Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

M/S Siddeshwara International vs State Of Karnataka on 28 August, 2008

Equivalent citations: 2009 (4) AIR KANT HCR 367, 2009 A I H C 2612 2009 (3) KCCR SN 99 (KAR), 2009 (3) KCCR SN 99 (KAR)

Author: N.Kumar

Bench: N.Kumar

 wvwn: vr nmmvwammn nan-in  OF KARNATAKA HEGH COURT OF KARNATAKA I-HGH COURT OF KMNAMKA Hlfi-I COUET OF KARNNAKA PHGH O

Q.,,,...;

3"?

 

mxrm ms mm ma 3%? :3? gmauggr 2@;:>;a _
aamag %   A

 

 

EETWER:

ms $m$Bs§§@a.w,g§ :§i%F;RT§§fg%T:€}Na:'  
3-zmammzev 

    
 

gmmégg .   

 

:33;   am;
F!v:ga%§§;T%$i:%:$I--§<%f:*§2'#5§;%§e@£.,?;§:;%§4 .%fiTE=$§

é.I*¥I§:

 -    v-3i'3fiE-E?:'_§s,R  =

A  A :&i£»T:?%%.s1%§J Yma:

S'Tfi§TE  5:? V 
ggésia .3"? gm ..i$aE.fiE';%'}¥;"&E§.*'
. fig?

       

 . A''Bg§ar§'G~£5§L%£3[Vl!¢;€5,~5ée§ am

 ER:  

 - .M;3.EUE.«EG
 mxsawm-55$ mg;

$5; Rfrg§¥§a§@vmr:mH'§
"  ' .  E'? %E%'' §'§EE§E

  
      

  saw 'Ws'r2.E3%" a-ream 1a%m*f3:[email protected]'?

fififfifififllfiffi
 R §I$'TEIfiT
%§RE-SE»I*3"'7§}%§ 3? F23

  
   

     
   



$3..

   

2, '}{k  £3 3;    firm gagged Q,

the htzszirxms af  it wag grmxtaé 3 

fiatml 3.331 ajszneg

 

 

 far a fZ1fiI"iQ(i Q1' 261 :;:y:a;if'§:fuvé§ii;~ 

mtam af 1113 am% is: $§rJ%'fi.1.i2§ mi' 

mam "§'a1u§£, mm Hggm *m%*%

 

kg, zszwagi. 

 

seam gm  22$  :§ft;"'::::€=

  

mm: vzaf whémh t%1:_2':  
Eianumm gzags  tftmir mm
mm 3%:    éctrasent go: the

   

uasiab   '  

mpg    §vap§2t_§* fiamfimm' af

   

E'mrm13f',;« Eff  333% 

  fix }:k%3.1%f§  

   

  fiafiirxg am thfi gafi mpgrtg {ha

OF KAINATAKA HIGH COURT OF KAWJARKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COIKFOF KRRNAMKA HiGH C!

 

 ~ rmmmasmled far ism}: <3? mi:m?1g base.

 tk pafifimnar agpéifi firm' Emwimnmmuirafi

.' ' -. An " Q:  

uwvrl MVUKI U? h%NNHlflKA H15" C§3U_RT

 

in at: 231%  §' :2r3{3.§ ax pm"

 



 *  ifififlgfiét,  33$   

 

"gm

 ,§ 120635 as ya" éxwxazxswié Em?::'1*'m'1mgz':taE

   

C$mnm
mficrzs tlm

 

a::.:;%:m2im§Ema wag  . _ A

awmmminatfi Ea 1%  § mm 

 

 §flfla3    

ma  
sham  ta   

 

 

 m"%an figs 'hm 

 

Eeasafi. prewrgru 3%  
am 1%    wag ma
   Vim aéajwé fig: am
«mg mg 122%  E mafia 2%? which ia
§¢9&wfi fig  m §'1m aha mm,

    rwrmmsiatizagzz, éaéfifi 

 

  mam m  T 

 

 

V'   names: 3% be pazmaii Eajgtfirzg fiw said

 

 

 

A  3uw&;u£=fiig%': Emma}. {»

  %&: pxfiéiamg m fiafiifiékfi rm mm  § fie

 ...........'. 'WI .....m.....,....-. ruwn ug_.--;;. ur mmmmm mun COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or xAamAw<A ms:-1 oomror KARNATAKA HIGH co

 



COUKF OF KARNA"£'AlCA I-"G4 CW3! OF KARNATAKA MGR CC

   wag

nun uvulu Ur !\m*<NA:A!S.A Hitifl  GP K&RNA'TAi(A HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH

..$._

ptwacluow Elm oamamt leétaf afigtairifi unflar water

{Pnevermcm mg fianfifil {sf %11u:{imnj fin: 
iirmmzm-Q arid Air {Praia-antwn aw 

 

Folhztion} Am E5 per     

Ensrimrxmexma}. Clerasranm   

the afiresafi aasflmé. ktigm  2

 

E '  fig   _ 

   

  rm': ms

 
 
 

 

 lfiifififi  "iiifi-'£3§Qfifl' R83»

 

amfimz ::f_t}1ea ~  

3. A  _   mm gawk E3": the wifi

 _ am: aigjmmm wag}: hafi  gmrited bf;

    &W"fi at thug

 

 the §¢ti$§£;r1c:* zxheaa mi $$ mks

Qmmmigwlmwmf

 

"  mi' ihia writ giitrism, tfftua Tmmt gm an

 

"   fir §mp , w}:u7$ wag 
  and mfifira, thg am armyaé as. rmganflmita-3

arzrié.

H:   



V  ~\  .df%fiiflg tm 
 M.

'V fiht, :9 wimfiaw Em §§'i:i'{;§%fi mfi 'aim fismft

nun Luum Ur KAMNAEAKA 1~lEGH  OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH, COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH CC

4.?"

3 Wkgfi {Ema

 

kaeping téw mzfixaéa in 

 vmarne  tém y$¥t:i.$:mz2m* mag a 

  

tapywantatimkn sap     

Em ymfiaa at the aim fif finquig'-1 fie  -A 

gtzxdzme tha imgaeet aszsmamriiéi   *a?fE;ii;»:??Ei,4' 

 

 

aymrturxiigpr send $3. m:w:i§mat£a,:*3. $5?'  ezsifa 

 

2% impuwfi      '

m xziahhismn €."?§   gzmxm wd

 

 fl;      "

 $2" fig 3"? fmpfanfimfi Egg

 

 £33: we éaya,

 

 

  :::';u1me1 far fig    that the

V' V'  Wfifiifi $3 w§§*.;hdg~$;w 'him pamtm' ' :1.

9.'I"E1emrt§*'w%@%$3ap§maah%th5 $:afir't%&a

-' 

 

    

 



 ..     V

V'  "azsagm  .. 

#lv: -5

 fiw win} fifmmfiéms *%%%s:;. ''s% giitimsgfir iaaarxta Em
withdraw thfi wrfi fififimn? :3:  f ha 

 

1:3" am  in   

mattm? §hr 'ma fiagsm af%r='a::a23=gmi::i§ia~;ra.§'§;:*»s1e 

 

aspmt 3% éxnéfifi  xi  fig 4é:'1§3%&s.3&§'   Wkflfi

fine Cam mficfi    smfi' $3 Fmmz

 

*  it .g1'1§'§_     Q   '2.

hmaa      mad man:

 

;:1fl:Ea.f§€§2é::*§;?;vw%3:_'£;:"$S:js'* whifix wax tbs mama

$1"  mm $2-mtaa is $5 fafiz

   

   

 

fimlai sf EEEE5

      

rwcmeaaarjz   {ha ab

 
 

f~:s.rag: 'tfiififi ataifitmrgs arzarzéwaiaim

£21 ifia  ::;3f'th.e law flaalayfi

  Efi ?£'éi;G§c:iwwm:m"£ mm mid

  ca 5% w%% 3% gag gm 3% the ma wwh

   %&fl  

   mmrfizg at am fifim-wzmt 13%!

...,... .......... .... ....W...Wm niwn «..,..;_.;. W nnnnntnnn 2-nu:-I count or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH com? 09 KARNATAKA HIGH cc

  fig iifaa a'3fi&}$

 

kq/,4



man Luau: Ur ixmcwnamflfl Hifi.-EH  OF KARNAYAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNAMKA FRGH CC

..§i...

13), It 22% in thfg mfitéxt it is rawxit ta miim aha

iawanfiw §ai:'1t.ag§ai§ dawhyfixe S'§.§,p   in

 

tha new 3%'       

awmaregmm in zzgéwg 322:: #332  K 

rm pewm afthe
wlzfiwtw

 

 

*"I§~m $29  .- .f.;§;g  ,'§;:g§;s~z'
mam 31% V ._  is-:A  " £5: »  '  
 Q.   = "A   
fiaa uwgrict 42?? V'  pawl;
    fig 

 

 

 %%%%    ,
      my: my
 gséiismészz :'£§¥m fif fiae

 

    

  ff;  a 

 

  
 

~   mm-:  asiigig 2»:%¢_§%A::% gsj 



  M 213% afiim mid  

.. u.."...,.... ..,. ...............m nnvn ...,..3.. u.- nnnmtunna mum L'uuI:T or mmAm<A HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH cc

..§g.,

wad grfixzmfgr fig fixes mart fif fiw §§§:@"$

 
 
     
 

 

. __  £3 mmfi §r$9§fi§§;s.é{_}g:, :' 
" %  fig Es:-srfigz. £2 :2; L.
=  may   
  aw a4£§3_§£'¥.§t:3m§'r93FV}m,  

.j  9.3:' gimuxgsm    '§t§§;a%*

1 - zf 

 

  

Erxm fiw

 

122 Kt  
pmfififismg    fiim way; :11:

    12% @§1W$§" E3 gszwtmt,

 

wwwm am am:.g§A%:agfia»A%m fmlimal ifi  
mar smm a;r;.»1%%»a::aa:e§'%%:%hg am ma aam by the

 €3¢:z?E.§f'f._ En  'éf an all-mi: efiert %;.s 2% am;

  farmt in 2% fi§'flI"1fi"}:" %r' 35% fixture

 'V'vgmar.s:?§_;cr:§.-§:?. "§';w:§V ia aaaefimrmé gttmpt %fi tlm @111, sf

 

A  sail} rm fiflfiifiii fig 

 

 



  'z:e$fi"¢a3" wmfi 3.3

 is ti: agpiy fa? a ::

W33-

3.3:': The smmimi €13: rmfirfi fiiasaiasm 

 

i€a;*r1a'£aa% ,. 'Yhg  % Emfi fiafmfin  -« 

a nan-@im1;1mr1M frem  j:.:i:§ hi 

 

inmmc: {mm a aaflrm fifihgg-'v' >"~'_xf%fi.¥E:3E1   je E 13113

éxmzm ?$ mzsm  tar t% §aj.r

  
 
 

 

ca:m¢"¥;i   Vfi    
  " "m t'% §°::s?'iat.a sf'

  mmh  "'

 

  mm mm 32$ 29% the am mm

'  Mafia Ea 22835.

  Wfifi 

 

 tiara: &.pp§i%t$:3g €232" 

firm gugghaasfi t}f;z*a~' %

4      

  51% mm 33% éuéy mm;

nun uuum wr wmm'mI'Ai£A fiitfl-I C:O'U.l':i¥ OF K&flNATAKA I-H65-I CGURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HKGH COURY OF KARNATAKA HIGH CC

 

% %     §'é.r1fie& mags}: Jwm, 2&5 fw a pm a fig' 2:3 gmfi. it fa

{Ea  sf t}1?m fimm fikat whenem 3 

 



our vTIIl'II\I'I I

....... ..3._...,_... W nnnnaiann usury;-uuxr or mmamm HIGH COUKF or xmmA1mcA man count or KARNAIAKA men at

...g,.g$-

 

hmse: 13 awiimd §9r;  am   § wan

ah: &%m§ tha mifi appiiwfizam ara mt &:§.spua%a'éA'iT 3%'.

Exam ii} ewes whmsz 121% Sam. Ehasa 
 us§ 3E. tainaa jgmm fir wmiés§a;€L%fi' V'

 

apylimfifimsga fax      

 

apike at? the 

 

wmfimfint an pmimiz thg 
paw and w& '_   3&5
 ' m: afiiw%. '    mid Q§13a;§Efi
Emse %a a

 

%5&W*efi    J   '  
ism,  ms: miitifii §';ss;u Tm
   g

 

..   V--§}¢§;2:§§:1¢r ' gxgmfiuzfifi glazgzg wfifia 1:113

 Ear mm Zaafiag what £5 &i}?'3£§ as.
 gian'    - '

 

    at  M an §m~.%. 
j &  he hag "méwfiy zxmram gm £$p%1r2aphyw'1d
VT   pality aw Imméfmim gwlagy fif  
Y mficpssit ficfifidfig agagxmg paitam  s

 

uzrzzimzw

"thg   

 



-mun uuun! ur nmszwatnltn I-I16!-I (: €}£.!..:RT BF KARNATAKA HIGH COUK!' OF KARNHAKA HGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH CO¥Jfi'l'OF KARNA'i'A§(A HIGH CC

wig-

 

 

tswarfis mafia and ms': __ax2fi__ §§€i..ieia*§.%;.::V'_?f;3"£'éte;*'_"A.V   V
BE; m*§m.t'ci3 Wmt 31$  ~    7]'

arm ia a Ema §a$1£<.¥a; 33,:§& séifig  

with mzxmnmemg faz:*§eva;%;';1m.i'.dfl§:t:3."§;A mrifiee
piantafiem I    gram ,
ahruba ax:-.:i__  arm.

 

A  Sawn fmm smzégfif  

 

2  3ta'émr'.z paint fa; Iamfifi

H   fix smxatémm fieumiazy af $5 mas

arm with an alfimfie af' 5%? mm abzrve

 

RISE». 'I".h.e apgfifi arm Ema aw i''_  '

hrsrfim lfifiii mag 'Q éfifil 

 --~ "f'}'2g apgifi arm 

 



.  V   .§1mr1 %:%'§k:§m

 'aha

,. --..... ... ...m..m........ mm gww Ur Mmamm :-mm cmm or KARNATAKA was comm" or KARNATAKA max COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH cc

wig-

Tima 3% arm aaurafi rgf wam' if: thaa agepiisai

 

 
 

     E   % $2

 

311d mm aux-im wi;~;§:§r,"i%1L_%»:  

  

A  T

  

 ' E¢»'35%'a.'.i"?&;fi;:a.:%e:3. '§f%"'Qu§ «   V

.    witk qmrm~

  
 

 

gfiummm  3%

,1;    Efi

 



Hum Luulu Ur flA%NATAKA MGR  OF KARNATAKA I-{£6-I-3 COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURV OF KARNAINCA HIGH COMET OF KARNWKA HIGH CC

-33..

alsfitick q%§ %fi fig fififlfiifififfi eta mi": fif' gha

Bfiaeat mzmpiw 3:? xmim éawaiteé in a sta§'.}.é~ 

Gffltfiifi mfimnmmt.

   'mm    

 

nmrgin sf 3%  

inwo" rtani mhmé fifiit   V'

 

ghnk gzwwga in  ._

 

  fibrrm mt

      5 .

 

 _ amvafigm am mw %mn reaha%§ita§ad afi aié

      '

 

k



'£a '§.%su?E 'Ea:1¥§:$:"énm&nta_§ §.:§£'$1fi.,%§§;'§ $32" 2:11:  4.-.

....... W..." Va' ......-..~..um..». nlun uumsu Ur Imlmamlm man COURT as MMMAKA man com? or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA men cc

  fig }§§'$%hz§'f£§  itlm

 

fiflfint :2? the apt-ax flauri. it ig in thm: 

petétixmaar wught far

 

granmég

lfig Thfi m&  am'   

22,gg2:::@5 mm 5%  awaga Fm:
Eavirwnmarltai   imr: fim in $3

scmfiufie   -"."§§..'£.T': «  af fiifififlifi

 

  E   gist:  as?   he    

 

$2.  fiitsrmammr rsf

 

 ---¥::§s*'E':§§:% fig figs fitrafifi fimi ifia

Eand in   '4 Va  af ax im%%§'%"§: mm my 3'?

 

 V.          

 

 

  E1: Em ai 'aka': afiagg the 35 rmpgndm

  thg   1

  

af  § 



 ~   ma, Ekwa 

HUN CUUKX U? KM'£NA{§'fiKA HSGH  OF KARNATAKA H§GH COURT OF KARNAYAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGR COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH CC

'fig...

aj '1"ZE13 arw ia 435% fig aéésituéfi, 2% a 3g ha,

with ma xamfifaxg if  :3 daxmz, s§m§.§'"» 
farwta aaé yéw m*ig?1rm Wifi ha   A' 
133 'Tim  arm :35 aurtmnfiad  Z T

 

hfi   

 

am gm':  

Yemmsedefiéi   ms

 

V H A.   ifiérfimwmm
  amfi $3 §£n§5

 

find    n  E      

 $3  %gask%§?.v g:¢: fmm thia ha and

 

   5 Km mad in fwmi

  



  ' '1f;9f,1V§£:Z3£,3§

W... ...W... W nnnwnlnnn nu.-in uqgvgcl ur mung-mm 2-luau «mun: or KARNATAKA HtGl-% COURT or KARNATAKA Hm-I COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH cc

-2a»«

021 ibw Ema:u% af tlim aaifi §epr%&1€£at3"::~z"1§ aim Fexmi

 

 1:? §&%ma m-'sfi gmmg; fiemmentg 
State Pefiutimfi cmamz.    k 

 
 

  ané saymra. Sm  

 

113' W&'%  .V 

the Kaxmtaka Emte ?3I1u§fs:fi fiaiifieéi  >

tha éffimm sssvf am1;2@w1'  'ya    th:
.   '  1?.  4 "E15

 

grflgfiéti .32:
?"5t§ti£3fim" was   by tlm
Emu:-9'   gm   mm" mm

mt1?fim§1f:§§  1: -f~i'«.':: émgm-ma arm, mama

 

 mg  it was mt dmpamhevfi fig

 _ *s:ima's'§5::a§' aha  =3§§2j_§g%:i§r:. fig wfitit-$m* was  

 
 

 e:}5a'*é$§%', aa W Eetm fiawfi :§.:2.;2a<:5. T1123

  
    
 



V   
 133 mg gm
   by am 

mann uuulu U!' KAKNflh"i'RKA HEGH  OF ICARNATAKA H163 COURT OF KAWHAMKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGHCOUKT OF KARNAVLKA men CC

$21..

fiirwmrfi &§i2'1¢'$ $5» gwlaggg
Q'w%I'H-£3 Q g&lu$ fifi gimp fifi 

 

 

mm aréma. Tllé
 =fI:'i=:sii Qxfiar fiflifi 3a3.Q§$!§H

    

 

mmprifizig af   
Call}, Em:}::3§r mad 3

 

  

Pulhzbimi iilifontmi    r3f;§§%§§mmg

 

 fiizwzik      ta
'km fiauaes xmw hi; 3%.   mpsrt.

  

The fiayuty $:)i£.€;§3m&:i5:t:r1:& *fi.¢;A:€;'
2.2.2

€}% mgr': Exam £3434 MW?" " Img %% % 13¢ 1.3 3:? '..'$-t':&:~:'V mmmr af §§'ax&fi.-:4 fig émw , gmmg 'Z3;;::%1*m.§ ' = L V Efigafi 5% pa .. .... -. ...,....,.......... ....... ..5.¢...W UPI" Iwmmp-tinna mu:-I mun or I(ARNA'i'AKA HIGH COURT or KARNA'W(A i-IGH couxror KARNAMKA HIGH cc WEE"

mnatlimméi $3; ififi fix tegm gswtaci fihm aitze an %3.3§32{K% E221: éifi mt afizéy $15 flaw srcaé' tbs arm. Theyafamg Ea mag aggsizz vséfiigfli $312 5.4. ané Em 3mg m'1£1%":*-
$1 Em aim % mm? .v &; aimzuxamim M553 <2: "The mfi zit fig aawilfififit 1% phinm.
33¢ giw.
f n £3' éagfi fit finsrgm grmzuéjw $3,r.$¥a:g1R3. sf £3 . K j, , .4 " $§fl'1fi mm» OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KAHVIKIAKA HIGH COUR¥' OF KARNAKKA HEGH COUIEOF KARNAVAKA HIGH C1 Emmsfifim mm, --_ nuvri uvwru ur nnvsmninfifl fllfifl CQHARY 'Q3- iflé swtuazy. "me Emtzira life yrapsmnaé 2% fim méiua fifim $3 ~ ' sag E;;.t,%t5¥a:%'5&;§;'=$ii;i'sm;' mm ma mg :1-1: E-EV' ti.'-'f Ems fix fizwm gsxflmaiuya, ha fines mm:
33; % :::a rm gmm am; we ympmea its iaasme m'§..§fim2§g:?:--:1 "amfimg af pafiawafi fiat, :*:%§ mad Ewmfifimnt Ealw Eéfifi rm tlrza yew Em mmé V A' fifiadmz fififid L.-fig aamtuaw as Em- és glam gnwssafi Ea Egg 3;. mm :§ 33% §{:=$-aamiééw wag. the __..... ..,. .................. mm w.,g... vr nnnntnzmxn mm calm? or KARNATAKA men COURT or xAmA'mm men comer :cAmA'rAxA HIGH cc The Exmrt C$?%n.m'E§§£ H -- ..gg..
fifw Ewwmifim g agmpt far witcd mld ?ifi1fE myth in '% "

flaw: @eé $11 {$3 5&3:

ymzagwaed thai rm *' $31 slaga =~. __ sf"
an -$35.-2 »g§g:*§:ia=3:ié=; 9 "

%:;1 'A am an 1:3,;3£%f;?a:I:é§ L __:z:%3$mra%}$ %m}m ma ugm a wmpia arid mat Ekrg, 'Eh: gspssw ugs hfi §%m %§$:u,aa 'I113 mm 31% gufmfiflfiafi, Egg Wwtsm Qham.

Efi $t'a§ed §'§§t§E.i,$m2amrt$§?'$§m't;&mfi%t$. Igfifififl nun s...vu-urn ur RMKNAIAKA HIGH OF KKRNATAKA HIGH COURY OF KARNATAKA H%GH COVE!' OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT Of XARNATAKA HIGH CC am

-25..

%?a€::*.:2* as gm" zgiggaaémé. W33 firm" m Tmk. $313; 13333 mar %:.2.réam 2% aims anrzi Lg}. I gmpmefi site

-.;-«ii away a': wry" $%%h nu &}3§}.13%§$fi $3»? 1%;

md :33 §§& giéé, pmgswmv __ yaxmi.

__V.E,Tr1damf§l:'%~s3':miu$£::mivVv' mgr': aiama rim fixmsmzd §§¢as:§eaz§§:;g; 235.3% 1 ii': rm gmpmam 3: the: mfiifi aéitsd giiai. £21 thaa 13$ §.;m:imnmmm,%:=; mung with mndmnm fig §a&m__..5:'V;A'gg%":V 15:33..

flfinflifiififlfi.

31..0m@m. Ha mngamaa sag $33 :32' Wfitfifi Ghamy It $5 -- 5%" mfi h&I1m§ {ha mum' ' maxmbe E233 aim" mm W am fif gm gmm and 'Em Q15 .

in ééamd fimi: thaa arm 33- may fliiitifi a ' 2 V fl-wizié' fihe Ealamh .- -

ffispmt: ;"§..rs Mam Ea' mnmm -T ;

afijamzfi. Ea $115 r:- 93% thé arm has get ahala =._ t§' gaing Em mid § ufiffi wag Ea tim Ifi3'%1$ij¢" im tim mm the pefifinm atafifi fix?

nan vuun: ur nnnmmumn mun h§J,§.H_§I Ur KAKNAIAIEA HIGH CDUKI OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH CO

- .. '" . $3.: _ u ... ....,..... ..A..i_..._... ur mmmnm mun noun or mmA'rAxA I-ilGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH ct _ '}"}5V.;é;V'§s;*a;§1ea*t€c' 53335; .--

... -

abmxt 2341 mm 3:: aafitg mfih arzé fiaamm £5» 93.: aémuttjfifififl mififi a§Q"'§§£: ffigls fiifld $11, fihag. 2;-uffi rag 1%: ma mm' .55 yaiia 193% mfi *§;:%m ympmed Emmi mam' anfi .f§3Efi" ':';';§_ is .. - mr;:&ze:§'m%a jam. _ izzéiatafiimns . V - = $§_aéfla;1i;£if'a g:;%a::e fig tam 'ta ' A agar fig mm}: 52:? 3 tfiea §::t~ejw€. arm an rim ' §é}l ané smasflfi it 5% 3. geatta E;-i1@e.. fin flaw ska ik gujmt gmpmnm has §';%!fi$ afiewn '€§5m}. pita mm abmzt ii) fiat: 3.5 HIV!!! ........... W .w..m..mm nzun wugu ur mmamm mun couxr or KARNATAKA may COURT or-' KARNATAKA HIGH mun: oz: KAENATAKA HIGH cc ..3@..

wharewr afiffi ifi asmfiabéa. am wad.--«.§za$ fl my the mag tn intense V. gmm 3:3 3.3 ms $331: héfiéfifi meta '§§%;1§£?é?§§i "¥a2:{f the hwy aisgm.

4: Haga:"<::@;1*1g:r5i %§.1s5x:21§ :;»;;ii' 'V L are sxtua' aw u E915 tiii §is£nm'""ja'nn :31' ' ~ mag Tm pefitkxfim' ~;as5ia~s, m§iéeé:;£'f§};~ gg 23.m..2§m. They fa3£e& :_.':£:- Eifig' the indian. :;«.s.z5L:z;@%%¢:: gii"-5-:7'i$.€?:®§§ wifiwh gm ware gmhfi ESQ E 'h€?_§___$'£1 aafiafieratisaxa af {Em afnrmid ths mntxantiafi, mi' tbs patitianer is m: a part 35 Wmmm fiham fer zmmfiat fill aim mmhafi 3f :;'51& ma mam? "wizzé harm visimfi %& gmpfisafi Sj,xE§s3.121 sf haw gwfbmifiaci mgaart fimt éfig said arm ia \.x/ ..3j_., firs: beam Y%f :3 '£%& mpari af mdémgauféfiilgg 3 safi zhm: $3515 s%ammmfi '€E4i2atJ_fi*;e af %§@~$£m*1"1_ .t'{'_§-%&t.§;----.. ' izf fig Fmwst ma K £353': 3. gart $17 ¥J¢;%i&m"%;"§';§35;e3;Lf$ $3 The Canwrmmf K Shara' ma ._V_%i;;a?:i3;d *2';4+2La% baa ciemgy is very mg £; Tm Eiesan §§ Vhifi 83.} 'aha aids cf """ éiia $3 iamamtfié ia Wei} aver 1;'?a${} mm. of Hfigmfifmfi mag: the Eamrn af am is mm inf Eiadsszz 1% mléw af time rfigaav J mafia: taswartis Wfit '5f . Q. and mwmfis Q23 ' - ma ix: .

£5 3 gm»: af the 3352:; range ...... Wu... vr ...-..m..m~. ruun uquagi ur uwmamm I-nun comfl or xAmAm(A HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA I-£iGl-i co \$s«*?1i:.:;:}3~;. §:s .%:m@':&é is %e fialzrsa Bu hill Rangem is wfigrit fifim $323 i§s§$%%@ ti: \ KAWNAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA I-IGH COURT OF KAHQATAKA Him'! COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH Cl

-32..

shmt sf the Sufvwg af' India. We Bé$Lcfbt11s 12573.1 mtg fig awn m 2-Ema 2;? m fiflfifint pkwsa aafi ma fad} A kratmhfia (sf chumh - As» 'V V per arm .§e!PEE; ~24? FGL 23932, ét. §'?%V}..~:'fi§i.;*'fv~'§'i'.::i::i::1fl::#*.:7:::'§:*.%}11rV"' Taiuk is a is uf T g sf' thm hm ranga " cf $59 ";§Jmte'm gimm and 2 mag wmfifi '£9 {Em entire ngiigfilzes , fifi fw tha rmsan Bnfim Eiadur Taluk $5 :Eaa»sifi$ aa V' 933.3% in 2313 mid fiewmsnt . % f ; % % gm;

wvn uwunl Ur flflfifimfliflhfl H35" Ci'-.}:..3_RT £§":3:£:if1cafia-:1 was fiaueé aa T ' 2. sf fiat Prwarzt Vakm are-$3. Had this zwfifzcamn éaalt with wise Ear dmawtimn 3? Eastern mun uwunl Ur nmnmnxnlxn nun": V-.sU.£,'!'(l U?' flflltflfliflflh HIGH (SOUR? OF KARNATAKA H§GH COURT OF KARNAYAKA. HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH CO #33", plaém am} "wmtam {3%wEa £2: Weulfi ham:

dmrly cahgafieé {Em izmtam Sykflaa, sf mama' 1% R mid ihazw thx;-: Wtfifififfl s;£:3_.&"¢;f the ;; ~ '~ n K rfig' am? {Em saw Efifi. T6f. .= «V mam Gmm am: ¥,hé: ' rm wf the hm mag Waatsm ei:E".
' of 1'3 é fiifmmrn fiffi.
Frm; '£1123: af tiw Wad @3215? he mt':
' gag 53 wag mtg ..
T%m¢ farm a pm gr gm Ba?:mbu& * ma fiaii witizézz 12$ ju.:r%fiaii£*:£imn czf Rfifificafiagz Sigma it 2% a $11 af rim ~ vizzagms mrtéffifeatcrrz Gmm. AL ' afifi gfiam aw Efii hfié my Q? '£325 fimtarn {mi §1$§%2' "--.. b€ cIa5a~i% 95 Eastarn -h V Efifificafisza $3, mg arm:
smmi    Vwatatinn
at    Afiefiifiuaua fzsrwt
""" H $33.3 enfififi pyayzmgd mgrm " gmpssneniis efigm 2&5; the A % é ;E$§v',gg;gA3O;ig;1"%§rfi; ma am tim ma man: af 2331. mum-ux2d%xg §E'$§$$$§ 'i.}'r:é¢r I " ~ 1 Eb?
"' ;:.=~.: 2.:mdca§:§m:€§§3r the . E7'$z¥%%3 .
aféa, mfiafiaratiagz 3% § ma? embgimfiyv atfituéeg higiz :
EGH COURT 0?' MRNATAKA MG?! OF KARNATAXA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA H363 COURT OF !(ARNA'l'AKA Hit'-3|-I COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH CO 2% izxzzrprfitgm' Eliza saéfi VV
2. Phyfiizcafiy the §§"¢;$§$é3§~;3§.§;«s;z£$ 3'33 ;m.g::.aa%; "gape V ,..3§.~ am: fimmammagawéy gamgitixm '§'?T%:;_f@a sharacaamg 353,: Sam? $v% fig farm: § fiaéafiwétiuaus farégéégfi %we.z* §1 §§aa§ 243:.' high mirgaa, % tygimal vizéimaéa of 'V t§mWe$t&r§3;:{}§§t§';' _ ~: ' ' Tile gampsmfi éfifiga' fir: sf time fiifaii 5&3} §.'$.1'¥$ is &§§'%1fi'§'§1 Bag fif m:;¢£a%s:afi1y 3 gr: as am hfififl iii thfi £3;
NEH . « COURT OF KAKNATAKA HIGH OF KARNATAKA HIGH COSJRT OF KARNAYAKA HIGH COURT OF KAKNATAXA HIGH COURT OF KRRNATAKA HIGH C0 fits!-.~i %:::.:;.;E£;____é§g".§;§,% mmans Whfifih 21$ _ 1?'. & maimaé aiaariy fifififihfififiéfi that in 31% fiamfinrfian af fig yetiiimnser V. pmémi; aim $3 :33: & fir: sf Wwégm fihats. a.Esm'1L1.§}J§' " has @113 alazmg mf?..'m jmfiiisner thai Em was '£3? '£9 flfi 3% haé 11$ H.951 CQURT CH' i(ARNATAKA HIGH OF KRRNATAKA H%Gl'i COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH. COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH C0 -33- anythim mntmfnfifi in wig' Qtimr may féf fig awn in fin-m in & Siam; gm State aufiwrfiy aimll maézm wzmgst Wifgh "aim pzimg" K fiwa flaazciwai .. agrtay rmersaueé famat C11' 9&5; gflfiifagfi the rmwwd fimtr fixxy V tlxeraef may 3% mefi v;'z'<Z~§.:::§:'V- gufifiaévé. Tlrmi any mm Eamd 3;» 311;?' he asaigneé by way sf imsgg gamma 3:' fizz:
agrxy autfic;    gr fizzy mhfl
 "  er mfiflfififi by
farm: lafi £3: azzy paritiam tlmarggéf ef aw w§i$ Etxmm gram ia "" M ' H w wffimis, Eh? 1% §Z1§%' $6 sf 331$ fitpiafiirinra ta fiw ma §§1I"$§$ "nian-farefit purwge"

V 28, in that :::;:";:Ew€., iiza fizzpmma Qieurt. $2: fim _<:::as¢ India aand mm :m ma 5;: am 1%? * the am am aw: with 22m &agsr§g:ig;; ;?%%{e:ié»§§_;%az'.k« x garagzaph-3 8% 4: 133% mzéar:- _ w is 3. ' qmtam akfiut --.;f;If -figrfiiat Cammmfimn §s[.cVt;- . u ":1 sf fim Ward 'f;i:s_3:'%'§:' is; aim as, wfi. sf grim' €;'~5§_r:tr*é$,._§ G;3&% £, as £7' in mégmci: at' "'»*;§m tésrmt arm whémifi am mum. it is witémna :FQ'I'%s?. é§;$'I3&ri§&fifl§1 §sct§ Eififi was m azhmk mm Jgggrmmgm niammxg,» rmzzém in 9:323; m; '£233 _ ' thfirafii far 'aim mnaafiatfin anfi fax" magma cemmatéé V' mm: aggfig % 33% farmia . .fg~réa{§®tisr3 £5 fix mamr: fig' awmmhfi $3' '"=%>_4"'z2}a:é"s§i':r;ra£?z§n §s Tbs ward 'f<;:*&$.' mast !£Gi-i COURT OF KARNATAKA MESH OF KARNATAKA HIGH CQURT OF KARNATAKA i-HG!-I COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURY OF KARNATAKA HIGH CG mfiamtaaé amzfiirg in 31% éiaiiaxaaty Tfixia éfiavxégstimn mwm a3} :v<l'I of any Staifi 'éufimzfiy, "§§$ Ema Ewma &m§? aim I Wvwn: 'urn I\I_':II'M\r1!£rIuB'\4'"§ I"N\7l'"l£ 'Jr fi§§KWVa§-"RH I1"?-3'! _.§_l..

statzztmfiy dwignatgé. as nt&z-wake $3' fim yurwaa zaf Smfiinn tfw Form: S3zz.&m*mfim"i Am. 'formt. lafifi mmammkg in I 6%}? include "fiarmt" 3,5 dictizenary mama, but as ftsxwt in aha r':m$ 2:c1 sf i3 it lms 'an be: u.:<§¢§~%a.%;i:§.e~;§%%%:§g: '§'§.'3.;..'§°_'§a$,«¢ ef' sectim 2 gr»: am a¢t;% saacw. in the gm the *s% wttmés r:3mr*}y an afi $12'-'mtg; af 'rim fiwfififififiifi {sf iizeszrmf. 3% *m1% mm abumanmy cm in ¥éha=1%«s:1ac=:w%wz:Es; mm if: fimbfm A V' " ~ ' aj' g, ' ta mama rims gamed wmti mm the fimiaiarm as am ,,.n..-

aim»: €33 dimpei am fimukig if M3; gag the Q37 bmazzm af tha sand mkm ma State sf Ra3'a%t11m§ am at théw Eat: stagfi, 'ad fmmts, whe*;§"iary'=._ gmtwtm

-42..

daeisimm cut' this Ceurt. It Fm rerasnnable in aamzms that any 3Za€fi Gevfimmmt has mm 333 appmfim the mm:

7m iaw so far? W133. fafihwiih mrxmt img % fiflfi take thfi :-. .':-='-vii:
wixrmmny fimher aezayx"
3&2? Iii1m§t.§.3m V Thm the Supremr: Zmshfiafi' 'V V directium:
"Ir: view .5: the in the fiat? $2: isv«.a'a~g§%.¥£§§$_fl%;i:;§t«:;$x§%r zmmmi sf the .__«iVgj far' gay nan-foiwusi-. arm sf 3&3; LL33; Smtian 2 G? ms Aaifg, égiflzin any fa-gwfiz 331 any 'Stab. fiw muggy, igitézaui V, upr£e3r af thg Carztrai Gamtamarit, % .
as: {arms gs ta remam in &!3% xvii}: {$23 35 {Em gem _V thsa flank-al fit. E3 the 93? any?' %?'sr1% Em ifi am Siam? suck as fi:c*1msh& ?md:mh, the Wm': ayatam 5-§§§i3{3§ thé fmilm' thfi 161-'5 COURT 0!' KARNATAKA HIGH OF KARNATAKA HSGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KAKNAIAIKA mun luv $&§§§§fi§$m:t3fi3y'E$"'§2}1$ ....>§3..

_ if '§'§'$ Sifiifi air 3% Status Fsrfit Sargfaéécsn, Each Siam Gfl fifii was éimwéeéi ' A mmtimte a Exmrt fiémmtflzas tr)' i6;é§:1*§1§f;%7:;§*3.é' A as:-mg wfifimh am a i"f"-..

wktlrzer they am as u

-::§amii"1a& under me mwfignd the zzzwnemhip iaéfltéw §f__g*s1¢}:é{ 'i'é§re:%'£, idanfify arm hut stand fi«asgra&$,_.2;§.e:§?,fi2;;s;~é"§z§; arid firm ma thsse ~

23. tirm wage? af :-:- j 'Stabs Afima"'F:%i.§$a;§ ea::§€§ amé afilma irégartefi Em {gm with fazmi wfi farm: End at p§:*za1§'gé*eeA1@}i: VZu.;'2;§} ggggm $3. m§m---

.. .,. ....,...........'., unrn ..W_;.. Ur nnatnnaann mam comm or KARNATAKA men COURT or xAmAmcA Rica own: or KARNATAKA HIGH cc A " .___ **'32Qw Tim weréa "fimymig at "ffiymt hm mt hwy; éefirzsed in tile gap. as:

43:4 gm Smxfiai Farm': am. in iraaim Ewiish T E3??? E§.:1,} tha wvaré; gfatrmtfi has bwn dafizm at p.558 $3 "a Ema wzmdfii arm havim a %i: grswm $1' gag am} piants, the arm af gush an amag .. «§j"I¥"Q?rm't the difwmi 2 Hum LUUIH Ur KAKNKIAKA Hit-EH OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT 0!' KAWATNM I-IGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KAINATAKA HIGH CC ...§g%.,.
rmmblfig & lags Egasidfii arw afigwiafly ix; éemity". 'Fm Sfzwwr Qxfirxi E2@i§..s%:.:
gffiémi as "an '-- I want cef lafi wmmé mifih ur3;:i,ef§¢:sw't§3k§ an .. mm". In wemsmrig L. fi@aflfif1'y at "farm? has ham siicfizicfls» *3. 1aéz%g¢9"*§:%iam§tv;:a£f ianci mvarafi Wiifia {if and ux1&crb:msh;'-- §:;e@;a§gk%%k;g;§r ma gamrally t$Ia .:'§3. €,,E::§ €§'%¥'¢§2§j§;§; Rap: far am §:'*§;"a':$.?:,Zaaz:3; mi" gmgm; % Tm, G1' sfivmfigsrmd farmt $§"i '33::.e A' _"'tha sazm 'catai sf herbs;
"ii'ééf1¢:* agf Eaves; branchm". = larsé $3: &$ifi;$ $3' % §+%::= pyezmém 311$ suiiivatifiiz". is fiaéig fiéafiaamavy ifiifi VQEQ at pfifiié "fsgmffi maam 4% gaiam %y myal aufiwriiy Q?' by ' "g3rmm*?$1:2wz1 far aim wammhk zmuxisizmnt 5? the &asta {gr Eirfig 3? Elm f fer mam af Ki%; 3. sufijwt may mg a farm: %: ggant fimm % firéwn; fig the grant 6%' fmémt $1: 3.. mwfs am: gmmfig 2%: l\/' nun W... W mmmmm I-Hurt t..q.5..-a_u ur mxum-Am mm»: COURT or KARNATAKA I-HGH COURT as xAmAmcA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH co ,_,4§-
. bu: 33$ lama itaaif pas$%;,-'--. w~:th:':;§:e mmzgg and wizmzz mg Biwisé LL33' fififiiaraafi {$5 §2§§:,§ j ----. : . "farm? at E3.%% £5 3% 213:1: fif _ with um mttfi awe wtmxzt". Sfimzyzhem % gammy afim mg %m;%at% was as "a. was zraeta' iaggd mvemzé with ééaéfiy gremtd azfi; rude ' ' After Eirwanwmt Pmt:ac't:m:n' mvém the Wvflaart Ewfi gm: m
- fem: and Pnfi af ibzmt wait}: 3? 1:133 £".£&'f.'.:l$1'§ ézzvimmngmt ané amiagf.
22; -fhwefow, fiw wamzé "§'$::e5:£" must 'cg &$i«:":r"ipfien mama afi stamiagy mmgtxiwé farmts, V U The ward, 'Fara? wcezfid izmiufia 3, iaga wswfié arm 3 fififlk mf fi% argfi piazgm, an &i£'%i¥E kw {i'epur'£:ed in am 2%? m 359;, as SSH COURT 0F i(AfiNATAi(A HIGH 0? KARNATKKA HIGH CGURT 0? KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURY OF KARNATAKA RIGH C0 ..,§§..

Enact :31' lamfl; mwraé wits}: 35% anti 2 rem: 133$ sat mm %=* as ymtwffmn mfi acuitivafimm mid a,°¥:i'Va.k::t gff wim mm and am ar%*m%:§iae:sh2¢% Thmeibre, tkre mmmt im the V Gamma: Fermi mg «iias ax' Formt with sf the matter af wiwkaflmmt Act, 1939 was % m aahmk mm mmtfiggfl ssgmztsa 13:: mzagxé.-ax gm' arfi' pvmvimians mafia thmein £62' :33 faémzst mfi far wgttam gagzxmteé.

" th¢I' zfiugt afi farmts irrmgpmfiw {::=E' riatara 1 is $31 ilzis mmmt fine iipm Smsrt has dac m % as: tim a task whixzfi mm; arzigg with. pafifiura mgfi .
;. -% 3 " "fs9%' "'_4'T M "

& » mifi jam £3 _ wat$~ s:it:a;z}a3t;§§; Aaé. Eriegmaimzglfi. The ..

AT raizzs thmugh ' U Hagarahafii mfi Yam K531 noun? OF KARNATAKA W62'-f OF KARNATAKA i-HGH COURY OF KARN.flTAKA H36?! COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF XARNATAKA HIGH C0 wég-

ea? $.t'f;it13.€§$ in the fiwiifif af sf"=._tI*1$ 3'33. "§'ha maimimé $3; zwsgrzzi éiigéfiasfix 3&3 'V in qtmgtiwn Km %wm&a Eizfi ' raxzg.-2:, 1%: 7% Farwt mwards Sczufiz Farm";

iiaewaréa 33¢ '$.f¢..a.:VV§$'3urm§3nd¢fi by Ehadra Q3333 with ' mfim §}aa*£at::'m1.

gfhfl mg. ;s::.~ «tjhtf-é "gage fiffifi, $@ufi:§§. éfi zzarthg B331 'ihfifi amsxm fif ' égfiiisg €113 H u afwatar af; §§$ga% ifi {fir = damfitifi gtngmsm, £3} "aim mg; @9353" kwig ' gain fim mnk at mg: 3::

aiming fin arm is mg fl.
altittzda E a 'fig § Wifii high E5 :.
ting $m};§g§::¢§§_.... _ 3 «.§g_ ahala fezmm mg fizfiar ' §?§3. E33 $;e$::*$§9=*:§ --"'-..pfiE mm whicfi wsmzlé; get waéer imm. gm M: u éewnziafi an fima 'w:::3;:£$ ha afim:m:.%%'%%%L/[[% A ' % 24* mass 3 sigma ::1f_§$1.i§"i;f$fi11§§ttf§g%»'.§$.'§£'ai3.z3£.%JSe;:§. "~.L' abmzt the scuziai ahiizgafifimg férfiéf win are enwlsyeé fer filxaflsaié mfi :9 gmfmt tlw fasrwaé. are tk ckar V . grafimi 1:
an 5 wvunl vr nnmmnlnvd-I mun hfiiwfsl ur IKAKNAIAKA I156?! SOUR? OF KARNATAKA PRGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF XARNATAKA HEGH CO "';'§f'?'::,§i:fa3x§t:?'A* "ii 'E.'-.I%£Z'i&'*£.1$i£'.§ as? 'me Eiw fiarmt am:u~:.ma;T% _}m:fi in q"§:a$tim"; $333; gm faflwithm iZ*;_r§43asst arm' mt éhrm pafi af Véiagtem Ghamgi' "aim 'V c;%.EaeV::*" & an auch Sign gawk: far, But.
fioifl 9% 5. §amgm% :m 39% r%p$::{i¢z2%;, th.§§'$ W63 no __ 555:? mmiizm' flue asaizi mmmmmiafisn. ffiiégéirfiicly, fizeazgha a fififiifiififl wigs mica: is gafani $3116: T " it Waa gm: agttzgahy awmmzgzrzkafigafi m 333:3 ipcfitirzzmarfi figifia {Em gffitififiigfif rwm 3% 'aha gaid z*&::a:xm'm:z"1{§a§m22. in kg ii mmmt be saifi fimt 3.11}; \x/ ma COURY or KARNATAKA HIGH cougar or KARNATAKA men coma or mmnmm mum wmn ur l\.:-tluvnu-uxn mm W URI VI' l\¢P'|l\IIl"l!l"||\l"I Iilwil 'awn {5} "film timiir stem 5-ind "€%°'if.§'1fif&%%'f: {Egg '- aim: g§*$;::'t@§ 5&2"
g%a@j"r.;8*t:?fi&%3% mawxm flfi E.:it§.1:r3a:a§y§ ix': mm: Efinsssg I gags thg fzzfllmgizg €§3:§;&3':- (:2; 'me Kmasxmizza Sémfi V' mm sag farfii" ;;§;§;:f§zz;g aémi of Tfaraqt"
Saar? ihgm wider fiam fime tn:
fa ckggk fig: A. §:':: g?;_%§*§':.rri.e' €?Ii?:§"i}§f§?2E§:E§ "
'flze ? ' afffimsi far afififims 'm fize iefiss" meg ss.4§;2m.s:. iav Em Wrii ?Efi5§i{§?3; where i: is VT : . .'g~z;a:aa am $323 pmgaaz 2&3 £9 mi gwgf Qfihe? Q!-I COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT G KARNATAKA HEGH COURT OF KARNATAXA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGHUUI £'G§ wfiz-
demaa fimsxg %.i?§£.§£'}.§'é :23 the rm: fejajgii fi1mpra§§m:s_ T' T cg' gm arsiw 2:; f§:§ S'&?mea$' &t§1- srggg gag $ § mpmm' T ' A 9fE€m:z3a§:s;__;%:* uéa';§I?m:§" ' ' ... 3d/'3 Iuddé L