State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Regional Provident Fund Commisssioner vs Hargovindbhai S Patel on 30 March, 2011
\\//~ N " at wfla; vi.u2e/zoos a. til 2'1sou'L--1_<». ulfimwa $5 $131242, ullhsra és :>:&<>'I---m5§'s21rt, m[?¢u4[?_t[& Mew, tsvaaéat 21%, Qzmatqta.
2. 2»t't$1:a tsnzmé, ant 2»'tsLG--a uiéla, waist, 731'~1l€-Q2505 uifitsva és 2»¢'1='i-1t25o's21vt, L 42131 213, :§°zrgra <»fia._t, ?2tH€.l<u8. [Emil Pm?-H evftféiamtzs zftzwéa <»{l/Re, :e=u<.>m aleuqél, C{%?tLGt 21$, Hméq-10:2 23% 2+ea<~2:1.v1'a %§a am, cLL.a:_~L--s12.$, @.2»+.=«LaLqLa. 1«L['ct.fi=1cLL€1 _g@Etl"&rrq:-- ['qcLLé1 rtaé :-- Fq. «men 2»u21.g;.-im u[?t[3l.Cll£'.1 rt2?::- E1. ufitfitfitafl Fa--'t2mm5 vizua a'mL;
L .=»1.2:tt»g,°ert, veufita Q10'-l 2¢.°g'1n{1 mm L .3.a3a=a, arm gen ;-- all o{l.=b't2¢.°er'u>£1, am Lm$c't :
'L was dam Fi€LL2'€L 59m, ?2t'°i'alC{LE. mi fifllltfi «Lwa/0.9 H1 dl.Q(:-
'2§--O(: «u 21% 3% gwafl rum: zmvl 2»1-mra gm 2u=ucuvLL2»1 was awn miat-{1 saw-<tu §§6Ul emrfl bu. wfla am 2%.
2. fcaslzfi rflvli =;;,%'°1 ggn am 279.
iszmélrft 2»u ::2'1tLL2=, vbgv. szcum azucl 2%..
zu=~LLqLv1L2:_{12A vtlél 2% sum C<t1'i'1_t Qtdaooo was 211 ML emucualt gscl 61 cuflvt Qyilrtt ufct cm ate astru <2-u°xru 2% 1121 32/9 "j,°¢'--<>1 e',srfl--?+ ewe' M21 azu zm-u.cu.U1L 3541 bull. ' %4.L"iL€uU1LM\LQ;{ Ctcscas all was ru smm. ~$t"lL*[1 2391 921-1 =u<{ls éswuvll 25H <8' wt 91 'K263 ail 2+mLcuuu M1142 gscl a+_'L zysflvu um mi 12 est-u ésrflz-L cwa M21 zgscfl ml.
amLcuuLL2»1 Mina am s2'1u.Lé1-% 2L'_D.'L2O3'o' &=+u M2 stéwi cstcufia Q 221% & am gsqefl rtl.<:SOX «[1 sin 39 24% a aw %' e2<uc'l°a? °i°b'°t °tL§§1 zécfl 25% ELQRXBO cu.2¢.-1-03 an 'HLHLCLLUIL $2'1zu£1+1 Mina 3&4 c'-Ll @2311 um cui °zm3.2 zvla cm: gwca 2H ma;-zoos an Q21 av./a 'j,"2s'°1 L-iivtz rgscl an --2;I}[1~'iL um qbi 'R astru as-[luv czwz' M91 gacfl mwl.
2u.mqL<:u2»1 amlci "tl°'[1g3ct élcu 2»+.«'1 ?2tL?l5.<'L o1e2sL2'1rtL 24291 at $21€u=éH zuka Hm2{1ss vuavu cwmzrtt ztdsiooo 2»t+'L ML sflqta vt=irtL 52.L\3.{3OOO gal.
3. s2"LqL€1v[1 $2'12«uev[I gsm .e§lsc1 2:141 Q 3:, silqtfl isilqtertt 5135 atzsaem °mL<1c--t mam 2.8, a§. sflmélvtt saw 'j,°b'°i clbfl 25sc{1w'Lva 2z1«2a2«{1q2'1'oL £slu.H'l cm-9-ac: all d.l.».9-.6-C1-L {,}fl---'Ll mu. eyfl «Emil 32d! é.dL. <s:flqLé1«tL §%L*i °;!,°b*°t «ml u1.$s alas *[121C:1"[I1{'Q{ Ltlcflosrt 2:133 --'1(:1R M 2»7LéslC3-'8 ri.aaa.¢8>n:as/use en eLbt<--u. ma 22H &Hr{1 eizsmzl 2»1sL2»'1s cu.e--c»c:1L ail 3!.Hé:L"a' cm 521 élfla 2»t+1 email M-K 2H cmm suiatz-{ 3125 am Mmcum 2»ur1c+ vtél 29H mu olzstqiaz aa oia .£vQCLl.Ht Lucia 2441 aim om sia 61 w.uC3 €;=rm sum $1011 was 2n was ru smm 2:191 mcfls sswu 2mzqL.uLLv't cqi °b"iL sztrlet rtél wk am étvtt-'oil ma cm mé 2mucu<Iu2»1 u'L.--$.s zlsavfl sscw 3 2:1 ma saw 'L?! on {1;'b'¢>l .3125 #5 sm.%2+2r{1 stziqtél 3ieL rtafl 2: 2~[1.L[1.2{1.rfi sew 'HO 33°56: 311$ uoLc--_u £'fl":lC'L r-tafl.
qggti sitmél ozagurl 232 3: cmlru LL1.£ssv[_1 23% étcu mé awflbl {M -Mt:
0tfi-'t 2+.L=ucu<I1L+1 ?2{U3L<i W1 .2w~LLcuu1L2A émri 22412 l»tL'1<--l at-r1 aH.LqL°LL2»l 2L\,.csox «ft 21.3 cu.23-=L-o3 rft Emru 1-uctmt Hlsétci 08¢ %°5Lrg+,.2oo3 -1 came: 2»w+cu.=u 3a{t5{<:L vusfl 22:9: clcfl 23H mm H<r1qnu>L 23% ..%2ctLRrfl£§1 wig. ve}2[1 .c'm'1221 21LHLq1uur"t cum-2-Q3 ru 21%' Im w»{H nuL2+ szcu °&>'U§L 32% mi :1 2»tg;2%mL~'1 2uHLqL.ULL2»1 am °2{CLL°i 2»wflv'L °er=9urlc1 3: =Lr:w_--c.s Ht udaooo, ae.cs--¢e HI udaooo, 'L<:cs~(:e Hi mdzooo ma a<:cc';--.a:
Hi ?.L\3.8ODO 2»+w'L °LG<:.C2~--<:'t lu ?.LQ.cooo 91131 gm zxwzaooo g{,sqqLHL wuclci 23: Wt' 2oo2~oa =11 2L\_,.c9OX =¢3cLcu=u 3:tL<lC'.t alas ecl sits °3,3<{¢LL'j, <>us'1 zéq, rtefl.
qgwi siltuzfl °areLL€L 25 is an H291 &9»f'L hem dl.3-X-O3 rd mm zmucuutfi avid aw oz:-gucla 3» 'Ct<5C1'l'C-.8 HL 110.3000? 2L<2[_1 Hlsefl zvmlei A <»u--c»m H13 23> MA 61 ouoiét 2uHLcu<Ju2>'+. 3«c[1 ila 2»u 23% 525 blrsm 325 am alga .2»wlc~t Q 8: °b"§Ll<{rtL rtafl 2491 €'t2»t1=3t Iuatgs C2? M'-tl--¢lLU1H wla 2% am mail 3125 zivél <72: M1.
s:21v¢e'1vLL "2f'~2lL--<{<{L °3;'2§°t c't2x:1«1L aeaa all was ru am e2uLLrmL "8 smm iswu 31'u.cmu =2»u;c1<»L 2,?) cl 2491 mciw $.LU1l?:fl ML 2+LHLcu<r1_L=A %i%%LL 'mall qeiaa. wen 2491 c'L2[1i mesvm 11%-a «ma mu wt .2mucuuu2»1 &°H bullet 1211 2:t--v'L 2+'.22LL utalzfl azucfl 23% qegi Qcu {L uoteu cflhu 6 cl W1 «M-3L M *2: °mL9.L5.«L2'1 siet 4.211 <1 3112 HQL amm zumqxvu-3L rm (Ma 0841 3125 "5 °zrcu?»t WQL 2mLcuU1L2.:1 c'tH.r't 2:tLfi.a wan. qgwi isflqtél WLLCI 2?» 5 amt bu 'ivftrtt 2»tg2{uLv'1 ulés sfimi mmquru 4:1 2:11 :2u=~LLqL<m +'L.2 -{ °a'2r>2'1v.u°LetL 4 cwri ilrflé ?2tlU..<LL °b"€LlCLClDiL wclca. AH acu Ml 2{LHLcu<ILL2é1 aaa ML Halal GU?-L.Lf'fl °zs'L§'L szcurl ma QL\3.3OOO ~{1 ah mé zrfl $3.30 2LsLe{H wet szcmu 2:ucLa'L am we °6'CLl'-'i W10 24% aca 3125 isé ctutzlet v12[1 3: 219.3000 r[1 efm 22{3'L um 3125 rtlua 3~2cLL-m weld 420 °8'a[l ML atmqtuttrfl OM12 <»1é2s12.'1 earl vw{1gm :a'+cu mmctt mm as, Hiatcfl ML éilltté. emet szcmu ?2{l.<1C*t $0. *5'. 2+mLqLuu?'t vftéla <»t°e'rc»;L Mr': .2+r=~ucuU1L2:1 wera uesvl °o'C{L--°.t 2»ut[H °2>'§'lt<1C~t 3, zmuqwu (12523 ans-3-03 ru 021% 8m-11 aund. °25'<Ll€'t rag 32.o.L=~.u mclca. 2?; Mr': 2mLcu<Iu2»1 Emru %<{L<'tHL <sr2;'1v.Lé1r(1 <:2'1qLe?+Li °a'Ieuv+L gwot bu silzuél clmt amt elcugt, angst zmcmu 2»u--c1c1 Q av} °2;"9lL'--=1 2% 3; <r2'124.ué12»1 °z? ah 'Q2 2LQ.3OOO c--[1€L<--L M ct'--lL3cL zucj, 2?» 24% 20 cm uéatrtt isirl atluql H3 an s§.
qgni eumcuuu °zrv;>u<l 23> 3:, «2i%izu«[1 mm mé 2»t1$'12[1=+a c{1sc[130a2r[1 szquu zvuclet 0125 91 =3,°m -02>' :2>u0LU1r[1 .a«L=+o[1z'1 am at} =2.»H 'r1Hru team uuxieex eilcum 9&5 vmfl '1 eitcuefl 52%-Ltélrfl 521412 122 szcu <x|2tLcLcm~LL 2»uc1<:+_ Q. mu H291 simtél tqm cu;.<Lx-'12.-05 ru 21% wuclvglvfl Hiouall szcfl. 22%;: 3:1???) 2»uu<:u=+L ?Ifl<3.C't 253 Oahu gcw am &%dL<1°A'1r[1 4t'L--=.>ua[1 szqmt 2»uc1<+ 29. H. 2»t=u:.1'1 Mat 2% gm Quziwl ?»tG%{L2~[ 320. 2»111_c+ra cLQ$%[1 ail ML2.?i.-lté2 FcL2Asq13sé acflaft am. élzwtlvsva d2$?fl _r1'i'il HBRE4 2~_[1 Fa-3L2L<HL25 Iixzttd acflcfl aia. q
9. .fi»{--vtFcaqLeL2~ua es'l_:m. 2A 25 3; e:s2"L2_u.2f1 --Q{L*tLCLlU_1l"_lL am 0125 zwucuvu Mrfl elcu 2>uLLcu aqua mom saga szcum =2>u<1<1.
fizmél .25sc.{1u.=lra '<?»1*'ib:>.!:Lw.H[ dL0.i+s-wee an 0-¢-cu zyfl '1'L321 $?.dt ecu. :s21zwé1=1.L "-fl.?21i=.5b15lC3'8 -rams/1200 HLc--[l% Q61 om séc-1 2»-% asmmzlvi gal am. % .0. wlfiaré wflanx asruél {gal Gatclet 29 % 2'12~u1vsva/ $2'1q1sfH 04103 {flail £LL?.L*U gem-ax éacn «mam-q_[2.L~1'iL butt 13 23>. 5flzu--é12»1 10411-as all 2003 {gen 3125 dam 3% viefl 24% 142491 cum 2003 Hi rL8?.l?. (mil? 3%.
5i1;m'Lrsra~11 sazsa zooé wt awn '°{LctLHL mt 233+ 112 3:1 firs émvta 21a<+='¢ra Q2 gsfia vxzué 21e~u7Lrsré same zoos Ht gm M-R ézhta-% mquqletwi bun 'i3 Q Mr} I."ce..a12=1 wlél am we 5% 8».
c. 2»m'L 2?L11<%var1_L saw zuel ma mu rtzfl, "arm. fleulvsvartt w.Lc1.L=u zéa zsml féalbt 2AQc~Lva zmcu «it eh, 2»+.l'vtttfimcu eh M.-E a--u 8R'§1 :--Z(,h'1--fl"$*'.8")t um gsqtflci ~'t em «I 5135 2415 aélssetrt svélrg, ovauq. aefl eues 23221: *~lLQL*fl saamx-zk €16"! 2wLH=«L[2L«t1 bum vtsctl wafl &gi, 24°} aztcllbl 29'12»1.
cs. zmlévavit gem 302501, 2m'1«s«2 352cm; s-,2cu.c1°er 'i(:61{--é.'~3 rfl zuavu Mara ml mom 08 eedtvlvxl gru elcuiail $1231 M81 23 as am rtél °m.L-*2 séqzdt zzdtdéal zhulrsvé 2% am '>8 FcL$12=1 33.LC{l ctil} $2'1=4.La~_tL %m%{r-Ht bflél €191 Fqztmatt @501 easel 2»1il<:%ravfl F<R7?k1f. iiggz am.
<10. 2201 zxlllararu saw anal 'aim amt vtzfl. st?-temt Lmtfim ['2+£tL'Lci. =3,°5<>t vswu scweruu £%dL<1°a' an (191 aeaxclvx ag szcu °z:1252»1. °o?1 azruchr rue: séa e,'m*d'L H1 [Md wucll °o'1--2S2:1 vz? zalld-2 wla rtefl aefl 2»1s1cL2{ ssrézra ;1 am 2:1-3L --a~1cmu ma mafia am 6. .
'V1. muiz 2"t2~1+1rsré Ifitcuru zweirnu 23 séet z2<uc1°o?'Lvt1 2»1I1_c--t-2 azmclw gztcu mm ultwz gig rtzfl «M1 Fq.a12=1 Idea 2% M R-Lzuzvgu $501 cw-4} law; gm siaz Q. =12. (misc: 242$. 2»{--& ma fémznru g.s=1==u ezctau szcu 'rt[°ld.l vtiafl 24% 4121 9'jfes'°t gsu 3212A 2912A.
: g 341 :
<1. '2»nfl.<¢ *'L'--~L2»9/O(: wan rLL°i§% szqmt bail 291.
2. . was d8?.R Fwcuzet 512%, wtatqts, 2:31 isiltua rmaz/os °u c.u.2c/X/oc: ru 2192: 3% gm qeuai 2mcm+L 2»u.c1 Q.
3. Mtfla-LL mi 2401 5125 gsn szcmu Qzilqcfl «M1.
X. zalfm-é 2»L~3mL $"fl-'2L*L'i,l 08 51.25 23% Wu mclrei em 9L as». cm «H1 (3142 arm 21% ceuvml 2»1.sLC3va Q41 #15 :»111c3LrarrL vu=+r't1 ahfldravtt Fq.2?-'L;scfL3a2flv'L :2»tmq'7L.
wmqte.
rtL.30-8--"L'L WW:
( %..Z<.a5,a<?¢ ) ( o{11=»1=+,L°es"f=[1 ) ( &"9.2»1.2:u.-gyzrt ) Law 2104 rzufits aw.
/ /