Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

"4.4 The question for consideration is whether the appellant was engaged in rendering technical services so as to be deprived of the benefit of deduction u/s 10A. However, from the materials placed before me during the appeal hearings, it is noticed that the appellant is engaged only in developing software. It has been held in the case of Infosys Technologies Ltd V JCIT (109 TTJ 631) that where an assessee is engaged in the development of computer program it should not be regarded as being engaged in rendering technical services but in the development of computer software. The appellant has relied on the decision in Zylog Systems Ltd (ITA No.1138/Mds/2007) to drive home the point that expenses incurred with staff in a foreign branch do not relate to rendering technical services as it is connected with the object of developing computer software. In view of these decisions, I hold that the AO erred in reducing the expenses mentioned above from the export turnover to restrict the deduction u/s 10A of the Act and direct the AO to allow the appellant's claim in this regard".

8. From the above Para of the ld. CIT(A)'s order, it is seen that he has followed the Tribunal order rendered in the case of M/s Infosys Technologies Ltd Vs JCIT(Supra), but in this case afterwards, the matter travelled up to Hon'ble Karnataka High Court and as per the judgment reported in 34 Taxman.com 91(Kar.), Hon'ble Karnataka High Court has restored the matter back to the file of the AO for fresh decision after examining this aspect as to whether the expenditure incurred in foreign currency was for providing technical services outside India. In the present case, the Bench wanted the ld. AR of the assessee to furnish the agreement/contracts with various buyers as per which the assessee was required to send its employees to the place of customers to find out whether the employees of the assessee company were sent to the place of customers in connection with supply of software to them or whether the employees of the assessee company were sent to the place of customers for rendering technical services and then only the issue can be decided as to whether such expenses incurred in foreign currency for deputing the employees of the assessee company to the place of foreign companies was in connection with supply of computer software or were in connection with rendering technical services but he replied that no such material is readily available. The ld.CIT(A) has also not given any clear finding about this factual aspect and he has passed a cryptic order on this issue by saying that as per the materials placed before him during the appellate proceedings, it is noticed by him that the assessee is engaged only in developing software but this is not coming out as to what was the material placed before him and on what basis, he came to this conclusion. Under these facts and in view of the subsequent judgment of the Hon'ble Karnataka High Court cited by the ld. DR of the revenue having been rendered in the case of CIT Vs M/s Infosys Technologies Ltd.(Supra), we feel it proper that this matter should go back to the file of the AO for a fresh decision after examining the factual aspect as to whether the employees of the assessee company were deputed to the place of foreign customers as a part of the agreement with them for supplying computer software, but if it is found that as per the agreement with foreign customer regarding supply of software, the assessee was under