Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

26. In C.W.P. No. 7001 of 1994 the petitioner Meenal Sharma is a resident of Panchkula and studied at Chandigarh. In C.W.P. No. 8340 of 1994, the petitioner Bharat B. Dua is a resident of Hodal. Petitioner's father is a doctor. The petitioner did 10th, 11 th and 12th from Himachal Pradesh. In C.W.P. No. 7445 of 1994, the petitioner Ms. Meetu Chhabra is resident of Panchkula and petitioner No. 2 Mr. Ashish Sharma is resident of Kirtinagar, Sirsa. Petitioner No. 1 studied at Chandigarh. Petitioner No. 2 also studied at Chandigarh. In C.W.P. No. 6766 of 1994 the petitioner Gaurav Bansal is a resident of Sonepat and studied upto 10th at Sonepat and finally did 10+ 1 and 10 + 2 at Delhi. In C.W.P. No. 8112 of 1994, the petitioner Miss Shaveta Arora is a resident of Chandigarh and did 10th and 10+1 from Haryana and 10 + 2 from Chandigarh. In C.W.P. No. 8113 of 1994 the petitioner Miss Anchal Gupta did 10th, 10 + 1 and 10 + 2 from Chandigarh. Her father is a domicile of Haryana employed in a Bank at Shahabad. In C.W.P. No. 7938 of 1994 the petitioner, Sahib Sangwan is a resident of Yamuna Nagar. He did X and XII classes from Mussoorie. In C.W.P. No. 8(X)4 of 1994, the petitioner Miss Suchita Verma's father is a resident of village Saidpur District Yamuna Nagar. The petitioner studied 10th, 11th and 12th at Chandigarh. In C.W.P. No. 7891 of 1994, the petitioner Vikas Garg is resident of Sirsa and studied upto 9th at Sirsa and did 10th, 10 + 1 and 10 + 2 from Pilani (Rajasthan). In C.W.P. No. 8095 of 1994, the petitioner, Shalini Jain studied in Haryana upto 8th class and did 9th, 10+1 and 10 + 2 from New Delhi. C.W.P. No. 9309 of 1994 has been filed by Haryana Students 'Welfare Society as public interest litigation.

In order to deal with the rival submissions in the context of difference of opinion between brother A.L. Bahri, J. and brother N.K. Kapoor, J. it is necessary to make a reference to the factual position of those cases.

49. In C.W.P. No. 7001 of 1994 petitioner Meenal Sharma is resident of Panchkula. She passed the Matriculation examination from the Bhartia Bhawan Vidyalya, Chandigarh, and then 10 + 2 examination from the Central Board of Secondary Education (for short 'the C.B.S.E.'). Her parents are doctors having a nursing home at Panchkula and they are the residents of Haryana. In C.W.P. No. 6766 of 1994 petitioner Gaurav Bansal studied at Saraswati Public School, Sonepat, from Class I to Class IV. He passed the 10th examination from Kulachi Hans Raj Model School, New Delhi, and then did 10 +1 and 10 + 2 classes from the Shambhu Dayal Modern School, Sonepat. In C.W.P. No. 7231 of 1994 petitioners Anant Madaan and Aman Aggarwal who are said to have born at Rohtak and Kurukshetra respectively studied within the State of Haryana and passed 10th class from Saint Theresa Convent School, Karnal, Both of them passed their 10 + 2 examination from the Delhi Public School, Delhi. They have claimed that their parents are permanent residents of the State of Haryana and are medical practitioners with the said State. In C.W.P. No. 7276 of 1994, petitioner Vikas Dambla passed 10th class examination from Sonepat and then did his 10 + 2 from Bal Bharti Public School, New Delhi. He claims that his father possesses domicile certificates issued by the Sub Divisional Officer (Civil) on 9.3.1993 and 24.6.1993. Anu Sharma, who is petitioner in C.W.P. No. 7441 of 1994 has come out with a case that she is a domicile of Haryana. Her parents are practising as doctors at Karnal. She did her 10 + 1 and 10 + 2 examinations from the Delhi Public School, R.K. Puram, New Delhi. C.W.P. No. 7036 of 1994 has been filed by Miss Shaloo and Miss Nidhi Garg. Both of them have claimed that they were born in Haryana. Their Parents are permanent residents of Haryana since generations. They passed 10th class examination from the C.B.S.E. Then they took admission in the Government Senior Secondary School, Sector 18, Chandigarh, and D.A.V. Model School, Chandigarh, and have passed 10 + 2 examination conducted by the C.B.S.E. New Delhi. Meetu Chhabra and Ashish Sharma petitioners in C.W.P. No. 7445 of 1994 have claimed that their parents are the residents of Haryana and both of them have passed 10th and 10 + 2 examinations from Chandigarh. In C.W.P. No. 8324 of 1994 petitioner Sandeep Arora is said to have studied in Sainik School, Kapurthala, and passed the examinations from Chandigarh. In C.W.P. No. 8324 of 1994 petitioner Sandeep Arora is said to have studied in Sainik School, Kapurthala, and passed the examinations conducted by the C.B.S.E. In C.W.P. No. 7466 of 1994 petitioners Gaurav and Alka Chauhan are said to be the residents of Gurgaon. Petitioner No. 1 passed the Matriculation examination while studying at the Air Force Central School, New Delhi Cantt and then 10 + 2 examination from the Rotary Public School, Gurgaon. His father is a doctor by profession. Petitioner No. 2 passed the Matriculation examination from Gurgaon and then 10 + 2 examination as a student of Air Force Senior Secondary School, Palam, Delhi Cantt. C.W.P. No. 7467 of 1994 has been filed by Dinesh Madan who says that he is a resident of Gurgaon, had studied up to 10th class at Gurgaon and passed his 10 + examination from a school in New Delhi. He has produced the domicile certificate issued by the City Magistrate, Gurgaon, on 26.5.1994, Annexure P.3. C.W.P. No. 7764 of 1994 has been filed by Balijinder Singh. He has stated that he belongs to the State of Haryana. In support of this, he has produced the domicile certificate dated 16.5.1994. He passed the Matriculation examination conducted by the C.B.S.E. as well as 10 + 2 examination from Chandigarh. In C.W.P. No. 7891 of 1994 petitioner Vikas Garg has stated that he was born at Sirsa and his father is also a resident of Sirsa running a private nursing home there. He studied up to 9th class at Sirsa and the passed the Matriculation examination and 10 + 2 examination from Pilani. He has produced domicile certificate dated 21.5.1994. In C.W.P. No. 7947 of 1994 Roma Mehta has alleged that she is a resident of Yamunagar. For better studies she had joined Saint Mary S. Convent School, Kasauli. She passed the Matriculation examination from the C.B.S.E. She passed 10 + 1 and 10 + 2 examinations while studying at Yamunagar. In C.W.P. No. 8004 of 1994 Miss Suchita Verma has stated that she had passed Matriculation examination from the Yadvindra Public School, Chandigarh.

He has claimed that he has passed 10th examination as a student of Sant Nischal Singh Public School, Yamunanagar and 10 + 2 examination as a student of D.A.V. College, Chandigarh. C.W.P. No. 8196 of 1994 has been jointly filed by Mona Batra and Yukta Mehta. Petitioner No. 1 did her education at Ajmer and petitioner No. 2 at Chandigarh. In C.W.P. No. 8240 of 1994, Veena Singla has come out with a case that she had to study for 10th class at Chandigarh and she passed 10 + 1 and 10 + 2 examinations from the Chaman Lal D.A.V. Senior Secondary School, panchkula. Petitioners Swati and Ashutosh in C.W.P. No. 8248 of 1994 have passed their examinations from schools outside Chandigarh and the State of Haryana. They claimed that on account of service of their parents, they had to study outside the State of Haryana. Petitioner Seema Dua in C.W.P. No. 8262 of 1994 passed her 10th examination from Delhi and 10 + 2 examination from Sonepat. In C.W.P. No. 8271 of 1994 petitioner Sarbjeet Kaur has stated that she has passed 10th, 10 + 1 and 10 + 2 examinations from Chandigarh. In C.W.P. No. 8285 of 1994 Sushil Kumar has stated that he passed 10th examination from a school at Dabwali and 10+1 and 10 + 2 examinations from Chandigarh. Bharat B. Dua (C.W.P. No. 8340 of 1994) says that he is a resident of Hodal. However, for better studies he has taken his education at Shimla (Himachal Pradesh). C.W.P. No. 8341 of 1994 has been filed by petitioner Miss Rajni Mahajan who states that she is a resident of Panchkula but on account of lack of proper educational facilities she has passed 10th, 10 + 1 and 10 + 2 examinations from schools in Chandigarh. In C.W.P. No. 8468 of 1994 petitioner Anita Verma states that she is a resident of Panchkula but has passed 10th and 10 + 2 examinations from Chandigarh on account of lack of educational facilities at Panchkula. C.W.P. No. 8563 of 1994 has been filed by Ajay Malhotra who states that he is a resident of Haryana and has passed his 10th, 10 + 1 and 10 + 2 examinations from Chandigarh. Bhuvnesh Gupta petitioner in C.W.P. No. 8611 of 1994 states that he is an employee of Haryana but passed his 10th, and 10 + 2 examinations from New Delhi. Jatinder Singh has filed C.W.P. No. 8606 of 1994 with an allegation that he was admitted to the Sainik School Nagrota (Jammu) and has passed his 10 + 2 examination as a student of that school. In C.W.P. No. 8686 of 1994 Sangita Angrish says that she passed the 10th examination conducted by the C.B.S.E. in 1992 as also 10 + 2 examination conducted by the said Board. She has, however, not stated as to in which school she had studied before taking examinations conducted by the C.B.S.E. C.W.P. No. 8704 of 1994 has been filed by Shalini Sharma who states that she is a resident of Haryana (Karnal) but has passed 10 + 1 and 10 + 2 examinations from New Delhi. C.W.P.No.8678 of 1994 has been filed by Deni Gupta. He says that he has passed Matriculation examination from Bahadurgarh and then did 10 + 2 examination from New Delhi. His family is residing in Haryana for a number of years. Similar is the position in C.W.P. No. 8679 of 1994 filed by Mayank Gupta. The only difference in his case and the case of Deni Gupta is that Mayank Gupta has passed 10 + 2 examination from New Delhi. In C.W.P. No. 8680 of 1994 Bhawna Soneja has stated that her family is residing in Haryana (Rohtak) for the last many years but in order to get better education she has passed 10th and 10 + 2 examinations from New Delhi. C.W.P. No. 8783 of 1994 has been filed by Rajneesh Kumar who says that he is a permanent resident of Panchkula town and has passed the 10 + 1 and 10 + 2 examinations from Panchkula although he had passed the Matriculation examination from Mohali (Punjab). C.W.P. No. 8751 of 1994 has been filed by Reena Shivrain with an allegation that she has passed 10th and well as 10 + 2 examinations from Delhi because her father is an employee of the Government of India. C.W.P. No. 8772 of 1994 has been filed by Krishna Kumar who says that he has passed 10 + 2 examination from Delhi because at the relevant time his father was a teacher in the Delhi Administration. C.W.P. No. 7938 of 1994 has been filed by Sahib Sangwan who claims that he is a permanent resident of Haryana. He has studied at Jagadhri but passed his 10th and 10 + 2 examinations from Mussoorie.