Kerala High Court
Malabar Medical College Hospital And ... vs State Of Kerala on 4 March, 2020
Author: S.V.Bhatti
Bench: S.V.Bhatti
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE S.V.BHATTI
WEDNESDAY, THE 04TH DAY OF MARCH 2020 / 14TH PHALGUNA, 1941
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D)
PETITIONER:
MALABAR MEDICAL COLLEGE HOSPITAL AND RESEARCH CENTRE,
ESTABLISHED BY SREE ANJANEYA MEDICAL TRUST,
MODAKALLUR,
KOZHIKKODE-673323,
REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORISED SIGNATORY.
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.SANJAY
SMT.A.PARVATHI MENON
RESPONDENTS:
1 STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE,
SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695001.
2 KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES,
THRISSUR,
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR-680596.
3 MEDICAL COUNCIL OF INDIA
(PRESENTLY GOVERNED BY BOARD OF GOVERNORS),
POCKET-14, SECTOR 8,
DWARAKA,
NEW DELHI-110077.
* ADDL. R4 TO R91 IMPLEADED
4 DR. ANJALI ANIRUDHAN,
ANGELIC VILLA,
KOTHARI JUNCTION,
CHATHANNOOR, KOLLAM.
5 DR. ANJALI V. SREEHARI,
CHERUVANCHERY,
KANNUR.
6 DR. AASHIK J.S.,
NIZAR MANZIL,
VILAKUDY P.O.,
KOLLAM, PIN-691508.
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 2
7 DR. ABHINAND T.,
THARAYIL HOUSE,
KOLLAM, KOYILANDY-673307.
8 DR. HUDA,
PERUMTHOTTATHIL HOUSE, PAZHOOR P.O.,
MALAPPURAM.
9 DR. ADRA K.P.,
KOSALI PARAMBATH HOUSE,
CHOOLUR P.O., KOZHIKODE.
10 DR. RAJILA B.L.,
KALLATTU KOVILAKATH HOUSE,
THURUTHYAD P.O.,
BALUSSERY, KOZHIKODE.
11 DR. ARYA MADHU,
CHERUVALLIYIL HOUSE,
NEDUMKANDAM P.O., IDUKKI.
12 DR. ARAVIND S.,
KUNNANNOOR HOUSE,
KUMARANALLOOR, KOTTAYAM.
13 DR. GARGI G. PAVITHRAN,
PAVITHRAM, KANNADIPARAMBA,
KANNUR.
14 DR. FATHIMA SAMAD,
KOILAMPARAMBIL, NADACKAL P.O., ERATTUPETTA.
15 DR. NITHIN M.I.,
MELEDATH HOUSE, NEDUMBASSERRY P.O., ERNAKULAM
DISTRICT.
16 DR. PRAVEEN CHANDRA K.,
AISWARYA NIVEDS HOUSE, KOTTATHARA P.O., AGALI,
KOTTAYAM.
17 DR. RESHMA RAHIM,
PERUMBILLY HOUSE, EDAYAPPURAM, ALUVA, ERNAKULAM
DISTRICT.
18 DR. RASITHA M.R.,
MANNATH HOUSE, ARIYANNOOR P.O., THRISSUR.
19 DR. RATHI KRISHNAN R.,
KRISHNAS, CHOOZHAMPALA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 3
20 DR. NOSHA A.R.,
REENA BHAVAN, VANCHIYOOR, ATTINGAL,
THIRUVANANTAHPURAM DISTRICT.
21 DR. NATHASHA M.P.,
MULLAPPALLY HOUSE, PUTHUPARAMBA P.O., MALAPPURAM.
22 DR. AJITHAMOL P.S.,
PLAPPARAMBIL HOUSE, KOODAPPALAM, RAMAPURAM,
KOTTAYAM.
23 DR. SHAHEEDA M.B.,
MUBARAK MAHAL, PERUMANNUR CHALIESSERI, PALAKKAD.
24 DR. MUHAMMAED ABDUL RAOOF,
CHEMBAN MANGATTAYIL HOUSE, CHELEMBRA, MALAPPURAM.
25 DR. CHRIS MATHEW KOSHY,
VETTATHU HOUSE, MARAMON, KOZHENCHERRY,
PATHANAMTHITTA.
26 DR. SEETHAL K.,
W/O. GIREESH P.K., PALERI, KASARAGOD.
27 DR. SHADI ASHKAR V.,
VIRUTHULLIYIL, CHENNARA, MALAPPURAM.
28 DR. ATHIRA K.T.,
PALASSERI HOUSE, MELMURI P.O., MALAPPURAM.
29 DR. RESHMA RAJIKUMAR,
LAKSHMISREE HOUSE, KARIMUGAL.
30 DR. RINSILA RAHMATH,
KONEKKATHE PARAMBIL HOUSE, VEMBALLOOR, THRISSUR.
31 DR. SANJANA K.,
NANDHANAM HOUSE, OLVANNA, KOZHIKODE.
32 DR. SANDRA T.P.,
THOMPUNNAYIL HOUSE, PODIYOOR P.O., IRITTY, KANNUR.
33 DR. SAPTHA N.K.,
NIRMALYAM, MEPPAYIL, VATAKARA, KOZHIKODE.
34 DR. SAMNA S.,
KALATHIL HOUSE, KALIYAROAD, THRISSUR.
35 DR. VIJAYALAKSHMI C.K.,
CHEERAKKATTICKAL HOUSE, MALLAPPALLY,
PATHANAMTHITTA.
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 4
36 DR. ANIRUDH JAYARAJ,
NAVANEETHAM, PUZHAKULANGARA, KANNUR.
37 DR. ABHINAND,
SREYAS, MAKKARAPARAMBU, MALAPPURAM.
38 DR. HARI KRISHNAN T.,
ATHIRA HOUSE, MUKHATHALA, KOLLAM.
39 DR.HASNA M.C. ,
KATTIL HOUSE, ERAMANGALAM, MALAPPURAM.
40 DR. FATHIMA BHARKATH S.,
T.C. 20/2033-1, POOJAPURA ROAD, KARAMANA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
41 DR. ARJUN BABU,
THAYYALLATHIL HOUSE, ERAMALA, VATAKARA, KOZHIKODE.
42 DR. AISWARYA BALAKRISHNAN,
ARANGIL HOUSE, THIRUVANGOOR, CHEMANCHERI,
KOZHIKODE.
43 DR. DEVANA JAYAPRAKASH,
ANANDA VILAS, KANNUR.
44 DR. SHRAAVAN LEE AJITH,
K.K. APARTMENTS, KUNNAPPALLI P.O., MALAPPURAM.
45 DR. HARITHA K.,
KOLASSERY HOUSE, MANGATTU, TIRUR.
46 DR. FEBIN ISMAIL,
ATTUPURATH HOUSE, KADAVATHUR, THALASSERY.
47 DR. JULIE ANTONY,
JASMINE VILLA, PARAYIDATHI HOUSE, KANHANAGADU,
KASARAGOD.
48 DR. SAHALA BASHEER,
PALAKKADAN HOUSE, VARAPETTY.
49 DR. AMINA SHAMEEM,
AYSHAR, PURAVOORKONAM, VAZHAYILA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
50 DR. MOHAMMED NOWFAL T.P.,
THAZHATHE PEEDIKAKAL HOUSE, KADAMPUZHA.
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 5
51 DR. VAISHNA GIRISH,
VAISHNA NIVAS, GHSS, THOTTADA, KANNUR.
52 DR. SUJATHA NARAYANAN,
POOVATHUMPARAMBIL HOUSE, ALAGAPPANAGAR P.O.,
AMBALLUR, THRISSUR.
53 DR.ARUNIMA GOPI,
KEDARAM, SOUTH ARYAD, AVALUKUNNU, ALAPPUZHA.
54 MURSHIDA BEEGAM N.P.,
NAYAL PADIKKAL HOUSE, EDARIKODE, MALAPPURAM.
55 DR. NILEENA SARACHNDRAN,
PERINGAYIL HOUSE, MANALUR, THRISSUR.
56 DR, FIDHA P.O.,
RABATH, K.C. ROAD, TIRURANGADI, MALAPPURAM.
57 DR. HARITHA V.,
SAVIDHAM, PERINTHALMANNA, MALAPPURAM.
58 DR. SANGEETHA H.,
INDEEVARAM, PAZHIVEEDU, ALAPPUZHA.
59 DR. VISAKH V.S.,
PALAZHI, UDINIMMAVILA, KOTTUKAL,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
60 DR. BABU SAHIR C.,
MUKKOTTIL HOUSE, RARAPPARA, VELIMUKKU, MALAPPURAM.
61 DR. MUHAMMED RAFI N.,
AMEENA MANZIL, 10TH STONE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
62 DR. RISHAL P.,
PARAKKAL HOUSE, VALIYAPARAMBU, NELLIKAPARAMBA,
MUKKOM, KOZHIKODE.
63 DR. RAMSHAD A.C.,
AC HOUSE, KARUVANNUR, NADUVATTOM, KOZHIKODE.
64 DR. JITHIN SAGAR G.S.,
SREEMANGALAM HOUSE, IRINGATH, KOZHIKODE.
65 DR. ALWYIN JOHN,
32, CRESCENT AVENUE, WEST NADAKKAVU, KOZHIKODE.
66 ADDL. R66. DR. GOVIND S.S. ,
SARIKA, THACHOTTUKAVU, MALAYINKEEZHU,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 6
67 DR. ADARSH P.M.,
PUTHENVEETTIL, MANAKKADAVU, KANNUR.
68 DR. HASEEB SEHI P.,
PILAKKAL HOUSE, NARATH, RAMAPURAM, MALAPPURAM.
69 DR. DEREK JOSEPH,
PADIYARA HOUSE, CHAMPAKKARA, KOTTAYAM.
70 DR. NASEEF ABDURAHMAN,
EILAF, CHENNAMANGALLUR, MUKKOM.
71 DR. SHEHIM THAHMEES T.,
THULLISSERI HOUSE, KUTTIYIL VANIYAMBALAM,
MALAPPURAM.
72 DR. JAMSHEENA M.K.,
MANKKANDY HOUSE, KANDIYANGAD, PERAMBRA, KOZHIKODE.
73 DR. ASMI K.A.,
KANNANTHARA KALATHIL, KATTATHURUTH, NORTH PARAVUR,
ERNAKULAM.
74 DR. PRINCE LAWRENCE,
KUNNUMPURATH, ALPARA P.O., IDUKKI-685606.
75 DR. ANIRUDHAN K.,
KANCHINAMGAD (REVATHY), BHARATHAPPUZHA ROAD,
KANNIYAMPURAM P.O., OTTAPPALAM, PALAKKAD-679104.
76 DR. ARCHA S.,
CHINNANTAZHIKOM HOUSE, PALLICKAL P.O., KILIMANOOR,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM -695604.
77 DR. VEENAKRISHNA,
KARTHIKA, V.T. NAGAR, MANIKANDESHWARAM P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
78 DR. DIVYA A.J.,
THRIKKAKARA UNIVERSITY, KAKKANAD, ERNAKULAM.
79 DR. NITHYA P. DAS,
P.G. BHAVAN, M.C. NAGAR,
AYIR, PARASSALA, TRIVANDRUM.
80 DR. FARHANA P.P.,
PULIKKAPARAMBIL HOUSE,
KUTTIPURAM VIA, MALAPPURAM.
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 7
81 DR. CHANDINI M.C.,
MANAPPILLY HOUSE,
THEKKUMBHAGAM, TRIPUNITHURA, ERNAKULAM.
82 DR. ADHITHYA S. ANAND,
PUNNUKANDIYIL HOUSE, KAKKATTIL, KOZHIKODE.
83 DR. AHALYA V.,
VADAKKAN HOUSE, KOTTAKKAL, MALAPPURAM.
84 DR. MADHUMA R. KRISHNA,
CHARAPPATTIYIL HOUSE, KOTTAKKAL, MALAPPURAM.
85 DR. JAHRIN P.K.,
PERUVANKUZHIYIL HOUSE, IRUMBUZHI, MALAPPURAM.
86 DR. SHANA SHIRIN,
NADUVIKKALATHIL HOUSE, KARUVAMBRAM, MANJERI,
MALAPPURAM.
87 DR. FATHIMA ROSNA P.,
ROSEMAHAL HOUSE, PARAPIL,
PURAMERI, VADAKARA, KOZHIKODE.
88 DR. NAVAMI CHANDRAN,
SREEVALSAM, CHAKKALAKUTH ROAD,
NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM.
89 DR. SHAMNU JAHAN,
KALLUKUZHIYIL HOUSE,
VALIYAPARAMBA P.O., PULIKKAL.
90 DR. FAEBA THOMAS,
KULAKKATTU HOUSE, KNKUMAM,
AZAD NAGAR, MANJERI, MALAPPURAM.
91 DR. ATHIRA R. NAIR,
SOUPARNIKA MAKKADATH,
CHELANNUR P.O., KOZHIKODE.
(ADDITIONAL R4 TO R91 IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED
25/11/2019 IN IA NO.5/19)
R1 BY SMT. NISHA BOSE, SR. GOVERNMENT PLEADER
R2 BY SRI.P.SREEKUMAR,SC, KERALA UNIVERSITY OF
HEALTH SCIENCES
R3 BY SRI.TITUS MANI VETTOM, SC, MCI
R4-R91 BY ADV. S.VINOD BHAT
R4-R91 BY ADV. KUM.ANAGHA LAKSHMY RAMAN
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
04.03.2020, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 8
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 4th day of March 2020 The petitioner challenges the decision communicated by the second respondent University in Exts.P1 to P9 granting consent of affiliation to petitioner as follows:-
Sl. No. P.G. Medical Course No. of No. of seats seats fixed applied by for University 1 MD General Medicine 6 2 2 MS General Surgery 10 2 3 MD Paediatrics 8 2 4 MS Orthopaedics 8 2 5 MD Dermatology, 3 2 Venerology & Leprosy 6 MS Oto-Rhinolaryngology 3 2 7 MS Opthalmology 4 2 8 MD Psychiatry 3 2 9 MD Community Medicine 4 2
2. In other words second respondent by more or less fixing a benchmark of two seats disposed of the application of petitioner made for granting consent of affiliation.
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 9
3. The petitioner challenges the said decision on various grounds including non-application of mind to the details furnished by the petitioner, facilities and faculty put in place, commensurate to the number of seats for which the application was made. Adv. Sri. P. Sanjay, for the petitioner treating M.D. General Medicine and M.S. General Surgery as illustrative cases, made detailed submissions on the entitlement of petitioner for the number of seats for which application was made. The gist of his argument proceeds on the ground that a Medical College without complying with applicable checklist of second respondent cannot insist on grant of consent of affiliation. Likewise when the Medical College is fully compliant with Faculty/Facility for the seats for which application was made, denial by second respondent amounts to arbitrary disposal of a request made by the college. Therefore, warrants interference of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
4. Sri. P. Sreekumar, appearing for second respondent and Adv. Sri. Titus Mani Vettom, WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 10 Standing Counsel for the third respondent have opposed writ prayers firstly by drawing my attention to record of second respondent and the conclusions recorded by the authority having jurisdiction in this behalf, restricting consent for affiliation as noted above. Stated simply it is argued that the facts of the case do not warrant interference of this Court. The criteria for granting consent of affiliation is also changed and a decision is taken by second respondent for processing all applications in the near future. Respondents have further brought to the notice of this Court that the last date for granting permissions by the statutory authorities expired on 31.01.2020. The consideration of petitioner's grievance would be purely academic. Instead it has been suggested by the counsel appearing for respondents that the petitioner can be permitted to make an application for sanction of consent of affiliation for the balance of seats for which the consent of affiliation was not granted by respondents and on such application being made, the case of WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 11 petitioner is considered and orders as are deemed fit are passed and communicated.
5. Adv. Sri. P. Sreekumar, submits that the petitioner can apply for enhancement of seats subject to complying with the minimum period of instruction as is stipulated by the Medical Council of India in this behalf and therefore necessary clarification is required from the Medical Council of India to treat the present effort of petitioner as one in continuation of an application already made in this behalf. For the application of petitioner has resulted in the orders impugned in the writ petition, thereby the renewed effort of petitioner may have to be treated as an application for enhancement of seats
6. Adv. Sri. Titus Mani Vettom, Standing Counsel for the third respondent submits that in cases like the present, the Health University can firstly consider relaxation and secondly treat the case of the petitioner as an application revived in continuation of the request already made, proceed to decide according to the merits of the request of WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 12 petitioner. The statement made on behalf of the third respondent is placed on record and accepted.
7. Keeping in view the changed criteria by referring to which the case for grant of consent of affiliation is considered and granted by respondents, I am satisfied the writ petition can be disposed of by this judgment:-
a) The petitioner is given two weeks time from today to submit or upload the application of petitioner for grant of consent of affiliation for the balance of seats for which the University did not favourably consider for the academic year 2019-20.
b) To enable petitioner to submit or upload, the second respondent University is directed to facilitate by keeping the window of petitioner college open for fifteen days from today.
c) The application now presented by the petitioner shall be treated as one submitted or uploaded for reconsideration by the second respondent University and if necessary, relaxation as is available with respondents is directed to be WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 13 considered and granted to petitioner while processing the present request.
d) The respondents after carrying out inspections as are required in this behalf, upon receipt of reports in this behalf, will consider the case of the petitioner for grant of consent of affiliation for the academic year 2021-22, as early as possible preferably within the time schedule applicable in this behalf.
No order as to costs.
SD/-
S.V.BHATTI JUDGE DCS WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 14 APPENDIX PETITIONER'S/S EXHIBITS:
EXHIBIT P1 TRUE COPY OF THE CONSENT OF AFFILIATION NO.2494/2019/ACI/MED/A3/KUHS/B DATED 14.05.2019 FOR MD GENERAL MEDICINE.
EXHIBIT P2 TRUE COPY OF THE CONSENT OF AFFILIATION NO.2494/2019/ACI/MED/A3/KUHS/D DATED 14.05.2019 FOR MS GENERAL SURGERY. EXHIBIT P3 TRUE COPY OF THE CONSENT OF AFFILIATION NO.2494/2019/ACI/MED/A3/KUHS/A DATED 14.05.2019 FOR MD PAEDIATRICS.
EXHIBIT P4 TRUE COPY OF THE CONSENT OF AFFILIATION NO.2019/2494/ACI/MED/A3/KUHS/A DATED 03.04.2019 FOR MS ORTHOPAEDICS.
EXHIBIT P5 TRUE COPY OF THE CONSENT OF AFFILIATION NO.2019/2494/ACI/MED/A3/KUHS/B DATED 03.04.2019 FOR MD DERMATOLOGY VENEROLOGY AND LEPROSY.
EXHIBIT P6 TRUE COPY OF THE CONSENT OF AFFILIATION NO.2494/2019/ACI/MED/A3/KUHS/C DATED 14.05.2019 FOR MS OTO-RHINOLARYNGOLOGY. EXHIBIT P7 TRUE COPY OF THE CONSENT OF AFFILIATION NO.2494/2019/ACI/MED/A3/KUHS/F DATED 14.05.2019 FOR MS OPTHALMOLOGY.
EXHIBIT P8 TRUE COPY OF THE CONSENT OF AFFILIATION NO.2494/2019/ACI/MED/A3/KUHS/G DATED 14.05.2019 FOR MD PSYCHIATRY.
EXHIBIT P9 TRUE COPY OF THE CONSENT OF AFFILIATION NO.2494/2019/ACI/MED/A3/KUHS/E DATED 14.05.2019 FOR MD COMMUNITY MEDICINE. EXHIBIT P10 TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT NO.2494/ACI/A3/2019/KUHS DATED 02.04.2019 FOR MD GENERAL MEDICINE.
EXHIBIT 10(A) TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT NO.2494/ACI/MED/A3/2019/KUHS DATED 04.04.2019 FOR MS GENERAL SURGERY. EXHIBIT P10(B) TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT NO.2494/AC1/MED/A3/2019/KUHS DATED02.04.2019 FOR MD PAEDIATRICS. WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 15 EXHIBIT P10(C) TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT NO.2494/ACI/MED/A3/2019/KUHS DATED 16.03.2019 FOR MS ORTHOPAEDICS.
EXHIBIT P10(D) TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT NO.2494/ACI/MED/A3/2019/KUHS DATED 16.03.2019 FOR MD DERMATOLOGY VENEROLOGY AND LEPROSY.
EXHIBIT P10(E) TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT DATED 05.04.2019 FOR MS OTO-RHINOLARYNGOLOGY. EXHIBIT P10(F) TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT NO.2494/ACI/MED/A3/2019/KUHS DATED 17.04.2018 FOR MS OPTHALMOLOGY.
EXHIBIT P10(G) TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT NO.2494/ACI/MED/A3/2019/KUHS DATED 02.04.2019 FOR MD PSYCHIATRY.
EXHIBIT P10(H) TRUE COPY OF THE INSPECTION REPORT NO.2494/ACI/MED/A3/2019/KUHS DATED 17.04.2019 FOR MD COMMUNITY MEDICINE. EXHIBIT P11 TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL LIST MEDICAL COLLEGES WHO WERE GRANTED POSTGRADUATE COURSES IN THE ACADEMIC YEAR 2016-17 BY THE MCI DATED NIL.
EXHIBIT P12 TRUE COPY OF THE PUBLIC NOTICE ISSUED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT CALLING FOR BANK GUARANTEES FOR ISSUING LETTER OF PERMISSION (LOP) IN RESPECT OF PG COURSES DATED AUGUST AND OCTOBER 2017.
EXHIBIT P13 TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION NO.MMC&RC/KUHS/PG/004/2019 DATED 08.04.2019.
EXHIBIT P11 (IN I.A. TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 19.08.2019 OF NO. 1/2019) THE HON'BLE SUPREME COURT IN SPECIAL LEAVE TO APPEAL NO. 18988/2019 EXHIBIT P12 (IN I.A. TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION NO. MMC & NO. 1/2019) RC/MCI/PG-MEDICAL/APPLICATION/08/2019 DATED 29/08/2019.
EXHIBIT P14 NIL
EXHIBIT P15 NIL
EXHIBIT P16 TRUE COPY OF THE LIST OF DATES ALONG WITH
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 16
DETAILS OF THE INSPECTORS WERE CARRIED OUT INSPECTIONS AT THE PETITIONER'S INSTITUTION DATED NIL.
EXHIBIT P17 . TRUE COPY OF THE GAZETTE NOTIFICATION DATED 05/04/2019 ISSUED BY THE MEDICAL COUNCIL OF INDIA.
EXHIBIT-P18 TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION NO.
PAS/2019/21 DATED 06.02.2019 FOR POSTGRADUATE SEATS IN MD GENERAL MEDICINE. EXHIBIT-P18(a) TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION NO.
PAS/2019/22 DATED 06.02.2019 FOR POSTGRADUATE SEATS IN MD GENERAL SURGERY EXHIBIT-P18(b) TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION NO.
PAS/2019/23 DATED 06.02.2019 FOR POSTGRADUATE SEATS IN MD PAEDIATRICS. EXHIBIT-P18(c) TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION NO.
PAS/2019/24 DATED 06.02.2019 FOR POSTGRADUATE SEATS IN MS ORTHOPAEDICS EXHIBIT-P18(d) TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION NO.
PAS/2019/26 DATED 06.02.2019 FOR POSTGRADUATE SEATS IN MD DERMATOLOGY. EXHIBIT-P18(e) TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION NO.
PAS/2019/28 DATED 06.02.2019 FOR POSTGRADUATE SEATS IN MS OTO-
RHYNOLRYNGOLOGY.
EXHIBIT-P18(f) TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION NO.
PAS/2019/29 DATED 06.02.2019 FOR POSTGRADUATE SEATS IN MS OPHTALMOLOGY. EXHIBIT-P18(g) TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION NO.
PAS/2019/30 DATED 06.02.2019 FOR POSTGRADUATE SEATS IN MD PSYCHIATRY. EXHIBIT-P18(h) TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION DATED 06.02.2019 FOR POSTGRADUATE SEATS IN MD COMMUNITY MEDICINE EXHIBIT-P19 AS AN EXAMPLE PETITIONER IS PRODUCING A CHART SHOWING THE ELIGIBILITY AS PER THE MCI GUIDLINES DATED NIL.
EXHIBIT-P20 TRUE COPY OF THE TOPPERS REPORT PUBLISHED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT UNIVERSITY DATED 08.- 2.2016.
WP(C).No.14835 OF 2019(D) 17EXHIBIT-P21 TRUE COPY OF THE RANK HOLDERS LIST PUBLISHED IN FEBRUARY 2019 BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT UNIVERSITY DATED NILL. RESPONDENT'S/S EXHIBITS:
EXHIBIT R4(A) COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 18.11.2019 SENT TO VICE CHANCELLOR, KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES EXHIBIT R4(B) COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 18.11.2019 SENT TO BOARD OF GOVERNORS IN SUPERSESSION OF MEDICAL COUNCIL OF INDIA