Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

34. PW29 is the Senior Divisional Operations Manager of the South Central Railways, Hyderabad Division at Secunderabad. He produced the reservation requisition for Ext.P48 by which Shakeer (A9's assumed name), Jabbar (A15), Anaz (A17? - but acquitted), Ringmon (A10), Rebi (A8's assumed name) and Fayaz(A7) booked tickets from Secunderabad to Nizamuddin. Crl.A Nos.1575/2013&con.cases However Ext.P49, PNR history indicates that only five of them, excluding A7-Fayaz travelled on 12.09.2008 in the sleeper class, one in a confirmed ticket and the others in RAC. Ext.P50 is the document evidencing cancellation of the booking for Fayaz. Here we have to immediately notice that though the travel of A7 has not been established with documentary proof, his death in Kashmir stands confirmed. The reservation chart at Ext.P51, proved through the TTE, PW62, confirms the journey and the seat numbers of the other five persons who travelled as per ticket issued on Ext. P48. The other travel details as evidenced from Ext. P51 relate to persons who travelled from Hyderabad back to Kerala. Relevant is the fact that one of the persons in Ext. P52 ticket is the wife of A15, who was a resident of Hyderabad. Equally relevant is the fact that Ext. P48 & P52 shows the applicant as Jabbar and Abdul Jabbar (A15) with addresses shown respectively of that at Hyderabad and Kerala. The mobile numbers as shown in the reservation forms, respectively are 99126 61040 and 97466 22350; of which the first one has a significance, as proved to be carried by A7 to A10 and Crl.A Nos.1575/2013&con.cases A15 to Delhi.