Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments


                                                                 W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of         Alleged defamatory         Date Name of      G.O.   Nature of
 No.         the           Article published          of      the    sanction Challenge
         Petitioners                                Publi Public       ing
                                                    cation Figure prosecut
                                                       s   who has ion and
                                                             been      date
                                                           allegedly
                                                           defamed
of       esh, Editor, $wpajhtJ:                       2011   Chief        No.1224 complaint
2012     Printer   &  vdJ                     kfd;           Minister,    dated    C.C.No.3
                      cjaepjp             ];lhypd;>
         Publisher    ez;gh;        uh[h     rq;fh;          Selvi        23.12.20 of 2012
                      kw;Wk; rpyh; kPJ ngha;                 J.Jayalali   11
                      tof;F                   gjpT           tha
                      nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
4861     R.M.R.Ram NghyPrhNu                   ,J                                   Governme
of       esh, Editor, njhlu;ghf                                                     nt Order
2012     Printer   & gj;jpupiffSf;F nra;jp
                      nfhLj;Js;sdh;.
         Publisher    vg;.I.Mh; vd;gJ gh;];l;
                      ,d;gh;Nk\d; upg;Nghu;l”;
                      vd;gJ jhd;. Mdhy;>
                      mjpKf Ml;rpapy; mJ
                      “gpuhl;         ,d;gh;Nk\d;
                      upg;Nghu;l”; lhf cs;sJ.
                      vd; kPJk;> FLk;gj;jhh;
                      kPJk;        ngha;      Gfhh;
                      nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. ,J
                      gw;wp           NgRtjw;fhf
                      b[pgpia              re;jpf;f
                      te;Njd;.              mtiu
                      re;jpf;Fk;            tha;gG;
                      fpilf;ftpy;iy. epu;thf
                      gpupT     Vb[pgpaplk;         2
                      kDf;fs;
                      nfhLj;Js;Nsd;.
                      Kjy; kDtpy;> “vd;
                      kPJ       ngha;       tof;F
                      Nghlg;gl;Ls;sJ. mjpy;
                      $wg;gl;Ls;s
                      nrhj;Jf;Fk;         vdf;Nfh
                      vd;      Flk;gj;jhUf;Nfh
                      ve;j              rk;ke;jKk;
                      ,y;iy. cjaepjp
                      ];lhypd;             elj;Jk;
                      rpdpkh           fk;ngdpf;F
                      thlif          mbg;gilapy;
                      xg;ge;jk;        nra;ag;gl;L
                      kfSk;>             kUkfDk;
                      me;j                  tPl;by;


                                                              W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of        Alleged defamatory          Date Name of      G.O.   Nature of
 No.         the          Article published           of      the    sanction Challenge
         Petitioners                                Publi Public       ing
                                                    cation Figure prosecut
                                                       s   who has ion and
                                                             been      date
                                                           allegedly
                                                           defamed
                       jq;fpAs;sdh;.       ngha;
                       Gfhh; nfhLj;jth; kPF
                       eltbf;if            vLf;f
                       Ntz;Lk;”             vd;W
                       $wpAs;Nsd;.
                       ve;j             tof;fhf
                       ,Ue;jhYk;           mij
                       re;jpf;f          jahuhf
                       ,Uf;fpNwd;.        vd;id
                       ifJ           nra;Aq;fs;
                       vd;Wjhd;     Vb[pgpaplk;
                       nrhd;Ndd;.          mij
                       Nfl;L mth; Kopf;fpwhh;.
                       cz;ikahd              epy
                       Mf;fpukpg;G Gfhh; kPJ
                       eltbf;if            vLf;f
                       Ntz;Lk;           vd;why;
                       NfhlehL           v];Nll;
                       gpdhkp            ngaupy;
                       Mf;fpukpg;G
                       nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
                       rpWjhT+h;         gq;fsh
                       fl;bAs;s ,lk; jypj;
                       kf;fspd; ,lk;. mJ
                       Mf;fpukpg;G
                       nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
                       Kjy;th;       Xa;Tf;fhf
                       mq;F          nrd;Wjhd;
                       jq;Ffpwhh;.      ,jdhy;
                       ,e;j      ,uz;L       epy
                       Mf;fpukpg;G          Gfhh;
                       Fwpj;J Kjy;th; kPJ
                       eltbf;if            vLf;f
                       Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk;> mth;
                       kPJ      vg;IMh;     gjpT
                       nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk;
                       2-tJ              kDtpy;
                       $wpAs;Nsd;.         mjpy;
                       epahak;        fpilf;Fk;
                       vd;W          ek;GfpNwd;.
                       ,t;thW K.f.];lhypd;
                       $wpdhh;.


                                                            W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch




Name of the Newspaper : Murasoli

 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory      Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published     Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english       ons      Public      ng
                            translation                   Figure prosecuti
                                                         who has on and
                                                           been      date
                                                         allegedly
                                                         defamed
23679 S.Selvam,        fiyQh; gjpy;fs;      30.07.20 Former       G.O.Ms. Governme
of    Printer,         Nfs;tp:- jkpofj;jpy; 12       Chief        No.709 nt order
2012 Publisher         ,Jtiu vj;jidNah               Minister,    dt.
      and Editor       Kjyikr;rh;fs;                 Selvi        8.8.2012
                       ,Ue;jpUf;fpwhh;fs;.           J.Jayalali
25296                  mth;fspy; ve;jnthU                                      Criminal
of                                                   tha                       Complaint
                       Kjyikr;ruhtJ
2012                   gjtpapy;                                                C.C.No.14
                       ,Uf;Fk;NghNj>                                           of 2012
                       ,uz;L khj
                       fhyj;jpw;F Xa;T
                       vd;W VNjh xU
                       Chpy; Ngha; jq;fpaJ
                       cz;lh?
                       fiyQh;:- ,Nj
                       Nfs;tpiaj;jhd;
                       gh.k.f. epWtdh;
                       lhf;lh; uhkjhRk;
                       Nfl;bUf;fpwhh;. ,e;j
                       mstpw;F
                       mth;fSf;F Xa;T
                       Njitg;gLfpwJ
                       NghYk;! mijg;gw;wpa
                       ftiy> mtUf;F
                       thf;fspj;jth;fSf;f
                       y;yth Vw;glNtz;Lk;.
                       “Kalaignar Pathilgal”




                                                              W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory        Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published       Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english         ons      Public      ng
                            translation                     Figure prosecuti
                                                           who has on and
                                                             been      date
                                                           allegedly
                                                           defamed
                       Question:- There have
                       been many Chief
                       Ministers of Tamil
                       Nadu and has any
                       Chief Minister while
                       holding position taken
                       a vacation for over two
                       months.
                 Answer:-A       similar
                 question was asked by
                 the     P.M.K.Founder
                 Dr.Ramadass and may
                 be the Chief Minister
                 requires such vacation.
                 This is a matter of
                 concern for the voters
                 who have voted.
23680 S.Selvam, “vd;               Ngr;R 09.08.20 Former            G.O.No.7 Governme
of    Printer,   cz;   i kf;F  khwhdJ    12       Chief             16        nt Order
                 vd;why;
2012 Publisher & Mjhug;G+h;tkhf                   Minister,         dt.14.8.2

25297
                 Ntz;baJjhNd!                     J.Jayalali                     Criminal
                 Vjph;fl;rpfspd;                  tha
of               nra;jpfis>                                                      Complaint
2012             Ngr;Rf;fis                                                      C.C.No.16
                 ntspapLk;                                                       of 2012
                 gj;jphpiffs;       kPJ
                 tof;F!
                 thuf;fzf;fpy;
                 khjf;fzf;fpy;
                 Kjyikr;rh;        Xa;T
                 vLj;jhy;        kf;fs;
                 gpujpepjpfs;


                                                            W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory      Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published     Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english       ons      Public      ng
                            translation                   Figure prosecuti
                                                         who has on and
                                                           been      date
                                                         allegedly
                                                         defamed
mijg;gw;wp
                       Ngrf;$lhjh?
                       jkpo;ehl;by;
                       mwptpf;fg;glhj
                       neUf;fb        epiyah
                       ePbf;fpwJ?
                       n[ayypjhtpd;
                       tof;if
                       ePjpkd;wj;jpy;
                       re;jpg;Ngd;!
                       The statement made by
                       Tr.M.K.Stalin is as
                       under:-
                       “NkYk; jkJ
                       mwpf;ifapy;>
                       thuf;fzf;fpy;> khjf;
                       fzf;fpy;
                       Kjyikr;rh; Xa;T
                       vLj;jhy; kf;fs;
                       gpujpepjpfs;
                       mijg;gw;wp
                       Ngrf;$lhjh vd;Wk;
                       n[ayypjhtpd;
                       tof;if
                       ePjpkd;wj;jpy;
                       rl;lg;gb re;jpg;Ngd;
                       vd;Wk; jsgjp
                       K.f.];lhypd;
                       mth;fs;
                       Fwpg;gpl;Ls;shh;.
                       “mk;ikahh; fle;j
                       xd;wiu khjkhf
                       Mw;wpa gzpfs;
                       vd;d?
                       nfhlehl;by; xU
                       Kjyikr;rh; Xa;T


                                                          W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory    Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published   Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english     ons      Public      ng
                            translation                 Figure prosecuti
                                                       who has on and
                                                         been      date
                                                       allegedly
                                                       defamed
                       vd;why; xU rpy
                       ehl;fs; ,Uf;fyhk;.
                       Mdhy;>
                       thuf;fzf;fpy;>
                       khjf;fzf;fpy;
                       Kjyikr;rh; Xa;T
                       vd;why; kf;fs;
                       gpujpepjpfs;
                       mijg;gw;wp
                       Ngrf;Rlhjh?
                       md;whlk; mwpf;if
                       xd;W Kjy;
                       mikr;rh; ngahpy;
                       te;jijj; jtpu
                       Ntnwd;d gzp
                       Kiwahf
                       eilngw;wJ?


33290 S.Selvam, “fiyQh; gjpy;fs;”    23.08.20 Minister          G.O.Ms. Governme
of    Printer,   Nfs;tp:- “Mde;j     12       for               No.874 nt Order
2012 Publisher & tpfld;” thu ,jopy;           Tourism,          dt.12.10.
      Editor                                  Tmt.              2012
                 “Nfhl;ilapy;
                                              S.Gokula
                 Kjy;tUf;F
                 mikr;rh;fspd;                Indira
                 khpahij” vd;w
                 jiyg;Gld; xU
                 ePz;l “fpA+”
                 thpirapy;
                 mikr;rh;fs; vy;yhk;
                 thpirahf Fk;gpl;l
                 ifNahL Kjy;tiu
                 tzq;Fk; glj;NjhL
                 vOjg;gl;Ls;s
                 fl;Liu vg;gb?



                                                             W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory       Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published      Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english        ons      Public      ng
                            translation                    Figure prosecuti
                                                          who has on and
                                                            been      date
                                                          allegedly
                                                          defamed
                       fiyQh;:- me;jf;
                       fl;Liuapy;
                       m.jp.K.f.
                       mikr;rh;fSk;>
                       mth;fSila
                       cjtpahsh;fSk;
                       vg;gb ele;J
                       nfhs;fpwhh;fs; vd;W
                       vOjg;gl;Ls;sJ.
                       mjpNy cs;s rpy
                       Kf;fpa gFjpfs;
                       tUkhW:-
                       gjtpg; gpukhzj;ijf;
                       FLk;g jiyth;
                       Vw;Wf;nfhz;lhYk;>
                       FLk;g cWg;gpdh;fs;
                       %yk; /igy;fis
                       f;spah; nra;tJ
                       elf;fpwJ;
                       tdj;Jiw mikr;rh;
                       gr;irkhYf;F mtuJ
                       kidtpAk;> NfhFy
                       ,e;jpuhTf;F mtuJ
                       fztUk;;jhd;
                       Nrdy;fs;.”
                       Kalaignar Pathilgal
                       Question: asking an
                       opinion from
                       Tr.Karunanidhi about
                       the photo published in
                       the weekly “Ananda
                       Vikatan”on the
                       heading “respect given


                                                                W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory          Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published         Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english           ons      Public      ng
                            translation                       Figure prosecuti
                                                             who has on and
                                                               been      date
                                                             allegedly
                                                             defamed
                       by the Ministers to the
                       Chief Minister”
                       wherein the photo
                       showed them standing
                       in a straight line with
                       folded hands.
                       Answer:Some of the
                       Ministers in the
                       Cabinet are under the
                       hands of their relatives.
                       Even though Minister
                       heads the department,
                       files are being cleared
                       by their family
                       members. The husband
                       of Hon’ble Minister
                       for Tourism,
                       Tmt.S.Gokula Indira is
                       the channel for the said
                       Minister.



33291 S.Selvam,        fiyQh; gjpy;fs;             23.08.20 Minister G.O.Ms. Governme
of    Printer,         Nfs;tp:- “Mde;j             12       for      No.954 nt Order
2012 Publisher &       tpfld;” thu ,jopy;                   Labour dt.
      Editor           “Nfhl;ilapy;                         Tr.S.T.C 6.11.201
                       Kjy;tUf;F                            hellapan 2
                       mikr;rh;fspd;                        dian
                       khpahij” vd;w



                                                          W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory    Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published   Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english     ons      Public      ng
                            translation                 Figure prosecuti
                                                       who has on and
                                                         been      date
                                                       allegedly
                                                       defamed
                       jiyg;Gld; xU
                       ePz;l “fpA+”
                       thpirapy;
                       mikr;rh;fs; vy;yhk;
                       thpirahf Fk;gpl;l
                       ifNahL Kjy;tiu
                       tzq;Fk; glj;NjhL
                       vOjg;gl;Ls;s
                       fl;Liu vg;gb?
                       fiyQh;:- me;jf;
                       fl;Liuapy;
                       m.jp.K.f.
                       mikr;rh;fSk;>
                       mth;fSila
                       cjtpahsh;fSk;
                       vg;gb ele;J
                       nfhs;fpwhh;fs; vd;W
                       vOjg;gl;Ls;sJ.
                       mjpNy cs;s rpy
                       Kf;fpa gFjpfs;
                       tUkhW:-
                       “gjtpg;
                       gpukhzj;ijf; FLk;g
                       jiyth;
                       Vw;Wf;nfhz;lhYk;>
                       FLk;g cWg;gpdh;fs;
                       %yk; /igy;fis
                       f;spah; nra;tJ
                       elf;fpwJ;
                       “rp.j.nry;yghz;badp
                       d; kfd;fSila
                       Ml;rp
                       J}j;Jf;Fbiaj;
                       jhz;b nrd;id
                       tiuf;Fk;


                                                                W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory          Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published         Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english           ons      Public      ng
                            translation                       Figure prosecuti
                                                             who has on and
                                                               been      date
                                                             allegedly
                                                             defamed
                       te;Jtpl;lJ.”
                       Kalaignar Pathilgal
                       Question: asking an
                       opinion from
                       Tr.Karunanidhi about
                       the photo published in
                       the weekly “Ananda
                       Vikatan”on the
                       heading “respect given
                       by the Ministers to the
                       Chief Minister”
                       wherein the photo
                       showed them standing
                       in a straight line with
                       folded hands.
                       Answer: Some of the
                       Ministers in the
                       Cabinet are under the
                       hands of their relatives.
                       Even though Minister
                       heads the department,
                       files are being cleared
                       by his family
                       members. The sons of
                       Hon’ble Minister for
                       Labour
                       Tr.S.T.Chellapandian
                       had extended beyond
                       Thoothukudi and


                                                             W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory       Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published      Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english        ons      Public      ng
                            translation                    Figure prosecuti
                                                          who has on and
                                                            been      date
                                                          allegedly
                                                          defamed
                       reached up to Chennai.



32392 S.Selvam, fiyQh; gjpy;fs;      23.08.20 Minister             G.O.Ms. Governme
of    Printer,   Nfs;tp:- “Mde;j     12       for                  No.840 nt Order
2012 Publisher & tpfld;” thu ,jopy;           Forest               dt.03.10.
      Editor                                  Mr.K.T.              2012
                 “Nfhl;ilapy;
                                              Pachama
                 Kjy;tUf;F
                 mikr;rh;fspd;                l
                 khpahij” vd;w
                 jiyg;Gld; xU
                 ePz;l “fpA+”
                 thpirapy;
                 mikr;rh;fs; vy;yhk;
                 thpirahf Fk;gpl;l
                 ifNahL Kjy;tiu
                 tzq;Fk; glj;NjhL
                 vOjg;gl;Ls;s
                 fl;Liu vg;gb?
                 fiyQh;:- me;jf;
                 fl;Liuapy;
                 m.jp.K.f.
                 mikr;rh;fSk;>
                 mth;fSila
                 cjtpahsh;fSk;
                 vg;gb ele;J
                 nfhs;fpwhh;fs; vd;W
                 vOjg;gl;Ls;sJ.
                 mjpNy cs;s rpy
                 Kf;fpa gFjpfs;
                 tUkhW:-
                       “gjtpg;
                       gpukhzj;ijf; FLk;g


                                                              W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory        Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published       Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english         ons      Public      ng
                            translation                     Figure prosecuti
                                                           who has on and
                                                             been      date
                                                           allegedly
                                                           defamed
                       jiyth;
                       Vw;Wf;nfhz;lhYk;>
                       FLk;g cWg;gpdh;fs;
                       %yk; /igy;fis
                       f;spah; nra;tJ
                       elf;fpwJ; gs;sp
                       fy;tpj; Jiw
                       mikr;rh; rptgjpad;
                       ,uz;L jk;gpfs;
                       mLj;jLj;j ,uz;L
                       Xl;ly;fspy;
                       cl;fhh;eJ; nfhz;L
                       Jiw tp\aq;fis
                       By; nra;fpwhh;fs;.
                       tdj;Jiw mikr;rh;
                       gr;irkhYf;F mtuJ
                       kidtpAk;> NfhFy
                       ,e;jpuhTf;F mtuJ
                       fztUk;;jhd;
                       Nrdy;fs;.”


                       Kalaignar Pathilgal
                       Question: asking an
                       opinion from
                       Tr.Karunanidhi about
                       the photo published in
                       the weekly “Ananda
                       Vikatan”on the
                       heading “respect given
                       by the Ministers to the
                       Chief
                       Minister”wherein the


                                                              W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory        Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published       Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english         ons      Public      ng
                            translation                     Figure prosecuti
                                                           who has on and
                                                             been      date
                                                           allegedly
                                                           defamed
                       photo showed them
                       standing in a straight
                       line with folded hands.
                 Answer:Some of the
                 Ministers in the
                 Cabinet are under the
                 hands of their relatives.
                 Even though Minister
                 heads the department,
                 files are being cleared
                 by his family
                 members.The two
                 brothers of Hon’ble
                 Minister for Education,
                 Mr.Sivapadhiyan, are
                 dealing with the
                 matters about the
                 department in two
                 subsequent, hotels.
                 The wife of Hon’ble
                 Minister for Forests
                 Thiru.K.T.Pachamal is
                 the channel for the said
                 minister.
32393 S.Selvam, fiyQh; gjpy;fs;            23.08.20       Minister    G.O.Ms. Governme
of    Printer,   Nfs;tp:- “Mde;j           12             for         No.927 nt Order
2012 Publisher & tpfld;” thu ,jopy;                       Finance.    dt.25.10.
      Editor                                              Mr.O.Pa     2012
                 “Nfhl;ilapy;
                                                          neerselva
                 Kjy;tUf;F



                                                            W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory      Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published     Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english       ons      Public      ng
                            translation                   Figure prosecuti
                                                         who has on and
                                                           been      date
                                                         allegedly
                                                         defamed
mikr;rh;fspd;                    m
                       khpahij” vd;w
                       jiyg;Gld; xU
                       ePz;l “fpA+”
                       thpirapy;
                       mikr;rh;fs; vy;yhk;
                       thpirahf Fk;gpl;l
                       ifNahL Kjy;tiu
                       tzq;Fk; glj;NjhL
                       vOjg;gl;Ls;s
                       fl;Liu vg;gb?
                       fiyQh;:- me;jf;
                       fl;Liuapy;
                       m.jp.K.f.
                       mikr;rh;fSk;>
                       mth;fSila
                       cjtpahsh;fSk;
                       vg;gb ele;J
                       nfhs;fpwhh;fs; vd;W
                       vOjg;gl;Ls;sJ.
                       mjpNy cs;s rpy
                       Kf;fpa gFjpfs;
                       tUkhW:-
                       “gjtpg;
                       gpukhzj;ijf; FLk;g
                       jiyth;
                       Vw;Wf;nfhz;lhYk;>
                       FLk;g cWg;gpdh;fs;
                       %yk; /igy;fis
                       f;spah; nra;tJ
                       elf;fpwJ;
                       “X.gd;dPh;nry;tj;jpd;
                       kfd;fs; murpay;
                       hPjpahfTk;



                                                                W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory          Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published         Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english           ons      Public      ng
                            translation                       Figure prosecuti
                                                             who has on and
                                                               been      date
                                                             allegedly
                                                             defamed
Ml;rpapay;
                       hPjpahfTk; Kd;Ndwpf;
                       nfhz;bUf;fpwhh;fs;.
                       jk;gpAk; jd; gq;Ff;F
                       Mf;bt; Mf
                       ,Uf;fpwhh;”.
                       Kalaignar Pathilgal
                       Question: asking an
                       opinion from
                       Tr.Karunanidhi about
                       the photo published in
                       the weekly “Ananda
                       Vikatan”on the
                       heading “respect given
                       by the Ministers to the
                       Chief
                       Minister”wherein the
                       photo showed them
                       standing in a straight
                       line with folded hands.
                       Answer:Some of the
                       Ministers in the
                       Cabinet are under the
                       hands of their relatives.
                       Even though Minister
                       heads the department,
                       files are being cleared
                       by his sons and
                       brother. The sons and
                       brother of Hon’ble


                                                          W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory    Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published   Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english     ons      Public      ng
                            translation                 Figure prosecuti
                                                       who has on and
                                                         been      date
                                                       allegedly
                                                       defamed
Minister for finance,
                 Tr.O.Paneerselvam,
                 are the channel for the
                 said Minister.
32394 S.Selvam, fiyQh; gjpy;fs;          23.08.20     Minister    G.O.Ms. Governme
of    Printer,   Nfs;tp:- “Mde;j         12           for         No.839 nt Order
2012 Publisher & tpfld;” thu ,jopy;                   School      dt.03.10.
      Editor                                          Educatio    2012
                 “Nfhl;ilapy;
                                                      n, Sports
                 Kjy;tUf;F
                 mikr;rh;fspd;                        & Youth
                                                      Welfare.
                 khpahij” vd;w
                                                      Thiru.
                 jiyg;Gld; xU
                                                      N.R.Siva
                 ePz;l “fpA+”                         pathy
                 thpirapy;
                 mikr;rh;fs; vy;yhk;
                 thpirahf Fk;gpl;l
                 ifNahL Kjy;tiu
                 tzq;Fk; glj;NjhL
                 vOjg;gl;Ls;s
                 fl;Liu vg;gb?
                 fiyQh;:- me;jf;
                 fl;Liuapy;
                 m.jp.K.f.
                 mikr;rh;fSk;>
                 mth;fSila
                 cjtpahsh;fSk;
                 vg;gb ele;J
                 nfhs;fpwhh;fs; vd;W
                 vOjg;gl;Ls;sJ.
                 mjpNy cs;s rpy
                 Kf;fpa gFjpfs;
                 tUkhW:-
                       “gjtpg;


                                                              W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory        Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published       Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english         ons      Public      ng
                            translation                     Figure prosecuti
                                                           who has on and
                                                             been      date
                                                           allegedly
                                                           defamed
                       gpukhzj;ijf; FLk;g
                       jiyth;
                       Vw;Wf;nfhz;lhYk;>
                       FLk;g cWg;gpdh;fs;
                       %yk; /igy;fis
                       f;spah; nra;tJ
                       elf;fpwJ; gs;sp
                       fy;tpj; Jiw
                       mikr;rh; rptgjpad;
                       ,uz;L jk;gpfs;
                       mLj;jLj;j ,uz;L
                       Xl;ly;fspy;
                       cl;fhh;eJ; nfhz;L
                       Jiw tp\aq;fis
                       By; nra;fpwhh;fs;.


                       Kalaignar Pathilgal
                       Question: asking an
                       opinion from
                       Tr.Karunanidhi about
                       the photo published in
                       the weekly “Ananda
                       Vikatan”on the
                       heading “respect given
                       by the Ministers to the
                       Chief
                       Minister”wherein the
                       photo showed them
                       standing in a straight
                       line with folded hands.
                       Answer:Some of the



                                                                W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory          Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published         Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english           ons      Public      ng
                            translation                       Figure prosecuti
                                                             who has on and
                                                               been      date
                                                             allegedly
                                                             defamed
Ministers in the
                       Cabinet are under the
                       hands of their relatives.
                       Even though Minister
                       heads the department,
                       files are being cleared
                       by his family
                       members.The brothers
                       of Hon’ble Minister
                       for School Education,
                       Sports and Youth
                       Welfare
                       Thiru.Sivapadhi, are
                       the channel for the said
                       Minister.


33218 S.Selvam, m.jp.K.f.       muir 01.08.20 Former                  G.O.Ms. Governme
of    Printer,   nray;l r;              12    Chief                   No.757 nt Order
                 nrhy;tjw;Nf       xU
2013 Publisher & fz;ld Mh;gg   ; hl;lk;       Minister,               dt.03.09.
      Editor     Njitg;gLfpwJ!”               Selvi                   2013
                                              J.Jayalali
                 “Neha; ,Uf;fpwjh
                 ,y;iyah vd;gjy;y             tha
                       Kf;fpak;. me;j Neha;
                       te;jhy; cldbahf
                       Nkw;nfhs;sg;gl
                       Ntz;ba eltbf;if
                       Nkw;nfhs;sg;gltpy;i
                       y vd;gJjhd;
                       jw;NghJ nrd;id
                       khefuhl;rp
                       eph;thfj;jpd; kPJs;s



                                                            W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory      Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published     Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english       ons      Public      ng
                            translation                   Figure prosecuti
                                                         who has on and
                                                           been      date
                                                         allegedly
                                                         defamed
                       Fw;wr;rhl;L.
                       mij fz;bf;Fk;
                       tpjj;jpy;jhd; jp.K.f.
                       rhh;gpy; jsgjp
                       K.f.];lhypd;
                       mth;fs; jiyikapy;
                       nrd;idapy; khngUk;
                       Mh;g;ghl;lk;
                       elj;jg;gLfpwJ.
                       Kiwg;gb eltbf;if
                       vLf;fhky;>
                       tpjz;lhthjkhf
                       mwpf;if tpLtJk;>
                       rthy; tpLtJk;
                       m.jp.K.f. muRf;F
                       nghOJ
                       Nghf;fhfptpl;lJ.
                       ,ijj;jhd;>
                       “jkpofj;jpd;
                       vy;iyapypUf;Fk;
                       nfhlehl;bypUe;J
                       cz;zhJ cioj;J>
                       cwq;fhJ tpopj;J
                       nghWg;Gf;fis
                       jtwhJ Ghpe;J tUk;
                       Ml;rp”vd;W
                       mth;fshff;
                       $wpf;nfhs;fpwhh;fNsh
                       ”.
                       There needs to be
                       meeting condemning
                       the Government to
                       make it work:



                                                              W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory        Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published       Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english         ons      Public      ng
                            translation                     Figure prosecuti
                                                           who has on and
                                                             been      date
                                                           allegedly
                                                           defamed
                       In the event of disease
                       outbreak, the Chennai
                       Corporation is not in a
                       position to take
                       appropriate remedial
                       measure. M.K.Stalin is
                       to hold a meeting
                       condemning this issue.
                       The Government has
                       not taken any action on
                       the complaint given
                       and instead of taking
                       actions, the
                       Government is making
                       statements and
                       challenging the
                       opposition. The
                       Government which is
                       working hard without
                       proper food, proper
                       sleep, and are
                       attending to their work
                       without any error.


23681 S.Selvam, jkpof        MWfspy; 20.05.20 Former                G.O.Ms. Governme
of    Printer,   kzy;            ms;sp 12     Chief                 No.457 nt Order
                 NfushTf;F flj;jpr;
2012 Publisher & nrd;W       nfhs;is          Minister,             dt.
      Editor     yhgk;      Ftpj;jpLk;        Selvi.J.J             21.05.20

                 ghyhw;wpy; kzy;              a


                                                            W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory      Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published     Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english       ons      Public      ng
                            translation                   Figure prosecuti
                                                         who has on and
                                                           been      date
                                                         allegedly
                                                         defamed
ms;Stij jLj;J
                       epWj;jpLk; fpuhk
                       kf;fis gopthq;fpl
                       FbePh; fpzw;wpy;
                       tp\k; fye;j
                       nfhLik!
                       n[ayypjhtpd;
                       khgpah kzy;
                       jhjhf;fs; muh[fk;!
                       mjpfhhpfs;
                       nghJkf;fis
                       nfhd;W Ftpj;jpl
                       rjpj;jpl;lk;!
                       kzy; nfhs;isahy;
                       gy;yhapuf;fzf;fhd
                       fpuhkq;fs; FbePhpd;wp
                       jtpg;G! jdpahUf;F
                       Vhp Fsq;fspy; kzy;
                       ms;spl mDkjpah!
                       kf;fs; FKwy;!
                       Jkpof MWfspy;
                       kzy; ms;sp
                       NfushTf;Ff; flj;jp
                       nfhs;is yhgk;
                       Ftpj;jpLk; m.jp.K.f.
                       kzy; nfhs;isf;
                       $l;lk;> ghyhw;wpy;
                       kzy; ms;Stiu
                       jLj;j fpuhk
                       kf;fs;kPJ gop
                       jPhj
                          ; ;jpl FbePhpy;
                       tp\k; fye;j
                       nfhLikAk;
                       muq;Nfw;wpAs;sJld;
                       n[ayypjhtpd;



                                                          W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P.     Name of       Alleged defamatory    Date of Name of      G.O.    Nature of
 No.         the         Article published   Publicati    the    sanctioni Challenge
         Petitioners    along with english     ons      Public      ng
                            translation                 Figure prosecuti
                                                       who has on and
                                                         been      date
                                                       allegedly
                                                       defamed
                       khgpah kzy;
                       jhjhf;fs;> muR
                       mjpfhupfis>
                       nghJkf;;fis
                       nfhd;W Ftpj;jpl
                       rjpj;jpl;lk; jPlb
                                       ;
                       njhlh; flj;jy;
                       nraypy; ms;s m.jp.K.f.
                       muR jhiu
                       thh;j;Js;sJ
                       kf;fspilNa
                       nfhe;jspg;ig
                       Vw;gLj;jpAs;sJ.”



Name of the Newspaper: Dinakaran

 W.P. Name of the   Alleged defamatory      Date Name of    G.O. Nature of
 No. Petitioners Article published along     of the Public sanctio Challenge
                  with english translation Publi Figure     ning
                                           cation who has prosecu
                                              s     been     tion
                                                  allegedly  and
                                                  defamed   date

11727 R.M.R.           jkpofj;jpy;    elg;gJ 31.01. Former        G.O.Ms Governme
of    Ramesh,          Ml;rpah     rh;thjpfhu 2013 Chief          .No.120 nt Order
                       Ml;rpah”
2012 Editor,                                        Minister,     dt.04.02
                       “,d;iwa     Kjy;tUk;


                                                    W.P.No.5129 of 2012 etc., batch


 W.P. Name of the   Alleged defamatory      Date Name of    G.O. Nature of
 No. Petitioners Article published along     of the Public sanctio Challenge
                  with english translation Publi Figure     ning
                                           cation who has prosecu
                                              s     been     tion
                                                  allegedly  and
                                                  defamed   date

11728 Printer   & rhp> ehDk; rhp jkpo;          Selvi.      .2013      C.C.No.14
of    Publisher   jpiuAyfpy;                    J.Jayalalit            of 2013
                  ,Ue;Jjhd;
2013              murpaYf;F                     ha
                  te;Js;Nshk;. Vwpte;j
                  Vzpia              vl;b
                  cijg;gij tof;fkhf
                  nfhz;Ls;s      Kjy;th;
                  n[ayypjh.
                  ,g;glj;jpd;
                  gpur;ridf;F fhuzNk>
                  n[ah
                  njhiyf;fhl;rpf;F
                  tp];t&gk      glj;jpd;
                  chpikia toq;fhjJ
                  vd;Wk;>          kj;jpa
                  epjpaikr;rh; g.rpjk;guk;
                  tpohtpy;    fky;`hrd;
                  mtiu            ghuhl;b
                  NgrpaJk;           jhd;
                  fhuzkhf        ,Uf;ff;
                  $Lk;.”