Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

4. Considered the submissions made by counsel for applicant.

5. Paragraph F of the transfer petition reads as under:-

"F. That, applicant no. 1, daughter, father and mother are totally dependent upon father's pension. Moreover, earlier applicant was working in a software company but in 2022 father of the applicant met with paralysis disease and Brain Haemorrhage as well. Since, then she is the only one who is taking care of. Therefore, she is in trouble related to finance (due to medicinal support nothing remains), health (no one is there to take care of his ridden father). Though, applicant is not in a position to regular attend case pending before the family Court Gwalior Madhya Pradesh."

6. According to the applicant, applicant, as well as, mother are completely dependent upon their father's pension. Earlier, applicant was working in a software company but as father of applicant met with paralysis disease as well as brain hemorrhage in the year 2022, since then she is the only one who is taking care of him. Thus, it is clear that it is the case of the applicant that in the year 2022, her father had suffered a paralytic stroke and NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2025:MPHC-GWL:33716 3 MCC-40-2025 since then she is taking care of her father after leaving the job in the year 2022. If the FIR which has been lodged by applicant is considered, then it appears that she had leveled an allegation that she got married to the respondent on 11/12/2021. She was kept properly for a period of one month and thereafter the respondent and her in-laws started passing taunts that her father has not given anything. For the second time when she went to her matrimonial house on 5/2/2022, again taunts were passed and she was being treated with cruelty and, therefore, she came back to her parental home. Thus, if the FIR is considered then it appears that the applicant left her matrimonial house on account of cruelty meted out to her, whereas if paragraph F of the transfer petition is considered, then it is clear that she has claimed that since her father had suffered a paralytic stroke in the year 2022, therefore, she came back to her parental home to look after him and in the meanwhile she had also left her job which she was doing in a software company. Whether the applicant is residing in her parental home on account of cruelty meted out to her or whether she is residing in her parental home on her own is a question to be decided by the trial Court, but for the purposes of this transfer petition, this Court is of considered opinion that the ground raised in paragraph F of the transfer petition has to be given preference.

7. There is another aspect to give preference to paragraph F. In paragraph F, it is alleged that her father had suffered a paralytic stroke in the year 2022. Applicant has filed the medical prescriptions of her father, according to which her father who is aged about 64 years was having tremors in both hands. The MRI (Brain) report as well as EEG report have been NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2025:MPHC-GWL:33716 4 MCC-40-2025 placed on record. Since this Court is not a medical expert, therefore, it took the services of the medical doctor posted in the dispensary of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Gwalior Bench, who after going through the record informed that there is nothing like paralysis in the prescription reports. Even the EEG is normal and certain diseases are age related diseases and there is no abnormality.