Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

45. There can be no two opinions that the issues of encroachment on public land, mushrooming of slums on such lands and illegal constructions on such land, as also, on any open land in the city, and the total collapse of the machinery available in law to control these issues, adversely affecting the urban agglomeration, is a sad story of an invited misery and a massive failure on the part of the State Government and the municipal bodies. An overview of these adversities, depicts a sorry and painful state of affairs, having a harmful and an overbearing effect not only on those who are residing in the slums and unauthorized constructions, but also, the hard impact it creates on the infrastructure in cities and the continuous and successive damage to the limited resources. The consequence of all this, is ghastly and harmful. As to what is in store for the future generations cannot be imagined. Admittedly, these are larger issues to be effectively looked into by the policy makers before things further worsen, albeit there appears to be a stage of no return, unless aggressive planning and commitment to the constitutional principles is kept at the forefront by the policy makers. Happening of encroachments, unauthorized and illegal structures being put up and deliberate neglect to these issues, when all this is unpleasantly happening before the open eyes and to the knowledge of the authorities, is not without purpose. From the report of the learned Commissioner, it appears to be a deep rooted menace, perpetrated for years together, which has ruined the cities and its scare resources. There are vested interests as pointed out by the learned Commissioner, namely political interest, slumlords and ultimately the cancer of corruption, which is the primary cause, for the authorities not taking action to remove illegal structures which continue to exist for years together.
46. However, it clearly appears that the State Government being aware of the grabbing of Government lands at the hands of these unscrupulous elements, from time to time, issued directives to the Additional Collector P. V. Rane SMWP1_2024.DOC (Encroachment), Chief Executive Officer of the Slum Authority and other Chief Officers of the local authorities. Such directives made it incumbent to take all steps to protect the Government lands, by preventing grabbing of lands by encroachment and to register criminal complaints of such encroachment and taking stern action of demolition of the unauthorized constructions and unauthorized hutments. However, it appears that the said directives at all material times have remained to be dead letters. Learned Commissioner has referred to some of the Circulars, which, if were to be implemented in its letter and spirit, the scenario would have been completely different, from what it prevails today. The city would have been a better place to live. Hundreds of Government lands could have been saved, to be utilized for public purposes. The circulars are certainly binding on the Government and its officers, provided the officers had an intention to look at them. The directives as contained in some of the Circulars are required to be noted with particular emphasis of their relevant contents. They read thus: (I) By Government Circular dated September 19, 2003 issued to the CEO, SRA, Additional Collector (Encroachment & Removal), Mumbai City, Eastern Suburb, Western Suburb and the Director, Mumbai Development Division, on removal of unauthorized constructions and unauthorized hutments on semi-Government and private lands, guidelines were issued stating that day by day encroachment, illegal constructions and illegal hutments are increasing on such category of lands and such activities are required to be controlled and which were sought to be controlled by various circulars as referred in the reference in the said circular. This circular stated that the respective divisions would be primarily responsible to protect such land, however, as the concerned division did not protect the lands, illegal constructions setting up of unauthorized hutments have taken place and have increased. It was directed that the concerned Division to take immediate steps to prepare a scheme to protect the lands. The circular records that all unauthorized hutments and illegal constructions in the hutment areas put up after 1 January 1995 should immediately be removed. It was also provided that if these instructions are not implemented by the concerned officer or there is negligence or delay in taking such action, in that event the proceedings would be initiated against him as per the provisions of the Slums Act. The officers were also instructed that in regard to the unauthorized constructions, the concerned officer shall meticulously and from time to time adhere to the different directives of the State Government. (II) By a further Circular dated September 7, 2010, the State Government again issued directives in regard to the prevention of encroachment, demolition of unauthorized construction/hutments and registering of complaints. The Circular stated that from time to time the directives were issued, however, there was no serious implementation of the said circular at the level of different divisions as noticed by the State Government. As a result of which the Government lands were encroached and are being grabbed. The Circular states that in some instances the persons in the adjoining areas and/or local people are opposing removal of encroachment and demolition of unauthorized structures and force is required to be used to resist such opposition which creates law and order problem. However, in this situation, considering the ownership of the Government in respect of its land, the Government machinery was required to register complaints, as for non-filing of such complaints, the police are not in a position to take action, as informed by the Home Department. Considering such situations, the Government issue the following directives:- (i) To notify all details of the Government land and which be displayed in the Revenue Office or in the office of the Local bodies at a P. V. Rane SMWP1_2024.DOC prominent place alongwith which a clear notice be given that if the Government land is encroached, legal action would be taken in regard to such encroachment. (ii) If there is any encroachment on the Government land or the land belonging to the local bodies, immediate action be taken to remove the encroachment or to demolish the unauthorized construction.
84. Illegal encroachments and unauthorized structures are a menace and a potential danger not only to the city of Mumbai, which is being ruined by encroachments and illegal constructions, but also to the other bigger cities.

These factors also depict a picture of absolute lawlessness in implementation of the municipal laws. This for more than one reason. Firstly, as seen from the State policies, it creates two categories of citizens, the first category is of those citizens who are law abiding, who would put up lawful construction and possess buildings/structures which are lawfully constructed thereby enjoying only the legitimate and permissible benefits therefrom. The second category is of those persons who brazenly violate law and put up illegal and unlawful constructions and enjoy with impunity such illegal structures, under the blessings of municipal and government officers. There is yet another category of persons, who illegally enter and encroach on public lands, construct unauthorized structures, they continue to reside in such structures for long periods with the blessings of all the authorities, and yet get rewarded under the government policies which offer them a premium on such illegality of encroachment, in entitling them with a free of cost accommodation, under the garb of slum redevelopment as made permissible under the State policies as discussed above. There cannot be a bigger unconstitutionality and breach of the public trust doctrine in such mechanism, under which valuable public largess is siphoned off from the pool of public assets to reward encroachers as also for private benefits. P. V. Rane SMWP1_2024.DOC

105. On our way towards conclusion, we may note that a chaotic state of affairs of mushrooming of slums and unauthorized and illegal constructions in every possible pocket of open land could have been avoided, provided there was a desire to have a proper vision and an effort to make an effective plan for mass public housing, which would cater to the housing needs, for a large percentage of population in a city like Mumbai. It cannot be overlooked that for a city as large as Mumbai or any other comparable city in the State, large work force and which may be migrant workforce is indispensable and perennially required, who cater to the various manpower requirements the city consumes. However, we find that in contemporary times, there is not much thought been given by the policy makers to such vital issues of affordable mass public housing, to be created to accommodate such large work force either temporarily or permanently. Moreover, the entire focus is on putting up skyscrapers on slum lands. It cannot be a situation that people from all parts of the country come to work in urban areas and there is no alternative to them but to encroach on government/public lands or private open lands and reside in filthy surroundings and in illegal structures. Such is the sorry state of affairs. Even P. V. Rane SMWP1_2024.DOC such persons have a right to live with dignity and in appropriate humane and pleasant livable surroundings.