Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

Mr.M.V.S.V.K.Appa Rao/declarant filed L.R.A.No.494 of 1976 and on 08.03.1978, the Appellate Tribunal modified the order by excluding Acs. 38.98 Cts from the holding of Mr.M.V.S.V.K.Appa Rao (land owner). It is matter of record that on 18.04.1978, the revision filed against the said order i.e., C.R.P.No.2194 of 1978 was dismissed. The Land Reforms Tribunal, on 14.12.1982, issued show-cause notice calling upon Mr.M.V.S.V.K.Appa Rao to surrender ceiling surplus land. Show-cause notice dated 14.12.1982 was assailed in W.P.No.799 of 1983 and on 09.10.1987, the writ petition was disposed of giving liberty to M.V.S.V.K.Appa Rao/declarant to raise objections in the surrender proceedings initiated through notice dated 14.12.1982. At that juncture, Meka Lakshmi Devi/purchaser availed the opportunity and filed objections against taking possession of agricultural land, which was included and held to be within the ceiling limit in C.C.No.1094/NZD/75.

The Primary Tribunal rejected the objections not only filed by M.V.S.V.K.Appa Rao (declarant) and Meka Lakshmi Devi (purchaser), but also a few other objections raised by purchasers of the subject matter from M.V.S.V.K.Appa Rao. The objectors filed L.R. Appeal before the Appellate Tribunal. The Land Reforms Tribunal, Krishna, Machilipatnam, through common judgment dated 24.04.1990, disposed of the appeals. The State aggrieved by the common order dated 24.04.1990 filed C.R.P.Nos.1089 and 1090 of 1991. The revision petitions filed by the State are either dismissed for default or otherwise. At this juncture, the contention of the revision petitioners is that the issue of holding of land both by M.V.S.V.K.Appa Rao and Meka Lakshmi Devi was the subject matter of Land Reform Appeals as well as Civil Revision Petition before this Court. The findings recorded in the earlier round of litigation on the very same subject matter cannot and could not be ignored by the authorities while taking possession of alleged ceiling surplus land liable to be surrendered in C.C.No.1104/NZD/75. On 23.06.1988, M.V.S.V.K.Appa Rao/declarant died unmarried and Meka Meher Rama Venkatadri Appa Rao is now shown as the legal representative of M.V.S.V.K.Appa Rao and the proceedings are continued. On 05.09.1989, the Land Reforms Tribunal/1st respondent rejected the objection petition of Meka Lakshmi Devi/purchaser which resulted in filing the appeal referred above.

The learned Assistant Government Pleader submits that M.V.S.V.K.Appa Rao is under obligation to surrender about 140 acres of land in C.C.No.1104/NZD/75. The 1st respondent has properly understood the direction issued by Appellate Tribunal in L.R.A.No.42 of 1989 and has called upon the petitioners herein to deliver possession of the ceiling surplus land. According to her, the transactions relied on by the revision petitioners are void and hit by Section 17 of the Act. She prays for dismissing the revisions.

This Court by taking note of the findings recorded in the earlier round of litigation and also that these orders have become final with the dismissal of CRPs, is of the view that the orders under revision are unsustainable and are, accordingly, set aside. In the instant batch of revisions, this Court has considered the effect of protection granted by the Land Reforms Appellate Tribunal which is excerpted above and not in respect of any other land which the 1st respondent can proceed and take possession in accordance with law from the enjoyers of ceiling surplus land.