Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

Annexure 'C is as follows:
STATEMENT REGARDING RESTRUCTURING OF GROUP 'C and 'D' STAFF OF COMMERCIAL DEPARTENT Annexure to Board's letter No, PC III/2003/CRC/6 dated 9.10.03. 
 CATEGORY    GRADE      EXISTING     REVISED
            (Rs.)       %AGE         %AGE
The above annexures show that Station Masters/Assistant Station Masters fall within one category and the Ticket Checking Staff is in another category. The said categories denote the cadre namely, cadre of Station Masters/Assistant Station Masters and the cadre of Ticket Checking Staff. In the said cadres., different grades of pay are provided as also the existing percentage of grades in the said cadre and the revised percentage. Corresponding charts showing total number of posts in each cadre, are found at page 5 of the O. As. and the said charts are as under:

30. The Principal Bench of Central Administrative Tribunal in Shiv Kumar v. Union of India and Ors. O.A. No. 1540/2003, has pointed out that a definite proposition of law has been held to distinguish promotion from upgradation and the test is creation of additional posts.

31. In the case before us, the category/cadre of Ticket Checking Staff O.A. 1318/2004 in Anncxures 'C to the scheme dated 9.10.2003 indicates that there are 5 scales thereunder. The existing percentage of each scale vis-a-vis entire cadre is also specified therein as also revised percentage on account of restructuring. The scales remain the same even after restructuring but only there is re-allocation of number of posts in each scale, but the total number of posts remain same. The position is same in the case of Station Masters/Assistant Station Masters O.A. 1347/2004, as can be seen from Annexure ' A' (i) to the scheme dated 9.10.2003 and Chart at page 5 of the said O.A.