Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

(r) intentionally insults or intimidates with intent to humiliate a member of a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe in any place within public view;
(s) abuses any member of a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe by caste name in any place within public view;"

32. The basic ingredients of the offence under Clause (r) of sub-Section (1) of Section 3 of the SC/ST Act are: (a) that there must be an 'intentional insult' or 'intimidation' with 'intend' to humiliate SC/ST member by a non-SC/ST member, and (b) that insult or intimidation must have been done in any place within the 'public view'.

"15. Basic ingredients for the offence under Clause (x) of Sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the Act, revealed through the bare reading of this section are as follows: (a) there should be intentional insult or intimidation by a person, who is not a member of SC or ST; (b) the insult must be with an intent to humiliate the member of the SC or ST.

As the intent to humiliate is necessary, it follows that the accused must have knowledge or awareness that the victim belongs to the SC or ST. This can be inferred even from long association; and (c) the incident must occur in any place within the public view. There cannot be any dispute that the offence can be committed at any place whether it is a private place or a "public view" as long as it is within the "public view". The requirement of "public view" can be satisfied even in a private place, where the public is present. I find myself in agreement with the following observations of learned brother Mr. Justice. B.A. Khan while expounding the ingredients of the offence:

"If the accused does not know that the person whom he was intentionally insulting or intimidating or humiliating is a member of SC or ST, an offence under this section would not be constituted. Similarly, if he does not do all this at any place within "public view", the offence would not be made out. Therefore, to attract an offence under Section 3(i)(x), an accused must know that victim belongs to SC/ST caste and he must intentionally insult, intimidate and humiliate him/her at a place within "public view". The place need not be a public place. It could be even at a private place provided the utterance was made within "public view"."