Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

Brief facts: Rashtriya Sanskrit Sansthan, an autonomous organization of the Ministry of Human Resource Development. Govt. of India imparts education for many programmes and the course of B.Ed (known as Siksha Shashtri) was inter alia one of them. The said course enables the successful candidates eligible for recruitment for the posts of Teacher. For obtaining admission in the said course, an entrance test was used to be held. The successful candidates were given admission in the said B.Ed. course. A complaint dt. 20.9.1991 was filed by Dr. P.K. Panually, Assistant Director (Examination) of the said Sansthan to the effect that on or before 18.09.1991 at A­48, Vishal Enclave, Rashtriya Sanskrit Sansthan, Raja Garden, Delhi, 09 candidates produced forged nishkarman parman patram (migration certificate) and mark sheets for obtaining admission in the said course of Shiksha Shastri (B. Ed.) and the said certificates and marksheets on verification were not found to be genuine and thus it is alleged that the accused persons cheated the said Sansthan. It is also alleged that accused persons fraudulently and dishonestly used these certificates as genuine which they knew or had reason to believe at the time when they were used, to be the forged documents. On the basis of said complaint, an FIR was registered and after completion of investigation, the final report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. was filed alleging offences punishable under Sections 420, 468 and 471 IPC.

7. PW­2 Smt. Kanchan was posted as Assistant at Rashtriya Sanskrit Sansthan, Vishal Enclave, Delhi. She deposed that on 28.02.1992 she handed over the marksheet and migration certificate to the police and a seizure memo was prepared and her statement was recorded. The seizure memo was proved as Ex. PW2/A. She proved the documents (migration certificates and marksheets) and the verification letters as original certificate bearing serial no. 451 is Ex. PW2/B, serial no. 456 is Ex. PW2/C, letter is Ex. PW2/D, letter of Baldev Sahai Sanskrit Mahavidyalya is Ex. PW2/E, marksheet of Sampurannand Sanskrit Mahavidyalya is Ex. PW2/F. She has also proved on record the certificates/marksheets submitted by accused along with other certificates as in case of State vs. Premlata is Ex. PW2/G, certificate in S vs. Bhagwan Singh is Ex. PW2/H, certificate in S vs. Dev Sharma is Ex. PW2/I, certificate in S vs. Satyawan is Ex. PW2/J, certificate in S vs. Udaiveer is Ex. PW2/K and letter in case S vs. Kishan Kumar Sharma is Ex. PW2/L. She has also proved on record the verification letters issued by the concerned authority and the said letters are marked as letter in case State vs. Kishan Kumar Sharma is Ex. PW2/L, copy of Ex. PW2/F in State vs. Kishan Kumar Sharma is mark 'A', copy of Ex. PW2/D in case of State vs. Prem Lata is mark 'A' and copy of Ex. PW2/E in all other cases is mark 'A'.

11. PW­6 Prabhat Ranjan is the Controller of Examination, University of Allahabad. He deposed that in reference to a letter sent by SHO, PS Rajouri Garden, Delhi regarding some clarifications about marksheets and migration certificates, he gave the details as per record through letter no. 547/92 dated 01.04.1992. He further stated that as per record the migration certificate bearing no. 24473 dated 15.11.1989 (Ex. PW2/J) as well as the marksheet bearing the said number in the name of accused were not issued from above said institution and the photocopy of said marksheet is Ex. PW6/A and his detailed report is Ex. PW6/B.

12. PW­7 R.K. Tripathy was a Principal in Yogender Nath Shastri Sansthan. He deposed that on 09.04.1992, he was working as Principal in Yogender Nath Shastri and he had gone through the certificate already Ex. PW2/E. He further stated that photocopy of the aforesaid documents is Ex. PW7/A.

13. PW­8 Prabhat Ranjan was the Deputy Registrar Examination in Sampuranand Sanskrit University, Varanasi, U.P. He deposed that on 01.04.1992 he sent a detailed report by post dated 01.04.1992 vide letter no. 547/92 in reference to a letter sent by SHO, Rajouri Garden seeking clarification about marksheet and migration certificate. He further stated that the above said certificate and mark sheet in respect of accused were not issued from the institute called Sampuranand Sanskrit Vishvidyalya as per the verification letter Ex. PW8/A dated 01.04.1992 and another letter dated 18.02.1994.