Indra Reddy @ Indrappa S/O ... vs K S Seethapathi S/O Siddappa on 20 July, 2009

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Indra Reddy @ Indrappa S/O ... vs K S Seethapathi S/O Siddappa on 20 July, 2009

Bench: N.K.Patil

mi ms area cazsmr as 5-<_aRa;A TARA A 3' swag {}A'i'}E3B T313 THE zarm DAE' <3? JULY, ;V---{: f _ ';PE'ESE3?€'l';

THE Hmmzz IﬁR.&IIS'i§'CE-'_§i;I§". F§&,'Tii'.*~ 5 * 7 A1'? .. _V mg ;§&w3LE2;m.ﬁ;.§$*:cE % B:u,Az>PA M1 5«".A_;*».zo_ 1 mi f?t:.éF SET'v"'sa'EE%'~i AsED:'4?x{EAR's'---.._ , .

ma :e<;;:..._1 G1,. E--3A8:;$.a;BARz4x$*aL~rA I €3:t%»%...ii:":,:. 'i.a;}v£§;~:;§4:g*:&:»:_': S=CH£"ﬁ'3L:

§{£L'f&%€#§'5£AGA'r?;R §'~'{}.'§.3'{, S;iN{3I%.LORE*V5?gx:3'§§ ' 1 gamma R%i:3L7:%'}§..tr4£",%§:;ﬁx_¥--;F*;f§ {3 'ff?iN'Ka%}€4}5\%€A?v1ANA RESIN 2 snz%3s~':;;rv§A :g:;<;.>...::«z§3ate;;a__;";.*'12::e2-' ggascg ' V _ 2 " _ _ REA m{:';<:r."s%; E§»%i';iUSF2BﬁRAPALYA ; Qiiié?' 'Ea G{>'JERNmE%&T scaaez, 5 ' E{AL1'ANANAGi3uF{é%__?£}$Y, ' ':3$'7£?>éG«ALURE--$58Ci45 fiF~'%i.i_A£'%T53 gag S.-'i: sV%;:é%s:éz.s*¢;-Ta ;-4.%ua*":"m', aavGcATE:;

ares: .. "

=2 _ K $%3.ETHR§3'A'%'£-=ii 3:0 8§{3ﬁAF3'£~'*A " GP?' K3 ﬁ5.{'~iGAi3§ K§3:i53%~§?€R§7*'§3'A {3Hi?<.}<ﬁ8Af~§RSR¥ﬁ.E3% §3E?§GAL{}RE {s'C.»"se"'ue':'*«§i5.:'?4i G? §"§~x'E VEHSCLEL}

2 'E"%~§E'; SEFGERRL §u'%§NA{3ER Eéﬁi i{}%'~éﬁ:.L fN8URﬁd'%C£{ Ci) LN} EJEREEC? é. £33.?'-3"§" $R?:§\§CH EQQ9, §..3N§ARﬁ.JL¥ $Ofv'£§'3'LEX '{3«ﬁ§§'€DF~%€£'3R2RR, 8ASA\:'AN?v;'3U{}§, B.-'?x¥'€f.§AL{}'RE~58§%-1 s2EsF«;2:§;'L>Ek~€é%?::. V' 2 2 {R-I S§~.~ZR'w'E;£3;

f3r$:P?3R';'%J%.S,ASVG{1ATE FQR R2} . _ _ ms F-f,F.A. :3 FELEB war» 1:?3;:;"{>:>rm;*..ac3< }5.{3AiNS"? T%€E¢ J%.J¥;3Gf'u'EE§'~i'€' ma AWARD DATES amzas smssgza {N wvc._~o.5'?V44;:c3 me FELE es" xv: A£}DL..JUDGE, MAST, '€2OLiR"3" oz: 'SMALL 'causes, METRGPQLETSW AREA E$ﬁ«NGRL€Z}RE {sCCH#1...-4},'--%?':'%.i'~2"¥'é_'{,.';f%§.i.G§'VIr-i{'3 ':'"H£'=, cmsm PETWQN FOR c;:oMPE:-:sAr.:{>r¢..._Ar40 SﬁEKi{'~£G E%§Ha§¢S,£rg1E_E4T GF._ » CGf'v'§§-9£E§'~§ESz¢'J'iC§"2 '§"u"§3H Ni §¥V'TERES'§ r"-'A. V '$1343 M.F.A. coming on .i:e:%"Aci1n:ssie:i' -t11;s.--Eia;.-r, Nit. PATIL J,de1iven=:d the _frﬂ]nur?ng;_ V ~-- _ pdgted today for Admissisn, with fhé'Qéétwséﬁf.Ab*§ ie:éi%§éd'. ccunsei appearing fer bath the" ;;§é¥"'§igs, i;§"iéE..Ef;I_'fié;i'?f3i€ is taken up far ﬁnai dispcsai.

21.T7§'£§é'--a-gzpeiiarutsj being aggrieveé by the juégmarrt 3'35: August 200"? passed in MVC No' the XV! Adéiféorzai Judge and Mﬁfﬂf "V~I%jﬁg:::;'i»:tie:'eV5Es siliaims ﬁibunai, Bangaiare, $3CC'ri-'E :3, (in §f?'¥G$'? 'Chime Trsbunaim have présenieé this appe.-3%, seeking enﬁanmment af ${3f'§'3ff}€F?$3'{fii3f"t, an ithe gmunczi that the amrnunt éwarcﬁeﬁ by tﬁe iiiaims Trivbt§.¥ffi*&§_V is inzacjequaie.

3. The appeiEants--1 and 232:3 ih_e"c:r§V t§<3::j=2"" 2 ﬁeceased Sri. Shanécara Red&y;"A:4sttjfﬁe}:t s2g_f;e<fI years. Gr: 'i1.9.2i303 at }a_ i'V:1_.uT'i§it§é:._;d'eaeé:sed"V Sri. Shamkara Reddygas gsa:;£e;san%g%%:n éh'va.L:i:;rickshaw hearing him. u Agata to Bahusa::>arap é§y§ §::§:r:v;§$r*%.}:g§_ 'gaid 3 utorickshaw drove ﬁns negiigenf manner whﬁe cmssing raiiway track ﬁ;ifi':g§:3tVsée.§'hA§A'Aﬁé§%ﬁ:éVi*'€663 of the raiiway track 'tried to @3533 iﬁé cﬁfasséng and at that ﬁme Sathya Sa§'5a§ é.AA'f?r;7i:3v came fmm Czhannasaﬁdra is Yeiahanka 1'3rjE§'--..ci9éiréé1::f._sééﬁwst the autarickshaw and as 3 resuit, the V --V daééasézj Sfr§M Sﬁanicar Raddy died an the spat Sn "..jj~y3n¢b0.;;ﬁt " cf the ﬁeafh $3' ﬁie ﬁeceased Sri. Shaﬁkara ifte appﬁants wim are the parents have ﬂied a r:£a§m peféiian, cmémimg mmpensatien of Rs,15,25,{i0Gi-. The méé ciaém petifien F236 came L33 far' wnsédaratéon before 'the Ciaims "fribunai on 3153 January C3aims:. Tribunai, has aﬁawécti the said part and awarded 3 sum R51 .-,'§zs.i3"':'.:'ﬁ;.':l"t_"gi;:: é'E':1$:::;i:':c3:rv""2" 2 under different 'rzéacis with CE"J*Si'S skid :féi:3*iV;"2ié'.ir1"£:e*+.{i*e>$'t:é!i_8*%2§ pa- frcm ihe daze of pet;té§3;§'%L2-3;: thé ﬁate"é'f.é3%é@étia:-'3.' ' Being aggrieved by t§1e..V.saidV.j::.V§g_:mé:1t.' 21.56 i:_=n4;a:*A:§6 passed by the Ciasms ﬁave presented this appeai, e§__§d;hpensat§on in so far as it ioss of expeciancy, imre ebsequées.

i*33§}:eA§Li.'Aé*§§:§;é-jiﬁ'ééarrmeci czzunssei appearing far hotifg 'Ei't8 paftéesg " "

§; '_i.:é 1'a?ir§sr3' cczzmgei appearing for the appeiiants siihtﬁiita%iv_v..ﬁ%ét;V..the Ciaéms; Tribune? has cnmmitieﬁ an

--V erféjf .§;§*V:;a;\s}é;r<§éhQ 3 sum ﬁf Rs_1,5{},G{3{)i-~ fawards icxss af igfar-.;.'&afvV§§apenﬁency, by taking the rmtienai incame sf thé ::§ec':é3$é€:i Sré. Sirssrzkara Reﬁdy am it mzght to have sdepteﬁ fvizziiipiier af '%8' mgteaci' sf '15' whiie cﬁcuiaﬁng the imss mf éeparxciency. i-ﬁe aisa submiﬁerﬁ that the -5- amaunt awardeci by the Ciaims Tribuﬁai *tarwar;j'$_"§é§§;ré*;§.f2eﬁV affecticn and other imidentai expenses is:-._:§naj§§éé:;i.é2te V' and it needs it: be enharxcad.

6. Per cantra, ieareigd :§c:~1,ir2$€ei avgépééféﬁgg 7f¢r g sectcﬁd respGr':<:fent~= iz1sut"'§*::.i;?¢ . ;in%ef-aiia, contended that 'i:i"1aV'";'%Tf4.i:I:;rL_.1'r:'%.%:Li cozﬁirﬁeratiaﬁ of the materiai :::'r*a. v§ecQrci';v:..f§'gssV'~ just and reatsonabig.--<_*;';,ir1f:3;i{é_§fjs#i:§g%:- tf;?v":vz'="..=;:'f-';'e:1';6iV"e, it was mt ca}? for ir:tg.:far__é:r::.*:;'é.:V':*1 submitted that the 3ppe§i:£a¥jtS tawarﬁs 3053 sf §epet§s'er§::3g; 'v§r:;v&:_ Aazsiéi...-"L'af§ect§on arid Qther irzciderﬁal < %x.?3€}ﬂ5§$. 2 _____ .. e V }"v;..b_"%.«'.+"\*fi*§i"*-..r:.$:*e§ui can-ceideratien cf the submissicms ﬁéaéie b§,r i a §:§':aé mange? appearing fer bath the parties:

éiiciudisfzg the guﬁgmeﬁt and award passgd by the Ciaims f§':%é%)§é:1ai, the aniy questicm firm? arims fer aur ....a:,:}:2n$§derai§m': is:

\:"xfir:éiher 1:-he arrmunt award by ﬁm Giaims Tr§b2ma§ i3 guat and gxaper?

I WW___km__,_a,,_.,H....m_.

1 M:

I status sf 'Em appeiiaﬁts and aime they have icgfi' have fairiy submitted 3313:, 3 iump sum ""'a:r1"2€s}V:2i"%Lt ' Rs.2,5{),GGﬁi- may ha awarded instgad sf R$.§,85,i3G{3i-- as:-.4_ aﬁiarﬁeﬁ A' Tﬁbuﬁai

11. ha fne iearned cmursgei appesrizjg fof..~~--ﬁ§9;t?;j 1v,.E'3éving regard to the f3:::t$ as states' abuve, and invVvx:i.ev~;v§;"':3f;::" ﬁne Apex Ccmrt in the case finéther Vs. Masafar Paswan and ansfhézff m§c:r%¢er3s:iL%L%"%k2ac5 Acid 99, we seem it fit to av.;:$"§é<§s;:,;rn nufV"iRva:;.2;5G,GGG1~ as fuii arid fine! seiftiemartf it"V:§t'&at%».:_:V'c>f""§*s,3,85,Gmi- as awaréed by the Ciaims fréﬁﬁnaih. ' Having regardf.-:)£%1e facts and circumsaﬁceg £3?

' ,.1V:§:e: ¥;;aea as stated abcve, the instarsi appeai ﬁiec by ihe VA ....;{p;)ei§an£s is aiiswed in part.

The impugned judgmant and aware? daied 3%" January 23% passeﬁf by the Ciasmg ?:":§s..:nai in MVC Ne. 5?«$4i2683 is Am 2' hereby ﬁzodified, granting a mmpeﬁsaiien cf Rs.2,:'3(};§§3G;'- insiead af R3,': ,85,8G0i- as awarded by the Ci3ii'!}$x with izkiemgt at 8% per arznum from the date of§§a'§itir::s;:»:{ii'§"ti3§§ Q date 3? reaaizaiieﬁ.

The secs-mi resacncient-- it2s5Li:*anc:e T €1};:fn2§ai13; =§S"--. ciireszted ta de-pmii ﬁne e::hanc1é&é:C£:n1peiiaaéticii-= ai4t;;;;§%3t with 'V inierest 3?: 6% pa. wstagre:gr:i%§yes::sk%A%%fram we date cf the feceépt 3? 'me ceriifietﬁ mpy award.

The Cis§irié§:;= T:'%¥:;§;%:1ai1_ disiéurse the said amsurﬁifﬁ aj§§;:ié2iié:*zi§$-, izziiiiediéteiy 0:3 depczsii by the gscoﬁév"zeéyxahdéﬁééiﬁsur§':1%,§é..~C§3:ripany. ffhe L:":f§vz*ua_é:;':%:;;*;--. by the Ciairﬁs Triburﬁ regarding V' . re:i:3éke;f::..afv%.i;he a:%é:::u:':iV paéci by {he insuiancue Cempaﬁy fmm 1:322 :§.'f"£3SBi3T3é$i'?t remaiﬁs uraﬁisturberi. ihe award, acxzsrdingiy. Sd /V"

FUDGE Sﬁ/..

Iifﬁgfg ism'

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court