Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

39
                       ,''                      •              j     lz•I_.                                                94t
                                                                                                                                                       I                               •I
7 n         i            i    I    Tutu,                                            I       'i        I.        i   \,                 .I             (W'             'i   '.1
        )fln•                .                  ;.                                  ',lj
                                   '
                                                           •i•                                   -%         I
                                                                                                                                                    s•     •                      I.
         I.        ,
                         •   r                  I              ',                                               Ill            --           I   'I
                                                                                                                                S     •             g
                                                                                                                                                              )
                                                                                                                                     '    I                 II

                                                                                                                                    S_I'           I
                                   a                                    J                                U
E                                      I )        /    -'                       I
                                                              1%            \          I('                       I I       )         I            (0
'       :                      .--''      •,\      1.j;i'c   )'ei                                                                    sT.j
            •'t. u'c,                                                                ')p 1                                                    J    II       y
1'      '     T' 1                            !   ii    1
                                                        T .                                  it                            •             •"             'S
                                                                                I)       I               I                                    •')•'.    it    I
                         I     . i.               (                             SI                               5.51
                                                                                                 1'
IUTI
.
1 j                                                                                                                                                    1)
            Sti          ii   %fg)7 f_        or         'P "i" jo P.C '1 ',J tiI'i                                                                         )"'
    1']           •     )      '
                                                                  P'FJ' ':j )":4..
                                       b,I.              _fl..dt4
Cs          I'        LLl(i)I                 1'i''                                                                                SA                   I
    1       IC    I
                                                                                             : 0 oa                                 I.                  'fi
                                                                                •ñrp,                             in '3urqL-urr
                                                                       t'O)4         1RE 1J 13 Lt IZ' (ft
                                                                                             '
                                                                                          ,s ç i. '] .
                                                                                                                                                  4!
                               tv1.ltb'               "j'OLIICId                I"
                                                                       U                 C''
     ltIPJI4Lhd"                                                                                     )   )9L'   HElP" Tilt
                                                                                                            P 'N 'T" IP
                                                                                                                       ) I "C t11L)\
                                                               b)PJ         •tlI)'%jt'IIUt.'                           ti ,j    3 1%          )
                                                                   I                 '       I               1         I            ",'       III
                                                                                                                       '%..,'1%T                       ici
                                                                                     I       )OZ ,1                    --           )'%'i      i)        11
      \q ltj                 S 1' 1 r1
                                    ct_ii j
     I        1)          1        C.
     r ti_.ia,'.                                  fl()    •2,

                                                                  S   V>,            kiar       h   e1
     '           )

             "       ['411(1 loLors Pvi.                              Li I
    J 9. aba i n1
    ',ubt, unit C ire)"
    H i it         r 1 1

    ii" 5i1 K S R r r,'wnkar N ' Pt IlL) A lit' 1k', p nc''                                                  c   Di K S
                       N V Ii cuii       cl's, cc ts


CONCEPT OF SERVICE TAX L NOJA FEDERATION OF TAX PRACTITIONERS AND OTHERS vs UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS [(2007) 9 VST I 26(SC)J 200 (7 STR o2i (SC xi ii ,C' -





                     I"                )1I1(                               111                 1C(t           f        '              (1'       I            i
        1:                Clot S                 ii        i'              '               (()ii' 11


                          'flI         UI        Cot!      I       'of         csr'i H                                     1-                   1! 1'! '1

        j                (                  II                                                  C

       I'            '1                H!        t,                JJ(                         'Hd            31')!                                      1'

        I au     15           ii                       1   ((C CCC                                        I')                   1(1             1   C        1 'Ct


                                   1        Ho                 t                           N         5'   t                                 V


        C            1                                                                           1            ii                                              I

             I   C j,'j            N         H        11               1   '     C                                    IC          o     7'              51         1
       -I                              I'll
                                                                   I                 ,,C
                                                                                                 ttt                       o'-1             ._                II




       (         '                                                                              III                               t1i                    /i



                     7)




                                        If                                                                        C
                                                                                                      ha c                                           Ilk

                                                           'W                                            S

                 Ct'                               Il'c,                                                 1         1                     '      (11011

tJ(LLL'f         C!'                IL             '       (APiIII;lI 1'                                     t          Es' .wZs                        ('WI
 ''i''niqnhvsr cf                                ;'fl•lt'                           fl,.        I)')!?! ';'iIisI:i
'in       tLs          1! Ic lIiis                     cc ' lIP 'I INC o 'Ik.e'! '1 I)(L%.'(i ('Ii tilt'

icytd priva                    •!'          •1 e'juiL'ctk.rlcr 'cinch                                                   I!'"            crnrzcls
                                                the (n                                          ton '             ick                   tttuuon

              hit,         j                           'iwl,                          1              20(                                             it

              )T I                                           I                       C                                                              CLIL

     z    It'd :                               n            'i       IL                         i     q Il(                                  .'iuc               1'
                 S         ')             SI           '    )17),7q'!               't'gI            '_      'i    11 S         LIL..    i

                                                                                                                                         t'IVh
pI'Iz'.Iinr                         .,1     '

                               --'      5•)
                                                3 )                •'               '   :'    :'.     •.;           .11             Ii.1.I    I                    ".ht.
                                                                                                                              .11                              !                         •.;
                                      c'":                        •'
                                                                                                                                                                             j
      •                                                                   •         'Iii                                                                             I            'I     I
     01                                         I             1'                                                          4                                                                  I
    ;'                               --,
                   j'                           '                              •:                                                                                        '
                               P                                                                                    PA 4)U1 LI                        h
                   'C    Ija'ULIL.ti Iii              )Ij.        j)'It        --        ) ':'..T           .       'p1111i           sII          .1 •,              ,.
A    •j'T..             •['ja'T             4j!      T             T
                                                         )j            '!.jj1 :tU                     )''             .._:.j.)_: •T                       ILIrLIjITI•) T).
.T             )S1                   Ip                                                      Thu                          "
                                                                                                                                       U                  •i       3.)           1I          U
                         L     --      tiLl                                          I                          4:                       1)))                                      1'
     4)        ILl )IT'U jIL'               '       '4 nis              ii          C        q.   kfl                              aa'.:          p       flj) 11)4                     Tn

                        •ql                     ej'       tLa          ..).   Ji)1tT 1111                  01 '4              11%    1W!          no
I)OOZ t')                %t        ttTIJ.t)         .1l.-.ttIi )I.11I()Ia')a't                        1•'l         ))1)(            Lf1 'L' III'tI                           3LI!pa
                                    41          )JLjO(                         IjtIT                           Ot                 Tqt'rI                                               WI
                   151         1 I                    )      I'          s    aj         jft      T   .)   ii'        II.
                                            1                                                                                 4)             e             ''JLi             l'ii. Li
4j        ''       '.I'Ij      %   I )Lt1I                                      .)Iss             TI'Ti;              --.'..
                                                                                                                              '     l
                                                                                                                                    "
                                                                                                                                    t 'j          )SLI             a. T                ),i   3
Jt. Titi       1        4a           'I'j       ,..s..    1
                                                          •t                                           "'i            •"
                                                                              ':'       :T--'"'                                II     'I'     I'd )3                              JtLt'       )
                                                                                        It
                                                                                                                                                                                                 I
                                                                                                                                                                                                 p
 I





                 )                                       t                                  I                '               )I         '         -             C                 TI

                                    ''                           --   ;';w-                      • t          n   1
                                                                                                                 t .%
                                                                                                                                       '41"LlI iltU                    j'

        pr'" snn                            Sc 'Iic'Ii                     "                                      t'.                  c      th it                         ,'c!"           'ti   54
             --           ir         I       T                        a                      a                       a         I        t          ,         a        at       it            t         it


        Let i'r:               a'bI              1.1             %U        Ii        'Ciii' 1'                    'lIe I.          u
                                                                                                                                   1          ha'. %up)res%ro                                          a

         nrkl-aM                        ilit                 '   aim-- ni                        I       usable              st     n-h'                   nr has              Iii-iiisl'c ci

             a                  Ic.                  e                                     ._tL                                        -      i1rc                    1(11%

        Cit't Sc-               ri              1'        a cr Its                     li               u'         1k tttc1                   dilki                   ii    ic-id                 '
                                                                                                                                                                                                  u
                                                                                                                                                                                                  4 1

        e'           fi         .       j   rj,t1e                   r ji 1 1.                          ii       1. -L       Ll)iisi)C' 1 liii                        tilt'       a%e--L-c



             I%'lI)I                        %It                        (        itcilc                                      ili_                  'it                         n"                      IlL

         , ft                  is           ci       '                      '               ".           I             (     ',        ;     t:t                             --                        ii

                                             'I.            \           Si                   its,-        !''             ,            :':         s,

    '.t      'I   tj't •                                    •    1
                                                                 it''             '•              '               •       I. ' ,''i                    '



                                        S                                                                                                         t

                ''a                          '
                                                                       U                •'
                                                                                                         i'.          ?        •
                                                                                                                                            ,

--   I     41;          cej,;s                    (,c,I. 1              '     i's                               'i."           'I       --   it.

5(           I''           ,'
                                                        '         ,j              ...         .
                                         I            •       1                   • an                      t.   'i.',l         '                   Id               iuclqii'cns                            Ld

         Ibnc.                  .' .                 Len'                    I           l         lie lift'                                            ' •fl
                                                                                                                                                                                  J Ua 1-                           s       '
         h itkcucui fsi                                              i       i                r            'c inja qi                                       .        ('II                     19S'                      t
        Ii R 12.'i ite                                               pieunq                             prc"w& i'i. I') 11W i'ZIL'l(                                                                       %ts          in

                      Rt'rems                                                'Iii             lIl,ji'               (4) ITt 1i.'iti                                   pritic                        1:bs.               In
        this              (4        i. t. *. .                       I           '       uisi bc                      ic guT L'(l                                        L.             iiii'.Artiiçj                       ci



        cnivc'pflo, oh                                                   rrs              or circle,                          which                         er           '    s         ibi           i i 'C                I
        tilt.         al'               1 ii         SIiCUI                      in           7         7.1           U       c       .    Iii              'ic I ilil                              hL      .   '   inc
        qric'nnsc                                   iicw                 in          ii c Ore' ci l)acsucl
                                                                                                           Ifl• ilk.                                                                                  it
                                                                                                                                                                                                       trol'cC
        an OJJ                      --                    vi (ci                               'igh s                      t   '           bail trend                                      'ir         iwuht'rq

         .i           sitiilar                                   a.ssessitc '                                                         slur's                                  'i              d            irtc,i
     • ((     k.a'z                 iq.                  1       e               ( can'iv (s.d. ncr                                            Id iii                         t1              tI'          (        I
    pitiU•                'idol                                  Ic,                          ii                    '.it              ( S           '.                c
                                                                                                                                                                              I                   Rc tr s.lz:
        &l'ii         ii".' 41('Il                                       hi          £ U               ".Cfl              P7          S        s    tic' piehs'i 4: i I'%
        i in          !             l(          i            ii'                         'q Ew                            Pc                        '1k             i.a             J be I nc
                'ci             '            .i4                 £       sIcci                         r,&          'p                     c        ne'rr                                     i       "         sit'
                     s          'i:             c.           ii'                     %'t          ef
                                                                                                                      I s                               J
                                                                                                                '
                                                                                                                                                                    54                                I'll)
    lb              11.                         zc               I           ci '                 ..'                     (ii             7'                'el' 'ii' 4
    '.7 ( 'lit                           '           I.. 'i
                                                         t
                                                         4                                        'I r                                    lUc                       I,             '.     '       '1 1          .11
        1 1     --     Jr                     Qi              1.11                    )            '1                iS'i                                    11                    4s
                                                                                                                                                                                  c'r'•               i'
•            '1 1                        1.              ;'                      ,i:--                  •                                  '('ilL
                            it..             .JiI. C                                              .1(41               1           t        •                        .1',
1'       '      vs        't.               1       LS               I                                  't           •'                                         a"'
                                                                                                                                  .                .•                                             i             1"

    .           i                               .                                    •
                          .
                                                                                                                                                                ,
                                                                                                                                                                             ,•     .',           •:.u.

                                                                         t               •i                     £                     t''                                                ..
                                                                                             3.i




                       'lit            Is..             sins,            ( 'ire,                        arLio:              hr           i'      iit,1         '*S
                                      U        I            'it'        jijV(               .l.                  fl.c
                                                                                ,

                                                                                                                            * "t'llLü                      I    w
                 nsitJ)h                  V ZLI (An                    liu     'Pit.          cL             )ljic I        wkqirct on
            the c'cii rccs PC 171asb411)ic in I a" and 1 has                                                                             r
                                                                                                                                                 aft 'ci n
            'O'          fi lit 1' inr vi                                 L 'JElL I'L ) tiLt S CI                                        '        )S%b c.
             UlC       the. Ii C H it 1L                                 ) JI'u ha                               ,ka             i   '       '         i       cli
            LL'liiClL         lie' Ccii 1115cC 1                                        1   rI 'S                ci     (j                   I        'ill I
           bc. r" IcAL (h- CI cr                                              ic' i                riot rr.lsc Liji i(
                                                                          .
                                                                                                                                                           Ic
            lit t% Sit lii.                                 Rev in                          .ii'                 lie        'i n             late      i

           th          Income tax Ollkc                           a I.uv. Ii        '& .11         s.istntne.bl