Karnataka High Court
A M Prabhu vs Diamond Rose Prabhu W/O Late G M Prabhu on 10 November, 2009
Bench: N.Kumar, C.R.Kumaraswamy
wsmi mm mm "mm 'ma mm mama?
fizimmrm they" Wmva mafia mtmfii ffim a";fim§".2x*m::57,§;2:3§§2se%-;;~."vv.4 {imam fiavm §m>ma:a:;%M £33m mam WW mm. ".?%;%tig$;§m3 * fihm §:xmrVt%m§ Em $3113? mmzfiimg eszrf a mfififlmamii[m;1'§m4¢fir§."'--T§§'§e§f;¢ '--._°*:§§a'.. "%.§"m., f gmwfiimg mt iém qmwmiwm mi' jmfiififififl, fimwv V ' -: w:::§E:.°*§m1Ré:s¢;i.. §}~::*:». gs _'_d§§=u::r%¥eé$ Sm; Frwfiam §:,PV15§r:&f'?§ fifi, £1} 3;§gm fif aiw*£:'r;3::éém3m"m mfww me. E_;f1:*E:3m1 Lmiai ;2%.i1f;if*zc;.;':"i@:;*§;¥ Esfiamgaimm 5?: $§.M;m'*§w;- . _§wz»a:?§fii mf&@"x'? Wm pmawm abm;;?a'..§;E '?f'ma_ Ea%a:w,i'«%f€;&.md'§3f'a2m£:ha1§m'ga%fi. Ex": Em). flf m'?"§§"7.;3§ mf Ewmmad; Cmflixm fiat it Ema mwmiflim é;i',§*7a§m"£v;Vv fihfi qumirimm mi" fifiammmhag . ' ,37.m. zEitm.i$9m;"'§:§x&£¥@;w mm. mfimy fig Ema miwmt in '§f3;Effi$3%£§iJffifia Emaéhem fim Lanai éiaifiirg aha afimfifiimm mafia W mimmfm.m«:£amz$3 3 'km 3%. Elm; fimwmmt pm-mwsarimw. 'rm m':;3;sez$° gmafimfi 1:131 rwagxxifiixg ma: rigiwé; ea?" $«&.€§f§"7E. wf mm .. ' y rmmzmhwm 'rm fltm flfifiififli mf EX fism fikzmm im 'ézifiw §;»m§m$:*?;:3;" fififi am §¥£&'$;§§§%;, wfi" mm gsragmrtjgr Whig mafia mm: in fitm mmgm aw? mi} fim 53 paxwammg 'flxmmfmmg \/ '@*:3*'fi§X" .$'&";:»»"é%%:§€'%}A?5'."i3»=*° aim ifiaurt mi" Eimwm 31 Elm m3'.:a-¢%,m'1&@ in €£*m*: Bight M?' mm afixxxgmaimm E;wfwm;'fé£r:s¢::
firmxa L-m3.§;§-. Kiwiéfiwg &.z.x.fiw1¢i€.im mmgfimfig "
@=m§::§' ggkmuzmad Exgg rm: Efrbazi Laud ex :§;ae::;.2m*§.3:1g ?:§m'§: mmh mm mi" fiwmiz' m*a:g ;a:37;zf3£.§i?g§w;§;4§' "fig? 3, , T afimw magi Efimm 32$ ism Emjxzzzi ,_i.;n @Rfe:":;§&as¢:a mi" TV»'€;%;:a;f<: "
iimégt, fiém prfiaami: m,:x.;rl§ _' "§$j:" $fé"§m}'-- far pmfméiimm mi' aha: awkiézaififiza ;%§x*a:Vw§1*?;3g'»..%"E§a;%:"€§$$§mt:<: mm aw mrwtmam. aim mm?mm:§gmE;§fi:..., §§#37°}e§?1~.'§::k=§m3}€;§§wEZ§X'."§'?»§Vv"."£.°fELfl pram far §%_._fi ._.;%>"fi cf§'\é::§'m'§;t¢%e@r;J:.a§V" a mama {km :33" 3§g1."§~;$@%"§ amhimg fimft wiikgmmfig mi." Em? fag" 3 right in p§mm§; §§mp&m3g' in gxmmwmmmma wf 'fim %Rm$;ig*; mgammaa Tm mm mg" aim §-iggh fi';im:ié:*§ E?:m"§im%mf3;§' Emu aamafi; mjgzwm mm aim Lfmm mm x V A -- f V. I' Q3: %fmx'3x§;ax"1m 3 in @3 am fllfié fluhwwumzxt ..-£;§*av.s.maf€:§*am"§ Wkm am fiimplfififlflfii gm pmfiiwwag '§"§:m§,r ffiafi; gm Writmsfi. mfifimmfimt mm-mtamciimg that fim yfifiimfifi Eiflfi 1" }{4f:i?€,"£f'i€7§» fimfim r§:!t3Em3 fiémf 13' Wamiifi" 33$ pm:mlm.: £361 C3a:*m;m EM afldrwwmi mgmmmmm: Ha cmxltwmnm. mndw Exiw fM;§*mn. '§"}";§§fl f{}3;'"&i3§{3fifEfy" Wm mrxzmriwfi j, .A in 4' émrggi "Em mzmt meg: aé;x;";:a:*~§&ti«m1'$;;a;.E._ "%axpm":f:~ia'}é.*:%:eV;.. t§fm ;: mmfi Em jg2*"m"ew;$:%m**- km?,fim'?'Whm- iéw.'~z"§p5 New fim,zh"%;. ma SW ¢ie;%§mf:afi;ia.«::;1:.;'*;\«-- ffiséfi pmfitiém' amfi rm Qmuréi mm mm wmmwmg%%g1figg;Wa ymémm.
Ema €§ "§;e.:=.- _ " & pmzimimm fax"
.. éémiri gmazéfiiwm mama 'm Em fimgmm _»"£2:.2:§."~2"';:'..;.v,a§"'az.§ gm agrmmmesxti wmiww mm m'i:w'mm« fiwwmmzzx flan mafia mamtgfmmmzifi-& {Em gxmim" gxzawwfi gm. fim m-:.fm}§2";%mi$&:
.§a%=.m@€"_ _ $m%;:a*,§;'§V"~.,1;pM'§nv Em flm prammfifizxgfi %:@f:3m mssé; Q in 4 ml g,m&g:gs;§; mmmis mm aeimitmfl amt firm pEm3"°;3;i§§" am mm; Em Erma Effim afimra im itifm aaifi * ggmyéfiwy fijfm. fixxah. mmfimmm, an mraim -Qéfiiimfi M: has:
2 . §g1%am&«£§ §:m::§fi.2§.zf% 'fimt wax}: wf 'flfw fggmiigs' nmmmm immfigufiimg, fifm pfimmtzifif fig fizfifiitimfl in tfififiififi} aezgafin wf Vfi&§$,3i"1°i Emmi in mmitfimm tm him V%m.;&3§§§:§;r% magi Kim Emmi m 9%; fia';':3'W3."}?' m fiw _ wwmmai. ksy" fim {mm}? 33% Wit:
maid mgrfiar (11% mm amsté; it haw Em mafia aémammfimmwwg m§%W§$E";%%a;.;1aii§'3;g%§'12& A ~ gfimami in fiw mxmywmmingg ;mt;s§?i.£vm;*:.«. '4 Qmurm M 313% fiefilifi. mmpxwmfmflz :¥§§<fi'fi__.'i§ 1§:%":"'§."fi.€:;'"§:<F€§=€f§_ am fiw mmfiam pmeemd kw fim 'V §§§,§fl71Q£"'i£13fi£% §%Ews:m kw im a c§¥m¥««€§§%ué:s2';,€1€:;:u §i"m:__i$ fimtgmz m Mfiih w}§.m:"m Jim fiw &m1'xwifi;m§mA..§§ra2v§:§}e:«?":*%§*L,. iéfimmri mnmxifimfi, m mamémm £:ix""2;=*9é&;z"; in :§L§:'E$§fE gm mix 1% mrmfi kw ma paiitfimm $3 Wmfi :¥ ?;.£fi%j{f?fl 'Em; ' Ema: mi:
%$h&fi§tE §%Z;* §;jx"%xmé;ga.&f%:*£:§°;. wfiiam smmmmaiafig, fiw gmmprrymxéflfi i:i£w,':$'f:;*v.°:%'=_§'a¥:§" mm: ~ imwrwfi am xfzaqfzfiureai " V. misgfiéav __.ae,.mfif "€'.:§'*;;;%;*:%a&a'f;c:'-°~a",;':éz'°:,>§:*m tmfamfimxta L? M %~ Whm Emmi §3.*°x£;"3;g:mx"t§g figifi mm": amqmzivaa mm? righi I =- - j~ - . V .1 .-
mp mprm mm fiammm am fine? giwzrw mf fim mxag' @Lx;hm;%,m tlém jam?
é...?a;§é;:;;;<*t mguiméa m Em mi»-aaifim, Elm rmgmiafiwmm mbmnétmai it 51% mm: in cififiggmm Wéu Fm" mmmm imxmmi mammal fm"
M' ' {3} .&:fi;§€1e:3:r' fiim §';§mm;ifi" ma; "Elm mm emf Eim msait awm 4% a::w«-mvmm: if fim whmm in fififi %m§%: aciamfifimha @at'£3§mfi§?~'"?* {Q} Wkfifimxr flfim fimxm mf' mmmgaszfiwmmw V' mm iiimm mqmétma 3."
Vtx*mi§jm;m? . A mm? Eéflik 2. T iéfl "§"Em- rafififiwgmfifipa éfizmflg gsaakfiéiafi- »4§;§"'xi§% in a.%3?s-mggtmmg ",§%§w tkw pémiarg mmm mfi izufig-;.§§ Fmmzhmx "Km mmmriwmfLm'§;._Vrr;°mm;ét;& :f3f;r.%ééz;af;%§m?:'aa§E¥$'.j1't'%kf:{:5c%z%£§§;§ Wém mfmthsam fimwfifi '§1%'_."E;?§T$¥vV $i;;'&??s%«V., _&@::r®».%§m%z;t .&&%£%& mg. §1*i;.3;"'§%'-? madam' wihiméx 'K§f".i§§ fmlfi. m fim aimrfi mi' Dr Q 3% ¥x%am;W:x;fi§"-. Eiwfgmv-Wm:';V'~~'&%w &%;Em7§ Ev§a%hx?aa¢w Yizmrmfwag Er" Q Mi .':{"f¢'7,i"i%'fi§;T3;®fi ya wait. rm fififi fififflg mix. the file mf Kim 1 ' --- ?iii§;»z,¢:%v'§":' g;.YV;,i§;§g2?&V§ . '§§§"::%7m§::%g& ma .
wf 'égrmmmmk fiflmfi Efivfigifififi mafia '$}3.£~'§; muzifi. »_ ma ::;;;>m;::;m {£3 kw a3.w:3r@mi§ Hmwvmwrg fi'};%$ mmmwhzififl wafixi Q} R Pmflsmhm wxmmmfi &. WEE} fiamd.
_ ' --..3;sa'§s..?i.:?;i&.W;§*f§ '%§?"§"E§$§TE ma amiy mfimmrmix E33 am 233.13% W112? ifl aé miE%;m3:2m:w mt: mm Eifigamimm, i%m%mmjfi,;z;mmfi§*, kl/, V' tkm m.mEii=.4!m7;'m;§€fi p:%*m§mr%:§m fig? mmtaarirxg imm 3%. Tim miimfmafimi rmim}; azzaimmrimfifiy aim a-mmamm Q am a« aha} ha W M: ami a&%::s s;@.:a3;:g;:9sz& % mwmm M" %:%"m ma: prmwrw. fimm mf time iZ$i"}?§§iE:E--fil" ' % mm :2-.e mm am am wid '"{J'¢"','i""%57.?f'§7J:§I.3'i~'%§""E',§.?,.' £;§t'*§f'§;";*éms%;;" 111$:
Qilfiffi mmm mi: Waém égwntézm mg 'vfiifiv $3g§f§;'_%§,i=»§:; wi" am gziaimifi" in wait migfi. a:m;1§§&§mx::ii&%__ p'«:i>--'%r,1:3€:'§;m§i-.. '"' }E¥':%:%m fim afmmmmfi m.zt;&;:£&s.f§_m;2--f%:m%, faqmam. ié£:%_z.3>}.@mr" 'tififwev _ Q ma "% E-"mfi, a §ar$me§mE§§i£}§§' pywyfirty.
gm":- fim mmggfsgzfiima':j;§;m%:i:%Ii<§'2'"2""gi*%svim'% g;.1#m?;w: ;@x*e2pm*t§«r m fimm m{:1£§'gi*r§i§1g§'%"}s';@V :r~3iae mm m fixes §3%fE3?;§w3&"' mi" thm 'aim }:3£m,t°.z%i37i;fi'" hm awn E Wfifgiaaia Erma {MW mmmstte a. aimrm: mf flaw Qflfigffig imht m fimt if x5???' mhmvae: Miami :;§,:§E'm& 'E"3%§.:'&3;**m§":";xm3 Em }":m im right in mm mid fififfifl hfxwmfm am fiwz mmtmmfimr; fimfi étém smifi mmpmmém 31$ mat mmai upeam fig: éfffiflflflfffiflfiiiw it ifi aim mmy m.x%mmr,am.m¢ Umfifir thaw a-;::mm.§§m&m1§z@m Ema V"
{mm gfirfi, {kw mgtzsr-%.%;mim}§;". mzwzimm '£:§*wm§ fimy §'§&€.."§ if tsgshwm mamézxfi &.if'm3;* "
mm mm exaf akwgm Ema mriwwci fimix" if :3 mafia amiwfixfifi §,i¥"m§§fiX'%.'§' in ffiwxm mf };§"%é3:;gx:;';$:%f§fi€"§i¢§§3;'§$ , mm? mpmam aa gmmiam ham rmaiwmi wtm.Emat.hie mmmaifi&£.»§f?;im;m Kim mm mm; aimfifi and mafia aaifi damaifix #§w.§;f1ail'f.?iT'fl§mfl1ffE'F¢'.;...:".{',N1t';f.?.$: wgfimxww Ema Emu ée;*f»v:f;x11.§3x*ef3:';:"x:iM»; ma §§fiMg1"E?3§;i{'§ 1 fixmfiuaivwky hmaaaa mm tfigfis V. ma rfigifififitmezi miaez £"{®£i€i%E., ?§"Emr@tfmfi*§ar§. Tififi. fimy fax" fim pisxizmtéifi" m mwmma-m:?}.%. zifmtgfmpmméfia wmififimm ia mm mzmfi mpmm» A " 1317:; .Emaw§&3Vé3£a§ t3'm fiffifiififlfiéiffifi °§:m'i7m*m "fizm Hrbam '*5I'i}<%%.?;§%1%:§§;"T~.%'%'§?;::'ia%*3m"3Z"%z3?.m am: mflmrtxmig 'Hwy arm the:
ifiifiatmi £23; 'Kim yam" $=@'"?£f%¢. Umzaim fiafim gfigasm pémfixw aww Mm }fmE.a§,:2?x:g iami iii emsamm mi' tim Eizmtfiy mam magmmmai. Km mm at fimimxrmfimm fimm % ....a£m fiikfialiw? Wéfiifi m-mwmpmtmfi amsri fihat maexmaa mm: Ezeafig m "amt 'w'f§fl:'m Wm fimwmammmt' 'Wm: vfigmemtimm mkm mm x/ .....m ra<a.nnhmh.fiOu u Ufimm mm iimfifamg flu'£..Emx*§:'t§;&$ Wmfi an 'firm agkmiriwd flay umfiaers." fiw fimt, Wiwiimr yammxrm $.§'€§§::j§ ~ ..
méxfi ggmmma mm iamfi in mama mi' ma z":%$:f.§:_i§.~::g "
Wifiww mm étifgfidrmm Wmm mxxtéfifigfi -W fi$:§Iz?§:¥,::§: ; A' Ervmam amxfiflr the wéiig fimrzifi. y;t7?m§jm*t§?' gr V '7£"'Efw&f@fmm%3 maxi'; mm aaf' fixletzéfi mwfiifimfi m my aim fihmmz gm akm iag&§g£%A%.;~;m;mg«ay%% 2i":E"mmg%:x mm mxfiazr mmm $222.; %§§2gé={'§g'&;§;a.r Efififimfifig WEW? Wyfifi fi»fifil%if'§m{§ "V".%§s2"§5m%:.}i"mxr thma $f;'--';{$ _'§€a;z%;r3mE sfiffifiéfififiafifl mf mm: miiiifig iitmfi '§'§fw§?*a~°§,§'m:*@.,AV'§§§:As3e:: §f:;§i:%1$1ia%.waémmw. mmaéea Etxy 'E m j'$im ickfifié ."1§Wfia2 «' mm": %m'fim1* -~ fim = ' Ema 'a;'i£;3:a::i£*=>:*ifi£s-$?§ if 3%'? aimrm Kim 38%;} %:~:-2» mmtiflrammfi in ahml gmmtmm 9 iii'-£3: SA&§§;«:;<%°);§;*:'.;%e$T'V:'§;:':"rf.;'as;+:@flmd.i;;.'*';g;m '%;m€.wwz1 film pamm Erzy Way 31" &«._m-1;:§.§3;r§~:i::im&§ %x;%mi:'1 mm plfimfiifi gmm up amt if 5%' }*;1}e%i%:§: by him in arm asahmimia §3z"=¢:apmt"t§; m flaw-my fiaxmghmmg mmmfiy ..
wxfiwr gmmmfi ma am'§E°m::"*i?:i% ix. Wm fim?Ew"m*;% fimi hm hm gm 'iffiih %§3i&§"fl,, Em: watmiszi mm: amgmim any figtmmfi in the
-"E: fim fimafiw mi" fim Eimthxar fizrysa V mmtiwm flat, mm fig waxy mifiw, §t ra.aa§.a""a§% mxwm":
mm {£3} mi" aubwfimiémm {IE a.§:a§}i.@$ %<;e:%{w " "
[.
Egigéfiw max A_ mi?' away Vc.%.%T. a €Z';Q7u.:£'t.
ifixmpé: a $13? éT§£€ii*éEfk}' .. sazggagrwamfi in 3% 'my: ,..s:9§;VK:%wem*1§;§1*'a:":f::§_A$§--& mad, mm3:*:x*:Em?.1t:g' " " gxzmgmrtga"
€§';"§."éE7$'*"'T~??'3iL"',V'-h' 'W1":.§Q};'.1é 33$ ma __ ~5'§s%i?,%;v§ii*;';€'§f&j?.w§IJ;'.'3§z\%_fE&;.§ff --..cs.%*fQ cm wit W Em. m%3zé;::€ Wwmizxfi w. flemmri WExx§&s., ;._-- my mgwraiégé dwmrm afiaigm, Eimii am"
am': mi" fzxmm, rfightgk fi$%3§$ «r§&3;&..Li:9z%,a'f:g:*%:;:$a:t§ Whmtkmr zmmd mi" mmtmant, .X@%Wflfifli& if far tim fimt fiéxmm aim gmmwmm gam $,,i'~§g§"§€ amgfiim" flaw ciwmmmm, "£"he§ axmzpriimx am " --f§:im¥f. .§i& if m afimamwam Q32' mzfim" mafia mm $1. mmgmmfiaa mm; immtammme. §.L>E"$§Z%fi?'"€:§3' £fi}f:mf* riimm mm mzbjwxi'; mmfimr emf fim wmit W yrmmmagiimgg wféw mgmimm "":§m:1'5?{"7,I..3} }%tE"1ir3g in. £::}mm®'"{:fm}' %T ' mmgimmfi Eiimt if tlm pmgmmy Whiimh 11$ tha m;b§ew?\/,. Fm" rm £a.f&:2*mwZ-£3 rmzfimmy aw; aw mm fizmzi mfirit $31 smy mf flaw ammmmtiama raiaégd.
Aaztmr Wm': WM thfl faifimwfigmg:
fififlfifi fljfimafi 21$ flgifififiiifl-fififim ?iT§L£§§§§$; awn wwmv . ~ Iudéé %;fm;"