Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

2. Ld. Judge, framed formal charge under aforementioned Sections and after being read over an explained appellant/accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

3. To prove the charge prosecution examined as many as sixteen witnesses namely Gopal Singh, Chairman cum Managing Director of ECL as PW1, Wasim Akram Khan, Sub Inspector, CBI, ACB, Kolkata as PW2, Baijyanta Mukhopadhyay, Deputy Director and Scientist 'D' (explosives) at CFSL, Kolkata as PW3, Gopal Sharan, Chief Welfare Inspector, D.R.M Office, Asansol as PW4, Om Prakash Mahato (complainant), Tub Repair Majdoor as PW5, Devanand Kumar, Vigilance Inspector, SAIL, ISP, Burnpur, as PW6, Rabindra Sharma, then Manager of Parbelia Colliery as PW7, Amar Jyoti Prasad, a witness to voice audio clips as PW8, Ashoke Kumar Poddar, a witness to voice audio clips as PW9, Diptarka Moitra, Colliery Engineer of Parbelia Colliery as PW10, Babu Lal Pandey, Assistant Manager (personnel)of Parbelia Colliery as PW11, Arbind Kumar Singh, agent of Parbelia Group of Mines at Sodpur area as PW12, Amitabha Ghosh, the then Inspector CBI, ACB, Kolkata as PW13, Amitabha Das, the then Inspector CBI, ACB, Kolkata as PW14, Doctor Subhrat Kumar Choudhury, Senior Scientific Officer (HOD) Computer Forensic Division, CFSL, New Delhi as PW 15 and one Mukesh Kumar, Inspector CBI, ACB, Shillong, attached to ACB, Kolkata as PW16.

31. Subhrat Kumar Chowdhury, Senior Scientific Officer, (HOD) Computer Forensic Division CFSL New Delhi, PW15 in his cross examination mentioned absence of hash value certificate of the voice recording which were tested. But, in his report he has clearly stated that Micro SD Card was original.

32. After delving into all the facts, circumstances, evidences adduced the following points of contentions are to be analyzed in order to secure the ends of justice.

33. The argument of the appellant regarding the doubtful verification of the complaint by the investigating officer is absurd as all the processes prescribed were properly complied with the relevant provisions of the CBI manual.