United India Insurance Co Ltd vs Sri Prakash P R S on 8 March, 2012

[Cites 0, Cited by 1]
Karnataka High Court

United India Insurance Co Ltd vs Sri Prakash P R S on 8 March, 2012

Equivalent citations: 2013 AAC 600 (KAR), 2013 (1) AIR KANT HCR 388, AIR 2013 (NOC) (SUPP) 566 (KAR.), (2013) 3 ACJ 1813

Bench: Dilip B.Bhosale, B.S.Indrakala

 

.7@

12%; "mg SEGH CGLER? a? K:%R§\E}'i'?§:§{A A'? Bgzaéggggag
§ﬁ;§'E§ 331$ mg 8?}: my Q? §;EARCE~§ 

FRESENT

THE 1=£OE\i'*BLE MR. JESTIQE mL:;P'3----  " *

ANJ
THE HOBFBLE MRS; ';.¥US'fIQE  %

MFA me, 98'?3,?iC§S§{1"£{'€C} E'£;'1?§" _ ' 

§4E°g.;e;fRC1B£*${}.--i3i§8/E§G?  »»»» 
MFA N0&§«8?3:''2SO6{M'VC'"' y'-' 1' ' .
BETVs/EEN V'  '

UNITED ;ND:.é;.,:N$URzmc£ ~::Q§ E§E'Df;, V
::H1CKM;s.G;ALL%;2,8R;;;~sé;:E£.jSFE~*:.::::  ' 
THROUGH His 'E?_}?ii;§1OI\?AL. GFETECE 

st; 25, 3§%A&s¥§A:?A1'\L%;?A3aé:?x:g;.BU:§;::mGS
§as£.{}.R:3AB, BP§'€{1'm.%£QRE35E¥QG€§E 
§E?,BY,:'§'E? §:EAN£§i'}f§iB;  LEZE{S§£Ev:FA?xEA;\E

 * V ' _ 1 ° _   A?P€:,L,sgx:?
53%' 8838 C '€~§%;E'§§;%Rsi;%:§%" Rag? §s.§"%f®C§§E"E§

 V'       ..... .. 'V

   ?\?§:§2"£{>:%i.'§3\§§#§ 9 E 3 3% Ram 223%
"  A@§:§} ssgf@{.}'§ 45:2 '::'§:g%§2.$
«A -..§:/A:':.'§x:Q%,';;e32§ 8'23 {ZERGEBSE 5:19 ?%2.%_§AR
' 2:: E:+?A;E:§¥:i, 5,;%;%EGé%E,§§E~?8

$22;  §§E£SH§%E'A g2a:§»§x.z:%* {§EL«E"§'E§}

A if "E3538 z%L§&A?*€ SAEEEE

' ~ -33% Eiéﬁiﬁ S923? E%§;%&{3R

REG?" §iE§L§E'ZE:R2?2 §§I€fri%EA§';%P£%TE\7.&

K}%§"i§R '§':%§£iE{

€f~§€§*{E\§A{:§E§LUR; QESYRESE"  §E$;?G§§§§§'§"§S
53%' SEE.  3%?/1';z'%£:'4i';E**£1i}R5'>;   {§§;}éjE'*«E§;§§(§J
;a:¥?§;:§33%{§ Fﬁﬁ E: E, z§:f§§E~§E;é

 

 



M3

mzs zxagg §a20.93':3;2@eg §*'::Ea {vs 3223:; GE'  2%C§'
A§é§NS'§ mg Jz;§G::€£r»:':' Mn gsmgs 99333: 3':,_55;gG@a
yassm gs: mic 3&0. :s?§,r2@<3: mg mg Egg 9%? 3*:i:::.'g:;§:;:%:.?-
JEESGE', {ZOEERT 0;? SMALL cazjggsg MEMsEg5;"§;::L;;%_

EVIE'TRC>FGi,IT§§3€ 333$? 8A_:x:GA:,aR£, {s:::cs;.:~a;«:};"i2_1_, egzxggégzznéiﬁfa " 
5% CC'%\s'I?ENSA'I§O§;¥ arr Rs.2,35;?&1§3;55a;~ E2'%2"2":'EE.:§?sf'?E;R;§::$':'_. "
we RA ms Rs.2,:3:,9§,:5g gaozw *:*:¥:§*°:; §:%5?§--:i3F:'P€§§i§§§:33"'§§LE,

E'2'%YMENT'

MFA.CRQB.NGa2§8 720$? V _ V
 > ..    .,  ' . . . 

PRAI{ASH5P.§:Sg 3x9 R:%J.'\kL3;  
AGES? ABQUT 35 YEARS,  ._ I
R/O 913,532, gm :::-Ross,-"" -- "
J.P.1\EAGéR, 1::  ._ 
BANGALaRE_;«.5a<:;0'7,s. .. ' _..-- g. ,

     _};..,a,€RﬁSS {')BJ13{':'"i'QR
[537 $R:A.:ag,, igégm E'<§§.R 533%" {3*BJE:'ZZ'Z%'@}"~i}

ANS : 
2 g UNEEVSBA zfaéaza :;=%siJ;3;{«3af{:5
€Q?s£{?}'«&'€':' :.:;::§T§:=3§ gggrgagz agmcg,
; *3"§-::3cagR:'»:~.5:gsLzx;§;A:,:3 B§;?§L§E?€Ga
 "7:.Rj'"_i_f'£\EQ. : 25;, 
 . C§*?EfET'E%z'E5';%_.i§Aii§§;§

    V 

-.,=:3;'<_;: ?;£§%': '§%;';%§E{z% S§E'1'E§éLR;§E&"L%§?~3~i
 LAEEEEE 1?'§,':Z}L§§§{
" EEG Sé ?é?£€?€£§
§*;i%;E}:i:ER *::.%:.m-;

w.   {i'3E§§E§:¥L~'§§,:%Li§R §E§f.i'§%{j§'E'.

 _   ..;é::,:5;a;:~; $331333, gm 2553223 338,

35$ EviE.,?LE§{E§E§,
f3?aK%é%E§1':'ﬁ§ATE'§;%, Eiﬁﬁﬁg '"§'"153L§§§*i,

C§*§E%§Eisi}2§:%£}.Z}'R1 mR§LS?%§'€§E';§€'§S

U «SB? 3%?' §,$.SE§'E'%§%._§éE;;Eé .%5%:£Z}; fai:¥'2f.? §'*ff}Ei SEE

 §§.Z§_2E5§'€E% 19333 {EEEEEER §}°'EZi'Z}§;§§;€}§§'}





'».arJ

}'?i*§§S §i«'EF£.CR€3E';k2§Sf2§G? IE2? META ?+3G.§S'?'3,§2€}§i'?3.__ ES
EELED {$59.4}: RULE 22 5}? CPS é'aG;%§E'*€S'§' 'EH2 Ji?DGMEN'i'..E%;§{}3

32:63:33) Qé:i"EE?::3_1.{i§.3é3Q:E>' PASSES 32:; zss§2a::,:a:@W;s:75;2§{::':."'a:i;x.,
-mg. FIELE 0? mg CHIEF' 359%, C<}i§R'.i' 0? SMAL§,WC;%f§8§f3;-V 

MEMBEER, PRL,  Ma*:Ra?@;:'?AN éggg,   '
gsccH.:x:04:;, PAR'£L);'" §:LEJ§'%EJING Tz»£g}»AA§:,A:§:r:.«::é:~:*:*'§f;':f3:%@w. $9233:
COMPENSATEON Emir; SEEKING  E:\:V2Aiés2%z;:E;§s;:E:::_*%$  ':23 

CQMPENSATYQN.

TEES MFA 5;: i\:i"EA'CE€€}SS ":i:§;z~:~"s;<:'s'z0§:'\::§V'<:1<}:s§sNC;'V._;{}za.:V~Vgin?

§iEARiNG mis ms: THE. CQURT a§::J:i;*:«:R'E;:> T:§§;€«%::;§L:§:>v:N;3;

wggmsmr {DILE 3., 3:3x§§i*--:.A,L1::§J;;' ; "=-

"%"h§s ¥'v§E3c§§§.&§§92e%_:3:.:3i;  mi §€3SL§%'3§'2€€
Camgany is  am Qrder

datsé 31..;'5;'2*3?G;€%'1.5%:-c§--e%e%§AV"'-%3y f§éé §'3:'%, Meter fasﬁéerzts

Ciaéms '§'%§"'Qs.:§'2§§ 'a:fi§ {:§?%§Ef._§i.s-si§§;%::, Cssgrt Q5' Emaif Causes at

Sgrggaiere - _%'=a§{.;--._iS~~? 'Vé,fZﬁG:g 83; iﬁe §§'§2§i,i§¥'%€§

 ..-';'%;;ég§?f:é';<::5 C%a%'::'7:'2*§:>~e?:'%'%a:§{;~;'2 ffigﬁ' §35_§'ES§C¥5?§§{Ei*C§3i§'}'%ai"§i

~»

§f{}?';b. §§"§{}A?§?._ §'§i?E'§ !V'i:§§§§'§"?§3%1f:} ﬁgs baegz §§§i§':«!¥E§ $52 gart

  §:;:£a'?;§§:'§ ar:;éi':jf2_%:.:;i:e§":§§%§§§% Q? Rs22f3;E;?$;§:E§.§Q §$§§?§";€%'

 :!€§;§°': cgsiig  3':§'_t§ §§?i"%?€§§ at §%!%;; gag" amam $9 3% éméﬁﬁi :33'
   f;;::%g~:;'V;»;2%;ki35[g;;,A.%25§.§a aa afies" ::i§§a§{:t§§'s§ §s,3,8%.{E§§;'--;,
 ___3aés::a§*s§§e§ étwgggﬁg atésaéaai £§'i§f§§§; fmm 32% 53:8 $2' the

u;£aa%§f::§a:": $3 $28 zfgfae Q5 agiugi §a*gm§§2%: ,2' éﬁmagéif aggmgi

 



 m w<v«v»«xnwA-\$M%»»<>I.M\V\\4S\VM'M

W1 'n

528 5§§€§§§§"it~§§'3§§..i¥'3ﬁ€§ Csm§a:2y {€35 smrt _...f:%:e

a§§3e§EanE"} and respariéent H33 jeérzify am aeveraf-§§f;--~: j _: '»,

2. Tfze ciaémant whs wag 35 years aid féi}év.ﬁ:2:L:"  
time, was Semis? Speciaiist -~ S.;§ftvg_;a :*e;,"A.[:{1:d:f§<£ré§~V, ér%;f?§h .A

Erisssan Cammunécaiians Indfa. ;_Pvt. L't;2f;"ané :s§§a3':AV»§r§:-géttingg 3

saéary :3? Rsg:,;48;2§3.,i~ per m§§'£'§i: Q§   abeui:
:Q,3Q gm. he was  femps  fmm

Eakharayaﬁatna ta Kaéur gﬂa-tAe,.   ;;3*§-§V§¢'g'€:%§fé._,'--V*'t§1e driver 3?

the Temgs T532: '::3§'§§§s'e the ::jsaf:né"in  ";%"'rra.:h and aegiigen:

manner arsé i%zhe;;9:'é:§§é'2éfeff§?zi§'§:. .:fea€hé»_Vd°::ear Lakshmiguram
0:: £h§ci<zj'r*:'a g7a'§z;s.t}f.~§f§<é»§f§'i:r._{éaé,. itgfammeé mtg g tree. As a
yasagéi gf f§<'aéémggzgtg?:§~":é"g§.§§§t§::2::e:" §:;$§a§:3§§ éajasragﬂ ﬁe

was i:3":mad§&ié%3zV_"a-é:f%:éiiés:;§ 33 €3SV&?':3{"2§€f';§E ﬁaggétaf, Kaésg

  :.i:;;:.:»%~¢§a§*:§§a§H§%§§§§t§L, aargggiare gm tﬁereafiégg he

é!¥'C%§_§53_??j2.Ef éasgggiéaig if: Eaagafmeg §"§€ aigfms

  Rgéiﬁﬁfﬁﬁﬁj- tiéé fiéiﬁg sf §§?€ Qéiitiéﬁ
.:_ :' _.§§Eﬁ{§%'§S1§§%§1§€§§ E§"&§§'§"'£"§Ei'§E. ﬁe %'::z"§';§'?ez* céaims, the igzjasrigg
}   §?§§"':'§ $5": ihé gsaiéésé :*e:'2d§?€ﬂ %:%§":': garmaaéniiy
 argé ma? affagigﬁ mm §;":e§"::a§§§z am f%§§a;:£§a¥§§:,

._.,_.,__§:~§;3;*z£%; §'%& ﬂies we gigém ﬁétitiﬁﬁ §§§:§<%§*:§ ggmgeézggiéan 0%"

. .,.m....W....VW.-»aaa«.s4~v~»w



gaying Q§SS§§"%§€f"_, he :3 mi e:"%E§'£E§§é fa: any :;'Q§?'%§€¥'ES8{§S%"E

53 grayed, £5: szgpgatt at}? éhés C$f'1§E¥'§§§§f'} he i€7\;%:ae.g§V'T'~s:3;'{;::f_
attantim :5 éthe {Erma arid €€)f":dE§:§QI'§S af %:t1e___.§_::i§é;«»;='a:-;2:§§eVf--V___"_
gsiécy Le Private Car 3' ?0§§€§; wffzfch :::_*;£*e::"a.{j§f§»é'~.::. %;--%}e 

%:2§:;:'e§ in the event 8% an aC€iéent9.:au:3'es;£§ §*;t.}=..e'%- a%iV§§~i--::_1g}=::V_ *

wt 5? a use sf migtsr car aéga_§nst 9.§§

giaimmts Qests 8§'§§ éxmnses i%izi;;;i;:i*s.V_V_t§*¥'.é,$"  shaii
éecame éegaiiy iiabéé m" ar mdiigs
észjury ts any ;3er:s:'2,:'§ E:"*:C:i_:..,:«<:,.*5§.s.?é_gj if; metar
can previded.:éé'%r§eﬁ fer hire 9:'
rewaré b;;:__Vg%:é's$ar3i ta meet the
req:;%§emé:nt__ 3383 (5%? Shﬂft 'the

ﬁa£€"}§ 'they s=§¥'f: 3§~i rig: §'§:{'i§%§'§.a§"y§hatﬁér 3:233"; éegth gr §§"§ji.j§°'3:'

a?§$€S'§'$*'i;§5§.Z-34?? a;':*:'§_V_€%:": iiéés §.:@§,§§'SE gs' ampfaigmggzi sf 3135?:

V"'~.§é%:'::;_§§'ir§"'%jA§*:s§:';':*2ga:§°§§s ﬁe aigg §§'§%£§i§§ S33? aiiereiésa Eé 237%

{:§7§;t.§§=-?'§:{é?:é§:'2+af{§§§v:-"" 9%' $313 iéaiméné Ea Si.§§g:'5G%'€ 9? §§'"'§§S

V' _::@§:t§%;'i:%$::._;" -.--$'*§£@::é§3;;, ﬁg Qhaﬁegzgeé tfég qgaaizgm 5:2'
H"" '::§':';2§%.:'¥s§%:éea §:I%?§f€§§é in §eg§e£i G? s:Ea%:':': éaé ciésaéééity 5'
 §.::§'£§'f~%':;::g:e éazcsma, issg :3? eammg éagrérzg {ha §%:*é§§ sf

 :'_4%::[-éaéamegzi 351$ éawasﬁg the §§§§ af fuiuég graegggiigz Ea

' 5:; :*2:::gf'"  Cijs::?.¥_:sV§ Eéig %



 

aiha? rxsgrés he déé mi ihaﬁeage téze §§%'EQ:i§'?§S $1'?

:':GE'?'3§E%"%Sat%§¥'2 awggééd amﬁer athe? heaégg

5; Férsiéyz, we wsuiﬁ iéke tg ﬂea? §*'*J§§§'} '§§"'%€  H

3:' iearned ééunsei far the 3i3§3€§§3E?'Em§;'S'§.?Z=if§'§'F?§_:«.%§§;:':.¥_§'§i%:,v"'-$1: 

Size érzsurer ﬁg gay C0mper:fs;'»§__ti13_:é 3.3-. "g:r:3:§?x=:-'§,--..AV"

Me: Seetharam Rae, Eeameé g:Q'~;.:';§i;<;e§ fa}v--i:.?éeV..§';f;§é:¥:§és'itsat

ihe Gzﬁtsei: invited 91;: a*£:'i:-':§j:%z2;z:,:é5"s:é_}:£:§é';':..(%%j §?"T:f'E3e"?r§va'£e

«:'1&E?. ::'§ the $6: is

.1.

Ca? 'E' 995$}: and se:té§%':T$' 
Caﬁiemé tiiai the <:§a§;s_-333$; w;a"$_T,a fa%?éL"_g3a;.?§:%Vjg Vvgagsenger ané

hence és nets"é0'%€e%é'{i3'«.__%ég'-.f%;;...§'=§§%_iC'€,~ In §{i;}pC::"i: sf this

cayéfeﬁiim'  §::\)Ef%;§~d "yafagr é*:i€i'IV"é§C§§§'E is iﬁe :s*§5s~«
exam§nat§'Q_n'§;_f iiwé c.§.'§.5.:V'e'§';?;§V2':A.-._§f%*:$ reiaxsazéi: gegiian to which

's

em' ai':e;'sti§§1"a-2:533 S§:éc%?~§.Ca§i--"§V é?a::xz;":; réaﬁs $2255:

._f°€;i3r:3>_.i::%:s3,%_éaiééf------a:€%&e:3E E had §$%%"% if; %-éaggga
'~a;::d_ '«.fz'f,_§1m_ ﬁassan I had baa": is

'5'§:%§:E2§'g?.a3n<é';;;»:'%;:"2& té méei my frieadg ;?m§i:é

 ..%.:__ias§a~ré_VL'4j'.£:5a:',é Sa%<%<ara3za§§tn§ E xasenét $35 $1.13

V %ﬁ:%%iv%'é';. ?"ET:¥.ii'TE§E?§ frgm Sgkéégrayggatxa E £a;ma
AA ':3; ﬁégg Siam a§":'}:.z:§§ §.3§m*:":. 33 bagseg '$562'?
 ":":*§§ aasaiiasée iencg E haameé we iemag irax
SE guestiea, Ea aha 232$ iemga irax aggﬁ fmm
§§'§ii€%' Eéiera aré E7 Gihés :s'§':a€§€:*s2 Fygm

§§§<§<ar&§a§§':m3 Tia §%<Za§¥;;i:;:' E wag §fQC§€§§%'%§ 



the said vehéﬁe, The saié temgg tax was
siatiaszed aéjacérzi: :52 we Siaﬁé. Eefarg

accident driver 0?' the iermo {tax éid 

€$i§8Ci any fare fram me. Befsre Ceiéectinﬁ 

fare the accident is auesticsn tggk s¥a§:'é;"v'~i:";:*§<3 "'~ 
ncsi: know who was the awner  t%:'é4Tisjz:i'r;€T>téé:f.¥'z'{§<5-., ~.. _' 
tray: as an the date :31' the  O ':f:_%A_A*»::m=:'~ V' K
ﬁate 0? accident I was n'<J{'k.r§ow§%'n:1__':ihe s§aﬁié" 
anti address sf 'the dr§\:er"4_L:<§'f. ti":;e[ séEé«--.é§m 
::;ag<4 2% is true {hv'é§'V:;n Ef'A:.E:_§ ai;-T-.*:.§?g§C€%ﬁé%i%I

was met famiéiar e§t§'ié;.i_"%v§'f'§§V"'t§ie__.§iVrE.%3:e%:2? with

the owner Q_f:ih__e sa:§'d  V': 'e':;:?é::;:s*,;:'*:«:.*?g><V_§"'VV¥ ~ 

.,   isijippfied}
in the Eight $12'-~..tféé:"';§é:;°§f§'s§EV§:;:.'s'~ by the ciaimaziif he
szgbméiteii  :§f's4i? §}v£3:_S'S;t§ﬁ€}{ in the ﬂight at abmgt

§,3§gm ::§éa:fi§?%+3%':'G:m:é"'v§%;i34{"*':§f§éV cfaimazzt éié mi have any

§:'r5§*:§3€r:":;':::§:2: is "::3i.»*§E 5:2 ﬁés éesiéaatésn am §§%?£% $233

1"._§:§:;;i:%§§"§:%*a;%:§;*;::$§5:;} wag :23: avaiaﬁée he mgméﬁ gm ?:""€:3":§§

"§rg%:'é::_ =:§;;e§'?:'.§v§:?:f."_'~--§§@;":g zsaséﬂ': 2% aiaimgsi E?'€§%"E 'mess five

 ':§'E%3€?ﬁVii:-§:'$%:}::?:3.A-Q we 'ifgmgs "%":*a3<§ Re 5% :29: §<§°:a:::22; She
Q?'  aaasrzar :::r §§"%8 ﬁréver Qf iéée iemgs '%":a::§g This
 vgiih gm a§§"ﬁ§§S§§¥"'§S giazar: *5}; {$38 giaémami
 ' _f;%;ai--it?1e dates" <3? 31% Temm ﬂax ﬁéd {mi csséiegt any fare

 him aaé :53: §€'§§§'"€ C€:§§€€i§§'%§ fags ?f§'§€ agaééam:



sQ:::;:':*§é,, aacerﬁirsg is ieameé cgungei fer the aggeiégrzi,

c%ear%3: Shaw that he was imaeiiéng if: ihe "§'emg3G 

fare paying gassenger, in view thegeef as 

and canditioas cf the Qaiicy ihe giaimgrst $5  u 

{she ccmpensatiert as grayeé ii: the $5.3é:r:_-«~-A;'s§?:%'§€:TQ§:«;..'   

?. 8:: the Gthéf ham 

ieameé senigr iaamseiV.&§3§ea;:§'§*:'§'f§..é:f* i;:§':$ c§a§§:*:a*:*é€ fafyéy
sésbmiiied that we sees? sééi%;_' e,ié%z'-ié;§1':*:"'imtg'-éa 'é::s:..2s,ique$i:§er":

whether fare gayéag '_§asS,_énge§:=is-.e%§:E:§e<:2 if-:2? mmgensatéars

am} 5 :3: £3 €£*--Ji.,.é'e:*a§§'%:i3}l._s::aﬁijf-..g;%§§.E:§f: 35:§;§V.«§ée gubmétted that if

an fa:t§ if"€%';e._:€:asé'€15"-§§"'é"2§'%d_§§ééE"i;§%e éiaimarit was a faré

gayiszg §*a;sée§9:ég€§§".§*:'a%%V;§e: bg Eniitﬁeé far any

mmpeasati@::'"--«..as._§rag$é'~~--"ér: azigsaz G? the teyms am

.__:he"'§§'§i--€;';' ﬁe asweverg suémétieﬁ "mat sa
 siaéazi that 33% c%a§m5z§i wag g ﬁrs

   iéze Teams Yrgxa %-$3 szﬁsméiieég frsm
 a:j:::é%~$%,'::>::"§%xza§: $3' 32% céaémant éitggif £3 $3 $335? Sm: ?"§€
  §a§§ gm: fag ﬁg am érixser 9? we 'fémgg T:*a§:.
 2:??? §?§'af§§' Sf Em Yemga "Rag 258$ %$ $33: hég

'V'"~...___' j%;§h%:§a as g garzégzgéar rgasie 3g 3 iaxi {SEE £335 :35 rawgrzé 3;



R
V.

ii?

charging fare fram Si§'§§"°%g€§'S ég mi}: asiaéﬁsézeﬁ ay.-._:§*':e

aggeifafst. He {hers suémitteé Eha: the best 
<:e:.s§é haxse staéeé whetéaer Eﬁsa ?'"em§s Tray: érféqfér  "

iafisci fare frsm {he paﬁsﬁgers wagwsiihesf' d:f9E§£e>$f'451§%¥:sia%}f'L'- 

GE' GWREE' sf ihe vehicfe at any Qthef'paI§:éér:gé:* _g%s§--*:Q_' ;«:é$"'§:::: "'

{ﬁe véhicfe at ihe reéevant :§}i:f_z:é'~-...a_r:§  s§.:i3:_s:g>...€?"r§ '}Eé§1§'E'§:ér:t

§a:'§eé £3 sxaméizg am: svgsh :««;§At:?:<=:':sTs.2..'g;j: §:2fé:*gr:.ce»ér: {he
Sasés ef the gaié admiSs§"e:§;§----.g§--a:_é§_}b§9'fifssiéaimant is the

crass ~examiﬁatio§s--»:a§m:;E ' V'

5:12 in ::§iew.:~5f>.i§€é*--'.'::;:'b~§§V:§S}s'i--e5:s :}f"£earr:ed ceungei 59:"
$33 §5rié§%Vé§5z§eTA»3§:eV :€§%j:5'a3>;'§;<éz;3§::'g_ the issase/quesiian as its
asmeiféer  fare §%VVa'§:~%§fg::;"';3.§::='.£:3'§'zger £3 3 grévaig \z€?2%z:§e

having f?;;fv§2:a§é"~£géVr'~'?;S'--'*' gaiiéfﬁz xfg entitieé 2%? £s§:'s§&r:sai§z3:2,

§'.'§;§%"€§é'3i§3€;?.. -»?%'¥f§*:"»£:iA§ s*€:?$3"%'f?:i'f§ fﬁi' :53 Ea sxamiyéa $5 {$23 fgstaéai

;**%:::a;7::§:;-:_ »v:é«.f§'§':§ Gas: 'ei?§?E§§"%€? tééa gtiaimazﬁ wag fag

Q   ga:/§§é':.;g__ §§g$.%%éi§§:~i% agéﬁiax" Wﬁéiﬁéf iése a§§€:%%a:':t grsxsed $53
 %;%&§és"':.:%§__%§*zE e'«»x§ées':s:e $23: 328 ciaimamé wag fag §%'§i'"§§

L  -;aa:§'ge;f:§'é':* in {§'':% E"e;?:§@ "ﬂax,

  Er: ﬁza Cigém §€iI§i§ﬁ§'§ €338 géaimané: ﬁaﬁ gtgteé éééaé'

 é$%%2e:2 as gay? %:%2% ?§s"§3;s§ "?:*§;<; ééa sfauzzzé 3:525: {jéééiﬁié $5



;}€'€}§§€ W€?'§ iaikmg £3 ting aréves am were a5i<%€zg_..__§:§m

¥%2'§'%€'€§'}E§' they an E8 émgﬁeé ﬂea Kadzzr gate aj':é'§:.f"L:h"*.

ﬁréxzer saéé 'yes', Eésthéng fartﬁér was staiesﬁ  "
ac: %:a§£<: abeggt fag? :6 ba saéé ta the _d»ré»aas:  V'

Ever; 3:': the examinaiésn-énvchief §§7e* ::£a"§mér2:A"szégeé'

gtaie anything abaui fare §e§ié[g:"'f§::§e€i %;rajvé.$:§iE:.g§":':':' {he

"§'€m§a Trax, ....... ..

In the cras$-exam%'f:a€§s:%:;__5%_ivs:é:::é:'::~i.f'te%'c:re accident

téze éﬂver of the fenﬁpe f'é*'a':-<:'  fare frsm
him and thaig   csiiecting the
farei  in {he C§"'C¥S$;w
exam§:°aaf§§r:._adm§s3§0n sash as; ?:he

€§5§¥?3&§":f d§§'v-..§**;::i::%:*_Eé%;:§§~4g..:%:e:"_.'*ﬁ:*iz»'e: am ighs swag: of érhe

_ "%"ar::§§._%f '"'§":°A;%>:,,  fsgie sasmert ihs apgééiaafs

*-£§:%;{'s§.s;%§i:;r: ;,'~%i%:«% :;:.:;_&$€§@n Es W§"'§S§§'°'£€i'" the §i1§§"}"i§§S§Qi"i§ azvgaiié

b€ ':--:a:Vf§§:;.§§%é§%%:::__ §g§§é2:; 3 aﬁeférgééa §§*%§E§"€%'?£€ ihat 2:'??? géaémani

"1; ézgg §5%%;é§s:Vy§?*:'§. aaggenger if: ma "éémgg Tax,
"   ..§i§e $993243 §G%'§% Ehfeagh 533% €?£%SS~€X§f?%§§"E§%§§?% Q? ':§2€

 2:;§Aa§é:Vé;5":é€§ E: ia mi gag: f;*§§'§: We €f€3SS~SX§{'%'E§?'%§§;§€}§"§ a3 is

 W<,:~;?%zéé '%£%S«§§ ma gzsggtiziar: ﬁiéf {Q ifae wiissegg 3?: the £f§$§*

 $x3m%2§é%§ag $9 e§§«::':'§ 3&3 afgregaéé aﬁmégsims; "'%'§2r2 férgé



aﬁmissign rzameiy "' 3353:? ECCESESE shiver $5 the Taifage

Trgrsq diﬁ mft CG§§$C§ gm! fare fmm him; £%ear§g 3§7<.:I§%}'§~:.f:'§jé':_4
as faré wag mid ﬁg; 'she cﬁaémani. Tézig 3dmi3rg§"én; "

in éssiatien, is met sufficient ta dra;<vwa.r:4 %nféfef§<:Te§I.'?;hV$t._jE':5e'"-.

wag Sif§QQSE§ is pay fare :3 the §r§'arer;:':A:';€§§ 

an énference gar: afsa be é';*a_fw,r.; Qr: "~i:£f3e.__§a;3ié=. {3'§'~thés

8ijfT'1§SS§§!'§ that since he was ne:..s;§'p;3'0"$;e;:'§ t§"§:::v3{.a:'§y fargi

the érévér éicf net €G§§€i;;i': f3?€___  _ "ﬂue next
admigsiorz rzameiy *'bgfore~"éé'i§--é:é;ti§f:'g,}:h§e' §ias:«é= é'he &cc%d€n*; Er:
questian teak   was suggesed :0 gay

the fare b:;;:_VV§t"'"smji*':;  it is as: ﬂags' 33 ﬁe
what qz:é;=__sté<;;2-  witness is éfiiiiéi this

adrreésséan frimf: +e°:§:"z:7;' _§:; §S" §§é:'é.:3s§bié that ting aagsiées gag: is

3% w§:4;3%3S§§.w§§  if £€3%"§'$C'§ that 353% assééem QCC§,fE"§"§§

' V.e;wg§;_ra~&§é'fé3'v%£%:.i%é~,f$:"e wag caiiegieﬁi am in sziew sf §'E§S

§:*:§§:;§'%.__§:2 %§é?é".v.a f'i%%%§%§§éve {ha agar? re:.:$:"§eé $325 aferesaﬁ

 V g_dm§337§"e:%:f:. '-. §§';;€§§§r%3; it is gagsiéig iézaé: ibé guggiéen gas? :3
" éf%*z§ ';éi§:f;esé'°wag "ﬁg £2: ::§2":*e<:: iééai: aver: §eif§:'& miieaiéag

 §;_§&~§7€"V.if"§§  agaiéeet §r: §%.§€S'€§§?"% task gfgcéi Sénae éfée

  --.§:"é§':»;é1%:' was is iﬁa gffirmaéizza saga aémégsisn wag

 '=_ :9é£@a*§eé by ﬁg §§§§"§'é€§ Easége; 'Eééggé §if%§€§§?%$;

 2/x/mz/.mm,,,,,,.wH....m.--w« -A « «



E3

ereeepeeeeg ihei {ere was ie ee eeie, eéeweeerf we eeenet

aseeeee eithee in feeeea" ea' éﬁe eepeﬁené: er the 
Er: em; eeee; it ﬁe net eeee§e¥e,. se£e%y en the  "
efereeafd eemiesiee - (§,e, befe:fe....,;e§ie_C%§f2§'Ae..faz?e ._'_:~§%7ee'..V V'

accident in qzsestiee teak eiace} §e:":5,§re?;§;%: ~:--:r2 [§'ef:ere'r:ee"~.§§*:eAf"C.

the reeeendent efaimeet was  ?e;'e
eedfer had boarded :he:__TemeeA__%§%VEe§<_'after.heegetiﬁieg fare
fer tzavefféeg frem Sa£<%§»a"re'gza::£&a_};:%:a_;'ee"é{;zi§§a..;:_ He eoes :20:
state, befere coi§.ec_'_cE;:g,"fa're eeeéeeet 5:':
euestien iieeaneet be statee
wet the  that time éréxier sf

°§"em,ee T':f_e><._;2se§"%:e.._e§'=;_?é%::eV:A\;:'e§f;§<:E'e ee 5 tax? / eézereéng fare

free": eeese:2~:;;'ersV em? '7i§§'e?::%}e4efe§mee§ bee eegeiéeiee fare

V with  eee ae7e3..V_eeeeeeee Se gee fare ee tee erieere if

  eeeeeeei ﬁe eeeeeee eéthee éee eeeer ef

eefgeepe %§'~;fe_'><~:je1':*. {fee eaeee?' ef iee "';§'e:'*eee '"?:"e>< ee eee ef'

 iee ee"eeee:ee:e étreeeiéiee iherem eieeg eee ﬁne eieeeeei
 feeeee eeeeeet eeree eihez" eeéeeeee ee reeere
 eeje*'e"e:t zeee eeee met the eréver eee the eaeee? e? we

[' --:'.4f§"e'meee 'ﬂee were eigxiee 2% er: e eereeeier meée ee %:e><:' aee

 Eézei ewe eieeeeee zeee izeeeeéee in Eee eeée eefeeée es e

 /rxx/zmz/m,,,"MMwn'-'w-.mA



2 4

fare gayéng pasgeréger. ivfereiy became he haé St5te§_.__%:§2a:

$15 ﬁiﬁ as: knsw éhe 3232523: as tfm §§'%'ss'€§' 23:" %:%*:e%§'.:j';";Va:§'_':3Vé§;~:,A'

§Q€S €29': necessariiig mean that he was i;*av§§é'§E---mg:&§§2 "§;--b.é'*1--[ '

Tempe "§'.:*a:x: as a fare~§ayE;":g §as:_es:.g_e :; _'?§ é" 

§£"3§U§t§Li§ ?§SSei"?Q8?" in the veh£cééL--.  1:§'[:*%'§e €:§r1::{':,::*ff:::ié;ai";?';L};:g7gf'v--T:,

we have m heaiiatian in 
ée graze that the Ciaénﬁant ' §'r:- :_hg §'¥'emge
Trax at tksé §'"€§$Va¥"1i f;§;"':":;e"'*':»;§:;4a' §A1;a.f§3.,';;;éi4§2%ﬁ:g:'9é;;assenger.

1%' T?;at€.vi5 !%'e:}.3 Jguﬁmissisn cf
§§amed   wmpensatien
awaféeéiv'b";?""*:§*:§if side gag aeeés :9
Se :°eéL:::::§é;r.r.i.: . E9.V¢§:'éi'j§:%f §:§:':A"a:§§reg§3:E me gizérﬁésséers sf

igamed' £%£,§%'§Si%§ -?5<;}§'f- if§"2é" §ar2:*%$§, we re-§{@§;s£s {ﬁg

'5«E3:°:G§:vs*:}%§ {§Di';:i}§j?'§§;"3%§";:S§'E'$%3'§: ﬁiéfﬁfdéﬁ 3,3315%?" défféféﬁf ééeaés.
:.4'a*;§5_:ée§ §§:§.;§Q;$§Q;"~ tagaiarés @337: and
  g:;ff.e?§'_:§§;  §.ff"3§'%£§S?i3§%G§'"E €?'§§f§E§;
 §::§db:a§ €:;<3an§§s; §'%i§g33;2G§;'-- ﬁg: §§":€
 éﬁﬁiéfféé ¥z%'§'E§§€ $928 éaémam wag in haggitaig
 £3: E329 $933 af §§22:§§"%"¥$ éwéag iyéaimeaég

'»-...,»,,l§;§,Z;@$§:§§28Sg'- fa' 331$ éiggbéiéiy / $5333 3? faszazras magma;



Rg.3_,84;i?S§;- tawardg atégsﬁaat charges; §;:,S§;:'f:GS;'~ far

fastuse mediéai EX§%%"'§§€S; am §,s.2G,.G:;§28.S£3 far ::%3.,é_ -i.§§s

sf fssizgre gmspetgtsf making the tom? gem§§.réV§é§i'§§}~--:_y_§£2_:_".

R3.2;35,?'8,1S§.SQ.

11, Learned seunseé fa: the a;§§1;:s3§»fa§§i su>:b'V:_%§;f§A§»fEve<i 

he has §E'!S*€?'UC'€§§E"iS to sear; re{ii2.§if:i'e.2n tﬁe
Campensaticn awarﬁeé, .§_§'s §"e§'pé?i:§  §€  t§2:e ""€;%a'§%:"r: fa:
disabifity f 3353 3?' fziiigé   éuriﬁg
iseaimentg and  ::~f   §Eroﬁ§%%':j§s§VV,v:;_"V§fj§<:;wever, ii'? View
9? the cressg' séaémaszt seeking

enhar%€err:E%r:'i----._§f cé:§ff:*s"§e§:$§'tiGag""afszé weuﬁd aisa iike is

cansééer V':5;h'§§4t'her 5éé':'~.es3.§%s.:3é:;én's&s':5: Q? the amesmis sf

wasgeﬁga%:§a%i"'--§wa;iée§d 7::¢"':é§'§9 athey ﬁgaés $3 aeégggary.

 'T12,  $$§§%*s§§"ama Rag: éegraeé ammgeé §S%'

{his3-§;p.és'§;:%ﬁ«i: _a%E '»i:*?é€ guise: isévétaé gm" aiiggétieyz $3 {ha

M '%';:rass~4';31as§fe§  mg Cﬁaxi "gazes 2?.S,2G§8 zézézgréﬁy ﬁg

H"'7' '¢::§a:-::'}§_§'3%: @533 §§f'€C'€€§ ia géage sf: ragga €33 énmme tax

 _é"%§:%E{:§--A"é§§%e§ ﬁefare 3523 gas; E":?E% acaiéeaf. Raiévgsi

V[ ' _§.§:3»rii5Gn $5 the grim' éaieé E?§832§§8 reaég thug:



W WW....W«



E6

"E.é,?é§,EE;'€3? E33 ﬁeers féisﬁ ﬁg; i:%":e,.._

aggefiaséi with a sragser E3 ﬁéreci ré§;";G:":ﬂe=_f2"'sE--:: "- '*.
N0': is Sis mg insgms Tax returrss periaé-ﬁéggqi"~7f"'*~ 
:3 the yegz' zggwaas  th.é.H §é%§e;::fi"'   A

sumegizeni ta 23%-2:233 ﬂied; ;:%}g; 

ihe Encame Tax Auther§tEé_V"s'*,---._ 
Gr: {iG§'?$§d€§'§§§GF"3  %I7;g/§Ca,f€.i£s..;§L
we ﬁeem if fit asﬁ"'-;f;}'§g3e«r__.13?'gfE'4%é{j§: §e5§©nd€n%
fafeﬁi {:0 fiie h»i.s'§ncQ.:*':':'e tVé3:;<  
Sf;    Caz; ns§§
 arse aageek
a:'i:é;%r  éfé the Eeamsa
§Z{3L§ r'§:§€.¥_:%e:r ::f*2'§ 
 3:?H:§f'§§"§"A.€:§5h§;§§'¥§"§;"§€CC¥E'§§§'ig§'§i' ﬁieé gffiéavéi ﬁ§§§§§

._E§§.;f§§""E%:E%§i§': §§'3£::"'f:%'§":€ Egg rsiasmg  i??§%

  :§@2«§3 is zagsaa "F%':e;*&§f:§;:. he
 §§a':s:&§% :f@§:?":e EEK :e%;:m*:§ {$5 $26 agggggmgai §€§¥'
}  §§{3¥"%§ wéiéz 3'23 mamas siataé 2:§g§.2Q€%8. §:2{:§m%
 séaimaﬁi fa: iézege yegrgf 53 disaieseé ié she Smeme

 Qﬁﬁéfiﬁéﬁﬁig §§ $53 agszgﬁar:



<:a§§<:§:=;;.;k "was Qaézxii-§; §ffe{L':e§ Er: azzéw ﬁf {ha §££§§e:2*::' ané

 gmggacfg. §%E gmbmfitaﬁ that a garage

'V'<:§%§:::a"é€%',. :;sg{ua:g:.--.""';~;g:i ééifﬁagééf bzgigigcgeageé aftar the
   Siﬁfiéﬁ eamézeg mag iééaﬁ aé3:.:§s'§ §§'§§ iizssme
 ""§év;27T::E"€§<af§:*e 5% a€$§§§:'*:'%: as am gmgésyae sf? EFECSSQQ
 : 1::fS;*":é'§z::;§:%€ai%a:3g Eréﬁéa @232; am. En fgzég E15 gsgbméiteﬁ,

x?:§e:fz3:'§ €535 §C€§§§§"E§ §"'§E $553 geiiéiég 33%;; §§Z>{%'f§ ggfary aazd

1 ;$S$8SSm§E'1?.: 3 E%'§CG%"E'E€ fswsm Ersgsme f:"s:':': ﬁmss 'ﬁzsiai  "%"ax paéé
Vaar 5 Saiary Gther Eﬂcome {R3}  ' '
' ﬁsurces  "

§.§§9~GG §,€}§,.§?5;;'- ,, 

'E  ~.

2s:>s:;@~a: :3;s4;9S3;'-» 3:,7:;?;~ ::3¢,.tse,;';:§§%s,:§5'T'V  §;ea,g§§2'}"

~:
. 5:
.V i '_
Vi

2Qa1~a2 2G;65,985;'- 5@§932,;:s""'  .2;;_2:;§§iV?:«e_ _ '§';8i;se8:zﬁ- "=

'2§@2--a3 23,2§§29;?;~ 55;9:0;}ég_ :?5,'2é',;§:?;?7"" 7§'§£i+?%;'e.;5;»

2ae3é€;zz 24,8:,.S§G;'- :,.5:.,_3.£:3/x "'=;e',143;;S3,{;¥""" 8,:9g%é5;~

20e4~s5 ::,§§;82§;g_§ :;a;;s;,2%f}s;g_ :3,é3',ves4.;i 3,8a,?5':;«

;7;,3§,2V::§;'~

2§GE=~@6 :6,2:,543;» 

--..';%1*'..::::?3g59;" 45953353/~

It is we the b§.§§.s  figﬁ'-:33 :::f':fjm:::;me Q? the daémant
befaye ar:_1c§__Va'fﬁ:§ 'r:~1'i::%f;V5e_ §3:fs::¥;::!'?e:'?;"':;,~.._..§V§a$'z'3e§ geamseé far the
agpe§%3n*i. -§::3z::f3:%:&V:V:G;é':';3.$f2:«{ xzehementiy gubmétteé ighat

the c§a%ma:z§'i:,__m:5iéé §:'§*;:e»-;C?:;--%_.é.z4; géaémmg 'aha: his sawing

§§:""§i.§f"ié.._§_:Tf_§£:iZ§'§'1$"§':;~:'*;.?£&2'%;€ §"€%E.§§'§%S C§%§?§';g' S§'§®2fiJ that éggcsme 3? iésg

'xgiikx





E8

after the acéiéeni he Eiﬁfiéé geiimg saébsisritéai énggme

fmm siher aeurces am ':he basis Q? mg §:.;a§§fi::aéf§:g'f>";~":..fE i';':u

view' thergof; he submiitsé, :sr2é&:* any Ci:52;:*:i%:;~:i:a:"1s;§[».é;,' §*7.é"*: '

ameurzt awarded by the Tribamaf tox5:ar§_s tfiéﬂf

inﬂame, #335 sf earning éuring ;'t;fea'§in':"er§i'~.én.;j 

gmsgects deserve is bé get a$$;§e:[.:fed;jCs:V:d;;.. iéhe
amcsunt 0? sempensatiogt: awaAf.c§ eia:__'::§y3ia:¥§s"--%.;?3.E__EQs$ Qf
eaming ﬁuring ireatmefﬁigéé::éé*:2_{:§i%,?*'§féE3}',ﬁé'»s_;2b:":'%§:ted, the
céaimarzt wag gettérgg  empleyer

during that  s;: pp§:s-:i§ h_e fi;m_'x§tééV GU? atteﬁtim': is

the incamg vta}§'::=§V%£%%_§§;;J'Ps$_"'§§:fV€id"  céaimant far the
reievant Kyeair.  During this gegésd :§":§

cfaémani ?:éd.._:é£':ea:2z1:':' Rj;§; :3::"%'§a%h3 mceme fyara saiaryz He

{beg SL§§'§§?'§§§'§éE3£§§ ii§';.é_§*é is szaihémg 9% f'E£€.}%'§ :3 éaéictaée 325:

 $23 peréad 9? %:§/de&E§'E'E%{}§§ Whiiﬁf

a€{:':31:*:§§.;f;g *t::*:%"::v%3;iev%:§$'§§7':a§':%; wgg amasé $3}: m@;:?z%2;3& Es: gﬁﬁfé

V'"§?e 3u§':':@§t%:éﬁ7 '2:§'z5é Ef'%€'Ci:§'?3% tax %"€iZE..§§'i'§S :f%%§§ 5%: 33% year ﬁf
' '7.v.§aE::.:T*§és,rf:_: Ciéérfg gésezég 1%: 81% §.?':€:G.f'¥'E€ 3? $33 giaémargi éégé
 '§§;.::§"§:%;a§§s:§ aﬁé; ihgrgfaref ééae amgmt sf <:a:*r:§e;'2§at§:3:§

V[ ' :§_a;:é2:-'*5?-:"§§§ méér am ﬁagé é€§§;rx:e$ ia bé 5&3 agiée,

Co"s"s: é:;f f£st:;§re'L'  V

 wm/n/xxx/,,,,,/,/,



§§

 

14, "E36 daimamt ait 52$ reievaat iéme was 35 §»_'_§§?§
aéd ané was Samar Sgecéafisi Saftwayg Erxgirzées
wéth Ericssen Cemmwsécatieas Eadia ?2;'z, 
that even after the 8CC§d8f?§C; he ;s:r£3%:_§_:fs§.:e§   V
MES, Erigssan Cammunécatiéng Zrﬁia é§%v*::;  
with Mfg, Wipre Te:h:2a§Qgies :{t?d.Vf5  in

pasagragh 4 9? the affidggét in »i.4;'3.:;§a£'E'1.§'f"%A5*£§€T§.?}.?§§:~::h§€f.
He further stated? at €?;1es.z§:':méA-. Eebrzgaryg
E84 he was warkivng  its". He
then stated  time arid that
affecied s§$§feir~efV§1:'--E§.§§   He further stated,
 after théax grippfezsi anﬁ has éeem
mmziag s:§s2§'3:'v~.§::2:z:f?2é~e:§ {megs assésiarzie fa: hig gii
533%?   %2 met Ea 5 §9s§%:§ar; is gvssk fa:
 §":Si.%3'§ 35:6 ﬁééﬁféfﬁgﬁf $26 hag 58%;":
 gag? ihﬁi am §3'"f§5:§€§§§§e', ﬁg $235
 ;5§_§§a ;é.€§€e§.':§::v'A---':"§Ae'%:a%% aiﬁifréﬁi ézég sgfzzsaiégzza §;§a§s'f§Ca%§a§':,,
"T' "': €;1%V§f'3.%"'if§'$§z '"§.£¥;gf£§§§"'%§ $3? mm @223 hgzza meréiaréasgg
  _§':A2',€*:.::_,':_€Z'-é'5%'£?.5%;¥:**;'2§E§%;,é*€$ ﬁe wasfg aéf §§'§§"Q%.}§?"EGL§i ééa ésas afgg
 ~ ;:;'§§;3§£€<ﬁ $2": ¥"€€3£';':§"§ meﬁécai E§f§f,§8§"§£8 £3: szgggmi sf éaés

 '<_ "€§3§;":":, ﬁg $:>:§§"§'§§§"§%§ ﬁr, $313 §%'%§§"§"%§ Egg {??f%;"1s'I§}, §§:';§§§"



El}

Sgeciaiistg §en&ra§ Hagpétaé Kaﬁur am as, §a§a§air§:_;shm%

(?fa%'13} ta grave éisaéiéities guffereé by him'

5:. Shams Rag wag er: éuéy whevzs ihé C_%;a?§-maf§::3 I@~a[é'*: '
férgt iakea is the hssgitai. an _e>:a,§3':ir2a1'i§1{§fé;"=§L:£* .V:':;:§,_1g§'2:'§"... V'

ientferness ans sweiféng %n "E331 E'::Aer?: i'eTt::é4€: :a..r2' d

céaimaﬁi became garapiegic. 
disiecathﬁn :3? "§'~3;2 L-i gazitb e>V§;fc:eTur':;A':;:»i.x_:é._v§ac:é?af:§§>.:f:W;:%§' sginai
wrd, Afi the injuries  accsréiag
:2» 551 Shama Raa_.wRere 

     Sr, Rajaiakshmi
gpxzxs. 3:5 zvzesscme and
Rehabi§§§a;tie_s:-- iehrfg Medicaé {;'::%§&ge

Hesgitafg 8'a§j:g;+;»2§§Fr;x_ €?}%'} _.'--€>i§§':f?§?'%3§i§!% she i":§E§CE€§ ﬁze

V §§%§§2;\{§:;':§" §?:§:,:r%€é':"--..._ V

 'n_é'§}  V.if%fEa:'E~$ siaﬁis 'E? 13$f:?§?, waif Qréaateﬁ §§€E"€
.    .'  _ 5 z
 *  ~. 353:?féai-éégarégéxzs, iaaéggraiizxax

 ':€ea?§éé gazrgisaﬁ S528!" iééaszam---§:.;m§a? %'€§§%§i

 -§:f§_:§ §¥§§é:.:m§$ éaaé exam ghawaﬁ gmswsaf E25 %*:€: merziai

 '%é;3A:*:§i§e§:§ gzsrmai 3 '€§§§"i Eﬁé as £%'§!%%a§ %'§%€"¥E
Limgaivsmeni,

§§§'%S§§"§f : Qégéeé "§".".i§; 26?: E" 3:"



gggw

fx.)
)-wmmui

Maia? : Awsménaig Sﬁiiiféiiiféig; Q gawg? 35;: LL
§"E"§i£SC§€S. U: aermai. '
Reféexes : Aria? wink: grésegéi, 

msmaé U;

{éj Biacfder manaaement icy 
hauriv. Reffex  isgwe?' with :a 5:':;je3.n.:VV  Sinai
Sensation,      1

 

{5} 3e:§endent:..i_§§':%«-335 ;§ct§V>;%%iés'»:;§u'f':f_a§§ fiviggé
She further §o:.md_that theré "~'3v'E':"'S f:¥_}i?> §Q':ffﬁ?;'§«§§'f§é§ recavery in
tile m::s::§e p§'vQe§_....:'"§f  %i*?}e?__ En respsect of

functimaé Vf;h.é"péi'§:*§i'cf§:é':*j sf9V1g.eV stI:ated thus:

 wséggi  *.§:;hg!'é.§},::>;--e§§%~«.. tie-Qendent. am fi.::2£%:'§:":§§

§§,:3§;ds:':" $2593, with Eiépﬂ W&a5s[ 5 géaggri 33:
5""ia»?:§§:*§<v.'§§";':Qg'%.C'§v{§ mt' Aésgiégée 3% werk faaeg iegks reséaix

  ': --§ff:;;af:i:;;§£%s:: E'; §:*:%:*§§::£§n 3%: er E wife

 --§5§L_. " ;.i'~ iz":é5§end$:'%:  graeméngg awe? $353?
 f.'_._%:;§.%ie§s§s%§: ___"§§ eggééni in Qzsiéser maﬁiﬁi Eiaééﬁ am
}   ;§:2;:;;§e'§":.§j:*Mg

 "v"é<:a%§@a: :f::¥§:§<:::g fer ésaéf a éaggf wark aésféﬁsﬁwigg

  T'  "§s;<i»~§sé.

$3,: iZ?':§§3*""'§£$§ $$§?i§S : génxiamgg bag: maiisgaigég

V



f'?



/.
/

 §;§c%:s §';%:«:a;'<§:§e""§%': {has gresgné aggeai.

"'2"?

£5.19;

Sésabféfty asgegsmersé: : §Q0f%; germaﬁeaa '
iemghasis 
is Si}§§3{}§"t; she gméassed Case §8§€E'S 
summery (Ex. P~:§ 3; Ex! P~2€}}}.__4  ;
mnséderéng was gféciteé SQ as is 

thege Ewe wéinesseg in theif_}i;::Qss~é>;am§$1.33-iafai"""~E":2?en

befege ass, the §::jur%e3__/ §§3a_§.iE§'t§.z=;s!".._§:;fféfed...,..wére mi
disputed by Seamed muffs-§¥%§T§:>%-- it Es against
this backdrop; we--. vweuiéta'  whether the

csmpengatierg   iéﬁaés éerreci andfer
not exce$s§_$.gf§;~~..Vf:='§%f;§_' to geek énta few
Eudgmenég of §ayi§zg éewrz g fax»; tg ﬁe
§€€;i}§ in as§e§.'é.:"'2é\g:f'§':§f§' §'<:=:a.%'E.:§f;;»*  éach $3333.

 % 132% S§§§.%i%§iv;'£'§€&:%:{?ri3§'E if? in s~§§§"2:a§~sG§m an

Aag~«;%,3$f._%;é;:*$V%5§§§2§.%"rm£, éiﬁiﬁiﬁg} $232: :33 Aﬁéﬁ Qmsas

  mg as': SC£§S§§%"2 is £55? wiéﬁ géméﬁar

25?'; $35: $36 22$,

3 %~fa,§fi&::§4a§§ ""%zs§:$ W35 §r3$:§£%::g géxsmaig §'E5€'§ met zzsséﬁé an
 'f:§;:§"§§':ﬁ:'A'§§3§ §§£§i"§'E€ ﬁaragiagié, Efﬁﬁéie ﬁeaférég wig? 3&3:
T' -:§:ﬁ3$% i§"£E §i,%§¥"§¥"§E€ mam': Er: yazagiagézg Q & 3;? sbgervgﬁ

 b%§*é:1S:



 

W.
\
'wW.'&{
«RH X"
W x

233

"*9 greaéw S§€§¥é§€":g zsvézéié f§:=<§:':§ an

ame:;r:':: sf §Sm§E§":S8if§§?2 §ayab%e is 3 v§€t§;§f:':%§f%'~ 

ags azaédeni, the ifsmageg have :3 be asA;$,e_'§;s; é*:§.'VV:..V'V
gagaraiety 33 pecuniary damagés anc§4' 3pve:§i::E2}.Li"'j"*A '
damages. Pecuniary damaqgs» are :Eézt:sé*:"_;e:§'ii'<::;f:'

the victim has actuaiiv ini:ur:fe{:jiA jafzd 
aanabie of ﬁeina caicuiated Is: farms Of1'_2f'ﬁ CI'F§€V"=; .
whereas mnmecuniar3é"'-»..damé::2.es".._aVr-3 "'i:ﬁ'i:s'e"

which are incapabie §:f"-. if_}€§.§fi€2 .a's5e:s_sed7 b

aﬁthmetécai C§';J:§{"3i4i_'§_'§__i'iVAQ%'E:S;' Carder m

agprecéate Ewé £G§f_é:a%§€:s:':"'§§::;ji;§*%"5§.i3;*2.29f;é%'.. ﬁamages
may Ema-:;§'Lg.§e g'é§£i5§e%§eé.:;e_?$'-ff=éncég:*:a?'§ $3: thg

€1aim_a§3t:f*"i'..médiéai a.tt;€.=-ndahéég E; $953 05

earsi§.ﬁg--:f §f_ p.r'ii:?*'ét_ :;:'i:; ft)'--'thé; éate <31' iriaig {iii}

:3i:f'§i5er. %}f§até.%f&'a%,'ézségf'  far rzsi:-peCur':§ar\;

2:§_ama'geé$59}é*::.?:fé%s::%.g:?*m.gc§",; thsy may iniézzées {E}

éaim,_;aLges §e§":§2s;%§-;§§ asé pﬁységai shaak, gain

..§;;ffe'%§::§;5"£3§r%éé3%" S%,%§fE%"§§ G? éikeiy €16 Ea

 s;;f%e_2fe§ égé 'f:s'i:":::'%£; {ii} éamagss EC! Qaﬁmerzggié

 §,<> §v':;':;_é"v§f9s§ £2? ﬁ¥'T2€?°§§§§€S 9% §§§e xaghiah £2333:

_. é§e:E;:§,;&;e=.['§"'é$a:'§&:*y€ Q? maiigrgg %,e,, an a€§§:::':%: ma

§:}j:2r'§{i1€§:e C§§§§T'%§§Ei may mi bé abte ::3 waékf

 9:" gig: 2:;f§§§'} égmageg far éﬁge mag 95
AA " '=.._&>»<§e:::ai%@:"% af éifa. §,§.,; €35: $559232": 9% éagmy

 5% m:':'>;2a% %e::§§:.;§:§s 9? i?'%@ §€f3::}E"§ gaséiarneﬁ

is ghggteﬁéég {iv} §§°%€$?':"%§%§'E§€§'%£%§ §":3?'§S§2%§;
§§§:.:e::2fs§*%:; §§§§;,}§£:§§';::*':'z;e:":'a. :%2;s%:=3%§@§2 am?

E""§'E€§"%§EZ§ girsas $2 iéfeg



24

:27: The afsim 3563: 3%! ?'af:§.3.§ fair as}:

and SE...i§fE¥'§§'3 am far $33 :22' amenéiéeg :2fV.§'E'f§._

under 8%, §\§§.:7 are iiaims far E'IG%"i*EECL%_§:fi§'»$':f:Tg 'j  
gag The 3§§8H3f"fi7 has cfaimed  H
amctrunt cf Rs,3;OO,,QQQ,!~ egg; :,.smf§éé*'  
heaésv The High cc;;rt:.% _%";;~g§%» 
Rs.1;OG,GGO/- agaénst:  cfa[.i:F'2??S;'A."'*"sfﬁ ' H

Rs=6,GG;8GG;'~, When', .§§éIj;3ehéat:c'rw  

awarded fer vain andﬁuffexigjg .én::'.§ _%as:=',5 cf

amerzii: 9? ﬁfe' :§ae:<:: a'£-f.céftumstances 9'?
:he daémani havé fa'iié':"*caE<ér£ f;ﬁ§:.;: account
Encludina ﬁfs acyé' :2§9::§§,:; a'§ V'd'v;&§r§vatiGn he
has chée{EFéct:_..'ﬁ5AeEe{3f"V§§n his future

fife. 5 Thé'_.é%ﬁ'C»':1nf'5.'i<}-f:'tam:§'ef§sation for r:on~

..€I":'s$i;§'Z'35:§a §"_  §é§i:s"~%.s"'z*2{§'i- easﬁffb' determine but the

awangi ~mL;:éiij"-:é?'§e¢'t»i:§ie»f:' different circumstances

haéke? éeerz 'éaiieé .:';€€;:§ C§ﬁ§§d8f'§EiG%'}. Assarééag

zg as,' 'a3_%:f':e.};~3§§'e:--3ifé;%é was 3:: advacaie bavéag

_f7:g§§:V?d»._§_§ra¢§§:;€:~~--~~::: déffsreaé e::@:::'2:$ am 33
  33$ aaaiﬁerét he 5335 Sea? éféggfeﬁ
  snfy 3;: whe&§ €ha%%3, 351% §""§§§§'§

".__ §f:G;:.:%{: é:'%"§§:.:§é have aﬁoazxseé gs': amezmt 3:?

§%$Q'§;E§;8Qﬁ,!'» in regasgaé Q? £§§§§"'€E E3: gaégé aw

 »v['..4_§uf?%é:*§§2g érzé §§.:;§§£}§G,f- if} :*::~:,=5§e§i §% ETESE
 -:3? §£"§"%€2""§§"C§§S sf fife, We §§:'@£i ﬁayment 9?

R$¢3;Cs8;§§G;'- €:§'i.§§§§S itwee §a§<%'"z$ 32%;}
agamsi 233% €§a%s:": sﬁf §s§§,§§i,Q§Gfw zmﬁa ihs



Ex.)
(J1

heaés 'Sam am E§uf:"e:'é:3§" ané 'Leg 3%

amenitieg 3? éife':"' {Emphasis samsiieujj)  

1;: THE DIVISIQNAL CONTROLLER,  

MAHADEVA SHETTY AND Au%QmER%--~'A:§~_V%gzéiog 

4132, the SUQFEETEE Cam': 3:2 i3aFé»'§?'a:;*'?1..;§.8";}§!':*S#§f'aié§::"::.?';;j€*:3§'A

",5: gersen netV'i§§':.§y szii'-fe ksV§n}'g3s*iA»:§;s.....Q;'1..
agceuniz ef accident b:.}"§t>..a7¥$e_ sz.}f'2"e§jusT'§:n Eginé
and may GE': a::':::;;,2{:t:§f"  Vé'<:.<:'ider1t "t§'2r7sé;g%:
his ﬁfe arm a feéiiség'isL.d%éi{:ei§;$é25,{t'§w.at he :5 me
more a a.Qrmaj.A"-;'na§': fa~n;j__:::${;rf;'3%t"'Jenj0y the
amenit?;' e4$§2§'E§fe:'as€a%ﬁ)t5'e;¥ :ié:)"r§m~:ai person can,

Whiiié _.fi'xE.ﬁ'G *'-. .C£"3ﬁ3;jVén§afE'0:':'~' fer ﬂair: and

Su%ff«9r_§r:L. '$'§i:::Sv§_S{E--.ii0--ET'§i§S'S"'9féE'é"!€ﬂ§{§€S 0%' ﬁfe ihe
M :'§eatureVS'Y.%%i<é<_§1i%s "-we-' maritai siatus and
 :.;f:z3_s7:.:aE ':§.e§r.§§*a:t%G_§é"iﬁé has iEf'%ﬁEf'ZZa§<éR Er: his

V. ééfe ié'a:§V_§<3» SEE ré:§{G%'3eéf'{emp%1as%s 3:;§pi§eﬁ§:

 :=:":f mg: §{§§¥'i§R Eiersass QJA'? iéesgeiag mg
 u{f2f$i:) 1 $€§ 343 $33 ﬁagmeme C9531"; Er':
$:3'%'«3§f§§§§?.;S12:"'§A3 & 15 Qbﬁéfifeﬁ Ehugi
_ . V "" :3, %$€E5{§i?§§3?€§%i 53%" {ha effgié 5?' §§"'%€
 §%§'¥"!'§§f3€%'§§ ﬁésaééiizzg 8%": $26 gﬁasaé €a2"{';§§'§§
iagacéizsg imsaéxseg tiwee giegzg, "E'E*:§ TT:'§§:s:,::':aE

has :3 E33" agﬁsriaéa whai aziiaziiiés rtéaé

géaiazéarzt gssgié €§§'§ 52:': in site 3? 3%



W

26

€§"{?"i3f§€F1§Z disaﬁéiii this is 3333 yeéevarsi fay'

awardma camﬁensatien améer we head cf %§5;'i§7

92' amenétieg ef fife . The secmé  A
ascertaén his axsecatiisng prefessisn ar2€§'::§2a?:.:;§}f§j,"A  H
3? werk befere the accider:g,>V» as a?':s"Q"'§:---%éf:
The third steg is ts find cgiajt   
daimant is tetaiéy disvaE3iec¥A1"i';§'<»:3':fnVear%:§::::§ "
idné of xvennoed,ax?{§;g~héth§r¢gfsp&é"o£'

the permanent disabifétgg'-,,::f';e_V c§a.i'm,a_:§v:__ :;j:%::%d
sﬁfi effe:t%s:e%y=  ::ar:y_"' §gf:'VA v"'é.%f_2_e;i.=, i'activities and
Eunatéensg which 'iéé.__ik¢é'3~v<§8"f§%_ef"{f%3;i?%§?i_.ng en; gr
{iii} whethe:f he§"":52a;~r.: :gzgezéiéssgisebf restréstw
fmm _V:§._%;s'c§;:i[a'%géa§.  g_;i:=$gfi,é:§£; "éctivities and
func%f_i_§n. S ;_,. .§a:¢ry  some other 3?'
§.es*s;3--:_:3;ai§é'}::'F _a?'<:i;Ifv'*~;2=¥f_§'e:s"_"7a?'s"'"':'d'§4 fuszctims SQ that
333 ::<,:r12f§ri"g;s$*-.*;A:L:*s:a:>»'éaff;~~..¢r"=.:a:"z carzténue ia aam
%§é%§e§haa§:  ff. :

§:'§;"'V--..i§:_ mag; %% ﬁeieé ma: zrzsﬁeﬁ

 "=.:.."*§:{'§?;2réé;i:§a:ie:2 $3 azrzzaréeﬁ 5* €§"%§§§%"i Tifée fasg

 za acii: 55 2§§% 'er avéié
 mare E3253 53%' ihe aeeé ta aaésaré
§e§*:9;3 éézsgiiw §8%3%'i:5§E§ isiéées' {ﬁe §"§§&ﬁ af
  §9's~ss G?' amssﬁiéag er §GSS :3? ex §¥:§'3?i'§$§"E gf ﬁfe:
1% §%§"'i%i'§»'sf§§% tﬁére ma' 5% a as ¥%£a%§§i'; fr: $23

§'%f*é§§'§ Q? £9??? $i'?§§§§$?%,». 8% ifzgf: 53 ii magi'

{:§i"§'%§§"§§S§§ sagggéieﬁj}



We

ﬁe

in ?§AGA?PA ya: $URU§15§YAL. SINGE' (2Q33}2 S3: 234

tee Seereme Ceiee heie {hat eemeeeeetéee :e e  a

meter xzehiae accident er in case ef a fate: e;_e%:iee'§:--€fj'?:é*<%3£§?:ee--.»

iegai representatives is awarded ggder we/'e"'§2e:e'ee';~»?ée§eeV§3}"» 

specie! eemages - which are euf?Eere;:fe£>:~:y ti**%.e""a::§"<:*:§§%';f"'ef'i3E:e

éegei representatives ené genefai dtani'eges;ﬁ§vAVE:_ievhV.§r§c£ude»."

eempeeeetier: fer eeée em   §ese_ Le§VAv;;$menitEes;
eareing ceeecity ef:Ad..z':"p§'(;:ep;ee%i%fe_'Vv:...}e';;.pg:2ses inciueéng
expenses for mevdicafe.-Av':vre.é':'5*'eerfe';.,1.pi' part of the
eamagee  f_'h'e 'e"esis ef the evidence
in eesseeeéjena with regard te the
seeenevv'   ef eenjecteres depending
ee the    Whiée eeéeefatieg eece

e?ee3,eE§;'ee;; the'..f'§4§eee:a§;eee¥€ ie reeeieee ﬁe eeve eeme

%§«:e%s: e}e:§<€e.§<§eg éeize eeeeeei ee ieﬁeeer; feetea:

 eeeeeeeezs e, eeeeee eeeeetee ie

 _ :§..§"~i§.§3:?* '§*=:*;:e;2 §.3§§ ée eeeegreehe g e. };$ eeeeezee tees:

Q. 'Tee eee eeeie eiemeeie ie eeeeeeeé

 .:é'e§ee;,: eeeeee ere fee §€?'SG{'§§§ fess eee

eeeeeieeg' ieee, in eeir wee» Leeeee eee

éeertie eéieetere Eeifeeey €eg ﬂee? Eeeiéee
Ceeiéeeee eéeeegeéeeee ee eee eeeeete eeee:



$5

 

Z8

":32 §SS§SS§!?g ifze cemyaensazém the

jsry ghméiﬁ take Esta acssaméz iwzs thigggi 
first; {:75 ggcuméary £535 {the ;:'§§§€3i§ff.}: "  b
szsstaénss by aasziidentr agcerzdigsg the 
31% $USt8E¥'I$ if: his pérserg, er %1%$_..§f:i":_A§.}":";?§;Va'§--T.::' 3
capacity cf enjaying §%feg:-JLE?JhemA_t§':Aey.; «:*{i#V:1:?-_; V ' A
ts the cansideratéan 0? $23 g:§_7'e€*é.§n§é::f:!"¥§$3  "
they have is take :n'i:s;_ acc§'u;:{":':Qt :::°2"iV'j,%'V;?<s:§:<,: 

gregent $955, but §'*:%s.:;'--v..L§§*i:::apac§i:*;,'«:_tr;:2»éé2rn"..Ea 

fasézejre imggrgxzeé EncQm.ef<._ 

Refer§1'--m §it_Q '§_ha;_ ;z'é'a.:j::__§~§ ﬁamages

in gersorgaf énjzi-ry 3'¢tibn3«..,?*§é§S{%:gor an

gamgqes ::j:4F¥y E_§1':~:'::c;.::;' "gage :2;
 ' 

"V'§ifjaii];,;i.:;--;:fso:i":24h§§§.c;,a§1y injigred may recsver

 """ "b':':»t.?};i.farEgés,;:e:{,:r:.§é:";:VV§:$Sses and his man»

'--;;%e::;;ri§aé?y._§§::s4é'::.f_  "-- these the g::2e:::m éary

' ~v.%és;:;es 'é:%:é:%2s~2%¥§;z';9.é4' Vésmgrége tame: seggarate

%%:é'::é_s5,'~x:é:  téze §c:::§s $5 eamérzgs am sine?

 gwgéng ":é%;?s§ai%1..:?2e gjiaéswziff wsuéd §"§3E:'€ f'E"':3§%
 zzeé: ééem %:?:;:,:r§é am ﬁze maﬁiiai
 €><§E%?'§:2$§ 33:: 2=*=;h%€%": 3:3 g m: a3 a
«%é:s:ga.:.f5?: sf §:?'%Q émjgm amj we 2:'§1,:;':s ézava
 $::"'§¥-ééézsiéeé §:§"'%§ §"'1{":%i"%-'Q*$§%.§§'E§§%"g' §@§§§S 252:9
" ' Lézéarea saéiageriea, viz"? gas: 335 asgffarmgi

{sag sf' arzzanéiéeg ::::f $59 532$ Essa é?
exgeiiaiéaﬁ sf Eéfef'

3% ii is "%'"r§:§ éaw $3137?  §ra:':i%:';§
§§§'"7?§§?%Sa%';'§§§3; fag? §§?"SQ:5"¥§§ égzjmgg Eﬁe

aséatéga"; has :5 % £8§'2!":g':2a%§?§ai%§ ii} §§?"





V_:%ai§:23§é:: ﬁe &bE$ is waik; ﬁamages fax {fee Eegs 0:

2%?

gain am suffering; {2} fgr E633 Q?'
amegaéiéea {3} S§"§§i"i$§"'I&§ exgeciaiim af

iéfe if aay; {4} £935 cf earszéizgs 3:" msg o§..... V 'V
eamérgg Qagacéty er 2": game Cases 
bath; am! {5} mesicai t:_;e.ai:::':€r'a%;'"éf1':§:'_j _ '* 

ether specéaé damages."

165 In graaiéag :Qr:*':pesi$_é"ai;.;9r: fé:_pe:jsCé;ja':«i._'é::§;.sﬁes

the visiim hag is be §anf:pensated '§s'2_?"='f'_§§sshf .a__§1f;g%%§£§es";

"E333 af expectatésn ef §§fé'?'; "%.g:>ai§;2 {3::2§"":é.:s~ff:é:%hg"'; sis' 'She

csmpensation uns_:i'e:f the'§é"~?é£§ad':_:._"'»-33 »§Vnc;af'§3éb%e 0?' being

assegged by §r§f*h4m5é§_i_;:aiv ::a!CL:,§ati«;:':téfs, B,é%z":ages fer mentaé

gr ph;,ss§;a§iM__Vs%é'{;»:_i%;;' ; 1;:e:§§_:_': a::'1rf§_ ;z;:ffe;f§V:f:g:§; aiready guffered er

iikehg EQ Vége :;uff.ér§:*.é"-.§A§i'%*ff:;':Ls§€:;..,iiamageg is atempangate far

the $955 3? fa7';f:;en§é;§é:3 at? §%§.§f"'_;v«;%:§:i2 may iaciasﬁs 5 xgariety $5

_.Vm§%%€;.r:§;V géggéz V'Ea"£..'s§:_az€<:§:m: 9? §ﬁ§§§?3?;;§§S:§§§§§§§? Eize

é'

%:>§'§;é;i:§:&i§§:§".'§§ §§§é; 53. %E'% aééﬁiiﬁi :3»? ingzms ﬁg ﬁaymaé

 %§::gexé1::*>g *§:%:§ $533!: £§i"§i':%?'§"3§€i is sZ%§§§a§:s$;
 "gq.;**:::f'§;*s;§r";éé'%":§€§ iéaréshégf §§S£§1'3"§§§§'§, §;§%S§Q§G§E'E%;'§E?53§""§i,

--.f§.:*:;A's-sjzéaiiéggé afié :'§2e:"::a§ gtraga in Egg; aye ;2§:*2~§@::u§:§&r*;,:

"-4.§§':§'ié§g&s, Sm gash aagés, $38 zzscém mi: agziy S2,§?f§§"$

5

§§"%§§.}§'§€S $3: §CC43L§§*z%: 9% mg acéiééézi 53:3: 333$ §u%:fe:"3  mémf



I////////aII 

$2: 

 

38

and bégzﬁy ism a€:§u::i: af iéze amass: éhreughméi i1§s_ fife

am 5 feeiéng is éeveiaged ihaii he is as mere 
mar: ans Caﬁﬂﬁi €ﬁjQ';' 331$ amenities sf Eife_.--jé;-3  '
normaé persen Can; The :zsn~pecun__§a.r.y_Ecss'§'e9iéy=Eﬁ::a.iéi::*.'t§f':é'v.. V

iéakﬁant i:ota¥§y :32' Qartiafiy Eélcapaizie '~':j=§a29i':~f.%_z:'l_c;;

sf Meféhssd. Butgn a given s.::;:3[;sé;....s:;ci'éA3S i:»§':e?g::fe';3 éi':":~~z;'E'ze,

inspﬁce of Qermanem: £§§sab§fE:3%_,.?:V :%§.§=.;§aé%%§a::--E.._A_.<:g..:;§f::£ stﬁi
effectivefy carry an the? 'a.<;§i§:£§§é.§'s3v:.,agéé" f§;:.gcé:*%§ms, whid': he
was eariier carryingvgn  Therefara,
it is  damages ta
 fess 3? expectatéoﬁ
<2?' ﬁfe;  ihe ciaémané; suffered

:§B% earréésig %<§isé'bi€'§":3;;»~ if yes, éfﬁém is 3 ﬁééé :3

award g;j:7s:z':L§§§:2§3:§~::_;éV Segssraiafy zgyzéa" me %2§a§§ 3:' $323 3%

:"._§%'§ae§::fi§§§""-zi§s'. %s:.g$ sf sxgeaiaiéisgé sf ﬁfe Q?' wig": 352$

$:;'%'f§:é§_;§ fit;T§a?.§:§;"s:§i:§§i£a:§§ﬁ ii'? azszgaré :2? aamgsségatéééa

1?; %:?2E gaeassi gags, me aiaémami thaaegh

 :§_g§~,%'f?"§e%:9yé':¢"«_.3§§2*%§$: §G% §§?'g'S§£§§ déggéiféty Eaiﬁg féﬂééfﬁﬁ
 ..__'?g3}é§raV§;2§eg:'Q; ﬁg Sig? :33: gzsfier eamégig §§§§§§§%€";,s*' 5: 5%, 5% 3

gaffer 3? fag?! hés iﬁcame iﬁifﬁaﬁﬁﬁ 3% mi c§§;::rea3€§§





_ E333  $5 agaémys this; §%?;§§"§"§E§ geagagsé
 that ihe a§§e§§a:":T: wsuiaj as: be
x en'§::§ié§§.V.% é*  mare than .§,$,3§§§;%§§;'- far iéze §§$§ §

  ::,:g? a:"s%é%:%.:z§§\.;:,Av.af:§§ $333 9?' §§<§€£'§5'3:§Gf'§ sf ﬁfe: E
K  =§~§§2z:*%é7§ zegasré ta 3% %:'a§::2*%e§ §Lé$i3%§'¥E§ by i§"§% §
 -f:§.;3§§::%§§2éA 3% tag éégasééiy §£§§'§:%§'E§; :1:3§w%i:$§¥g: ihgrg %g 3 §
T' ' «§:§V:S'é"§%§ €Zxf;':%€C%.f§i:§i":i§'} Q? Eife 5:33 §§::3 Q? gmggéiées :3? Eéfa. "ﬁg 

 ugigaggzrzang: ::x;§§§ ms: bs géie :2: waik aii %:§:mé;§%m::: mg 295% am §

31

Tﬁis §§Cii §"%&S as: war: éégguieé by me £§aim3§'2t. Er: xgjiéew
ihereci, améazzbteéﬁy he is entitéed 'CG Ciaim 
separaieigg zmder the ﬁeads "(ass sf 3men§i§e§"' 35:3  *

exgectatésn sf ﬁfe", We have m_a»§'.e__refz:%%é%itt:¥.'jg:§"  V

Qhyskgaf shack; pain, suffering afreaﬁy 3-.{_§2fféréT:§~.§r i§§<§§§}'_L:':ei§7--Tf
be guffered in future 33! the C2'é:_{ir"r:.§n!:. ww':%@

was absaiuteiy ééaie an_df %2ea:ft_3z §;as:'r?2;:;L;1 %§a'§-..;}Qy£§ bees

Cripgieé and gag: mmse s"§:E*g}j-3:9a-__v§§¥é§:e'§"'§j§§3ésfE_V HE siaimeﬁ

iump sum ameunt£;§_R;sg§?4'it*o*ré: :m§:§e r' 5~;iI«.:E5Aé;éiaaE$; Leamed

senier Cotmse-5§i1a.§.manELVbe.fore as hawever

gubmittedi__i_%ja;f'*V:§i"f'é§'§:»ia§:Ef: i?i':=--.a,:j2if:;:%§;:s':: sf mmpensatisn
awardeﬁ Egy theVV*E":?:§§3'z;:.§iz:+;%, {,:A:f::§€--§ii tE§e heaés disabiiityiiass <3'?

fuime §:3cc§f:x:=3__ be é<zg§:A{ie'a:*% "1{':2r tﬁe €as§ Q? amgafiies E95



 

E R

32

wwfé mauére 8SS§SE§§"ECE far 3%? éaéiyf iiaziszg asiivéiées sgj w§%§

hagze fﬁ be éegsndaaé

18, when ﬁamageg is cemgérgsate  
gufferirigg 3953 sf' amenities 9%' life Vsgf 

sf ﬁfe, are 1:0 be awarded the speciaf'«:E1?::;mst$§:.::éV§" éf :ghié* 'V

giaémant have is he taken §r2te"'a:;::t:::>L_;r':t §f';:»§i§':§§;*§g iage;
the ass2:.ssua% ciegréxjatien,ﬁzz.&§2a3A»"é':éVff%§4§§%i'}L'tbs ef§é:Ac i Vihere@f
er: ézés fsgture ﬁfe anﬁ $3  The amount
ef campen3atio€r:'--'§?i%§_{%.-  mt easy {G
determine   Rfjéfiéct that different

£§rca;m5ta'r%:é's- --%3 §:3.ve §'{e'Vé:?:,_i::E~:Vi:~i:e_a'1; i'nt5"%:ensEderatie:m

:9» I%*:w--,_:%:e {§*r»s§»:%n£: ?ga§e, 22% have gireaég maﬁa

r€fe;'€:;s:é' 33:} me"-:~:p§léc§a§V sémgmgiances 2?=:%**§§:::§*: make %:%:§§

 ~.;cafs1._e».§§é;?ﬁg?:.%:e--..ex£e§t%s:'2a§ {;§S€§ s,.»¥h€§e iéze géaémgni is

8é§i%:_%é§_§a%" :'%'}¢:r§::':§.§g;ée§f.s §§ wmgggésate 3%? 3' éesg af amamiéeg

{sf i§f'§""a§f:év:..ﬁ§é&1«*-"i iagg Sf axggctaiémi: sf ﬁgfei 'mg €§a§:*s*%a:'2E Es

'Ha§%;:z:?;}::%é%"e::g§:"":e%: 2!'s;%2£:3 ziiﬁ iaée SEE, immgzgisr ${:%e::§£)

 _1ag§é§".. §:a§ %a:@:'£<eé gg LE€.":i3E*8§ $3 Caﬁégazgéas' Sﬁiéﬁﬁé

 : ;§'2§':;:'§[':"t:":;':er2:; §*v'%.§%:':a§ Caﬁege 3? §§3§§§"£€€?"§¥"2§g ﬁgssang 2333::

::§::§:§ "§'"e:{§§ §:§"§§§f"iié'?'¥€§"§§§ Emﬁég Lisj, §73§§§ﬁ§§?'S§ ﬁe céaima

Nu-.~...W..~... .

$4



'LN
£3»)

ihgé: he was? §"%Li§'1"§§€f" sf awafﬁs at imtgrseatésrzai §ev&%,__ A?

tha §'e§3va:":2: ééréée E*:& was warkéag 3%: 
CG%"f'}§'Téi,§¥'!§C3{§§?'iS Endia Past, Ltd. 3% wag  ~
Rs§:;4?,.GG§,/~* pm. The cia§ma:;:t..,y;f§3 
Advance Sssgport System far Emui%§i:§0E:'j':'2a%':':';'i¥§

Emweve: has cripgled him ans' «_:"::---r:;.féz:é:::I*-:5  -94%-ﬁe

Carma: waék, my: and Qfzake  awex
Simifarlyf begause cf   gefinéte Easg
<31' exgaectatésfz Qfv-ﬁfe,  his iife is
shortened dtge  suffered in the
a«:c§aera2:,__§V: he East matﬁmaniai

ﬁfe at théai age :3?3.3}:_ §~:§'ég:1§Tri'g3_'mat in View am sorssidering

the %:*1f§ai§e::=~.§at:%:Qr;"%_r§"A<::;r '§§;in%ar:; Ehﬁ iﬁaimant is entitéeé

__fe?' §;:s..§}a%*e§:;§zt §'fA~«?gs}1?§S{§;GG$,?- Er; resgeci gf Ehe céaém far

'£3?_v»'§VA%";f*:a:§§.',Ees' aaé R§§3f§§,§i3i3::'~= fer iéée '$3.3 af

§%§;é7ﬁ§;:i§3é:=: "_@_§'ééééi "§'?;a;s; ﬁéé £§§§§T':§§'§i :3 €§"§?;§§§€{§ far

V' .--§3.1§';'E?§£§§§;"? %,;%'2§%?' :%:§ Eéeaé 'iasg Q? gmaaéiégg 9% ﬁfe'

  .'i~%.§j§é2i:f §f:<£§€£:i§i§§%"': £3? iifei

2%; §,E3f'§'E€§ Csasasei fer the §;:>§%§§§§:fi --- Eagmraﬁce

__4,,,,,,,_A .Li:@§2:§a§:*:;f aftar éazgiééng @331? §§Z?;§f'E§%§§"§ ﬁg {ﬁe rgéevggéi

 z4%44mu////x//1/x//xmW.mmWw_




, \

€:§§SCi.iS$§G§"% 3': tite Ezségméni in r"e§pect sf ihe 'mica:

CQ§T'E§Ei'ES§i§§?'E awariiaé ::?:ée:' differeréé heads; su§mi:;%:%é'::i 

that the céaimant under any Qércumstancegg havine§'~*-:€A§~'I. fd.j' 

:9 the increase in his incame after the a{:C_i€i1.€EV%_A'41:')(i'v,.VViS.1 §'I{}'f.3

entitked fer any campensatien in res»pecEt: §_f 

"£333 sf future §f§CO§'T'E€" ané "£033 £35 f:2iiL2_reI" §ra::_;3é<:%$"'§ Fig

saibmétted that the 'fribzgnai has {ﬁe  in
greger pergpeciigfe  '  VV'AAaV§%:ardeﬁ
§\s§2,GG,§9,285f~ asigd odd_,t;>.§%E§3-rd%§._4%i§}sa'bi§.§§§§._';f..E653 of future
income and Rsf_2?§  prospectus;
21, " :i::r"1 :~':.'jr':zi.:s§:":év£iV§§éb?ce/deposition has
stateé    after the accident

becauge §€'?ch eb%a€i§é%9{';=::_:;és:§%. :§;}'é§«:e§ gmbiemg haw he facég

emba;?:§S'§§f:f:en% 'a§:Ls:5"1%2::;€:§ii§:%a?: gaé haw iﬁai gitémaigiy

 *:ge}§%§§': iézeugés 'iiié he §%§QS€§ :3": ins iaga.

£57:'é:§';é';_,i«2i:%'-%::., §;~;%j;'V:'V1<'; ﬁg hag fwihay staiseé tag": 3 gergea

 _1A;ar§<§%s{3 E%f:"§%:«§ $Gf'£W3§'€ §%"§§§}Si§"3«' éﬁéag a fag? gréasvimg

.  :z fs§;:§:_a'3; gmigiz %  §:':é::g%": fag faga 3%} sitagaiéeség :s::%*:§£%2 32$

' mm.

¥:a:'*:_§é§:;;%§: VEEW Q? 5.335 §%saEs%%ii§€§ ggffaggé $3; ﬁém $9 we

- _ 1ae::e::§§s:%{, He i;*~:;; mi 2?: 3 §{::s%ti§%2 ﬁg xassréz fa? 3E§§%.3§§?:€§

»"'%'gr%<§§s§ ?%%i.§§"'§ am Eiseygfereg ha ms gmgeé £3:

 



 

'LN
W":

aemgiensaiien far the 5

m--f1:*a s§"§2,§i=v.'be

sazreﬁ and he wiii have ire ﬁve wéth it fér his §?--f§' é; 

states that because a? the d§sabi_£i.t;:,__he ¢:f§Vé" :?§:;§;

grogress in the atémaany where 

Qerused the evédergce "<3-f_

csrrebcratesfsupprsrts the cia.i;_ér§an_t"~§;3 aff "2'e::.,r3.e<:%; iszsafar

as shysical ﬁisabiiitgfé«é.V:"c9r'}§e;ﬁ§}:eé': . *~fffee Yribunaé after

having considered the,--.ev'v§ﬁ§:nCe._31f tféeqéfiaimaat aad the

dectars and ?§eihé':-._me.g§i§if\a£_ papers groéuced sin

reccrdg awair?:jve'£ .V;~§$;ZQG; rgspect 3f the cfaim

fa r é isaafiiiityg' {sf ':fa:tii:<e A:';<z égonﬁ E2

/ 22. '7T{?%e_  éisabéifty guffereé by the

§§§E§*?2az':§:~ gs %:'<:i:_ "§é'2 é:';<;§:_.:t€, éfasazexzgig frgm ihg

 é's;%,de'§'2r::.e;*':§f:a§s::f§.:a§ an 5§§§r{§, ii £3 Cigar 55353

if wag ghysiaéf
15§--sai§b;:;'1:§i}i;. _ J 

 Eaifﬁifig/§§§fE€€§§{§5§ §§§5b§§§§'§f, ﬁg

" "=.a?:és$%*xs.gé V_._-:%ar§.§é:; ms zézczsma $5 $13 <,%§a%::2as":§,  facég

"-- :]' "§§;'§€Z--?T$§S&§ ':.:2----§%e§' ihe a£c%§s§':é:, '?his 5;': a§§ faémeggg $255,: éaééé
A "=3:€é;3:*§s:§'A $3:

égameé gems? C{"}£:fE'?$€§ far iha céaimgzzi. ﬁfe
'= ,"'a.::%§;i'.:*;§§é'Ee:§ £73: 'i§""§€* §§"§€§§"%"':§ tax reéagsrsg féfsé Sf? rgssré

 gfww iéfzaz big §§"%:;";='.,:%%"":"E§: :':2;:§£a§&é afta' {he §f.T€§¥§%%"%§L

" 5}}: ﬂier" * .
.. maké;a}':~y  j: V
w{a"s*~ 'ia:§f§<§_{:g.._ ' "§2;=:\;*e. 'V

f?1:*s_    :é;:h5ch  >



36'

Z52 atfzer warﬁs, ﬁe €:§£"E€€é€€§ ihat there ;'s as $335 s:"__.§;:t::re

mcame. Héweverf he submittecf ?:hat the ars§'e.:}_'af"*.§f

mmpensatéen awarded 5;' the Tribgmaé Lznd:;:3%* 
may be treated Es: respect of c§a_§_m._jf'_Qr i::;~éé "4Ca'%'.'jvg.ré5e.fji~:iés 'V
and he may be granted at ieagt haff of "t§"§e 

ﬁne Same; Wfzﬁe e><amf?_2'i'zeq   the " :

énjuriesidésabféities suffered, ;é«;_é:'»v.§ja=azje aéceriiéiﬂéd what
agtivéties the ciaimant "a:<%;jE_.:i'-r;a;*:;2*};* 'Q:f's,'j'--a"z :*:::i_j:x;%":et§*:e:' he is

iotaiiy ﬁisabied from ea:rA2:E:%§::ady.§3f..§&i¥;éIihQo§ 9;' csuid

Stu! effectiveif.,VcaEfi;.§».onéhé-._act§§v§'ii'ies and functiens, which
he was eariia-i':rV.€7a:"13:y_ir3g' §'r:, t§_"ea§:i;:V_ cantinue ta eam,
23. :52..ﬁiéé',~;.°:§*é::§';*st '{:ase," fmm the §é"2§Q5%"i€ Q?' the

dgémant éf~i:e ri:§":é"a::'€§&:%::f;.»--.§i :5 C333: that 326 gccéﬁeszi SEQ

mi m§§<'e.a:é3s e?§§:3§,*§ §;*';§2%§ éaggcéiy is sass': izig ?§'sfE§§?'§Q§ﬁ£

 §<'"e:?.;és;§%;§ %§*é§§ %§?z._xz§ew ariﬁ ccazgiﬁering E339 S§§§i3"§§$S§§?§$ Q?

Ee'a.fs*;-T§§;.A§L:{;%';:,s;§§f§1§'.s# the gigémaszzg 235% §"§5§"a5£ as §'zG§%ta%§a§: $2

"'__§e:§:'r%§..g:s§§§;~---'§§r§: if €225 émgagyzed {2:"§&€ 3;; whéaﬁ gr;
: v:"'--e3;_%*%::::;s.§éi $7? €£%§'§"§§€§}S§§§{}§? gwarégé $5'; reggagi af gigém €33:

 ::§f§§;:3§§'§§é:ig ,5 £335 9? fagiare émama



 

3'7

245 Enssfaz as giaim far fgture §re§;3e{_fi:§ is

agncemedf zmcésubieﬁéy haxzészg regard ia the ta§<:s:.€i:';:{{f'~€:§f;e

giaimant and SO alga ms exgertise and the q:;_Es§--%f%a:_;éi§}§'r:} ;'§:'f?:' *

deﬁnitely weuid have achieved .¢a,:':.d;__eam'é'd"":%§u:'f': Vémore 2

than what he had achieved and f*:;as:'_bet3n:ea1*r3_i%'sgAV:2V§**.n;;7§f.

he was a nerma§ human bei'.r9V*r_g';---._Thé'vdisa.b§%§§;}AA$.;;ffe.r:§d by'- 

the daémant has asnde:;btedEyV_g:§V§ien'him :3' ;<,:e?i_ba,:§i< insofar
as future sraspecﬁ  noi~2cev§'r;e'é; 'j ..'§}:;*.e are therefore;
énciined te grantv Rs':1;'5§;{}Of);':_"-.:§;n}§I.asfiS" 3955 of future

prospects:  

_wé§;%g0§§'i'a:.:"§Eks _._t"§V'V'r:onsider was 01' earning
duréng  .:r:e5:§:v%'?:é:':%:_'[';;%$}**'é€:§%.-; '€336 Trihsmaé ms graaied

§.§,8g8_§ ,.?4§;f~  ia%<:EV§'%-QQ5V§:"ﬁ8;2§1j~ as maatﬁiy saigry 5?

  'E"h:e <:%a'§'n§3:";: wag iakéng ifeaimeni; $9: gémi

3%: §'r:€aﬁ:%*%_$l; . "§'i"}é'~.;a::;:§ée§'::, in the greserzt gage, Qiﬁtiffﬁé 9:":

2;é5.A:: §L2§§;._3; :%;'ige;'mgmg the asgessmeat 'yea? 2@a§a§:, "§°he

 .%;°::§me'~écLat.>< ysizgma féésé $52 §'é€G¥'§ Em 383$-E: aéaagiy

'=é'§':s;:§"""§:iig%: {ﬁg magma :3? 32% daémaszi: fgem gaiasy wag

 ..._ "2s .§:3g;":é+;9S3;'~ gm ﬁe hag? gség tax a? R§;é!.%3§,;é5§,z'--u ﬁg

 f§§5§ 3235 méamﬁ fmm 52%;" §§i§§'C€'S §5*33;?:?;';=, E: 5 3:":



.. W,mumm~.m»mmav<mm

2%; faééxéf we w::>:,:§€E §§£<e {S cssssééer aAs§set§§aé;F""»%f.h€s

amsszmﬁ awarﬁeé ﬁg fhe Trééurzaf under' the 

deserve ezshamsementf as contenﬁeé by _§He;a _%"r:.;s2d jSefiicér*"  

Coimsei far the eciaimantg. Firgfiy, 'v*a«$ *;MG'§;'£d.:

V

csrrsider whether an ameunt [sf Rs.i;--€}{?,{I2GO;'f. :.2*ﬁ$%<fIeéf 

the "ﬁébunai in respect 0:' Ehe ci"a"'§€r:éf§"fQsf  
£3 iﬁadequate. In the  w§ t::é§V}e made
detailed referenae is the   5% aise ts
the injzsries /  sg;:':';§ér.i4;*'cAij::'_'i;;é§,iV~.§:§§V§éEﬁaimant. We
have a§se  status of the
céaémanigs"f<'ée,:;.§%é§'   Cfear thaé §§3S§)§f€ the
:re&tm€r§?§i-..A:'é%,*é§az'e§'V:'.'§§L?f,q_':hV§"'»§t:§»:§§:3':ar:t in szaséezgg hasﬁtaég

zméer the g2.s:§'a:éa§*':'{:a§f é+;><§'iefé*:s; $13 $3 ienfineﬁ ta & v:zjﬁ§e§

 §é §e""§e§e:3den§ !;§$€§£'§ {}i?E€§'§ fer every

' :j§:sa::saé:%er; §§ §ava;e§§ $3: §f'§§§'§§i.§€§!E§ a
  %°§§"§g.fe3:*.'_ §A5,! E_¥;:§;%;:§--.:.'* §ef§§:2. 'ﬁg aiaimgfsi 5:"; éség affééaazéi af
 Eagi  Srigézzégan gag ﬁg: iéahgngéra §'§§§
 iiééé ggénai émjasg szsgigérggé $3; him ws;,:§§ mi:
 émém is QEE §a::§< ﬁg: mrmaf, 3% W33 am that isfgééeg

 5&2}-gei €G§"§§§'é;}§ aw §§:><:,;a§:%:*g amafé 9%: asme §:a::%:



 V C@§>:é1;3é%:$:a'::%As:*:: ?'gméaréeﬁ E? 3% Trééasﬁai §
 cégém f§§.."§%2;;'~35§£§f eiigwaesi
'V  AA  'ya'  '(E ' E! k , K
L  pa;_:<s.e:r2i:  33°23 '§u::;s;§ mgégca §:<§ez:§€§ g "'§'%:§ ?f"§§é§?§§§ hag

 §.$aEI;€::}i:}'g$®{3jﬂ tawafés medécaf

40

23525335 mater gezzazer is his iegg is regzsged and ma: there ss

{:3 chance 9% resmratéan sf mater pause: in tha-:j§7e;:jé*;._ 'vE'::

Sheri, fmm the matesiéai cu': receré it is  

Cfaimant wouid never recaver and_jv::£>,z,:§a' iisaérﬁtavi.guVf'E'e.:%';.f:§sj

his ﬁfe, the way he is gasfferinég a2.§_uw~;': 
accident, he was haréiy 3'3V__"3:g:ars'"0§}§i;~.._'§7f}é':. §§sa£§§f§ty 'V V

agsessed by the dccter is 90?z'q,___ §'§.§_s'~:i;§t d §§;:af:e§§~v'§that the

ciaémani suffered and "'%z§§§'i§..AC<;s*::§'g::ué*. 'f:s gaffer gem am

agmy thraughouthis iifeq-iii' §S'.a:g§i'r§st«»:.§f§:"§s ba£!<d:'Gp, ﬁr:

am' apfnieni  A35':-§§s314;QB}0O€§,}~ awarded by the
Tribunaf in rle-sVp'{~:c;V"'if;__ef  pain and sufferirsg' £2

énadequzgte _ar§: d, :"'--s:*3.A.;e:é;:~:% >é';::%.§_[§%E§.z{*:;. fhe cfaimani £3 entitéed far

3:": ar:ésuri§--..V_§1fcem§9L'2isa:§'é2;34eif Rs.3,p§Q,3ﬂG;'- £.:?'3d€¥" ibfg

heaég;'~

_ %:a§<e§ iéS :9 £:3¥"$§iS€?' iéze amgagtg af

5'? reggeci sf ihé

"exgenség §f'§CQ:?'?§§ 'ss'%J§"E§§€ £23»

gxgsngeg;



'   A£€és§5%"§e$_ 

41;».

Rs£23,2GC3,f~ agamst ifﬁé €X§§£':S§§ érecurred whiée in $23

hasgéiaé am R.sS§§,§Q§,!- §{§f'fUti1E"E meﬁégaé e:><§Enses,

28; The giaémaat ﬁr; the petétisn has siated"A.'§jiégaé:ﬁ§§:%§  M
the medicaﬁ expenses éncarred by "a;nc_§  

e><§er:se3 which he wsuéd have ta inizgr1'i:£$é2\:ar:§g;..As:a:.Eary"

attendant; diapers, catheter; 

"The fsiiasxaimg arg %:§2.§ ;:1eA:3?'i'i:'a§L'L_:7?;f>'<V§é3{éses:A§:*::::s:"Eeﬁ $3;
the petitioner:  A' '     
A; Hospitalization   V . ..  '$3.5 Lakhs
B. Medicines         1 Lakh
5. Wheel chairsgﬁr;d <.,s:§:g:}   as éakhs

Msnthiy E';<pe_r1.€:fé$ '{V  
A $35351; fé:jas$i5taV§é'i:;%{'»_   §.i3§.§{}%;*}.,
.Dia§e*_r3  " V    8;S@G;"~

3
_%%:f igzgggétég;;ge%;:%:'e--si.;;;;;e.s ::':a,5§0;*-»
§

,Vj'§2§§yé:a:§:§:ap;g.M ;,§$@;-
E} -£%€%a:.s'é§i€2, fsl'§.3xi:?i;<sg{§_}~:ha§:§ aszﬁ @329:
   3,€s§§;»~ W

25%..' Bgféfe we :*@£r::r:2:? gm' féaéérzg $2 {ﬁg éggsgeg ii

- VK;€§€§:.a;%§§'"---éeaég ééeéeasant E} 33333 gvefsrergae is the afféﬁavéi Q:

 +é«:s§¥';§§'® fﬁéé by 'ﬁe ciaimaaig Fmm %:%:§ mniaats thereeff

  §?.§$§e§;' {hat the ::%a;mam':'§ §FE'%§%@3r"€%' hag? Eakerz 3 §§@£§§

égaiéeai E:"'2S§.%i°'é%"%£€ Sééégy wééé': ijﬁéiaéﬁ Eméa §E"%S':§?"§¥'§£§



Carmany C§VEf§§'§§ is E§"%"!§§§'g'§€$ §§'%{i§L3£§§§":§ we siaémasst,

Ea %3§"€§€§ ta ::§a§m the amgmzé 3? csmgeasaiéan 

335$ méicyg the cfaimarzt had gmbmitted an  _
the expenditure incurred by him fcgfhés   
wgufd be reéevant: its reagreduce i::i'-:*;V'e 

frsm hi3 affidavit is knew haw»'m_:;ch éméusjzt :§%'é A.j§~£.a_§;:}a:3nt %

receéved frsm me Insurarzce §'€::jn1;3an3?".%i.¢S_§€sa:ﬁis the
exgenditure incurred by: ---§f2_.i'}m_f§3_r :hé"~€;re__éi§:n:ent am what
were the cansideratjgns fsgazf.:;3.:%avntiagu__ti'}é'V:sv:i'E{§§"'émount. The
reievant      
"1fX.;*..£;e':§?:_ j; »%%';ag..V'T?e;%r;p§':§§}ec§:L§ with Erissson
carj§m:§r§§A<:..?§€fi_f0ni¥§j4V'§:..;i:fd;; _'Erissgén had 3 Gmup
§c:s"*ai_e:%2:  Zi:1_s::;~2;;E2'::£'iéi%..'.V'§31i}{§':;3;,I with Lﬁﬁiteé E§1€§§a
§::s:s:'a%':»:;f_e" VCé;?2éa.;"r§..A:'_"'_.'*w éjszéer this gsaiéﬁy sf

E:;:'<_;'£;§§§:; E ':;,sV_1b%%:§f:é§ my céaéms {Q amétesé Eadia

  '§'§%ui.,,'E.r§c-gsan gfééég wiih 3% S18 efigirgaé bEé§§ éf

 .; £:§=s.§ '::%§§';;é,'r2$:}e*,:.:»ihai E mmrrgé Em" ?":9§§*§§$§§Z3§§@i":,
 sgmggwg iniiiaféy awaséeé me
§%:&.:' ;§,':$::.:§§'é 2,4? §35«£§"sS %":£§E§S §$s:;m%:";§ {$335
ijééﬁ 2%r=§S a i§%'E":§€:'§§§§"';f iéiaé éégabiéitga 5:2?
 "*  §é":$:* E %rz:>u§éz% is iééa §E'§$i§?'§§'%%i:% §5m§§:*:3z'$
 Ezééégé iisai ii $3 a wig: permweni ::§§$a§§%%t3.a
232$ uaééeé India §?"':§%.3§'§f'E§€ Qamgagzgs ihg:
1?%§?'@§% 5 Eeiéer §:; .2"; Egg 2&3: is my E§"7f'%§§G§fE?'



g, '

M?
/'i

at fee': time; iiéfeéréessen €emmeeice:ier:

{geey ef the eeme etteehed} erze eekee me '':e

esedece mere meﬁkei cesééféeaéiee ﬁe ereve that  

my ease 95 e Perzeeaeet Tetaé ﬁieebiiity. iﬁfhieérz

E submitted eii the medécai C€ft§f§Ca*C8S;""'€ﬁ€i'.. "' 

Unéted indie Insuranee Compeiriy 

verify Ciaémsé

Cempeey eeeeinted e deC'i<3_%:-....{>;2 A%'~%aVrshae"..V§*4i";:._j"-
Shah, {piease sefer te the %efte:* .frem"'LIh_ite£i Vi

énciée Ineefance eemeagy L'-3._1."V3uiy Zﬁvﬁyi;

ettached fer perusal} %e.e_§ee§<.u*'e:' V€;a;eeV__whe
checked my 'g3'§1x{sicaAE'VV':G:$§iii:_i'eA;je Eéent a
report an  ;;i§3'2'e§é_:.§cei'§. C5:c>{"V':V.cIi1._:i:e:~2 i:e %:'i"1e United
Ensurancé%C:?iﬁ1éé5e;$e : "{'f?if%'..':i*-F.§?:"' u§~"jveb  2002, the
Eeeure':nf'{:s:--.  "'--%:§j'f::$rr:éei:i"'*  emeieyei',
E§'§<:fse.en-.  page en additienai
emeeei§;'s';VE8';.§2:?§%$"'En eﬁdiiiee :9 the

ife;'"z3g3_e:°er%g"'%ei':e§V.Siieabéeéizeeét ef ReeSZ;5;Z32:L

{;§ ':'«:eE§3§: ef thVe'vv§-e-iier ee§m§%5:ed fee eeeeeeé
._ » jw-?1_V%e§"s_   eéeieeie tee deém
 . £1-:?i>__.%?ge'sE38s:3§g'<é'év2':~;"3X Z/Q: lfﬂif eeééey me,

eeeeee;§e;ee.e;e': 1 $491: 1;;

~ Veieeee szeie ihee ties eﬁeére wee eeéziéee

" Aeefeeueéeég Greee Eesereeee ﬁeiéey ﬁe: Ezéeeeee
"'._%ée::i'e:§?:E: the eeme %I"§SL£f'5E'%€§ eemeeeyg, iéeiieé

V%  , jeeie Eeeereeeeg E? E3 eereééeieg ie see the: iee

ééeéiee Eeeia Eeeerenee iiereeeeyg ﬁe eeee":

eietieg iiézeiz 9; ée iereeereras eeeeeeg."

The Limited En§3«ée»1--.§%isuré':j.:e~. «. "

 



~«%g"

$4

In {he C?"§S§~%:<3§"§'§§f§at§0i"%§ ihe ciaimani aémittsd that he

Qid :29: ;:':§"SC§£§€$ any éacumsnts befwe the ?§§.b;EL;.;j:;§._

regaréiag the céaim maﬁa by him V gmdfer 

insurance Scheme,

Thaugh it £5 net dear as is u ';j:de§*[:%25hiés:%:_.'"%'§é5<iS :§%3e'*i,_[_'A

amass}: was grasrieé ta the>tEa.§§§1an't-.._s;:':::§erT» :%§9;év.{f5;fgz§§§%

Insurance Scheme; ii: amears  the
entire amouné which ihé»  incéur 2%: fig
ireatmant frgm the; €t7afe~  he was
recevereci  reasen why the
claimant   'frébasrsaé erégénaf
documené.  far meéécai exgenseg

§i"':§ exgenéeg %%?:C:;r-re§.:'§:;§}i'i'§--é'$2 §:03§§taE, Thé £§a:mar2$:;

fizszxzeeaiegfg; '<:;?§a§se :"2:2: %;§ géaag dgéaiég 3? the €:%§§m mwe $3;

 .%:%;réf:«.:;é€d§%fé§j'aé>.._Vﬁrazgg Egzsagzaaﬁe ﬁchﬁmé, Eva: ié:%

3§?§§§§:é:;:5_§  Fﬁﬁféﬁ any aétemﬁ $53 gfiaii f::§t§'%E§'

";:;f§rr:":'§€*§§:<2"§f:'vr'és§e¢'€ iherésf m Ehﬁ £r@§3----éXa:T§%z:at§@§"a

E: a};:2'f§:e§rS fmm mg absergatéaﬁs maée in $26

 guégmergi éiﬁaé ihaggrgh a swig wag: Q? the $5
  _§js7¥3z;ve§ 33:2 Manigai ééaggiiaég Eangaiweg ﬁaieé 2€::23'2GGS

 "£5333 ;:2§§€:€§ 9?: raaerﬁf tbs i§§%§"%"§a§E'{ ﬁéé mi: gag E: mariégé in



45

evidence, Tee Tréeeeei has ebserved that :29 meteeeis €31

swear: ef tee eéeim fer meeieei expenses 

exgenees érscurree whiie in the hespitai wet.e'_ efe'ee'd._T'ezif.

§"ECG£'§; The Tribunal; however haying ee'::s§:j---eired"'ef¢*ere}: 

faete em circumstances of the 7,easeA,ein"eeg*;_az<t§&:aE'af;e'---.At'§*s1e:

eeeratéen zmdergene eg the.eée.§_manf'-aee:reefzéi§e«nt"ts§ker: 2 L'

by him, awardea Re.1,OG,OQG;? "te§;vaV§ds  vexpensee
eed Re*23;2CIO,z'= tew'e---refs; _Ae'f%<5e:':eé'3 '~ificsgrred whfie the

eiaimant was injhe h:>sp:i'i:a.§,*- _"Iiir'1_'<.-:¥'.A.'«::;Ee;E'eiw."c's".r*:f: was in the

hespitai for  It€;%§§V.tEj4:;:s--ei'ee'Fthat the daimant

was not seféeue. gLz;4sL§5}i'.§,:% «hi_5$ e§e§m befere the Tifbueal
iewereazi med;EA{:a§.--vexee:z$es'a.eé tee exggenses iecerred whee
ie tee he§'s;.p§'z;e%s' §VeV%!§e::§"'e_f"€?:e egeeeet received by him

eeeezj~%.§'2e §?oVe';:a§e$'e;ra§§ee §:%:ee'2;e§ Eéieeeéeg Eee:  zeee:

    §§2£<§%_eee ':He g§*e::§ eey eemeeeeeiien aeheteeevee
  =:§Ei§§'§"E fer eseeieeé exeeeeee eee eke
< exee':-%.._e5§i:.;'%eéﬂééeemee eshiée ie the eeseiéeii The ereeeei ef
 '"-..Ve'e:eeee.ee~%:%ee ewefeee eeéer ieese heeee %e se: eeieeé
  '§%;e ?:%eeee§§ $3": {jig §$§§£§%€}:A§§' ﬁeeseazee meee ee

 ie ewayeéeg §,e,f§8§,§{ZiG§---- eeiy eeée: {he heae feture

" "meeéeeé exeeeeee. E: ees eeree ee aeeege éeeé: ee zeei eeaze



mm

, .,  »vymy»wk\<wA\N¢<)INNVQM'«W»N"k\'N

A», W;

'$33?
''?A;\

 mg ::§a§'%:3 fgr

is €:a§<& ireaimémt zhrsaigheest hig fife. it 555 5'1§£'§§"'%€§" cgma

3:: §'€C§?"{§ tézat in View §§ the éngury is sgirzaé ssrd, §'¥'fv§.i.§£1§%:ii}iV.§';€§,'
there :2 3 iikeéihoaé 0? arepgéng am of se.;?é:*a1§L.. :§':§é'erV_"''_'T "
prebiems such as winery iraci infeetiifm, ;>'resV?4s":;::9;=»*,- S:sr¢:~E$, --»

spastiﬁétyf sgagmsg i'2E§€;'tQ§:)i€: os§;§f§c;:é%§'én, '§<_§é:2§;j§5 

biaddar stanes, kidney ;§§"v(}_:fvf:"§.§3:r11S 
Sﬁmifarfyf he wéh' have :53 E £uxr___:;é:;;:_'§f§~r};g §>€$§*;::.<i.ii:*z:§;re far
regiacemgnt Qf whee§V»:;;$§:f attendant,
diapers; catheter ,«' ggf£ X 

The   grayed far
Rs£8Q§GOGv,/_§-M"1f:3.§:::;=~%.%}=.§;:§§  Qther gcaessariesg

Rs,1Q;G@{%,,f'~  gaiary of attemant;

  R3,..S;§G{1%;'~ f5r_»4_jﬁ%avpé§\§S;'-A4gs;E:§.;~G%Qg'«~ my mgrath fer gatheter
;' g5? gig'§é1:.%ﬁ§£§:2é3«V._ §%2é &:R3§2§§G§;'~= gs: mmih %.':2:«::ar§5

 §§§§¥"?$i i§'%€ ﬁrager far the gfafesaié

§mé;n;»ﬁ-£935  hag aszazgrééé §;,§gSS;C%§§;'»- agaénsf

.?'e;i %:i':;r€ meéégaé exgﬁmég gm %i?;§3,,8%g$§§g'~

 :"%%§';._.i'§%%._§%_"%é%:éa§'":t €§":a;*§s§g '§'h§z§ :3 me désgagta Em: éégg

 z:_§a§r§a..aé€2.:"é«;s;s§§ :&ga:§:'s 5:': aiiezsdani thzsagheaé his Eéfsg

   "%"_%2?s"'":"':*§é:,s:2a% améer 33$ ézeazj hag awaféeé the saié ammgszi

 ?;s,Z;3§§;'<~ §€€ raga??? g3 aiiaééani <:§'2a;'§$5 sag E?
.  §



» «vlvm/n1uA1D<w%\WM6MVl\WrW16n\\

<>3§

Q5/"'

yearg §§i'e €X§€€?{3¥"1i'g' and, tg/$2.33; granieé {he saéé a:":f:.§_:;:2t

f::>s* the §€i'iQ€§ 3? E6 3f§§i'§ haazéizg regaré tea his 

refsxzani time. in my ggésaém, the amazznt  '
gar mcnth fer the attendant is toe meager: j'Tﬁé'=éﬁ::éh:i§;f2t".. K

gemapg wezﬁd have is ass§st the 

éiapers and Em evacuatim: 0f'V.i§c:ss§{ei 
Having fegard té the ngture  3% "p€%'.i§,G,,€:i§ wazzfd
gver agree :9 renderv   :G be an
attendant of sum*;3§;tée;j~i:"'f<3f::'§§:§f:2.;§31Q'L?;}"I--  manih. Thg
amount of   when it was
awardeé i's:¥:§:§Vf:_.»§uff§c§er:*: ever: wday,
in any  factor mtg aéﬂﬁijnfg the

ciaimagéi wie?:5.§_'g:3*  Rs.S,§QG/» gar manth 50:'

_ aha §t§%.;§%&9:2;a§.:":t§ §§mV:":§§§§:g,v far ﬁagersg Camgiéeréﬁg the: {he

 =.£§s;_§:*z*::.3n7:; égéziéi iifsfaxzg :@ age ggecéai gféagers maée "fa? §5i,é§§S

a:':'%§i§._:.§:_§.« %'§*:é%3_?é..§ r:3€;é'%:ﬁ $33 dsakg ﬁg waaiié $6 %§§'i§f§%é fa;

V'%?3,§,2§§§;i}f~'--~ §,:3. Evan Fm €§§§"§€E;€§"' ,5 geé j §%'E§ﬁ§C§?'%€§ ﬂag
 §%:a32.2§§ §§ eaéiéééé is: Rg,3§,§§§/~§.me 333*

  am; far §??3j§§§§Z§?§§'a§'g' 322$ massaga. Es*a§$f§r

 V  ' '«§S":é;%?:§&§ chaér am @:%2§? gccessmag 55$ C§%"E=C€%'§"':§§; ':a§<§;'2:;

 Qfém £§§'%S§§§%'a§j§§i'% thai 233$ samg %éé?§€€§ {ﬂair ézsgiié mi $33:



 

 


.6

;?%m§M¢?
ﬂ



 " 5:: _§:5;;a%@%§;::%:%%;..5'} éggs $5 é'5:%§é?2§fEe$

 ._£j:s Lo@:§"§ef §:%?:':s'é§§;::,"§::3%
. . ,_ gig .;f'f':,;%:.:ré mats
 4§§«.;§_'zan:é';§eréa:§@§: géargeg

.'  §:as§»vard:3 §§§§'"§ am? sufféring

'ﬁ}3"§%.ég?1C3i.,i'§'j 2:53 :§a§:te§s:€'$ Séfeg in my ggimea, ihe gfgémaat

wéaié Es ezztétied far ;§§.SC3;§§S;'~§ "%"§":u$; 

§g.§,5§,Q:::0/« gm. {Rs.5,§e9;> X 22 :><: 15:;  '
iihe céaim far the saéary ef att.e;:£i.af:t;i .Vfé§4,"Z§;E$;'i¥{Zi§Q;;L'.  V'

{Rs.2;aaa;» x :2 ><: :6) far ésapérgg L%<:;%5,%§f5,Vé':ijGzT§:'T1i.

(R3.3;§GG';'--/x X :2 x: 15} fer ca%V%§}=';:~:§r /'A'gje~§:_»;'w éné
RS.52;88,$G8;'*- {Rs.:,§a§g~ X 3_%%A2. lg~%:5}.,_§s:~%ph--;«s.;a::é%erapyg
massagg and exersise: cf gxgarig
T3233! the cfaémaéiéf7t§§iéé Vitﬁsééé.22,§8;{}8Gf-

pigs Rs.E0,GQ Qf--.»,,  §'h-ais" ;é:ir1 :i'.mV:1ﬁar' accesseréésg

 s::am§eﬁ§aE§Gn
is) the :::§2;:§§1'92$'n%, ~  Li? 3? ?;'%?8 C{3§'??§3E§"'35§§§é}§'"§
awaréaé :33:  heads is as f§§§{m5:
u A Qgg ?;f§Q;§§§f"
 §§;  f::5§ :§§ fs 3;3§f§a@z~
V . 39: asééa
§g,§i};3Q@/w
iﬁfﬁﬁﬁé'

3,§§f§§Gf"

 faiggég s:=':e§%€a§ QXQGESQS

éﬁfgiéegééaiaé C§'§&§"§€§,, é§§;::€:'§!



 

21%

Catheiéa, gef, medicézzegi eta} 22,.G8,§$§;"= __

£2} Ems af inmme éuring tseatméﬁi Set asigjé  '

5'} Future expenses mwarés wheeé   =
Chair & other accesseries  "

3"} Medicai e><pense§ incurred  
kﬁxpenses irzéurreé whiie mm-e;_   2    
hc:spi%:a§   '=.$_¢ii:.a*:--idé_E:

Yhug, the appea§:::<_§é._  Wejgirect the
appeilant and respende§:t..r§§-_.4  anci severalfy
the compens'a:j:ii§'f§.1'éif :t'c32_i*;ether with costs
and at  Rs,13,5o,0Qe;'~,, Le.
minus  .§ n_'. gaspect 0? the daims fer
fagturg mvxéiééﬁsgiVex;3é%;:A&:§:; pragpgcts and axsenéiture

m be A§::~:*a;§*:'e<§ %;z3;:z¥a':?§§"wheE§ chair am sine? a£:;:e§sG§*§e§

 V.  saga}, €:23r:*: 1329 gas Q? geifiém

%§.§.% 't§r:é'T'§;.§':s;&.v"é:€"je:§:%:ga§ gaxgmeréa E:3§"§S%" 3? éigméggiag the

'  §§t§§:§::_:": g g=::3£§?:§ b§g iéée Tribzsnai ggaéngi §'%§§Gi'?§€§3€ rm: ﬁg
"  §'i,*' ~.__é:°;§;f%m*2éa;i:" "éhe aggaiéagzi beéag as": §§""§S§.§?'E¥" £5 éigeated is
 T:§§igi?'%:%:_é*§' eaiérs §S§'§"3$%E'?;§§EEGf": §¥§'§Ii'§§§§ by 33$ §%'§§§" *@s'§§§"%§;i'7:

 ~a,§.é:ér§§§ gf fem" §?'3f:t§"%§§'§S 553:3 E$d&Y:



. ,...»--,--..».«.'.«»u.w,>~2>V»Av/ﬁrm

T5335; tha aggéai am ma crass

**§§}E<'.?*C%Gi"E§ are gwrtiy

 

am
#5..
S
G
C
9
Nu
fm
n
m
Q
.3
U
3
.$
.n..
L...»
$5.:
8

Sak



 

we

D383 8; BS1}:

14.03.;2€312 MFA§NG.§873/'36

PC;

Learned Sewer edveeete fer respeeeent m::;_f§$'

ettentien Ea the operative portion of the order,V.efn;jV:~A.é;j{;;bn~§'§ig.,u 

that threugh inadvertence e directévee"we_$"4._is:suATe"d._ui:e"'V"§h'e

eppeﬁant and respondent nee instead'.ei5':§feé,pe[ﬁd,Ae:'2i ee":5;..vte._V
gay jeimtiy and Severeiiy the amdé1_fé"{....ef eempe::eTei§<§;j';*v~ww We have eereeed the..,_erig§.n'e'i- §fj*;eVVr':'eere:1&e:j'r:': "ti? eppeai and Se else the titie efj:3d'&§,1g"een9Ee__y§i§.§?§Ivic§;i':.§§<{es;».:_that there are oniy three respondents in thee.;ipeVa--i.,&Vv»Re§pe:ﬁ,de'ht 91053; whe is ewner of the vehiC%§'e4;'&fgef¢ei_e fesp%;r'1"ije.§it.V:e'e'."4eefore the tribunaf. Under the ciréen€e':':eVti:fes, "{'i;E1e',e«ﬁeéfetive portéen of the judgment ee"'eer%eete'e~~--ie reed eeseeneee: neg? in the péaeie ef' s%Veé';':'e..:§e*e'zi"*€.e:'ree,'4'; After Cerryéeg cut the Cerrectieef ih'7ev.._e ffi:e 'ee eeeyj eeriiféee megs' ef éhe jeegmeeme Ehe4'teTe.%:%eev; .' " '--'ie:.:_!""
E 3 is %~i'e*§__ 1: g" .
Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court
