Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

(34) The complainant has filed on record copy of F.I.R. dated 06/09/2010. Police received said report on 23/09/2010. The complainant filed report against Mr.Prakash Chawala, Head of opponent, who is a builder. It is alleged that he had meeting with Mr.Prakash Chawala at Renaissance Club on 14/07/2010 regarding possession of flat No.201 (owner-Dr.Hari Nagpal), flat No.301 (owner-Dr.Pushpa Nagpal), flat No.401 (owner-Dr.Hari Nagpal, H.U.F.). The complainant and his family members were surprised to find that Manager Mr.Vipul Parikh was talking to them about possession instead of Mr.Prakash Chawala. Manager-Mr.Vipul Parikh prepared possession letters, affidavit-cum-indemnity bond and cash payment vouchers which according to him were mandatory for the complainant to sign so that Manager could send completed documents for signature of builder-Mr.Prakash Chawala before handing over possession of the flats. It is submitted that under pressure of need of getting flats, the complainant agreed to sign the documents under protest. After signatures of all three owners on documents and cash payment vouchers, Manager-Mr.Vipul Parikh took the documents to builder-Mr.Prakash Chawala for his signature. He came back within ten minutes and told that Mr.Prakash Chawala is not available in the office. Manager-Mr.Vipul Parikh stated that signatures of opponent would be taken and copies of all the documents would be handed over to the complainant and his family members. It is alleged that unfortunately complainant and his family members never received keys of the flats, duly signed copies of possession letters and affidavits as well as copies of payment vouchers. There were several calls on mobile, but Mr.Prakash Chawala or Manager-Mr.Vipul Parikh did not respond. Grievance raised by the complainant before Police in F.I.R. that the builder has harassed them for flats and also cheated them. By filing F.I.R. complainant sought help of Police. Contents of F.I.R. dated 23/09/2010 clearly shows that complainant and his wife-Pushpa Nagpal singed certain documents when meeting was held with Mr.Prakash Chawala and his Manager. It can be inferred that documents filed on record by the opponent bear signatures of the complainant-Dr.Hari Nagpal and his wife-Pushpa Nagpal. This fact is fully corroborated by the evidence of Handwriting Expert.