Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

41. Anand Patwardhan questioned an order of the FCAT which directed to cuts and one addition to the documentary film 'War and Peace' (Jang aur Aman). The first was with regard to a demonstration scene showing demonstration at Hutatma Chowk, Mumbai where demonstrators were shouting slogans "Hindu Bomb Hi Hi and Muslim Bomb Hi Hi." The FCAT directed that the slogans be deleted. The film showed a speech of a dalit leader Bhai Sangare who questioned why the bomb had been exploded on the day of Buddha Jayanti. He asked ""Why did'nt you do your blasts on Rama‟s birthday? It's your culture. All your gods are fully armed. Rama has an arrow, Shankar has a trident, Vishnu has a chopper. All have weapons. So when it's the birthday of armed ones, do your bomb blast. Our Buddha is unarmed." The CBFC directed deletion of the words "It is your culture" in the above speech. The Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Anand Patwardhan v. CBFC 2003 (5) Bom CR 58 held that the Petitioner was trying to canvas the cause of peace, and in that context it was pointed out that "a war unnecessarily leads to an unjustified production of arms and weapons and at times this is utilised by the politicians towards corrupt purposes." It was further held that there is no need to delete the scene showing people shouting slogans against the Hindu Bombs and the Muslim Bombs. It was reasoned that "if the scenes of riots in the television series (which are such at the residences of various people), could not affect the public order, there is no reason for anybody to imagine that any such slogans would affect the public order." It was further underscored that neither is the Indian bomb a Hindu bomb nor the Pakistan bomb a Muslim bomb. "One must know as to whether there is another perception and if so what is it. If the scene is deleted, people will not know as to what is the perception of the bombs in one section of the society." It was further held that "the whole speech or the scene is to be considered." As regards the speech of Bhai Sangare, the Bombay High Court held that he was entitled to his expression. It went on to observe: