Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

―31. We may take note of the fact that the CRZ notification dated 06.01.2011 specifically carves out an exception permitting mining of rare minerals not found elsewhere outside the CRZ areas. In fact, Clause 4(ii)(g) which provides for permissible activities within the CRZ reflects that mining of rare minerals is allowed. We may also take note of the fact that the applications for grant of exploration licence were made for seeking permission to explore the availability of, amongst others, of minerals as are mentioned in the First Schedule of OAMDR Act including atomic minerals. That being so, the entire basis of the impugned order dated 30.06.2016, namely the alleged mining within CRZ area not being permissible is erroneous. In fact, the learned Single Judge in para 81 of the impugned order holds that the order dated 30.06.2016 amounts to putting the cart before the horse inasmuch as unless and until exploration is undertaken and the reports disclose that there were no rare minerals/atomic minerals within the blocks granted, the alleged reasoning pertaining to prohibition on mining could not have been arrived at. In fact in these appeals, there is no challenge to the finding of the learned Single Judge regarding the issue of complete prohibition of mining in CRZ areas under the notification dated 06.01.2011. As far as the subsequent notification dated 06.10.2017 is concerned, this amendment, in our considered view, brings out further clarity on the rare minerals which can be mined under the CRZ. The amendment provides that atomic mineral as notified under Part-B of the First Schedule of the MMDR Act are permitted to be mined within the CRZ, The minerals mentioned, namely, ilmenite, rutile, zircon, etc. are identified as atomic minerals in Part B of the First Schedule to the MMDR Act. That being so, if the aforesaid minerals are found during exploration, there will be no impediment in granting the production lease for the said minerals as mining of the said minerals is expressly provided now by the CRZ notification. These facts were communicated by the then Controller General, IBM and the Administering Authority in his report vide e- mail dated 24.01.2017 to the Ministry of Mines by contending that in light of the CRZ notification dated 06.10.2017 now exploration license can be granted even for atomic minerals. That apart, the clarification available on record dated 09.02.2018 issued by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change also clarifies that mining of rare minerals was a permitted activity under the C.RZ notification dated 06.01.2011 and specified in Part B of the First Schedule to MMDRAct.