Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

8.2.3 Before dealing with the contentious issue of recognition, we find it apt to emphasize the key importance of the fulfillment of the first two requisites. This is because without the basic satisfaction of these essential conditions, no such claims can be entertainable; nor would the exercise be even worth the labour. To illustrate this point, the decision of the Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal in the OA 767/2009 (Shri Arvind Care & Ors vs UOI & Ors) decided vide an order dated 25.8.2011 is found relevant. (In this judgment one of us i.e. Member (A) was also a Member). The applicants of that OA had been working as Data Processing Assistants in different Divisions of the National Sample Survey Organization under the Ministry of Statistics & Programme Implementation. Their claims for absorption into Subordinate Statistical Service had not been found tenable considering the basic fact that the applicants were essentially Electronic Data Personnel and as per the statutory requirements, only Statistical personnel were eligible for the absorption.