J}1'ap;5a_.  é V

Aged About 50  '
O{:(::Ag,'1*i('u'1m_1';:: _ A "
 'O?ASom2iI1a§:he1pL:1'a Viliage and post:

 '-Akki-hebbe11E~It)f:}ii;'K.R. Pet.'1"'a}uk
' 2 , Ma .I}.iSfI'i(.'i".

 ~.   'CVV 'lvfgiiflj i:z;;f1{1i:.ha

A  / O V C'E1a,1 rm I1devaraiah.a
A;gc3tiAAbO1:t 42 Years
OC't::Agri<:12Ii:1:1'e
AA ' R./O S0m211fzai:.hap141r21 village and _p0si,

V' * .._AE:ki11ebb21} Hobii,  P<3i:'E'a}1?.:k

 1\ffz1I1cEya. Disi:'1.*jC't'  .Pet1'ii<>I1<3rés

[By Sri I?<1i:'a:1 KL1ma.1", S11' MK. Sm*<;-*,s~;E':x 81'
Sri Ch21:'1<iz'as;hek::3_r 1,. .Aciv:+;.,}



E0

And:

1. T he Si.at',e:t of Karr1e1i.z;1k2;1
E)epart.a:nen'r. af Mines and Mitlerzds
Vidhzma S()Lz<:iha
Bangalore
By Its Seirretary

iv

The DiI'€C'f.()I'    _
iZ'«epa.1*1:met1t, of Mmes and Mi:=;1er3.Es'  "
Kanijzz Bh an-*e1.:15.R21c:e C012 rse  ~ 'T
Bar1gaI()re ' "

3. '1"'I'1e Daptliiy COIn1'I1iSS;i0II1€§*.._
Pamdavapu1'a S11b_.I)ivisi()11.  '
Chairman __  ._  _ V '
Sand M0nit.0r'ing C0n1mi'i'._tc;§'@ }
Pandahvapxlra " V 1
Mandya Di§;1f1"i_(:t.

4. Seniori'Ge§)§-og§is'i:.__ 
Membe1=..S'e.(:;%ie;i,21r;V  ¢ 
Sand."Tv*IQf§;it,<)fi;%:1'g C<)1'11n1itfé'e" 'V
Dé.p21ri:n1ééI1'f;V Of "}'<./i1':1«r::é an d [Minerals
Myé;:)r€._ V    '

5. Senier "C:e01Q;};.iSt.7--,
 S'cc_féf.ary
. A  1'./{0111t<ji'1n--g_3§«Committee
' V. 3 1)-r:pa,r£;1ff3;e._11i: of 1\/1.11138 and Minerais
_   .V V

(3, ' __J 0iz1t.IfJi:1_*:fc:t.()1"
'EL')ep::3.rf,;fi1e,r1i; of i\/[mes and E\!Ii2'1c2raIss
Mézniilya

x _ The W'a.I':m' Resc)ur<:e5s D€;'\?€;?I(}}}EI1€'i'}i. If}ep21r'€.;11<:2I1i':
Vi<;i1'122.'r12=1 St:):.'1dha
V1'r:lh.a.1'1a Veecihi
EBa:1_;;;2::l<'>r<:=%, Resp, Sec;*ei'.21;ry  Re3s3p<3.I'1cia2:1i:s3

{By SEE RS" Eialie, AC};'3a for 814?}



ti

This Writ: P<=:1'.it4icm is ﬁiecl 1.II'}d€?I.' A.I"ﬁCI€S 226 and
227 of the Co1T1st.itut.i011 (If India p:'z1yi:1g to issue a writ.
of pmhibit_io:1 .e1.gaiz1s;i' t'11e respc)ndc",~m's No} to 5 and
pemons a(:i'.ir3g undetr t:he R1 to 5 fmirl calling for fresh
auCtio'11 .i.nSide the Kaveri Rivez', Kapiia E{1've:j7.._ei'r3d

Hemavatihi Rivez" for thsa pU.'{'p{)S€ of q141.2u'1j\_Iing (2'tdir34';1yyr,,
sand, wit.h0ut f<;>Il0w1'I1gg the mies as-3 laid ci<:>__x.;v'1'1"i1f;--...:£1E:__"«

etc. .

Kamatiaka Miztlor Mineral C(>zi1<:es:+;i<;m R1.1Ies;'-,_19.9rﬁg "a.i%1d _' --

WRIT PETITION No. 1258/2008 {QM;xg:1t»i';s#ptL)<   

Between :

1. Mahacicva
S/O Rama Gowda  
Aged 38 Years " _ --
R/O MugurL1  V  t 
T.N.Pu1"a, Mysore D'i's£:ri§:1, " 

L Gur11rs1111*--th__V . «-
S /0 Pat-31"'j;Lin§§%:§gnivdé1
Aged 33 Y€a:'--s5._  ' 
AkI{u¢r'Vi1iag€'«."'~.V 

TN. P1;:r'a~'I'a11t1k',"  JDis'::rict

%"'~'

_ 3.   ~

, '- S7C?'-LNavris\,xra1niy"""
. ' 2 _,Age:vd v.3€:3. 'Y~:321,rs
A  " A  12/I'>u;;;:;ja%}1a111:
' ~. '.(I*:,'N.'Pti1"_i'V1:Eii1.1I{. Mysore Dis;t'.r'i<t1,

--

. S/O___M S Nalayemaswamy A' 'Aged 28 '((32113 * ._Ir{.--B€1ai:}1.ur'e H.K.Keie 'I'z;11uk. Mysore D.i.:S-3i3"f(f,"[.

in]

9. 10'; V _ _ _ 2 '-Aged Y+;%'a1"s ._II EVIV£1]'I1",:'_2I1d Cross, ,._; V. ' Satish S / O Shivakunaar Swamy Aged 33 Years M'£1gl1I"£,i T.N.Pura Taiuk. E\fiys<)re Ilistricéti Swamy S /O P1.lHE1SVVa1'11y Aged 28 Years K.K.HaI1i, Maddur 'l.'a1uk, Mzmdya I')istr;€ct . :3 A B R21j(~3sah S/O I) Basava1"a} Aged 33 Years Mug-§11r11, '1'. N. 1311 raf" ﬁ Mysore DiStri(:f, " ' Mahadeva Swamyy" --

S/O Mahad*:jVé1ppa: =:

Aged 3_9-vYf3aEf§__--.'. ' ' Reddy3C0}.0"n,y . » T. ,_}?Lv1r'é's..,_ Mj.,«4*.:3_c)Vre __Disi;1'i"c,t_ V V V V. S/O :v{;1c2hz.1"--

Aged 4G~VYé:arsV-.

" O(3wR(-zddy Cfﬂony '- a T1'. N__.~P t1rg1, MyS'()'1"'<3' I)m;x§a3g;a»r"" "

T. P11 fa, Raddy Colony Mj,a':5gire District:

* Ijf='21yeu'1aradz1 K S 8/0 K V Shaaai; K't.:mar Ageii 34 Years R/O K.K£Ha.i1i M2:1d«:1m° T2,-13Lt1'E~:., 1'VI3._1":£iya, EI)E::«;ir'icét;

122. Rex-'21111'1a S / O Na11_;L1nagud1.I Agecl 35 Year:-3 Vivekam11'1cia Nagar No.1 L 2nd Cross.

'_['.N.Pura. Ikriysore i.3'e::i':31t4i<tr11er:j;i...__' ' [By 81"} Y N Nz1ga.I*aj21, A(iv.,} And : _ E. The S1:.at,e of K211'n.at:aka. ~ Reprc-3$e1.1t'ed by its Chiei'. Se(71'eAi--a:'y.. E3r..Ambe<:ika.r V(':'.€dhi Vidhana Smlciha Bangalore 55000)

2. The Senior Mixleraf'Sc--i.emié§i.} Mines 8: Geoiogy I)esp'a:ftrﬁ'£:>rii; V _ . N0 . 4, Gagar1'a1::h.L1nibi" DE; '. .R0ad.._ KL1vemp1;".Nf?f:§i1r, My5;%0r'é

3. The Déptlty' _C()xi:_n14i.'Séic)r1cr' _ C11_z1I1121féa.Ji_ai'1*ié1g;§e1r }7?_}is.__t_,r'i{:1" -. V .

C¥1ve1m_:2z'e1?}ai.::1.géu* «V 4' The 1}.£:3pL1i:y"Cdi':1'Ii1:5:=siOz1er MySc)re"'£3iSt;rj(;~t, Mysore» ' V' v-'.J._'.F11e;:---LSu.pe'ri11t;é1"2'd'if1g E11giI1e.€r . I\§;»1_t'iq11..21I"'Highways Circie V _ 'K. E<;;Ci_r(?'1s3_, E321r1gaI(tu'<3 56000}

6. ' .__DiSiiI"i(§i.jSiIpC1"i1'}ifirldﬁlfli, of Police C}1e3m2u'e1*ja11'1gz11~ I)isi;:'ici.. My.srférc:

2 jfl,'-t':s't.x'i('.t: Su.pe1':i.1'n'<e%:'1::i€:nt: Of P()1ic:'-2 _M.ys:;()rc% £')is'sf.ricf Ps/Iys<,>:'e,

9.

14.

V' 6.' 14 The }Z)ir<:ct,0r M11163 <3: Geologittral Scrience R£1(')€ C(')urs<=: Road, Barlgalore 56000} The Asgisiant: EIXeC.1,1tjVe E11_gi;'1<:re,1* National Highway Sub £)iVisi01'a E\2'i2z1av2z1.1i, Evlandya Districxt.

The Executive Engineer ~ Public Works Depart,me:t.1i:

Mysore Iﬁvision, Mysore The C()}"11I'.{1iSSiOI1€l" of P<)E;.Qé'~~ Mysore L' 'V The SL1peri11t.e11d€;?:ff)£' F'O1ig3€. "

.1\ﬂI'/*"So_1"é3 "

The Sez1iQ:1'«Cfe€:10gist: _, Mines &Vi}eQ:E0g#v.V Mysare: "

Régional V'VI'§-*2::n_s"p01*'t_Qff1C;~e;¥ Mys;;re._EaSf;

Mysore -

" Igiégizwxiaﬂ T'1i2ifié§p0ft, Ofﬁcer

- City st), Mysore.

A _ '}T'h:é'-'1fé.l"iési\i(i;a,r " .fjf«.N£1ras_;pa;;I*a, Mysore.

ﬂy'.' SL1perinie1'1den':; of }?'(.)1_i.C<:r 'Faiiz1._IééadL1. '1' N. pura 'I'aI'L1k ' * =.My3Vor<»:

'i'1"2€< E>:<:<:'L:i:ive E_.',:ngj§in<;éer P.W.IL)<e:part.r11e1'1i: Sub DiViSi.OET1 Na rasi pug: ]j'v'EyES()1'e ymd U:

19. 'I'he Regio1'121]_ '.l.'1*a-11'as:po1'€' Commissioner Mysore lT)i$t,r:ie1:

Hard Week Ci.rcle. .lVIys()re 2,0. T116 EIXe(:ut'.ive Engineel' l\§a.tio:1al Highway I)ivisio1'1 4t.}1 F-'ioor. C.F.C.B1,:ilding N1*141pa1f:h11.1'}§;21 Road Bar1g'a1_()re 550001 ._ 7]. 'I'}1e Exeemive Engineer l\L'aI:iona1 Higlmray li)ivisi.o1'.1 ._ " A , l%3a1.1g_§al()re & National l~li(g.-A"§.1V1'"E.?F_»?'21};' Ac1m'n_ B2111ge1lore l' Al "

22. The Police Sub ln's:.g_)e«r2to'--if 'l'a1akadu Police Si:21'tio'r: ' 'l'.Na1'asip111jaTaluk. _ g '"I'a1akadu_ V Ree~p()11dent,s Rl--R22) 'l'V?ii's§"\}':»'.1r:i:'§:., Pe'Eijt'iori'~.lS filecl"t1nder Articles 226 and 227 of'€;_l1e._{3()i1é;':,i'1;ﬁlio'tsl._ol7__1'ndia p1'21y'ing to call for the entire re'eords 1'e'r(V)r'12':_l'£~'.',r_1l'c:~..R'1.,i.;~1 respect. of all the relevantl doctzmentsl'c:o11(:eI'I1'i11gViihe s::md--aL1et1'on related filed forthw1t:h 1.e'.= 1i1w1ie'spé';~.Ci:A"'of Amzexul-es A. B and C the press} I51o.f,ifieaf1o.r1s is.-sued by S1". Geologist (Mines), '-Mi.I1'e_e§' 9,2-zed -.Geologfy""DVepa1-t.men.1_. No.4, Gagemaclmmbi Jo'cli Road, Km%ezn}3111'121.g21;', My-sore i;l"1e R2.

gymrr' No.28o43/2009 [GM-MM-S] Betw__€eI.l~':' 'I; x Sri 'l.<I"V" Ya;n:e1nz1raya1'1a ~ V /0 Sri. 'v'22:suclev:=aial'1 V' *».J?s;gr:%(.l Abo1,.;t 58 'xf"ear$ R/O K1.II'.'1l.'t.3V2'.1E1I E\l'aJ:::bz;1lzz \fi1.I.2,-1ge l\/leligge E3oe*£:, Pizl (fo{§e--5'?? 41.53} And Ev [6 "l'11e<2rtha11a1}i 'I'aluk, S13.i1n<3§{g21 I)is_~:t'1'ict4, K;-xrnataka Si'.ai'.<3 Pei.it'i011<3.1* {By S1-3 Ga1'1<;'*.Sh Bhat Y H. Am.-'.,] '_£'h<=> [Di-2put'.y C0mm.issi()ner Shimoggal E.)ist'.z*iCi Ofﬁce. <)f1:he: Depmy Commissioner _ .. Ba.}a.ra_j Ur:-3 Road, Shivan1()gg21?5'7??2O..1 i. S Karr1ata1s.a St;ai.e A .5 The Assistant Commiss£'o'r'i--e_1' a11c.§..Chai1':iia:j»._ Ordiraezry Sand Auction C(9.1ji1z1§t,1;.<2e'---- _ Shlmogga Sub {Division ' V _» ' Office: of the Assistmqzt. Cc3mn1issi(>S:1.cr Balaraj Urs Road, E31<:'iV;:1Li11o2g;>;5;§21¥53??"'£30I, Karn21t.aka S1:S21t.e 'S "

The Senmr ';'}_é'_(>1og:1_si:(l'.{{i.i1e'r2i1'}S '.A:1V_c.1 Membsr.S,e(::§é§3.ry Q1*d.ina1:ry Sglnd Auctioil Cy,-'J41n1i1i't1.ee"'Cj ; Mi11éé§' Ge."('x:1"0 pari"'rr1éi.1i, Minerjal I)ViV;s:«:i_(5r:S. f2.«nEi...Ef"Ir>Qn Right Wing Office of the Dé~p£:{;y"C,o1::1missiomer, Be1}21"2{ji Urs Poéid, ..S"f3iVv'am0ggaw5772O I Karnatéxka" SiV;;i--iSeL*~._ " "

~The--S71"e:hA21si}da'r""&' Member ' 2 _, c)i'Q'2'gii.13éxry Sand Auction Com.mi1:t<S:e V _ T11 c;'z:,.1ft}<1 "$1211.11 Taiuk _ " --.(f}ffi'(2~e'_'v_o£' Tahasiidar A ._"I'hcf<-3 Fflh'§ihE1}}i Post TY') 9 Chief' Exemitive Officer ' * S-.a11dV'M€mber of Ordinary Sand * A'(:ti(>n C<)mmii.i'.t:3e V' {/E. '1"a1'L1k ¥'a11<:haye1.t.11 ofThee:*t.}13.h21_}1i "i."'I1ee,rt4Ir:2111:.:1}Ii Post', 1'./Em~"xz'1ii Kxmaar S/G Siacasshezppa {§}<:>ww:.i2:1 Aged About. 35 Yea3_'s Kurtwaiii Past 'Theerthah21.I3i Tahlk ... R€Sp(}I1(i€§I'ltlS (By Sn' RC}. K0110, AGA for R1 to 5, R6 Serveédﬂ 'I"'h:is: Writ Pe:tiI:.i0n is filed ur1d::=.r ArticE§::«;i_ 227 of the C01'1si:i'£.uti0r3 of India pr3.y_iI1g {:0 "qL1a:s_h 1:hé:~ _ ordinary sand tender cum p1.:bEig'.....ap1(:t.ir:j)1;i"'I\§et{ifié'ati0nx "

dt.27?.8.09, produced as A:m1wF, in so iar as -it -r_ei.:1Vtr.-:s["t0 the auct:i0r1ing of the sand & graI1"t;i:1g'_'q:i21ri*3?it';.g'1:3ét$€--~ respeci: of an area of 2 acres. of 'i'h.= 2r1ga I'iV(.'--}ﬂ .b'£u'1ks;; in Sy.N0. 10 of Keiakeri \"ill21g§e,'E\/Itrttxzr Hr)bi.i._T'I<1e£::1fthah%111i Tq. referred to in SLNO. H e1r1<:1V}:i:.t;<?;;A, ' -- WRIT PETITION No. 1A 8.*a.5_§A.i2oL1;mQ.M 1(::§_M~MMuS §9'm.) Between :

1. Sri. J Aged A-1)"O';'1€; 58--ﬁ'ea«1f_éi--«/_ V ' S/O Ja'»ZaI9a33«pa ' ' K srm _ M % Aged About i38':Yéar_s;- ,» "

S / O iv _ 3. Viﬁri H Kariy'a'_:§f1z1 About. 38*~--'--fe:3,rs, A S,/C).}"{a.f1::;'mar1tharaya K _ .._§~:..ri' 'f{«V"i{.<;~I1§§'Eiamurthy ' Aged .Ab;:.;"ut. 38 Years. 3 / G R'a.§n21(:l'}2111drappa u *a.Sri 33{ I\§ag..;esh r Ab{')u1: 40 Yiaarﬁs, S / 0 Ram ac}1211'1<:i:r21ppa " Sri B Ane1I1E:.I*1z1z1e1g1.1.

Aggd About 35 'ﬁszarisz.

S/O Bheezmappa

7. Sri R Ha ['11)ﬂ1&1T{.h£i1'E1yE1 Aged About 45 'fears, S/O R211'1ga.1:>}'321

8. S11' I-3 Vt':e:"3.r":I1a Aged Abaut" 43 Years.

3/ O Bacie1::ma

9. Sr: T M Kuma1'aswamy Aged About 25 Yt:ar$.

8/0 I) 1V§a11ju_r1ath

10. Sn {)5 Manj'L111ath Aged About 28 S/O D Sreenivasii All are residing; At _ ' 'I'h<):'eE)c:e1j2w1gxhailiﬁz V Beiagerg 'Ci1al1ai;ere *;*a2u1;"

Ch_itraduzga= I3'1§~.{;rietV:[--'.,, V? _ . . ..Petit.i0ners [Bj-i_Sr._i Ski Rohith I) K, Ac1Vs._.) 1 , C}£")_V"f;"'.I'f1Iu1';f-j_IV] E'; of Ké":rIiéii.21k21 ,.§1§§eprese11t.ec1..13y its S€Crei:z«11*y, " «I)'epa1'f.1nent, ()f 1V[ii1.es and G<3()I()gy » A * -. .8 E3Lii,Iti~i.11g, 550001

2. A 115: vI)ép'::1'i'1y Commisskmer C}1it.1jadt1_1'ge1 District'. V ' C}iii;.3'i-1Ci113'g::1 T 3 " .._'I7§1.£: De:2})L,1i:..y if)i1'e(:'£0r Mine:-3 21ml G-eolcnggy C 1': ii.I°2;1e:1 L1rg2é1 20 Ser1i0r Ge0£(>gisi,{Mi:1e:'a1s) 8: I\/{ember Secrertary Sand Auctiozl Commitme Mines; 8: Gecﬁogy D€pEiI"(.II}€I111. Mandya.

4. The Divisional C0mmissi011€:1* 8: Pmssident Sand Au(:ti0n C0rnmit.t:ee Mines 6%: Geology {Department Pa.ndavpura Sub If)iv1s1011 Mandya.

(By Sri 12.0.1/(0119, AGA :'1féor?jR1'T§4jT'*~ This VVrit Peti.t;j0n is fiitci und'€_r"ArticE<3':~:AT228 §:{j1--l(x:i' 227 of the Constitution of E:1.di'a_Vpray1:;g.'g'.0'~ qi};iS1'1' the imp1,1gned 1c::t.'t.<«:1~ di;.11.5.10 issimci by the prgduoed as Anni'), directing the .pet.ii4i011::rf,"-ai€>t to use-.m.o to:rized boat for the purpose 0f5.._s"i;:nd--'_qu.a1,';*r3{1r1g'«zf$z. allow this WP with costs, in the circuni$f;_a'13TC<::§'*of <::~.'i's3«f:* and etc. WRIT 1=ET:Txo1:§jﬁn.6924/$m§93{§_;1j/iélxzgi-J1-s~P1L) Between: L V'

1. S'rj'VVi5é{hd£.1:£f;;ari§gé1 Shastry 8/ S-1 i131Véis"'Sh;1s1;Ij3}"v---- ., ' - Aged. About . _ AnaI1('}3}IT£\?1I1ffii.fEiﬂ} ~ V T,.E3. Ter'I1pIVewRt>ad*. A ' ,E§Ia1'1hz1r«5 7'7._.6O1 V .Petit1o11er A Poonacha 81 Sri Deepa, Advs., for Leaxpiexus, Adv. ,) j I . Siglitj of K8.1'r1at;ak.a » [3épz1rt.n1e':'1t, of Miness and Geology AA 'TL5f:.h F10()r. Khanija Bhavan * .,_R~é1ce Course Road, Ba1'1ga1()m~56GOO1 Repressented by its I)ir<-:(ti.0r id (3.

2! Depuity Dire.ctor I)eparii11';e11E', of Miiics and Geoicxgzy Hospet, {Deputy 1I)irect'.()r Ii}ep.:~n"t,n3<-311$, of Mines and Geoiogy Chitradurga The Senior Geoiogisi, Department. (if Mines and G€(.T'.1()g§T4 H:2m<::hi_m11a Building lsi. Cross, Gzmdhinageir. Dha:£'w9;~:i."

The Deputy Commi$sioi1cif"

Bellary Dist:::*ici' * ' Bellary The Deputy CommiSé_it>r1'a1".E"

Haveri Disi;rJf_<:t ' Haveri i '1'Ii>j6 fieptﬁiy CE}ﬁ'1rﬁ'isVSi I132; ' V DEE}-'(:11?:&1g{3I"C%, f;).is't'tfi{:i, ' __ -- E)av--:mage1"s: " A ' The D'c}:;ut.y CQIr;;Iiis_é:'i0r1e1' DiE€e'{:AI'Vl(",f V .....

'i"h_é Riagjicnriai Dire(:t()r(E111v.) ' V _ u}i").f.2vv}V3'£:.1'v1'"1':»!"I"1f.§I'E"T,:. of Env1'r(>11meIi':, & Ec(>1c)gy ' --.I3r. '$é:vl.i_n1:;B1:iidi11g;s

-- A Radio Beilary.

Thé AS(»:%(:retary* SE;.!%.C «Si Seiiior DiI'(jtCTZO1" ["i'e<t:hnic::a1 C611) «If)epz;1ri,me13i; of E:-11vi.rm't1mer1é. & Ec01c)g.,_>}r

-§V[.S.§31,ii1€1iI1§§, 'I:3.2mga1<')re R«:%sp01'id&{1£:ss (E33! 81*}: E%1.{}i Kcélie, ASA} N U:

R/C3 Tamaéaddi T q: Jamakhandi Dist: Bagaikat Respandﬁnts (By Sri R13. Kisiiﬁr, AGA for Rita 10, Sr: GB. Shastrjr, for R12, R11 served}~~._ » i- A Thig Writ Petition is filed LEIIEIE1" A1."ti¢1€:é" 24' V' 22? of the Constitution Of India praying to.V*;?i§_1"_éc:i; "

to take necessary actien & to stogysanéd :'f:1iniﬁg'4aictivjityi'v., by R12, in Survey Nos. 174, £715; "7Efan1'a.r;1add.ii f Viliage, Jamakancii Tq 8:: Bagalkot 'E3151; "Dire'a:t 1h;e..R'3_';'«t.d'~. take necessary actien in respect cf iiiggel mini*:;gVof sémd by using machines, motor b0ais._& alga1r:.j;.111siiié1g""i:1e'9.vy lorries, [t3.var<:$I vehicies in trzé;nsportiz1g-- the said lifted sand and to protect the .¢:r1Vi1f:}r11*;i<_§nf 'and e'éc.",-. These Writ Peiiti}fiﬁ$" hearing on interlocutozy app1_icaii0ns..£h_is <:1ay,_ C'1*1i+3i"2Jj_u:s€i:iCe made the ibllowing order'; * - ~ ' J.s.mmKm, cg.

»V._§;VVarii0us pgiitioﬁs came to be ﬂied in public Court aasailing the acﬁcm of base-

'i;.3;i'1%1r1*ying sand out of river beds, with the 2-18$-i§'E;a»3'i*V*:..:.AVu.5: mechanized baats. It is in the background V' '[§}{:';'[f)VVIV'ﬁ}'€1" in the petitions fiied in public interest. that ' Qperaiiens with the aS$isia.r1{:e sf mechanized ii Hﬁiciats were ordered ta be :3-"stayéd by this Court, perradirig 26 the finalization of a policy at the hands of the State Government:, in (:0nne(:iio11 therewith.

2. A policy deei.s3icm is :~s1:at,eci to have be.en."t,e3~:e1: by .21 highmpowered c<)111rI1i1'":tee c:onSti"€:L1t.eci bykllei' ~ G0v<;~.1'nn1ent on 291.201 1.. Tl1€T""' decision has also been placed on f'h.e7*fe(,it)rd'-<)_f this; along with a "presentation

3. Al} the sL1ee:e§3.sf111.A"'i:>,i(i§}e'fs:._t xvhe"*h.:1"(§ been granted quarrying iease for 'eXtr'éiaii.i()_ri'--<S_f from river beds, angj ":b..5;:v:» 'qua.L'_ryeegﬁeratieijis eaijme to be stalied as c0ne;:'e'{iL ie11.ﬁ:§ve_0{"'ffVfgjL1i1rAjfiir_)11 granted by this Court, are ready and the terms and Conditions 111$' policy decision dated V' Igeigirned eouz.1:=s<~:1 for the pet'.i.1:i.0ners, who had a;5;;3ri>'aeE':.r;t1v 4'€,hje_.Cc)L11't. by filing writ pei:iticm.s in pubiie inieteet, l1'e§v<3e§?e1' vehemently ctcmtenci. that in e1c1dit:i<)11 x_t,0 t.he~~ cie._termi:1.21ti<)r1 ef the Statte G<)vej':1n1e'11t in the igg3r«:}1c%.xj dé:i':eé:i 29.1.2011 if is iziaperative to require 211} _' '£iEi:é'3'5+s<:" x:¥1"1<3 have been iS5§55i.1(E?(i {fL1£1}T'I"'}'iE1§§ leasses. to add.itione1lly, obtain "em=i1"o11m.<:%ntal <:1erar2m(:e" from the (',()Y1C€'}f'1'l€d a.ut;horitieS. before they are pernaiiied to use of mec:h.a:ni7;ecl bmats far exi;ra<:t.i()I1 of 3211161 fr()1"r;'*.:f':{a.<'_ei1§ beciss. in This; behalf. our at.E:eI1'£.i0n has ~ an "<-:nvir(m1'ner1i:al clearaalce" <>rci.<':1"; ~;,>;ra:'§.i:€ciV"'i1'i.'aV"c:.2i:3e by the <3nvi1'<:>nme11t,al aL1t.ho'rii.ies, °}':>v:'()'3<.1lil';>'i?l'.ing_§_vi'.'.la<;: mechanized boats for €Kt1'aC'€iUI_1\"Of Salld_'ffO1ff11".T{'ii$~g:Vf"b€dS.

5. Having given e:Qn$id§fllt.ion to the submission :a.ldvan§ted:..3gi' the learned coxmsel forlhéyg this Court in it would be in the {:0 require all quarrying leaseAh0ldVi:2isMl r:jXf.i'2_1c§TEin'gEand from river beds. to seek an ~a;§:l€1il4i011a1'"=7?<§:;1Vi;f0nmentz1.l clearance" from the e1jV'irQ11.r_11:2snt.;:'lvauthorities, before they can be p€3ITi'1iU",€d t,h!;: {:59 ciiﬁaéilgz-harzized beats for c-:xt:'1'acl*.i0r1. of sand ﬁozn ' . V :"iVe1' heiifs. V V In Vi€\V of our del:em1ina1,i()1'1_ l1erei.nab<)ve, we ' lléareby climct all qua.r':yiI1;g :1-;a11d l<321se«h.()lder$ from river b{=3d.ss, is file an 21i':%'i£§zwi.i. wit.hi:'1 =:.:>m~.= 1?Vf;?.f3§<Z from i.<>clay,

7. A1} such 'tee1se~i1()1ders wiii be entit,1ed {:0 ex'i:r21{:i: ssemd {£11 ihﬁ? and of the pezioti co1'1t.e1np121tc3<i uncier tgheir :'espe<:i:ive 162156 a1g.reen1e':1i',ss, and in addiiiion . 't."o-._ "éh'i:_ af(:>resai<fl. for an 21d£iiti011a1 péerioﬂ eyqual to t4h'é=d:_1f21fi€:1:f§."*'--T ' £131" whicih, they were I'eSt.r21i'ne:d by $1716 j='_11i;(:'415i'I"rVIz'4 ()fd.€}}'.'SV"v isssued by this C1oL1rt: from ext-re1<rt.I: ig_; aéc-1ﬁd. Disp0s<:~,d of in izhe 21f'care:::.,i;i;ie:i,_Mf;ern*12s,_ ' % %%k%%%%%%%%[§;:g;g£ Rzgﬁs fa Sk/W _ _ Indc::x: yesfno'

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court