Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Krishan Kumar Sharma vs M/O Information And Broadcasting on 9 October, 2017
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENCH
O. A. No 3534/2017
M.A. No 3756/2017
New Delhi, this the 9th day of October, 2017
HON'BLE MR. V. AJAY KUMAR, MEMBER (J)
HON'BLE MS. NITA CHOWDHURY, MEMBER (A)
1. Krishan Kumar Sharma,
S/o Sh. L.C. Sharma,
Aged about 53 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Delhi,
R/o 245E, Subhash Marg,
East Babar Pur, Shahdara, Delhi-32.
2. Pradeep Kumar,
S/o Sh. Banarsi Dass,
Aged 49 years,
Working as SEA in DD News,
F-1/2, Naya Gaon,
New Usmanpur, Delhi-110053.
3. Rajeshwar Pandit,
S/o Sh. Ram Mulan Pandit,
Aged about 54 years and
Working as SEA in Pritam Pura,
1378, WP-Block, Pitam Pura, Delhi-34.
4. Suraj Prakash,
S/o Sh. Laxmi Narain,
Aged about 46 years and
Working as EA in DDK Delhi,
R/o YP-18-C, 3rd Floor,
Pitampura, Delhi-34.
5. Bharat Bhushan,
S/o Sh. Daulat Ram Sharma,
Aged about 52 years and
Working as SEA in DD News,
R/o C/o Bijender Singh, Flat No 1657 A,
Block No B-1 Basant Kunj, New Delhi-70.
2
OA 3534/2017
6. Sanjay Razdan,
S/o Late N. K. Razdan,
Aged about 53 years and
working as SEA in DDK Delhi,
R/O 62, Amarpali Apartments,
Patparganj, Delhi.
7. Arvind Arora,
S/o Sh. J.B. Arora,
Aged about 51 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Delhi,
R/o B-2/49-C, Keshav Puram, Delhi-35.
8. Santosh Kaur,
D/o Sh. Gurbachan Singh,
Aged 51 years and working as DDK Delhi,
R/o 297, Laxmi Bai Nagar, New Delhi.
9. Praveen Kr. Rattan,
S/o Shri Ravinder Kumar Rattan,
Aged about 51 years and
Working as SEA in Pritam Pura,
Pocket GH 5 & 7, Flat No.996,
Pachim Vihar, Delhi-87.
10. Ram Sharan Ram,
S/o Sh. Jattan Ram,
Aged about 54 years and
working as SEA in Pritam Pura,
B-94, Gali No 7, Shiv Vihar, Phase-I,
Karawal Nagar, Delhi-94.
11. Anita Garg,
D/o Sh. S. C. Gupta,
Aged about 51 years and
working as SEA in Pritam Pura,
C-543, Saraswati Vihar, Delhi-34.
12. Mahesh Kumar Yadav,
S/o Shri Tejpal Yadav,
Aged about 53 years and
Working as SEA in Pritam Pura,
R/o WZ-257, Shakur Pur Village,
Delhi-34.
13. Sunil Kumar Tyagi,
S/o Sh. Mangoo Singh Tyagi,
3
OA 3534/2017
Aged about 50 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Jaipur,
16, Sudha Sagar Colony,
Hari Marg, Malvi Nagar, Jaipur.
14. Sushma Ahluwalia,
D/o Late Sh. Rameshwar Nath Sharma,
Aged about 56 years and
Working as AE in Pritam Pura,
FU-6, Pitam Pura, Delhi.
15. Umesh Kumar Garg,
S/o Sh. Jai Prakash Garg,
Aged about 53 years and
Working as AE in Todapur,
11/396, UG-2, Lalita Park,
Laxmi Nagar, Delhi-92.
16. Pritam Singh,
S/o Shri Kishori Lal,
Aged about 53 years and
Working as AE in DDE Delhi,
R/o A31/28A, Netaji Gali No.1,
Mauj Pur, Delhi-53.
17. Madan Mohan,
S/o Shri Sheodan Singh Verma,
Aged about 55 years and
Working as AE in DDK Jaipur,
B-514, Balaji Tower,
Near Jawahar Circle,
Jaipur Raj-302017.
18. Kishan Pal Singh,
S/o Late Sh. Mange Ram,
Aged about 47 years and
Working as AE in DDK Delhi,
4/P-112, Gali No.7,
Bihari Colony, Shahdara, Delhi-32.
19. Shailendra Shah,
S/o Late Sh. Nand Lal Shah,
Aged about 53 years and
Working as AE in DDK Delhi,
54B, Pocket A, Mayur Vihar,
Phase-II, Delhi-91.
4
OA 3534/2017
20. Md. Nasim,
S/o Sh. Sirajul Islam,
Aged about 58 years and
Working as AE in DDK Delhi,
Quarter No.D11/3, Radio Colony,
Kingsway Camp, Delhi-09.
21. Pradeep Kumar Kulshresth,
S/o Late S.S. Kulshrestha,
Aged about 53 years and
Working as AE in DDK Jaipur,
69B, Ajmera Garden,
Kings Road, Jaipur-302019.
22. Mahipal Singh Yadav,
S/o Late Jhanjhu Singh Yadav,
Aged about 51 years and
Working as AE in DDK Jaipur,
R/o 7/375, Malviya Nagar,
Jaipur Rajasthan-302017.
23. Sunil Verma,
S/o Late R.K. Verma,
Aged about 49 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Jaipur,
R/o 77/145, Mansarovar,
Jaipur-302020.
24. Arjun Lal Bairwa,
S/o Sh. Ram Narayan,
Aged about 48 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Jaipur,
R/o 71/240, Pratap Nagar,
Samnager, Jaipur-302033.
25. Jai Prakash Sharma,
S/o Sh. Laxmi Narayan Sharma,
Aged about 47 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Jaipur,
R/o C-16A, G-1, Milan Apartment,
Kusum Vihar, Jagatpura,
Jaipur-302017.
26. Akhilesh Kumar Dwivedi,
S/o Late K.L. Sharma,
Aged about 46 years and
Working as EA in DDK Jaipur,
5
OA 3534/2017
R/o C-27, Sector-22, Pratap Nagar,
Jaipur-302033.
27. Yogendra Kumar Pateriya,
S/o Sh. S.P. Sharma,
Aged about 48 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Jaipur,
R/o B I/19, Doordarshan Colony,
Jhalana Doongri, Jaipur-302004.
28. Rajeev Kumar Goyal,
S/o Late R.S. Goyal,
Aged about 47 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Jaipur,
R/o 246, Patel Nagar,
Mansarovar, Jaipur-302020.
29. Vijay Kumar Meena,
S/o Sh. Ramji Lal Meena,
Aged about 50 years and
Working as AE in DDK Jaipur,
R/o B-2, J.P. Colony,
Tonl-Phatak, Jaipur-302015.
30. Vijay Shanker Bansal,
S/o Sh. D.L. Bansal,
Aged about 55 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Jaipur,
R/o C-511, Nirman Nagar,
Jaipur-302019.
31. Rakesh Kumar Gupta,
S/o Sh. Ram Ratan Gupta,
Aged about 49 years and
Working as AE in DDK Jaipur,
R/o 104/142, Aurawal Farm,
Mansarovar, Jaipur-302020.
32. Radha Raman Sharma,
S/o Shri R.P. Bhardwaj,
Aged about 54 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Jaipur,
R/o B-95, Anand Vihar,
Railway Colony, Jagatpura, Jaipur-302017.
33. Ghanshyam,
S/o Shri Budh Ram,
6
OA 3534/2017
Aged about 51 years and
Working as SEA in DDK Jaipur,
R/o Flat No.F-4, First Floor,
Royal Pride Plus, Plot No.24-25,
Kapil Vihar, Ist Chake Gatore,
Sanganer, Jaipur.
34. Praveen Bhatia,
S/o Late H.M. Mehta,
Aged about 54 years and
Working as AE in Todapur,
C-125, Moti Nagar,
New Delhi-15.
35. Ravinder Kumar Gupta,
S/o Sh. B.L. Gupta,
Aged about 53 years and
Working as AE in Todapur,
C-303, Neelachal Appartment,
Pocket-2, Sector-4, Dwarka,
New Delhi-78.
36. Raj Kumar,
S/o Late Mam Chand,
Aged about 58 years and
Working as AE in Todapur,
B-163, Kendriya Vihar,
Sector-51, Noida.
37. Manoj Kumar Tiwari,
S/o Sh. Kailash Kumar Tiwari,
Aged about 52 years and
Working as SEA in Todapur,
F-531/532, Budh Nagar,
Inder Puri, New Delhi-12.
38. Promod Kumar Juglan,
S/o Sh. A.R. Juglan,
Aged about 52 years and
Working as AE in Todapur,
B 7/67, Sector 18, Rohini,
Delhi-89.
39. Jogender Singh,
S/o Sh. Hari Singh,
Aged about 47 years and
Working as AE in Todapur,
7
OA 3534/2017
C-7/66, Sector-8, Rohini,
New Delhi-85.
40. Madhu Gadi,
D/o Sh. Devika Nandan,
Aged about 59 years 11 months and
Working as AE in CPC Doordarshan,
R/o E-99, IInd Floor, Amar Colony,
Lajpat Nagar IV, New Delhi-110024.
41. Renu Girdhar,
D/o Sh. D.V. Arora,
Aged about 54 years,
Working as AE, DD Maintenance Mathura,
R/o 26/21, West Patel Nagar,
New Delhi-110008.
42. Amar Pal Singh,
S/o Late Shri Jeet Singh,
Aged about 55 years and
Working in DDK Delhi,
R/o 590, Sector-3, R.K. Puram,
New Delhi-110022.
43. Rajni Pundir,
D/o Sh. Bhopal Singh,
Aged 55 years,
Working as AE in DDK Delhi,
R/o 73, Sector 22, Dwarka,
New Delhi.
44. A.P.S. Kushwah,
S/o Late C. Singh,
Aged about 56 years,
Working as AE in ADG North Zone,
R/o Z-39, Sarojini Nagar,
New Delhi-110023.
45. Harbachan Singh,
S/o Late Niranjan Singh,
Aged 56 years,
Working as AE in ADG North Zone,
H.No.268/Ward 18, Vivekanand Nagar,
Bahadurgarh, Haryana-124507.
46. Sugar Lal,
S/o Sh. Kalika Prasad,
8
OA 3534/2017
Aged 58 years,
Working as AE in HPT Kanpur,
R/o 115/240(A), Maswanpur,
Post Rawat Pur, Kanpur U.P.
47. Archana Aggarwal,
S/o Sh. D.P. Gupta,
Aged about 55 years,
Working as AE in DDK Delhi,
B-370, Sector-51,
Kendriya Vihar, Noida U.P.
48. Sanjiv Khosla,
S/o Ramesh Khosla,
Aged about 49 years,
Working as AE in ADG N/Z,
R/o 936/7C, Faridabad,
Haryana-16.
49. Mahipal Singh,
S/o Sh. Jatan Singh Negi,
Aged about 47 years and
Working as AE,
R/o D-34, Radio Colony,
Kingsway Camp, Delhi-9.
50. Lokendra Kumar,
S/o Sh. P.B. Swarup,
Aged about 48 years and
Working as AE in ADG N/Z,
5/1177, Sector-5,
Vasundhra, Ghaziabad U.P.
51. Vinod Kumar Sharma,
S/o Sh. C.P. Sharma,
Aged about 59 years and
Working as AE in ADG N/Z,
R/o 4/106, New Defence Colony,
Muradnagar, Dist. Gaziabad U.P.
52. Mahesh Mathur,
S/o Late G.L. Mathur,
Aged about 56 years and
Working as AE in ADG N/Z,
R/o Flat No.2003, Ashoka Enclave,
Plt. No.8A, Sector-11, Dwarka,
New Delhi-75.
9
OA 3534/2017
53. Anil Kumar Sharma,
S/o Shri S.D. Sharma,
Aged about 53 years and
Working as AE in ADG North Zone,
R/o D4/10, Radio Colony,
Kingsway Camp, Delhi-110032.
54. Dinesh Chandra Mishra,
S/o Shri M.D. Mishra,
Aged about 48 years and
Working as SEA in ADG N/Z,
D-8/14, Radio Colony,
Kingsway Camp, Delhi-9.
55. Suresh Chand Durgapal,
S/o Shri M.C. Durga Pal,
Aged about 51 years and
Working as SEA in ADG N/Z,
D-11/15, Radio Colony,
Kingsway Camp, Delhi-9.
56. Rajesh Kumar Maheshwari,
S/o Sunhari Lal Maheshwari,
Aged about 55 years and
Working as AE in DG DD,
R/o Flat-1111, Gaur Ganga-B Apartment,
Sector-4, Vaishali, Gaziabad U.P.
57. Shashi Wali,
D/o Shri P.N. Liddhov,
Aged about 57 years and
Working as AE in ADG N/Z,
R/o A-63, Sushant Lok,
Phase-III, Gurgaon Haryana.
58. Prem Chandra,
S/o Sh. Lala Ram,
Aged about 54 years and
Working as ADE in ADG N/Z,
D-2/10, Radio Colony,
Kingsway Camp, Delhi-9.
59. Tahir Hasan,
S/o Late Mukhtar Hasan,
Aged about 51 years and
Working as AE in CPC Doordarshan,
10
OA 3534/2017
R/o D-16, Lane No.2, Batla House,
Jamia Nagar, New Delhi-25.
60. George Varghese,
S/o Shri Mathai Varghese,
Aged about 48 years and
Working as SEA,
Athickal House, Neyyasserry Idukki,
Dist. Kerala-685581.
61. Jitendra Saraswat,
S/o Shri Prakash Chandra,
Aged about 49 years and
Working as AE in ADG N/Z,
5/1176, Vasundra,
Ghaziabad U.P.
62. T.D. Jacob,
S/o Shri T.P. Devassy,
Aged about 50 years and
Working as AE in Thattil, Mandi House
Kanjany P.O. Trichur,
Dist. Kerala-680612.
63. Vinod Kumar,
S/o Late Chandra Sekharan Nair,
Aged about 50 years and
Working as EA,
Haritham P.O. Nileshwar Kasargod
District Kerala-671314.
64. George Kora P.
S/o Shri P.U. Kora,
Aged about 48 years and
Working as EA,
3/5, All India Radio Staff Quarters,
HPT, AIR Malad (W) Mumbai-400095.
65. Abdul Nazar,
S/o Moideenkutty K.
Aged about 47 years and
Working as SEA,
Kolakkal House,
Chettippadi Post Malapuram,
Kerala Pin 676319.
11
OA 3534/2017
66. Dhirendra Kumar Gupta,
S/o Shri Raghu Nath,
Aged about 46 years and
Working as EA in DDK Delhi,
Block C-4-9, Radio Colony,
Kingsway Camp, Delhi-110009. .. Applicants
(By Advocate : Dr. Ashwani Bhardwaj with Shri Vinay Bhardwaj
and Ms. Bhawna Massey)
Versus
1. Union of India, through
The Secretary,
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting,
Govt. of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi-110001.
2. Under Secretary, BA(E)
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting,
Govt. of India, Shastri Bhawan,
New Delhi-110001.
3. Director General, Doordarshan,
Mandi House, Copernicus Marg,
New Delhi.
4. Director General, All India Radio
Akashwani Bhawan, Sansad Marg,
New Delhi. .. Respondents
(By Advocate : Shri D.S. Mahendru for R-1 & 2 and
Shri S.M. Arif with Shri S.M. Aatif for R-3 & 4)
ORDER (ORAL)
By Mr. V. Ajay Kumar, Member (J) Heard both the sides.
2. The applicants, who have originally filed O.A. No.58/2015, withdrew the same in view of rejection of their claim by the 12 OA 3534/2017 respondents during the pendency of the O.A., with liberty to file a fresh O.A. on the same cause of action.
3. The applicants without questioning the said speaking order dated 13.10.2015 filed the instant O.A. again seeking benefit of various decisions of this Tribunal, though the respondents distinguished the applicants from that of the applicants in the said decisions by giving reasons vide their speaking order dated 13.10.2015.
4. In the circumstances and in view of the submission made by the learned counsel for the applicants, the O.A. is dismissed as withdrawn with liberty as was permitted by this Tribunal vide order dated 21.08.2017 in O.A. No.58/2015. No order as to costs.
(Nita Chowdhury) (V. Ajay Kumar)
Member (A) Member (J)
/Jyoti /