Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

1.in what context does RBI take the allegation of IT DATA Theft by NBFC.where as No IT DATA theft has been reported to RBI as per Cyber security Guideline Annex-I (to be reported within 24 hrs after incident happened in NBFC as per Guideline) whereas unlike what NBFC complainant Ashish Jain is being accused of IT DATA Theft by NBFC through legal Notice and filed Civil Suit Case in Kota against me in this regard does RBI accept it as per Guideline where as Rs.10000 from Salary and reliving letter of complainant Ashish Jain has been held by NBFC HDB Financial services Ltd due to Allegation of IT DATA Theft Since November-21 to till dated. Please share complete information.
8
The appeal is dismissed accordingly. The order may be served on the appellant."

CIC/RBIND/A/2022/654313 Information sought:

The Appellant filed an RTI application dated 27.05.2022 seeking the following information:
"refer your RBIND/R/E/22/02361 Dated 26 May 22 RTI reply where No such incident has been reported to RBI by NBFC. Please share below information under RTI Act.
1.In what context does RBI take the allegation of IT DATA Theft by NBFC. Where as No IT DATA theft has been reported to RBI as per Cyber security Guideline Annex-I (to be reported within 24 hrs after incident happened in NBFC as per Guideline) whereas unlike what NBFC complainant Ashish Jain is being accused of IT DATA Theft by NBFC through legal Notice and filed Civil Suit Case in Kota against me in this regard does RBI accept it as per Guideline where as Rs.10000 from Salary and reliving letter of complainant Ashish Jain has been held by NBFC HDB Financial services Ltd due to Allegation of IT DATA Theft Since November-21 to till dated. Please share complete information.
2.Why did not RBI Examine Cyber Security incident which is constantly being alleged by HDB Financial Services Ltd that 11 mails which contains huge company DATA Theft over me and refer RTI reply no information has been reported to RBI by NBFC HDB finance. What was main root cause reason to not examine this issue by RBI once complainant sending emails to RBI in this regard.
3.Whether any action is pending at the level of Department of Supervision if yes or not. Please share information.
4.Whether NBFC has the right to take legal action against the complainant without informing the RBI with out evidence or facts and not to inform RBI as per guideline regarding IT DATA theft whether RBI considers It correct if yes then why and if not in this regard when the NBFC has taken legal action and filed civil suit for IT DATA theft against the complainant Ashish Jain, does the RBI agree with the action of the NBFC. Please find enclosement and share complete information."
The Respondent further apprised the Commission that the matter of the Appellant is related to HDB Financial Services Ltd. and it is the dispute between the employer and the employee. A civil suit in this regard is also pending before the Court for adjudication. On a query from the Commission, the Respondent submitted that they have furnished their latest written submissions along with the annexures with the Appellant in all the above mentioned appeals.
Decision:
The Commission based on a perusal of the facts on record finds that the dissatisfaction of the Appellant with the replies provided by the CPIO is bereft of merit as the RTI Applications merely seeks for clarifications and answers to interrogative queries viz. "Why RBI was not examined this matter of IT DATA Theft at that time means since Dec-21 to March-22 once complainant regular approached through chains of Email to RBI to examine this matter. Once RBI has confirmed that NBFC has no reported any such incident to RBI in RTI reply if the IT DATA Theft is not reported to RBI by NBFC can it be assumed that it is an act of wrong fales and willful act by NBFC which is totally wrong whether RBI believes it to be correct if yes so does RBI propose to impose penalty and other restrictions on the NBFC and at the same time direct the NBFC to pay compensation to the complainant due to which the complainants goodwill has been spoiled; Whether it is RBI process that without provide any facts (either related to customer information or company related DATA ) NBFC can imposed IT DATA theft allegations as per Cyber Security Guideline of RBI. does NBFC having any rights to take action legally without follow RBI guideline. What is RBI Guideline in this matter. Please share information", etc. It appears that the Appellant is harbouring a grievance and is not seeking access to information as envisaged under the RTI Act. Despite this, the CPIO provided the response to the Appellant on each of his RTI application as mentioned above; in the spirit of RTI Act.