Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

10. Narrating the instances of malafide action on the part of  the appellant, it is submitted that initially, an order was passed by  the  General Manager (Civil), which was subsequently withdrawn  vide   order   dated   19.03.2014   signed   on   20.03.2014   and   on   the  same   day,   the   Chairman   passed   another   order   dated   20.03.2014  affirming debarment of the respondent­Joint Venture on the ground  that Dev Multicom Pvt. Ltd. was a partner in   Gopalka Dev Joint  Venture, which has been debarred by order dated 27.11.2013 for  producing forged credentials. It is submitted that a petition seeking  initiation   of   criminal   contempt   for   filing   a   false   affidavit   in   the  Court has been filed and in the said proceeding, the Chairman has  tendered   apology   taking   a   plea   of   human   error.   It   is   finally  submitted that, since the appellant has already filed I.A No. 1814 of  2014   and   I.A.   No.   1816   of   2014   seeking   recall   of   order   dated  12.03.2014   and   only   the   initial   order   of   status­quo   dated  05.03.2014   has   been   impugned   in   the   present   Letters   Patent  Appeals,   this   Court   may   not   entertain   the   present   Letters   Patent  Appeals.   It   is   further   submitted   that   the   present   Letters   Patent  Appeals  have  been  filed against  order dated 05.03.2014 and the  subsequent   orders   passed   by   the   Writ   Court   on   09.04.2014   and  23.04.2014 have not been challenged therefore, the Letters Patent  Appeals are fit to be dismissed.