Central Administrative Tribunal - Allahabad
Mes Rashtriya Karamchari Through ... vs M/O Defence on 1 April, 2025
Open Court
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ALLAHABAD BENCH,
ALLAHABAD.
(This the 01st day of April, 2025)
Original Application No.1413 of 2024
With
Original Application No. 260 of 2025
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Joshi, Member (Judicial)
Hon'ble Mr. Anjani Nandan Sharan, Member (Administrative)
O.A. No.1413/2024
1. MES-374420, Birendra Pratap, aged about 62-Years, S/O Hori
Lal, presently posted as Refg. Mech MCM, C/O GE (I) Kanpur
Cantt,
2. MES-480172, Virendra Kumar Verma, S/O Ram Lal, FGM MCM,
C/O GE (I) Kanpur Cantt,
3. MES NO-471480, Satya Prakash Narayan Singh, S/O Ram Deni
Singh, Electrician SK, C/O GE (E/M) Chakeri, Kanpur
4. MES NO 452765, Ram Sagar, S/O Malhoo Ram, Electrician SK,
C/O GE (E/M) Chakeri, Kanpur
5. MES NO-19277, Anil Kumar Rai, S/O Late Markendey Rai,
Electrician HS II, C/O GE (E/M) Chakeri, Kanpur
6. MES NO 471462, Chandrika Pandey, S/O Raghunath Pandey,
Electrician HS II, C/O GE (E/M) Chakeri, Kanpur
7. MES NO 452776, Karan Bahadur, S/O Late Dhan Bahadur,
Carpenter SK, C/O GE (B/R) Chakeri, Kanpur
8. MES NO-452777, Shiv Prasad Pal, S/O Niranjan Prasad Pal,
Mason HS-I, C/O GE (B/R) Chakeri, Kanpur
9. MES NO 439456, Rajender Singh, S/O Roshan Lal, Pipe Fitter
HS-II, C/O GE (I), R&D, Kanpur
10. MES NO 471373, Raj Kumar Maurya, S/O Vijay Kumar,
Carpenter SK, C/O GE (I), R&D, Kanpur
11. MES NO 439431, Harish Chandra, S/O Ram Sabad, Electrician
MCM, C/O GE (I), R&D, Kanpur
12. MES-472320, S C Saxena, S/O V K Saxena, Elect MCM C/O GE
(I) R&D Kanpur
13. MES NO 1491243, Shashi Kumar Trivedi, S/O Hari Prasad
Trivedi, Pipe/Fitter SK. C/O GE (I) Kanpur Cantt
...Applicants
By Advocate: Shri Ashish Srivastava
Versus
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
1. Union of India through Secretary to Govt. of India, Ministry of
Defence, New Delhi-110011.
2. Engineer-in-Chief, Ministry of Defence, Kashmir House, Rajaji
Marg, Army HQ, New Delhi.
3. HQ Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow.
4. HQ Chief Engineer, Lucknow Zone, Lucknow
5. HQ, Commander Works Engineer (AF), Air Force Chakeri
Station, Kanpur.
6. Principal Controller of Defence Accounts, (CC), Lucknow.
... Respondents
14. By Advocate: Shri Chakrapani Vatsyayan
With
O.A. No.260 of 2025
1. MES RASHTRIYA KARAMCHARI UNION, CWE KANPUR AREA
THROUGH ASHUTOSH TIWARI, S/O HARI NATH TIWARI,
GENERAL SECRETARY,
2. MES KARAMCHARI UNION, CWE CHAKERI AREA THROUGH
ANKIT KUMAR, VICE PRESIDENT,
3. UP MES WORKERS UNION, KANPUR THROUGH SAMAR
SINGH, JOINT SECRETARY
4. MES NO-609044 SHRI ASHUTOSH TIWARI FGM HS-II S/O
HARI NATH TIWARI C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
Page 2 of 21
5. MES NO-471360 SHRI BALRAM ELECTRICIANRICIAN SK S/O
CHAMANLAL, ELECTRICIAN HS-II C/O GARRISON ENGINEER
(I) KANPUR CANTT
6. MES NO-186516 SHRI KANCHAN SINGH FGM HS-1 S/O LATE
ROSHAN LAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
7. MES NO-421737 SHRI RAM NARAYAN SINGH ELECTRICIAN
SK S/O BHAJANLAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1) KANPUR
CANTT
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
8. MES NO-471320 MOHD SALIM FGM HS-I S/O CHOTE C/O
GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
9. MES NO-T-21 SHRI MANOJ KUMAR REF/MECH HS-II S/O PD
YADAV C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1) KANPUR CANTT
10. MES NO-433624 SHRI HIMANSHU PRAJAPATI MATE
PIPE/FITTER S/O JAGDEEP PRAJAPATI C/O GARRISON
ENGINEER (1) KANPUR CANTT
11. MES NO-427006 SHRI RAHUL KUMAR PANDEY CARPENTER
SK S/O PANCHDEV PANDEY C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
12. MES NO-483986 ANKIT DUTT FIPE/FITTER SK S/O RAVI
DUTT C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
13. MES NO-1491243 A SHRI SHASHI KUMAR TRIVEDI
PIPE/FITTER SK S/O HARI PRASAD TRIVEDI C/O GARRISON
ENGINEER (1) KANPUR CANTT
14. MES NO - 471356 SHRI VIRENDRA KUMAR FGM HS-II S/O
RAM AVTAR C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
15. MES NO - 472337 SHRI GYAN BABOO ELECTRICIAN SK S/O
RAM BABU C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
16. MES NO - 483996 SHRI VIRENDRA KUMAR FGM SK S/O
SOHAN LAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
17. MES NO-471576 SHRI ASHOK KUMAR FGM HS-II S/O LATE
BISHAMBER C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
18. MES NO-372015 SHRI SAMAR SINGH ELECTRICIAN HS-1 S/O
RAGHURAJ SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
Page 3 of 21
19. MES NO - 483988 SHRI AMAN KUMAR SAHNI FGM SK S/O
RAM KUMAR PRASAD C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
20. MES NO-471562 SHRI HARI SHANKAR MASON HS-II S/O
CHOTE LAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
21. MES NO - 471563 SHRI KULDEEP KUMAR PIPE FITTER SK
S/O RAM SABAD C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
22. MES NO - 486435 SHRI RAVINDER KUMAR MATE PAINTER
S/O VISHNU DAYAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
23. MES NO-426516 SHRI SHASHI KUMAR GUPTA FGM SK S/O
UMA SHANKER GUPTA C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
24. MES NO - 483984 SHRI MANU THAKUR ELECTRICIANRICIAN
SK S/O VIRENDRA THAKUR C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
25. MES NO - T-16923 NIHAL AHMAD PIPE FITTER SK S/O MOHD
ISMAIL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
26. MES NO-471318 SHRI MAN MOHAN MISHRA FGM HS-I S/O
MAHAVEER MISHRA C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1) KANPUR
CANTT
27. MES NO-472309 SHRI SHYAM MOHAN PIPE FITTER MCM S/O
BAICHAN C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
28. MES NO-471322 SHRI VIDYA SAGAR PIPE FITTER HS-II S/O
PAREEKSHAN THAKUR C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1)
KANPUR CANTT
29. MES NO - T-3245 SHRI ASHOK KUMAR FGM HS-I S/O LAL
CHANDRA C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
30. MES NO-471308 SHRI AJAY YADAV ELECTRICIANRICIAN HS-
I S/O CHUNNI LAL YADAV C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1)
KANPUR CANTT
Page 4 of 21
31. MES NO-471389 SHRI CHAKRESH ELECTRICIAN HS-II S/O
HANUMANT SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1) KANPUR
CANTT
32. MES NO - 483991 SHRI NITEESH KUMAR
ELECTRICIANRICIAN SK S/O RAJ BAHADUR SINGH C/O
GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
33. MES NO-471570 SHRI GIRJA SHANKER PIPE FITTER SK S/O
SHIV SURAJ BALI C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
CANTT
34. MES NO-A-1484803 Y SHRI SHIV KUMAR SINGH MATE PIPE
FITTER S/O BHIKKU PRASAD YADAV C/O GARRISON
ENGINEER (1) KANPUR CANTT
35. MES NO-615600 SHRI RANJEET KUMAR PAL MATE FGM S/O
SHRI OM PRAKASH PAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
36. MES NO-13684082 SHRI RAGHURAJ SINGH PAINTER SK S/O
VARDANI SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
37. MES NO-483983 SHRI SAURABH KUMAR
ELECTRICIANRICIAN SK S/O MITHLESH C/O GARRISON
ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
38. MES NO - 421590 SHRI RAVINDRA KUMAR VERMA
CARPENTER HS-I S/O RAM AASRE C/O GARRISON
ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
39. MES NO - 483995 SHRI GAURAV PANDEY ELECTRICIAN SK
S/O BABBAN PANDEY C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
40. MES NO - 601097 SHRI GIRENDER SINGH PIPE FITTER SK
S/O RAJENDRA SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
41. MES NO-471575 SHRI PRAMOD KUMAR ELECTRICIANRICIAN
HS-II S/O RAM DAS SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
Page 5 of 21
42. MES NO - 471573 SHRI RAJESH KUMAR
ELECTRICIANRICIAN SK S/O RAM AADHAR C/O GARRISON
ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
43. MES NO - 426484 SHRI MANISH SINGH FGM SK S/O RAM
JEWAN SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1) KANPUR
CANTT
44. MES NO-A-14605354 A SHRI ANIL KUMAR SHUKLA PIPE
FITTER SK S/O KANHAIYALAL SHUKLA C/O GARRISON
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
ENGINEER (1) KANPUR CANTT
45. MES NO-375593 SHRI RAM BARAN ELECTRICIANRICIAN HS-
II S/O SWAMI DEEN C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1) KANPUR
CANTT
46. MES NO-483989 SHRI AVINASH SINGH ELECTRICIANRICIAN
SK S/O LALLAN SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
47. MES NO - 425905 SHRI RAJEEV YADAV REF/MECH SK S/O
RAJENDRA SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
48. MES NO - 426536 SHRI SHUSHIL KUMAR GAUTAM
VEH/MECH SK S/O RAJMAN C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
49. MES NO-471553 SHRI HIRA LALCARPENTER HS-IIS/O DORE
LALC/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1) KANPUR CANTT
50. MES NO-471544 SHRI RAM GOPAL S/O MAYARAM C/O
GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
51. MES NO-426528 SHRI ASHISH NARAYAN SHARMA
CARPENTER SK S/O ASHARAM SHARMA C/O GARRISON
ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
52. MES NO-471541 SHRI RAM MILAN CARPENTER MCM S/O
HARIBANSH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1) KANPUR CANTT
53. MES NO-471319 SHRI RANJEET SINGH PIPE FITTER SK S/O
VIKRAM C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1) KANPUR CANTT
Page 6 of 21
54. MES NO - 471566 SHRI CHANDRA SHEKHAR PIPE/FITTER
HS-II S/O MOHAN LAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1)
KANPUR CANTT
55. MES NO-141152 SHRI MERAJ ALAM FGM-HS II S/O MASOOD
ALAM C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
56. MES NO - 439460 SHRI SHAYM SUNDAR PIPE/FITTER HS-II
S/O KASHI PRASAD C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
57. MES NO-615530 SHRI AJAY PAL CARPENTER SK S/O RAM
PAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
58. MES NO-426556 SHRI PANNA LAL CANEMAN S/O VIJAY
NARAYAN GUPTA C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
59. MES NO-471401 SMT KAMLEESH PAL ELECTRICIANRICIAN
SK W/O LATE RAJ KUMAR PAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER
(1) KANPUR CANTT
60. MES NO-T-1103 SMT KIRAN ELECTRICIANRICIAN HS-I W/O
DHOOP CHAND C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
61. MES NO-421691 SHRI SIDDHARTH KUMAR CARPENTER
MCM S/O JIYA LAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
62. MES NO - 483987 SHRI KUNWAR BAHADUR S/O PRABHU
LAL ELECTRICIANRICIAN SK C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
63. MES-425730 SHRI VISHNU KUMAR PIPE FITTER SK S/O
LATE RAM AVTAR C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
64. MES-471567 SHRI RAVINDER KUMAR PIPE FITTER HS-II S/O
MOOL CHAND C/O GARRIS ON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
65. MES-148213 L SHRI DAYARAM MATE PIPE ITTER S/O RAM
DEEN C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (1) KANPUR CANTT
Page 7 of 21
66. MES-438387 SHRI RAM GOPAL YADAV MASON HS-1 S/O LAL
PATI YADAVC/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR CANTT
67. MES-471370 SHRI AJAY KUMAR SINGH CARPENTEF SK S/O
SHRI RAJESH SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) KANPUR
CANTT
68. MES-439416 SHRI GAUTAM RAWAT REF MECH FHS-I S/O
LATE SHIV NATH RAWAT C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
KANPUR CANTT
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
69. MES NO-42485 SHRI SUREN DRA KUMAR PIPE FITTER SK
S/O CHOTE LAL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) (R&D)
KANPUR
70. MES NO-426441 SHRI AJEET MISHRA REF/MECHSK S/O
JAGDISHI MISHRA C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) (R&D)
KANPUR
71. MES NO - 42.6443 SHRI SHANT ANU PAUL FGM SK S/O
SHANKAR PAUL C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) (R&D)
KANPUR
72. MES NO - 483933 SHRI ASHIS) (KUMAR JALOTA REF/MECH
SK S/O KAILAS I NATH JALOTA C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
(R&D) KANPUR
73. MES NO-471372 SHYAMA DEVI ELECTRICIANRICIAN HS-II
D/O SURAJ PAL CHAURASIYA C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
(R&D) KANPUR
74. MES NO 42:6434 SHRI VICKY LALWANI REF/MECH SK S/O
PRAHLAD LALWANI C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) (R&D)
KANPUR
75. MES NO-426479 SHRI VINAY KUMAR ELECTRICIANRICIAN
SK S/O RAM NARAYAN MISHRA C/O GARRISON ENGINEER
(I) (R&D) KANPUR
76. MES-ANO-1583233 W SHRI JAGRAM SINGH PIPE FITTER SK
S/O GYAN SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) (R&D)
KANPUR
Page 8 of 21
77. MES NO-426433 SHRI ANIL KUMAR GOND
ELECTRICIANRICIAN SK S/O SHYAM BABU GOND C/O
GARRISON ENGINEER (I) (R&D) KANPUR
78. MES NO-426439 SHRI SAURABH KUMAR AWASTHI FGM SK
S/O NAND KISHORE AWASTHI C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I)
(R&D) KANPUR
79. MES-373576 SHRI NAND LAL PIPE FITTER MCM S/O GYAN
SINGH C/O GARRISON ENGINEER (I) (R&D) KANPUR
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
80. MES-426450 DEEP CHANDRA VERMA ELECTRICIAN SK S/O
ARUN KUMAR VERMA C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON
ENGINEER (I), FATEHGARH CANTT
81. MES-426451 SHRI KULDEEP AWASTHI ELECTRICIAN SK S/O
SATYA DEV AWASTHI C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON
ENGINEER (I), FATEHGARH CANTT
82. MES-267239 SHRI DINESH KUMAR REF MECH SK S/O
SUNAHAR SINGH C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I),
FATEHGARH CANTT
83. MES-426453 SHRI MITHLESH KUMAR FGM SK S/O
JAGATRAJ C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I),
FATEHGARH CANTT
84. MES-449100 SANJEEV KUMAR DUBEY FGM HS-II S/O HARI
OM DUBEY C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I),
FATEHGARH CANTT
85. MES-427007 SHRI AJAY PRATAP SINGH MATE FGM S/O
GIRAND SINGH C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I),
FATEHGARH CANTT
86. MES-426513 SHRI KARMU SINGH FGM SK S/O SHIV KUMAR
C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I), FATEHGARH
CANTT Α/ΝΟ-148357M
87. SHRI HARI NATH MATE FGM S/O KANHAIYA LAL C/O
ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I), FATEHGARH CANTT
88. MES-426476 SHRI OM PRAKASH DWIVEDI FGM SK S/O
AVDESH KUMAR DWIVEDI C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON
ENGINEER (I), FATEHGARH CANTT
Page 9 of 21
89. MES-426483 SHRI ROHIT SHARMA MATE ELECTRICIAN S/O
VIRENDRA KUMAR C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER
(I). FATEHGARH CANTT
90. MES-426465 SHRI DHARMVEER SINGH FGM SK S/O RAM
BABU C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (1),
FATEHGARH CANTT
91. MES-426510 SHRI BIRENDRA KUMAR ELECTRICIAN SK S/O
RAMDHANI SINGH C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
(I), FATEHGARH CANTT
92. MES-449135 SHRI RAJVEER DUBEY PIPE/FITTER SK S/O
HARI OM DUBEY C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I),
FATEHGARH CANTT
93. MES-426458 MANTU KUMAR SINGH ELECTRICIAN SK S/O
SAKALDIP SINGH C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I),
FATEHGARH CANTT -426447
94. SHRI ANUJ FGM SK S/O RAMNATH C/O ASSISTANT
GARRISON ENGINEER (I), FATEHGARH CANTT
95. MES-426454 SHRI NEELESH KUMAR FGM SK S/O RAM
KISHAN C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (1),
FATEHGARH CANTT
96. MES-123710 SHRI SUKHRAM SINGH PIPE FITTER HS-II S/O
ANOKHELAL C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I),
FATEHGARH CANTT
97. MES-471374 SHRI DEEPAK KUMAR ELECTRICIANHS-II S/O
SHRI SUBEDAR C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I),
FATEHGARH CANTT
98. MES-426471 SHRI VIKASH KUMAR FGM SK S/O RAM VILAS
KUMAR
99. MES-426465 SHRI BABLU ORAON FGM SK S/O BUDHMAN
ORAON C/O ASSISTANT GARRISON ENGINEER (I),
FATEHGARH CANTT
100. MES-425969 SHRI ANKIT KUMAR FGM (SK) S/O AWADHESH
KUMAR C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
Page 10 of 21
101. MES-471508 SHRIDINESH SACHAN FGM (MCM) S/O SHIV
CHARAN C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
102. MES/A-14116B SHRI SANTOSH KUMAR TIWARI, FGM (HS-II)
S/O GENDA LAL TIWARI C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
103. MES-425983 SHRI DHARMENDRA KUMAR PRAJAPATI FGM
(SK) S/O SUNDAR LAL C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
104. MES-425965 SHRI VIMAL PAL FGM (SK) S/O AMRAT LAL C/O
GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
105. MES-425980 SHRI VIKASH KUMAR SAHU FGM (SK) S/O JANG
BAHADUR C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
106. MES-426502 SHRI LALIT KUMAR FGM (SK) S/O SURESH
KUMAR VERMA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
107. MES-425986 SHRI RAKESH SINGH RANA ELECTRICIAN (SK)
S/O SURENDRA SINGH RANA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER
(AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
108. MES-426501 SHRI MILAN MUNDU FGM (SK) S/O AMARJAN
MUNDU C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
109. MES-426529 SHRI PUSHPENDRA KUMAR FGM (SK) S/O
PRAMOD KUMAR C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
110. MES-426499 SHRI MUKESH KUMAR ELECTRICIAN (SK) S/O
RAMCHANDRA MAHTO C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
111. MES-425970 SHRI SUNIL KUMAR VERMA FGM (SK) S/O
CHANDRIKA PRASAD VERMA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER
(AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
Page 11 of 21
112. MES-425976 SHRI RAHUL KUMAR MATE (ELECTRICIAN) S/O
KAUSHAL KISHORE VISHWAKARMA C/O GARRISION
ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
113. MES-426525 SHRI SUMANT YADAV MATE (ELECTRICIAN)
S/O FOOLESHWAR YADAV C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF)
E/M AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
114. MES-EX-A-1492435K SHRI JUGNU SINGH YADAV MATE
(ELECTRICIAN) S/O RAM AWADH SINGH YADAV C/O
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
115. MES-426503 SHRI AMIT KUMAR VERMA MATE (FGM) S/O OM
PRAKASH VERMA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
116. MES-426500 SHRI RAM PRAKASH FGM (SK) S/O DEVI
PRASAD C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
117. MES-A 15369992X SHRI USMAN ALI MATE (FGM) S/O YASIN
ALI C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
118. MES-426530 SHRI AMAR NATH FGM(SK) S/O MAHESH
SINGH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
119. MES/425990 SHRI ANKUR KUMAR FGM (SK) S/O ASHOK
KUMAR C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
120. MES-375888 SHRI AJAY SINGH FGM (HS-I) S/O SURESH
CHANDRA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
121. MES-425989 SHRI SANDEEP KUMAR FGM (SK) S/O SUGHAR
SINGH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
122. MES-611064 SHRI SUSHIL KUMAR REF/MECH (SK) M S/O
SHREERAM CO GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
Page 12 of 21
123. MES-483054 SHRI MOHD AYAS REF/MECH (SK) S/O MOHD
ISHAHAQ C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
124. MES-426498 SHRI VINAY KUMAR SHAH REF/MECH (SK) S/O
UDHAV JI SHAH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKER KANPUR
125. MES-T.NO. 15230K SHRI MAHENDRA PAL REF/MECH (HS-II)
S/O RAMSHANKAR PAL C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
126. MES-425984 SHRI VISHAL RAJPUT REF/MECH (SK) S/O
RAJESH RAJPUT C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
127. MES-425962 SHRI DINESH KUMAR RAWAT REF/MECH (SK)
S/O SATYA PAL SINGH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
128. MES-471500 SHRI RAMA KANT ELECTRICIAN (MCM) S/O
RAM NARESH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
129. MES-422694 SH LALIT KUMAR FGM (HS-II)S/O RAMBROSE
LAL C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
130. MES-483057 SHRI RAJENDRA KUMAR FGM(HS-II) S/O
CHHOTE LAL C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
131. MES-448751 SHRI DHARAM RAJ ELECTRICIAN (HS-II) S/O
AGNU PRASAD C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
132. MES-471502 SHRI PREM CHANDRA SRIVASTAVA FGM(HS-I)
S/O SHYAM NARAYAN C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
133. MES-471510 SHRI DHARMENDRA KUMAR SACHAN FGM(HS-
I) S/O KEDAR NATH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
Page 13 of 21
134. MES-425987 SHRI MANISH YADAV ELECTRICIAN (SK) S/O
SATYABHAN SINGH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
135. MES-425982 SHRI ANURAG SINGH KUSHWAHA
ELECTRICIAN (SK) S/O RAM NATH KUSHWAHA C/O
GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
136. MES-471354 SHRI SURESH KUMAR ELECTRICIAN (HS-II) S/O
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
RAM SHIVBARAN C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
137. MES-485940 SHRI SURESH SHAH ELECTRICIAN (HS-II) S/O
MUNDRIKA SHAH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
138. MES-483053 SHRI DAYA RAM FGM(HS-II) S/O PACCHU LAL
C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
139. MES-425974 SHRI PRAMWSHWAR KUMAR ELECTRICIAN
(SK) S/O BALIRAM SHAH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF)
E/M AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
140. MES-426526 SHRI SHASHANK SAURABH MATE (FGM) S/O
PADAM PANI C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
141. MES-427034 SHRI HONEY DUGGAL MATE (FGM) S/O SUNIL
KUMAR DUGGAL C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
142. MES-A-14596965L SHRI SHYAM PRAKASH MISHRA
ELECTRICIAN (HS-II) S/O KAMAL PRAKASH MISHR C/O
GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
143. MES-615528 SHRI VIKAS PAL VEHICLE MECHANIC (SK) S/O
SARVESH PAL C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
Page 14 of 21
144. MES-471505 SHRI SANJAY KUMAR BAJPAI ELECTRICIAN
(HS-I) S/O NAND LAL BAJPΑΙ C/O GARRISION ENGINEER
(AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
145. MES-168558 SHRI VED PRAKASH REF/MECH (HS-II) S/O
BABURAM C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
146. MES-483085 SHRI PARMESHWAR NATH VERMA POST -
REF/MECH (HS-II) S/O PARMATNA NAND VERMA C/O
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
147. MES-421624 SHRI GIRISH KUMAR ELECTRICIAN HS-I S/O
RAMNARAYAN SINGH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
148. MES-471365 SHRI SANDEEP VERMA ELECTRICIAN HS-II
S/OMANGAT RAM VERMA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF)
E/M AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
149. MES-448740 SHRI TEJ BAHADUR FGM HS-II S/O NANKAU
C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
150. MES-471368 SHRI KUMAR RAGHVENDRA CHAUHAN FGM
HS-II S/O SRIKRISHNA CHAUHAN C/O GARRISION
ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
151. MES-471366 SHRI AMIT KUMAR YADAV ELECTRICIAN SK
S/OPARAS YADAV C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
152. MES-471384 SHRI DHIRENDRA SINGH ELECTRICIAN SK S/O
LAXMI NARAYAN C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
153. MES-425994 SHRI ABHISHEK YADAV ELECTRICIAN SK S/O
NAVAB SINGH YADAV C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
154. MES-426415 SHRI AMIT KUMAR ELECTRICIAN SK S/O
GOVARDHAN PRASADC/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
Page 15 of 21
155. MES-426480 SHRI ARVIND KUMAR ELECTRICIAN SK S/O
AWADH RAJ C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
156. MES-426421 SHRI SHAMBHOO PRAJAPATI ELECTRICIAN SK
S/O SURESH PRAJAPATI C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF)
E/M AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
157. MES-425972 SHRI AJAY BAHADUR FGM SK S/O RAM KRIPAL
KUSHWAHA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
158. MES-452736 SHRI BALRAJ ELECTRICIAN HS-II S/O RAM
BAHADUR C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) E/M AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
159. MES-452775 SHRI RAM KEWAL MASON MCM S/O LATE
GANGA RAM C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
160. MES-452773 SHRI VISHRAM BABU CARPENTER MCM S/O
MOOLCHANDRA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
161. MES-315942 SHRI RAKESH PAL REF/MECH SK S/O SONEY
LAL PAL C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
162. MES-A14916877X SHRI SURESH PRATAP SINGH PIPE
FITTER SK S/O JAL RAM SINGH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER
(AF) B/R AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
163. MES-T-56 SHRI LAVEKUSH KUMAR PIPE FITTER SK S/O
SARJU PRASAD C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
164. MES-425995 SHRI GIRIJESH KUMAR PIPE FITTER SK S/O
NATHU RAM PAL C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
165. MES-475997 SHRI VAIBHAV DWIVEDI CARP SK S/O OM
PRAKASH DWIVEDI C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
Page 16 of 21
166. MES-425999 SHRI ARJUN KUMAR PIPE FITTER SK S/O RAM
LAL C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
167. MES-1494848 SHRI PRAMOD KUMAR PIPE FITTER SK S/O
OMKAR SINGH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
168. MES-1484606W SHRI RAM PRAKASH PIPE FITTER SK S/O
DEVI CHARAN C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
169. MES-426420 SHRI SHIVAM SAHU PIPE FITTER SK S/O RAJA
RAM C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
170. MES-426418 SHRI SUDEEP KUJUR MASON SK S/O ALBERT
KUJUR C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
171. MES-426419 SHRI HIMANSHU PIPE FITTER SK S/O
AMARJEET C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
172. MES-373335 SHRI BRIJ NARAYN MISHRA ELECTRICIAN HS-II
S/O JAGANNATH MISHRA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF)
B/R AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
173. MES-452781 SHRI SHAKIR ALI PIPE FITTER HS-II S/O FAHRI
ALAM C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
174. MES-483064 SHRI ANWAR SINGH FGM SK S/O PRITHVI PAL
C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
175. MES-483078 SMT KUSUM DEVI FGM SK W/O RAM CHANDRA
C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
176. MES-426414 SHRI AMBESH KUMAR VERMA ELECTRICIAN
SK S/O RAM CHANDRA VERMA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER
(AF) B/R AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
Page 17 of 21
177. MES-426416 SHRI SHAILENDRA SINGH CHAUHAN
ELECTRICIAN SK S/O SURENDRA SINGH CHAUHAN C/O
GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
178. MES-426424 SHRI ALOK RAV FGM SK S/O AVDHESH KUMAR
C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
179. MES-425992 SHRI ABHISHEK TIWARI FGM SK S/O RAJESH
PUNIT KUMAR
MISHRA
KUMAR C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE
STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
180. MES-426426 SHRI AMIT KUMAR GUPTA REF MECH SK S/O
AKSHAY KUMAR GUPTA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF)
B/R AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
181. MES-425993 SHRI RAJESH KUMAR SINGH REF MECH SK
S/O JANG BALI SINGH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
182. MES-426000 SHRI ASHUMENDRA PRATAP SINGH FGM SK
S/O RAM KINKAR SINGH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF)
B/R AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
183. MES-426474 SHRI ANKIT KUMAR MATE ELECTRICIAN S/O
ASHOK KUMAR C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
184. MES-426425 SHRI ASHISH KUMAR GUPTA MATE FGM S/O
ASHOK KUMAR GUPTA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
185. MES-426481 SHRI SHUBHAM SRIVASTAVA MATE FGM S/O
SHANKER LAL SRIVASTAVA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF)
B/R AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
186. MES-433627 SHRI ALOK KUMAR REF MECH SK S/O RAMFAL
C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR FORCE STATION
CHAKERI KANPUR
187. MES-471364 SHRI VIPIN KUMAR SINGH PIPE FITTER SK S/O
PREM NATH SINGH C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
Page 18 of 21
188. MES-426423 SHRI PANKAJ KUMAR YADAV FGM SK S/O
NAND LAL YADAV C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R AIR
FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
189. MES-425998 SHRI ANUBHAV SOORMA PIPE FITTER SK S/O
ANIL KUMAR SOORMA C/O GARRISION ENGINEER (AF) B/R
AIR FORCE STATION CHAKERI KANPUR
..Applicants
PUNIT KUMAR
By Advocate: Shri Ashish Srivastava
MISHRA
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary to Govt. of India, Ministry of
Defence, New Delhi-110011.
2. HQ Engineer-in-Chief, Ministry of Defence, Kashmir House, Rajaji
Marg, Army HQ, New Delhi.
3. HQ Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow.
4. HQ Chief Engineer, Lucknow Zone, Lucknow
5. HQ, Commander Works Engineer (AF), Air Force Chakeri
Station, Kanpur.
6. Principal Controller of Defence Accounts, (CC), Lucknow
.... Respondents
By Advocate: Shri Chakrapani Vatsyayan
ORDER
By Hon'ble Mr. Justice Rajiv Joshi, Member (Judicial):-
Heard Shri Ashish Srivastava, learned counsel for the applicants and Shri Chakrapani Vatsyayan, learned counsel for the respondents in both the cases and with the consent of both the parties, the cases are being disposed of at the admission stage itself.
2. Both the Original Applications under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunal Act, 1985 has been filed by the applicants, for direction to the respondents to allow Dress Allowances to the applicants for the year from 2017/18 to 2024-25 pursuant to the Government Orders issued in compliance to 7th Central Pay Commission dated 02.08.2017, 08.08.2017 and 01.08.2018 and in compliance of the various Courts orders and also compliance orders issued by various Page 19 of 21 Units under respondents @ Rs.5000/- per annum along with 12 % interest thereupon. Further, prayer has been made for a direction upon the respondents to refund the recovered amount of dress allowances paid to the applicant earlier along with 12 % interest thereupon and also to direct the respondents to keep on payment of annual dress allowance to all the applicants @ 5000/- per annum depending upon DA in future at the due time.
PUNIT KUMAR MISHRA
3. In para 4.1 of the Original Application No.260/2025, it is stated that applicant-1-3 are the representative of MES Workers Union, while the other applicants are working in the Military Engineer Services (MES) on various posts and they fall within the term 'Industrial Employees' and belong to Group -C post.
4. At the very outset, learned counsel for the applicants in both the cases submits that the applicants are entitled for dress allowance from 2017 onwards in terms of the O.M dated 02.08.2017 issued by Government of India, Ministry of Finance, Department of Expenditure and the order dated 05.06.2020 passed in OA No.60/1228/2019 by the Hon'ble CAT, Chandigarh Bench.
5. In support of the claim of the applicants, the learned counsel for the applicants cited the order dated 19.02.2020 passed by the Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal in OA No. 1228/2019 - MES No. 372437, Gurmit Singh & others Vs. Union of India & Ors wherein the applicants were held entitled for dress allowance pursuant to the aforesaid O.Ms dated 31.08.2017 and 02.08.2017. He further states that the Guwahati Bench of this Tribunal in Original Application No.59/2023, All Assam MES Employees Union vs. Union of India and others, has decided the identical controversy vide order dated 23.03.2023 at the admission stage and the respondents have also implemented the same vide order dated 31.07.2024.
6. Learned counsel for the applicants also contended that he will be satisfied if a direction is given to the Respondents to decide the claim of the applicants in the light of the order dated 19.02.2020 passed by the Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal in O.A No. 1228/2019 and the order dated 23.03.2023 passed by the Guwahati Bench of this Tribunal in Original Application No.59/2023.
Page 20 of 217. Per contra, Shri Chakrapani Vatsyayan, learned counsel for the respondents states that the applicants without representing the respondents, have directly approached this Tribunal and as such, both the Original Applications are liable to be dismissed. However, he further submits that issue involved in these Original Application has already been set at rest.
8. The record reflects that the applicants in both the Original Applications have directly approached this Tribunal regarding their PUNIT KUMAR MISHRA grievances without filing any representation before the respondents and as such, all the applicants are hereby directed to file a fresh representation annexing all the relevant documents on which they are relying on along with a copy of this order before the respondent concerned, within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. On receipt of such representation, the Competent Authority amongst the respondents is directed to take an appropriate decision on the representation of the applicants in the light of the order dated 19.02.2020 passed by the Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal in O.A. Nos. 1152/2022 & 1228/2019 as well as the order dated 23.03.2023 passed by the Guwahati Bench of this Tribunal in Original Application No.59/2023, by way of reasoned and speaking order under intimation to the applicants, in accordance with law, within a further period of four months.
9. It is made clear that the aforesaid order is confined to only those candidates, who have filed these Original Applications.
10. Further, it is made clear that this Court has not gone into the merits of the case.
11. With the aforesaid observation and direction, both the Original Application stand disposed of.
12. All pending MAs shall stand disposed of accordingly. No order as to costs.
(Anjani Nandan Sharan) (Justice Rajiv Joshi)
Member-A Member-J
Priydarshana/PM
Page 21 of 21