Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

29. To verify as to what steps the High Court and the Government have taken to give effect to the amendments that are made in the Act to Sections 2(1)(i), 3(1A) and 3(3) of the Act, we have called for the record from the concerned Registry and we have gone through the same. The record reveals that after the amendments came into force on 03-5-2018, the Administrative Committee of the High Court in its meeting held on 25- 3-2019 made certain recommendations to the Government by way of passing a resolution. The two important resolutions among them are the Committee resolved to confer pecuniary jurisdiction from three lakh rupees to fifty lakh rupees on Commercial Courts in the cadre of Senior Civil Judges to be established one court in each district and further resolved to request the Government to make the 13 existing Fast Track Courts one in each of the 13 districts in the State of Andhra Pradesh as permanent Commercial Courts in the cadre of Senior Civil Judge Courts with pecuniary jurisdiction from three lakh rupees to fifty lakh rupees. Thus, it is now evident that the said resolution is passed in view of Sections 3(1A) and 3(1)(3) of the Act as amended. Thereafter, the Registry has also addressed various letters to the Government requesting to establish the said Commercial Courts in the cadre of Senior Civil Judge Courts below the level of District Judge with the above pecuniary jurisdiction. But, the Government has only issued a belated G.O.Rt. No.609 on 05-6-2023 after lapse of four years period from the date on which the aforesaid resolution was passed, ordering to convert the existing 13 Fast Track Courts as Commercial Courts in the cadre of Senior Civil Judge. However, para-2 of the said G.O. reads that the pecuniary and geographical jurisdiction of the converted courts and their headquarters will be decided by way of issuing orders to that effect separately. Thus, everything is only on paper till now to implement the amended provisions of Sections 3(1A) and 3(1)(3) of the Act. Even though the aforesaid G.O.Rt.No.609 was issued about three years ago on 05-6-2023 to convert the existing 13 Fast Track Courts as Commercial Courts in the cadre of Senior Civil Judge, till now the said G.O. is not implemented and the Fast Track Courts in the cadre of Senior Civil Judge are not converted into Commercial Courts and they are not established and made functional. The High Court also did not further pursue the matter. It is not clarified as to why the 13 Fast Track Courts which are converted into Commercial Courts in the cadre of Senior Civil Judge are not made functional till now. Thus everything is only on paper and the amendments are not actually implemented in its true spirit and letter. Therefore, to achieve the object of the amendment, the High Court is directed to pursue the matter with the Government and the Government shall also immediately take steps to implement G.O.Rt.No.609, dated 05- 6-2023 and make the said Commercial Courts in the cadre of Senior Civil Judge functional. The State Government of Andhra Pradesh should also give notification in terms of Section 3(1A) of the Act specifying the pecuniary value of the said Commercial Courts in the cadre of Senior Civil Judge as recommended by the High Court in its resolution dated 25-3- 2019 conferring pecuniary jurisdiction on the said Courts from three lakh rupees to fifty lakh rupees. The Government should give a notification under Section 3(1A) of the Act fixing the pecuniary limits of the Commercial Courts of the District Judge cadre also conferring pecuniary jurisdiction on the said Courts from above fifty lakh rupees with unlimited jurisdiction. As now the Commercial Courts in two different cadres i.e., at the District Judge level and at the level of Senior Civil Judge would come into existence, issuance of notification under Section 3(1A) of the Act conferring pecuniary jurisdiction on the said courts is imperative. The said notification issued in terms of Section 3(1A) of the Act would be independent of the A.P. Civil Courts Act and this notification conferring pecuniary jurisdiction on the Commercial Courts would be issued for the purpose of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. Section 16 of the A.P. Civil Courts Act confers pecuniary jurisdiction on the ordinary Civil Courts established under the Act whereas notification to be issued under Section 3(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act confers pecuniary jurisdiction on the Commercial Courts established under the Commercial Courts Act.