Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

PW2 testified that she had moved several applications dated 10.9.2003, 07.10.2003, 06.11.2003, 04.1.2005, letter dated 04.1.2005 was received on 04.2.2005 etc. for obtaining the copy of the said order dated 24.7.2003 but could not find the same. The original of the same was with Bar Association, New Delhi. Copies of her letters are Mark K, Mark L, & Mark M, Mark N. She had also filed a complaint dated 17.12.2005 which was pending in the court of Shri Sudesh Kumar learned MM against accused Bhupinder Singh. In the said case she had filed many PF for calling the said order. The copy of the order is Ex. PW2/2 (dated 23.2.2008 to 2.11.2008). PW2 stated that on 24.7.2003, in the meeting of Executive Body, Mr. S.B. Dandapani said to Secretary R.K. Wadhawa that 'Madam ki chhat ke level tod ker uska level hamari chhato se neeche kiya jaye'. Then she said, 'waha par sabhi ke chamber ki chhate unchi-neechi bani hui hai'. Advocate Bhupinder said to Mr. Wadhawa, ' madam apni complaints jo thane mai di hai wapis le '. Then she said, ' agar ye written mai mujhse mafi mangte hai to mai complaint wapis le lungi'. Then Mr. Bhupinder said, ' hum madam ki di hui complaint se darne wali nahi hai' and advocate Mr. Sanjeev said, ' chahe to 50 complaint aur de kar aaye', then advocate Solanki said, ' chahe to roz dekar aaye, hamara kya bigad legi'. Then advocate Bhupinder said, 'agar madam nahi manti hai to madam ka chamber phir se seal kiya jaye' and advocate Dandapani also said the same. On 6.8.2003, she was not well because of which she did not come in the court. Then, a member of NDBA staff namely Mr. Jairam called her and said, 'madam, please come to the court today and today itself we have to start making wall in your chamber'. Then she came to the court and met Jairam in the office. Then Jairam said, 'hamare pass court ki permission hai aur hame aaj hi apke chamber mai diwar banani hai, agar aap apne chamber ki chabi nahi dengi to hum chamber ka taala tod kar banayenge'. Jairam said the same to members of office staff namely Pawan and Tejwir. Then they broke the lock of her chamber and started construction of wall in her chamber. They threw the chair, tables and all other articles of her chamber in the park. The photograph of making wall by the Mistri in the chamber is mark PW2/O. Advocates Solanki, Bhupinder, Sanjeev, S.B. Dandapani were going inside her chamber and giving instructions to 'Mistri' who was making the wall. She was standing in front of her chamber in the park. Advocates Solanki, Bhupinder, Sanjeev,S.B. Dandapani were washing there hands and gargling in front of her chamber by showing her and laughing on this that she could not do anything to stop them. After that, Jairam brought an old iron pipe and directed to 'Mistri' to put it in her chamber's roof. When she asked Jairam, 'why are you putting it in roof", he replied that Bhupinder had sent this to put it in her chamber's roof. Jairam also said to Mistri, 'Why are you wasting time on measuring the wall again and again, just make it like anything.' Then she said to Jairam, 'agar aise hi bina nape diwar banaoge to kal ko yeh mere upar hi gir jayegi'. Then Jairam said, 'humne to bina nape diwar banwa kar buildings khadi karwa di hai, jab wo nahi giri to ye kaise gir jayegi aur hamare kam ke beech mai aap mat bolo'. Then she went to park and sat there on her chair. Thereafter a person came there and said to her that he had come from Ms. Kamini Lau, then judge in-charge's court and asked her that did she have the permission of making the said wall in her chamber? Then she replied that she was not making the wall, Bar/Executive body was making the said wall and they said that they had the permission. Then that person said to her that if she did not have permission, her chamber would be sealed by the court and to please meet Madam Ms. Kamini Lau. Then she went to Vice President Mr. Pradeep Gaur's chamber to take the permission letter of court from him. There Secretary Wadhwa and Addl. Secretary Avnish Rana were sitting. On asking the permission letter of the court, Mr. Avnish Rana said to her, 'Don't worry, nobody will seal your chamber, we have the permission letter and we will show it to anyone.' Thereafter, Jairam put his all building material in her chamber and her chamber articles as well and locked the chamber by his own lock by saying, '3-4 din ya kam khatam hone tak hamara hi taala lagega apke chamber per aur baki kam kal hoga.' The photograph of the same is Mark PW2/P. PW2 deposed that on 7.8.2003, Ms. Kamini Lau sealed her chamber due to the said construction work. The photograph is Mark PW2/Q. When she reached her chamber on 23.7.2003, the notice of Executive Body was affixed on her chamber door dated 22.7.2003. The photograph of same is Mark PW2/J1. Thereafter, she went to Pradeep Gaur and asked him, 'aap to keh rahe the ki aap ke pass permission hai to mera chamber kyo seal hua aur usee khulwaye', then he replied by threatening her, 'apne Ms. Kamini Lau ko hamari complaint kyo kari?', then she asked Mr. Rana, Addl. Secretary, 'aap to keh rahe the ki chamber seal nahi hoga aur hamare pass permission hai hum dikha denge, to phir ye kyo hua, ab ise wo permission dikha ke khulwaye'. Even he replied in a threatening way and said, 'apne Ms. Kamini Lau ko complaint hamare against complaint kyo di, ab yeh kabhi nahi khulega'. Then she said, 'yeh aap sabhi logo ki saazish thi mera chamber seal karane ki aur mujhe chamber se bahar karne ki'. On 10.9.2003, she wrote a complaint against them to the learned Judge-in-charge Mr. A. K. Sarpal. The photocopy of the same is Mark PW2/R consisting of 59 pages (from page 10 to 68). On 15.9.2003 she gave a copy of the said complaint to the Bar Council of Delhi and Hon'ble the Chief Justice of High Court of Delhi and Hon'ble the Chief Justice of Supreme Court of India. The photocopy of the receipts are Mark PW2/S, PW2/T and PW2/U. On 25.9.2003, a copy of the same complaint was given to the then learned District & Session Judge Shri J.P. Singh in the morning. The photocopy of the receiving is Mark PW2/V. On the same date, after lunch, she went to meet the learned Judge-In charge Mr. A.K. Sarpal and asked him about her complaint dated 10.9.2003, then he replied, 'please give an undertaking stating that neither you nor Executive Body/NDBA will do any illegal construction in your chamber and you will demolish the wall which was constructed by the executive body at your own cost.' The photocopy of the undertaking dated 25.9.2003 is Mark PW2/W. She filed a reply of the said undertaking on 25.9.2003 and the clarification of reply was filed on 26.9.2003. The photocopies of the same are Mark PW2/X and PW2/Y. PW2 further stated that on 1.10.2003, she was told by a caretaker of learned Judge-In charge that the orders of opening of her chamber's seal had been passed by the learned Judge-In charge and gave her the order dated 30.9.2003. The photocopy of the same is Mark PW2/Z and he also told her to demolish the wall within 8 days from the said order. On 1.10.2003, her chamber was unsealed by the caretaker of the learned Judge-In charge in the evening. During the court holidays from 2.10.2003 to 5.10.2003, she demolished the wall and repaired her chamber on her cost. The photographs of demolishing and repairing of wall, her articles which were lying in the chamber along with broken lock, tubelight, 'chhaini-hathoda' by which the lock was broken are Mark PW2/Z1-12. On 6.10.2003, Advocates Bhupinder, Solanki, S.B. Dandapani & Sanjeev came to her chamber and S.B. Dandapani asked her, 'aapne Bar ki banayi hui diwar kyo todi?' She replied to them that she demolished the illegal wall by the order of learned Judge-In charge Sh. A.K. Sarpal. Then Mr. Dandapni said, 'ye A.K. Sarpal kaun hota hai hamare mamle mai interfere karne wala', and Advocate Bhupinder said, 'aap phir se diwar banayengi nahi to hum phir se apke khilaf complaint denge aur apka chamber phir se seal karayenge Bar/Executive Body se.' On 7.10.2003, when she reached her chamber, she saw a threatening notice dated 6.10.2003 pasted on her chamber's door stating that there was meeting of Executive Body at 3.30 on the basis of complaint of Advocates Dandapani, Bhupinder, Sanjeev, Salanki. The photocopy and photograph of the same are Mark PW2/Z13 and PW2/Z14. On 7.10.2003 she wrote an application to the Secretary of Executive Body for taking copy of order of dated 24.7.2003 of the Executive Body. The photocopy of the same is Mark PW2/Z15. Thereafter, she along with her advocate sister went to Secretary Madan Lal's chamber to know about the notice. In the meanwhile, staff clerk Ramesh came there with the said application dated 7.10.2003 and said to Madan Lal, 'Madam order dated 24.7.2003 ki copy maang rahi hai'. Then Mr. Madan Lal threw the application on her by saying that no copy would be given and said in a threatening way, 'aap Bar/Executive Body ke against complaint deti hai'. Then she said to him, 'copy kyo nahi milegi'. Then he replied, ' jo kehna hai meeting mai aakar kehna'. When she along with her Advocate sister went to the meeting, Advocate Dandapani said to President Santosh Mishra that Madam would sit alone in the meeting, send her sister outside. Then she said, 'my sister will sit quietly and will not say a word'. On this condition they made her sit in the meeting. Then Mr. Madan Lal said to her that they had received a complaint from 4 advocates against her and she would make the wall in her chamber and would change the door. Then she said that there was a common wall in her chamber and she would not make any wall. Previously an illegal wall was made by the Executive Body in the chamber despite the common wall and due to that the court sealed her chamber. Then in a threatening way Mr. Madan Lal said, ' aap Executive Body aur advocates ke against kai jagah complaint di hai'. Then she told everything to them. Then president Ms. Santosh Mishra said to her, ' un sab baato ke liye inse sorry bulwa denge aur aap apne chamber me dubara se diwar banayengi', then she said, ' maine pehle bhi kai bar in logo ke sorry bolne par aur executive body ke member ke kehne par maine inke sath compromise kiya hai aur inhe maaf bhi kiya hai par in logo ka conduct hamesha se waisa hi raha hai aur iska result ye nikla ki inhone mujh par table chori ka jhoota ilzam lagaya ek typist dwara meri reputation kharab karne ke liye court me aur mere against jhooti complaint dete hai khud bhi, jiske aadhar par mera chamber bina mujhse reply mange mera chamber seal kar diya aur bad me court se bhi seal kara diya aur ab mai koi illegal wall nahi banaungi aur ye kehte hue maine unhe court ka order dated 25.9.2003/26.9.2003 dikhaya.' After seeing that order, Ms. Santosh Mishra said, ' hamare liye is court ke order ki koi value nahi hai'. They said that the said order mattered a lot to them and they came out of the meeting. On 18.10.2003, she filed an application to take out a copy of the advocate's complaint dated 6.10.2003. The photocopy of the same is Mark PW2/Z16.