Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

71. ASI Hari Singh (PW31) and SI R. Srinivasan (PW38) both have stated that so long as case property remained with them, the case property was not tampered with. The prosecution has further examined Dr. Anupama Raina (PW36) who has stated that she has received 16 pulandas from MHC(M), PS Mangolpuri containing 5 pulandas with seal of KGT, 7 pulandas with seal of AS, 4 pulandas with seal of SGMH and further took the blood samples of Mrs. Savitri Devi and Mr. Bansi Dhar Swami parents of Vijay Kumar Swami and Varun Dalal and Ashish Dalal sons of SI Satish Dalal. She then opened the sealed parcels and resealed the same and affixed the seal of Deptt. of Forensic Medicine AIIMS and prepared 2 pulandas which was sent to APFSL, Hyderabad. The APFSL Report Ex.PW29/P2 shows that the pulandas so sent from AIIMS were received and after analysis the report was sent to AIIMS to Dr. Anupama Raina (PW36), she on analysing the same prepared DNA report Ex.PW36/B which is reproduced hereunder: -

i. No suggestion on this point was put either to ASI Hari Singh (PW31) or to SI R. Sriniwasan (PW38) who brought the case property and deposited it with AIIMS.

ii. The accused persons has not denied that Mrs. Savitri Devi and Mr. Bansi Dhar Swami are not parents of Vijay Kumar Swami and that Varun Dalal and Ashish Dalal are not the sons of SI Satish Dalal for the purposes of DNA analysis.

iii. It is admitted fact that deceased persons are not alive. Moreover, the purpose of sending the aforesaid articles to APFSL, Hyderabad was to analyze factually the articles recovered were of any connection to the incident and not to implicate the false accusations. The accused in their statements under section 313 does not say that the report obtained in DNA report was on the basis of tampering of evidence.

iv. The contention of learned defence counsel that prosecution has not examined the persons who took the property from AIIMS to APFSL, Hyderabad loses its significance on the aforesaid reasons.

FSL Report

73. The prosecution has examined ASI Hari Singh (PW31) who has proved the malkhana register Ex.PW31/C and Ct. Rajinder (PW28) both has specifically stated that Ct. Rajinder received 11 seal items from MHC(M) on 24/5/2004 and deposited the same with FSL, Rohini against the Receipt Ex. PW28/B and vide RC.

99. The statement of Pradeep Sharma (PW4) and Harish Dalal (PW5) of indentifying the headless bodies and skulls are corroborated with DNA report Ex.PW36/A and Ex.PW36/B therefore, the prosecution is abled to prove that dead bodies were infact of SI Satish Dalal and Vijay Kumar Swami.

100. The aforesaid set of evidences are so consistent with each other as well as the post-mortem report Ex.PW2/A and Ex.PW2/E, CFSL report Ex.PW29/P4, Ex.PW29/P5 and Ex.PW29/P6, APFSL report Ex.PW29/P2 and DNA report Ex.PW36/A and Ex.PW36/B indicates the involvement of the accused Rajinder and Joginder.