Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

2. Assailing the decision of the PCI Selection Committee, Mr Varun Singh, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that as per the eligibility criteria for selection in Tokyo Paralympics, each athlete interested in participating in the event had to achieve a Minimum Qualifying Score (MQS) at a Shooting Event, which would then be used to calculate his Final Average Score (FAS). To that end, there were two kinds of events, being international and domestic, in which the athlete could participate to build his FAS. He submits that however, the FAS calculated by the Committee appeared to deliberately deviate from the 2019-20 calculation criteria and contained inflated scores, which issue was raised by the petitioner in an e- mail sent by him to the President of the PCI on 17.07.2021. He draws my attention to a chart reflecting the score tabulation between the petitioner and respondent no.4 and submits that, contrary to the usual policy, the respondents decided to factor in the scores obtained by respondent no.4 in the Novi Sad 2021 World Shooting Para Sport (WSPS) Grand Prix, held between 01.04.2021 and 04.04.2021, even though it was not a recognised event for the purpose of score tabulation either by the PCI or the International Paralympic Committee (IPC). He submits that the Detailed Selection Criteria uploaded by the PCI on 18.06.2019 on its website for the Indian Paralympic Shooting Team at the Tokyo Paralympics, clearly stated that for the purpose of calculating MQS, only scores accumulated from the following eight shooting events would be considered - (i) Cheongju 2018 WSPS World Championship, Korea, (ii) Chateauroux 2018 World Cup, France (iii) Para-Asian Games, Jakarta, Indonesia 2013, (iv) Al Ain 2019 WSPS World Cup, UAE, (v) Osijek 2019 WSPS World Cup, Croatia, (vi) WSPS World Championship Sydney 2019, Australia, (vii) AI Ain 2020/21 WSPS World Cup, UAE and, (viii) Paralympic Selection Trials 2019-20/21. He submits that the criterion intentionally did not enlist Novi Sad Grand Prix as one of the qualifying events given that a World Cup is a tougher competition where a large number of countries participate, whereas Grand Prix have lesser competitors. This is why, as a matter of practice, even the Schedule issued by the parent body, IPC, did not include Grand Prix event scores for tallying the FAS of an athlete.