Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

51. In the backdrop of above facts and circumstances in our considered view, the appellant has not been able to establish a strong prima facie case. The claim is predicated on disputed demurrage allegedly arising from liquidated damages and the very liability is yet to be determined. The validity of the Notice of Readiness dated 21.05.2021 and its issuance at Vung Tau instead of the contractually agreed discharge port at Ho Chi Minh City, the alleged waiver by the respondents, the unsigned Statement of Facts, and the disputed issuance and service of invoices are all contentious issues requiring adjudication. In the absence of a determination on liability, the claim does not crystallize into an enforceable or actionable debt. Hence, the prima facie case may be arguable, but it does not operate conclusively as a strong prima facie case in favour of the appellant.