Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Lok Sabha Debates

Presented A Statement Of The Estimated Receipts And Expenditure Of The ... on 8 July, 2014

Sixteenth Loksabha an> Title: Presented a statement of the estimated receipts and expenditure of the Government of India for the year 2014-15 in respect of Railways.

THE MINISTER OF RAILWAYS (SHRI D.V. SADANANDA GOWDA): Madam Speaker, I rise to present before this august House the Statement of Estimated Receipts and Expenditure for the year 2014-15 for Railways. As I stand in this Temple of Democracy, I owe this opportunity to the people of this country who have elected us to represent them and to shape their destiny.

          I am grateful to the Hon’ble Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi ji for having reposed his faith in me and entrusting this huge responsibility of leading Indian Railways.  I promise to fulfill this responsibility and make every endeavour not only to lead Indian Railways, but also aid in building a vibrant India under the dynamic leadership of Shri Narendra Modi ji.  I believe in the saying, ‘honesty is the first chapter in the book of wisdom.’  I do follow this. 

          It  gives  me  immense  pleasure  to  present my  maiden  Railway Budget. Indian Railways, being the nation’s prime mover, is the structure and soul of Indian economy. It echoes rhyme and rhythm in the hearts of every citizen of this country – from Baramulla in the North  to Kanyakumari in the South and from Okha in the West to Lekhapani  in the East. Madam Speaker, we all  know  that Indian Railways cut across all barriers of regions, classes and creed and is a microcosm of India on the move.

          From a man on the streets of Bengaluru to fish vendors in Kolkata to the hustle bustle at Nizamuddin Station, everywhere you find a citizen of this country rushing to connect with Indian Railways.

           Madam Speaker, though I am hardly a month old in the office, I am flooded with requests and suggestions for new trains, new railway lines and better services from the Hon’ble Members of the Parliament,  from  my  colleagues  in the Government, from  States, from stake holders, from organizations and from people of all walks of life. I know that everybody feels that there is a solution for the challenges which Indian Railways face.

I too thought so when I was an outsider to this system before I was exposed to the intricacies and complexities of this vast organization. Now, I am overwhelmed with the enormity of my responsibility in fulfilling these expectations as Minister of Railways.

          Madam Speaker, it reminds me of Kautilya’s words:

    “प्रजासुखे सुखं राज्ञः प्रजानां च हिते हितम्। नात्मप्रियं हितं राज्ञः प्रजानां तु प्रियं हितम्।।"
    This translates as:
‘In the happiness of the people lies the Ruler’s happiness Their welfare is his welfare What pleases him, the Ruler shall not consider good but whatever pleases his people the Ruler shall consider good.’             Indian Railways run 12500 trains to carry over 23 million passengers per day connecting more than 7000 stations spread across the subcontinent. It is equivalent to moving the entire population of the Australia.  We run   more  than  7400 freight  trains  carrying  about three Million Tonnes of  freight  every  day.  
Madam  Speaker,  having achieved the distinction of entering the select club of railways of China,  Russia  and USA  in carrying  more than one billion tons of freight,  I  now  target to become the largest  freight  carrier  in the world.
Madam Speaker, as you know, apart from serving the passengers, the Indian Railways carries coal It carries steel.
It carries cement.
It carries salt.
It carries food grains and fodder and it also carries milk.
Thus, the Indian Railways   practically  carries  anything and everything and it never says no to  ‘a thing’ if it fits  in the wagons. Most importantly, we are the backbone of supply chain of the defence establishment and play a very crucial role in security of the nation.
             Madam Speaker, while we carry 23 million passengers a day, there are still a large number of people who have not set a foot on a train yet. We carry over one billion tonnes of freight a year, connecting ports and mines to industrial clusters, but still there are vast tracts of hinterland waiting for rail connectivity. Though freight business has grown steadily over the years, the Indian Railways carries only 31 per cent of the total freight   carried  in the country  by  all  modes. These are the challenges we have to face.
           Madam   Speaker,  an organization  of  this  magnitude  vested with varied responsibilities, is expected to earn like a commercial enterprise but serve like a welfare organization. These two objectives are like two rails of the railway track, which though travel together but   never  meet. So  far,  the Indian  Railways  have  managed to  do a tight-rope walking by balancing these twin conflicting objectives.
Social service obligation rose from 9.4 per cent of Gross Traffic Receipts in 2000-01 to 16.6 per cent in 2010-11. In 2012-13, such obligations stood over Rs. 20,000 crore. The total investment, which is the Plan Outlay under budgetary  resources,  in the  same year, was  Rs. 35,241 crore. 
          Madam  Speaker,  the Indian  Railways  would  continue  to fulfil its  social obligations, but sustaining these objectives  beyond a point is  not  possible  without compromising  on  efficiency  and safety of train operations.
          We have a total track length of 1.16 lakh kilometres; around 63,000 coaches; more than 2.4 lakh wagons and 13 lakh employees. This calls for  an expenditure on fuel, salary and pension, track and coach maintenance and more importantly on safety works. This takes up most of our earning from the Gross Traffic Receipts. In the year 2013-14, Gross Traffic  Receipts  were Rs. 1,39, 558 crore and total Working Expenses were Rs. 1,30,321 crore, which works  out  to an Operating  Ratio  of almost 94 per cent.
 This, Madam Speaker, implies that we spend 94 paisa out of every rupee earned, leaving  six  paisa  only as surplus.  This surplus, apart from being meagre, is continuously on decline due to non-revision of fare. The surplus, after paying obligatory dividend and lease charges, was  Rs. 11,754 crore  in  2007-08 and  is  estimated  to  be  Rs. 602 crore in the current financial year.
 Madam Speaker,  this  meagre surplus  so generated is  required  to finance  the  Plan  Outlay  for  safety,  capacity  expansion, infrastructure, improving passenger services and amenities.
           Funds to the tune of about Rs. 5 lakh crore i.e. around Rs. 50,000 crore per year for next 10 years, are required for ongoing projects alone. This   leaves  a huge gap between what is  available  as surplus  and what is needed.
           While prudent efforts should have been made to address this gap, the tariff policy adopted lacked rational approach. Passenger fares were kept lower than costs, thus causing loss in the passenger train operations. This loss kept on increasing from 10 paisa per passenger kilometre   in 2000-01 to   23 paisa in 2012-13.
            On the other hand, freight rates were revised periodically and kept high in order to compensate the losses sustained in passenger sector resulting in freight traffic getting diverted consistently. Also, the share of Railways in freight traffic came down consistently in the last 30 years. Madam Speaker, it is important to note that decline in the share of total freight traffic is revenue foregone.
            Madam Speaker, having  spoken about how revenue was frittered away,  now,   let   me  touch   upon   how   the  investments   were misdirected.
           There has been focus on sanctioning projects rather than completing them. In the last 30 years, as many as 676 projects were sanctioned worth  Rs.1,57,883 crore.  Of   these,  only 317  projects  could   be completed and 359 projects remain to be completed which will now require as much as Rs. 1,82,000 crore.
        In the last 10 years, 99 New Line projects worth  Rs. 60,000 crore were sanctioned out of which only one project is complete till date. In fact, there are  four projects that are as old as 30 years, but  are still  not complete for one reason or another. The more projects we add, the thinner   we spread our  resources and longer  it takes to complete them.
I am sure, if this trend is allowed to continue, many more thousands of crore will get spent yielding hardly any returns.
         Madam   Speaker,  having  spoken about  never-ending  projects of the Indian Railways,  let  me throw  some light on the kind of priority accorded in choosing projects. It is investment in doubling and tripling to decongest the over-utilized network, which brings money to Railways. On the other hand, construction of new lines, most of the times do not even meet the operational cost.
          In the last  10 years, the Indian Railways  made an investment  of over Rs. 41,000 crore in laying 3,738 kilometers of New lines. On the other hand,  it spent only about Rs. 18,400 crore for   doubling of 5,050 kilometers though it was a priority over the new lines.
         I would   like  to read a comment on the Indian Railways  by someone, which I chanced upon. I did not understand it till I  learnt  about the facts I talked about so far:
 “It is unheard of a business that has a monopoly, that has nearly 100 crore customer base, that has 100 per cent sale on advance payment; but still starved of funds.” This, Madam Speaker, is the story of the Indian Railways so far.
          Railways serving the social obligation would not have been an issue.  However in the name of social viability, the chosen projects were populist  in nature, bringing hardly any revenue to the Railways. On the whole, neither the projects brought returns to Railways nor the social responsibility was met in full for many years.
         This   mismanagement   and  apathy   brought   Railways   into  the situation of severe funds crunch for many years, which is a result of the ‘decade of golden dilemma’ – the dilemma of choosing between commercial viability and social viability.
Madam Speaker, I am sure, my esteemed predecessors were aware of  this  precarious  situation,  but  they,  however,  fell  prey  to  the ‘nasha’ of claps in the House when they announced these projects.
        Madam Speaker,  I also  can get claps  from  this  august House by announcing   many  new  projects,  but  that  would  be  rendering injustice  to the struggling  organization.  I would like   to take steps throughout the year by setting the things in order.
       This  state of  affairs  of  Indian Railways  needs immediate  course correction.  Among the many corrective steps that I have planned out, fare revision was one, which was a tough but a necessary decision. Madam Speaker, as they say:
यत्तदग्रे विष्­ामिव परिणामे अमृतोपमम्।
“The medicine appears as bitter in the beginning, but is like nectar in the end.” This fare revision will bring the Indian Railways an additional revenue of about  Rs. 8,000 crore. However, we need more than  Rs. 9 Lakh crore to   complete   the   Golden   Quadrilateral   Network    and   about  Rs. 60,000 crore for introducing one bullet train alone.
          But Madam Speaker, can I depend only on hiking fare and burden the public to mobilise these funds?… (Interruptions)
          I want to read it again.  Please hear me for a while.  If you do not have a patience to hear my Budget, what can we do? … (Interruptions)
          Madam, Speaker, can I depend only on hiking fare and  burden the public to mobilise these funds? This is  unrealistic.  Thus, I need to explore  the alternative sources of resource mobilisation.
           
I.     RESOURCE MOBILISATION:
          The first source is Leveraging Railway PSU Resources Madam Speaker, Railway PSUs have done very well and are financially sound. I propose to bring investible surplus   funds   of   Railway   PSUs   in  the infrastructure   projects  of Railways, which can generate attractive returns for PSUs.
          The second source is Private  investment  in Rail  Infrastructure  through  Domestic  and Foreign Direct Investment (FDI);
The growth of Railway Sector depends heavily on availability of funds for investment  in rail  infrastructure.  Internal   revenue resources and Government  funding   are  insufficient   to  meet  the  requirement. Hence, the Ministry  of Railways  is  seeking  Cabinet  approval  to allow FDI in Rail Sector except railway operations.… (Interruptions)
          The third source is Public Private Partnership:
There has been a lot of talk about public private  partnership  for raising resources. Railways being a capital intensive sector have not been successful so far in raising   substantial  resource through  PPP route. Madam Speaker,  it is  my endeavour to pursue this  in right earnestness. It is our target that bulk of our future projects will be financed   through  PPP mode, including  the high-speed  rail  which requires huge investments.
Madam  Speaker,  apart from  mobilizing resources, I also  need to strategically manage other  aspects of  railway planning  and administration.
To meet this end, I propose the following initiatives:
a)       Near Plan Holiday approach;  

b)        Prioritizing  and  setting   timelines for     completion        of  the ongoing projects;  

 c)      Devising  a  mechanism  for  raising  funds  for  Rail infrastructure;  

d)       Decision Support System for project implementation;  

e)       Strategic partnerships and transparency in procurements;  

f)        Aggressive indigenization of imported products;  

g)      Adopting safety standards matching  international  practices and  setting  up      of  Simulation  Centre  to  study  causes of accidents.  

h)       Encouraging   development   of  Wagon Leasing Market.  

Now, Madam Speaker, let me place before this august House the  

Financial Performance of 2013-14:  

II.     FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE 2013-14:  

Now, Madam Speaker, let me place before this House, the financial performance  of 2013-14.
      Since presentation of Interim Budget and passing of the ’Vote on Account‘   in   February   last,   the financial   position   has  undergone a change.
Madam Speaker, Railways carried 1050.18 million tonnes of freights. Goods  Earnings   were   short   only   by  Rs. 94 crore.   Originating passengers   also  were less  by 46 million over Revised  target and Passenger earnings were short by Rs. 968 crore over Revised target.
          Over all, though the Gross Traffic Receipts grew by 12.8% to reach Rs. 1,39,558 crore, it was short of Revised target by Rs. 942 crore. On the other   hand,  Ordinary Working Expenses stood at  Rs. 97,571 crore, which was in excess by  Rs. 511 crore.
         Appropriation to Pension Fund had to be stepped up to match the actual outgo.
          As   a   result,   instead   of   ending   the   year   with   a   surplus of Rs.7,493 crore, the surplus was actually Rs.  3,783 crore, that is, a shortfall of  Rs. 4,160 crore. This   is  after fulfilling the dividend  commitment of  Rs. 8,010 crore.
           The internal resource generation for Plan, in 2013-14, was Rs.11,710 crore, as against Revised target of  Rs. 14,496 crore. This is short by Rs. 2,786 crore.
           In 2013-14, there was a decline in traffic growth as compared to Revised projections. Expenditure however, shot up and was more than what was estimated. The Operating Ratio deteriorated by 2.7% over the Revised target to touch 93.5% by the end of 2013-14 fiscal.
          So far as our Plan Expenditure for 2013-14 is concerned, it fell short of Revised target of  Rs. 59,359 crore mainly due to non-materialization of PPP targets. Madam Speaker, now I proceed to present before this House the Budget Estimates for the year 2014-15.
III.    BUDGET ESTIMATES FOR 2014-15:
          Anticipating a healthier growth of economy, I hope to achieve total receipts of  Rs. 1,64,374 crore and I would peg total expenditure at Rs.1,49,176 crore.
          I anticipate freight traffic growth of 4.9% amounting to 1,101.25 million tonne, an increment of 51.07 million tonne over 2013-14, based on trends in the first two months. I also anticipate a small growth in Passenger Traffic over 2013-14. Earnings from Freight Traffic are estimated at Rs. 1,05,770 crore and from Passenger Traffic Rs. 44,645 crore.
 
          The fare revision which came into effect from 25.06.2014 has provided Railways a much needed respite however little it may be. As I have considered the requests of the suburban passengers for revision in monthly season ticket fares, the Revenue foregone on this account would be around Rs.610 crore.
          Here I may point out that periodic revision in passenger fare and freight rates, as approved by this august House, will be linked to revisions in fuel prices in order to insulate the Railway revenues from fuel cost escalation.
 
          Madam Speaker, out of total expenditure, the ordinary working expenses have been proposed at Rs. 1,12,649 crore, which is Rs.15,078 crore higher than 2013-14. This has been necessitated by fuel price hike and increase in staff costs. Pension outgo in 2013-14 had grown by about 16%. Keeping the same trend, provision for pension is kept at Rs. 28,850 crore.
 
IV.    ANNUAL PLAN 2014-15:
          Madam Speaker, I thank the Finance Minister for extending Additional Budgetary Support of Rs.1,100 crore as Capital and Rs.273 crore as Railway share from diesel cess for important Road Safety works. Largely owing to this measure and to the additional resource mobilization efforts, I propose to increase the plan outlay under budgetary sources to Rs. 47,650 crore which is higher by Rs.9,383 crore over 2013-14. A large part of this higher plan outlay goes to safety related works which is also a high priority of our Government.
          As I have increased internal resource component of Plan, I propose to scale down market borrowings through Indian Railway Finance Corporation to Rs. 11,790 crore.
          Madam Speaker, time overruns and consequential cost escalations in completion of most of the railway projects have been a chronic worry of Railways for years. I propose to provide maximum financial outlays to projects targeted for completion in the current year itself, keeping in mind the priorities and safety. I have ensured adequate allocations for 30 priority works for their timely progress.
          It is my concern to allocate the available resources to high priority areas like safety, cleanliness, passenger amenities and capacity augmentation. Madam Speaker, let me now spell out details of the focus areas of this Budget:
V.     PASSENGER AMENITIES & STATION MANAGEMENT  

Amenities at Stations:  

          I will first touch upon steps proposed for improving passenger amenities.   

In the passenger amenities, Indian Railways envisage to provide foot-over bridges, escalators and lifts at all major stations through PPP route.
Indian Railways would make earnest attempt this year to provide sufficient water supply, platform shelters and toilets at all the Railway Stations.
Passenger Amenities through private entity:
Indian Railways propose to extend service of Battery-operated Carts to facilitate differently-abled and senior citizens to reach any platform comfortably at all major stations.
We propose to involve individuals, NGOs, Trusts, Charitable Institutions, Corporates, etc. to provide passenger amenities.
Office on Wheels:
As Indian Railways serve lot of business travellers who spend substantial time on travel, in order to add best value to their time, I propose to provide workstations in select trains on payment basis. A pilot project will be launched by this year.
e-Booking of Railway Retiring Room:
Online booking facility of Railway Retiring Room will be extended to all the stations during the course of the year.
Madam Speaker, extending passenger friendly services is the motto of Indian Railways. In this direction, I am expanding the scope of online booking:

People can book a Train  

People can book a Coach  

People can book a Berth and  

People can book a Seat in the Chair Car  

VI.    CATERING  

Madam Speaker, catering on Railways has been a major issue of concern for long.
In order to improve the quality, hygiene of on-board catering services and to provide variety, I propose to introduce Pre-cooked (Ready-to-eat) Meals of reputed brands in a phased manner.
Further, I sincerely desire to bring perceptible improvement in the catering services by introducing Quality Assurance Mechanism through Third Party Audit by NABCB certified agencies.
In addition to the third party audit, a system of collecting feedback through IVRS mechanism, from the travelling passengers on the quality of food served, will be launched shortly.
If the service is not to the standards set, especially in hygiene and the taste, severe action would be initiated against the vendors including cancellation of the contract.
Food Courts at Stations and Regional Cuisine while onboard:-
Indian Railways also proposes to set up Food Courts at major stations to provide the option of ordering regional cuisine while onboard, through emails, SMS and Smart Phones, etc. A pilot project will be started shortly between New Delhi-Amritsar and New Delhi-Jammu Tawi sections.
VII. CLEANLINESS Madam Speaker, ‘Cleanliness is next to Godliness’, said Mahatma Gandhi Ji, our beloved Father of the Nation.
Madam, I am aware of the sorry state of affairs of cleanliness in the trains and stations. Railways have been attaching high priority to cleanliness, but it has always been a challenge to maintain the acceptable level of cleanliness owing to the sheer number of passengers handled at the stations.
 
Madam Speaker, I have substantially increased budget allocation for cleanliness in the current year, which is a 40% increase over the previous year. I propose to outsource cleaning activities at 50 major stations to professional agencies and to set up a separate Housekeeping Wing to have focused attention and exclusive responsibility of maintaining cleanliness and sanitation at stations.
Madam Speaker, a Corpus Fund for upkeep will be set up at Stations in order to provide enough financial resources to the officers who are entrusted with the responsibility.
CCTVs at Stations will be used to monitor cleanliness activities. All-India level  helpline number will be printed on the back of the tickets. System of periodic third-party inspections will be introduced.
Further, Bio-toilets will be increased in sufficient numbers in trains in order to mitigate the problem of direct discharge of human waste on the tracks and platform aprons at stations.
Onboard Housekeeping Services, currently operational in 400 trains, has received good feedback from passengers. This will be extended to all the important trains. I also propose to increase Mechanized Laundries in order to improve quality of the bedrolls provided in AC Coaches.
Potable Water:
We will introduce on an experimental basis RO drinking water units at Stations and in trains.
Reputed and willing NGOs, charitable institutions and Corporate Houses will be encouraged to adopt and maintain stations for better cleanliness and upkeep.
VIII.   SAFETY Madam Speaker, safety of passengers is of paramount importance for Indian Railways. It is estimated that over Rs.40,000 crore would be needed to be invested in track renewals, elimination of unmanned level crossing and construction of Road-under-bridges and Road-over-bridges.
 
I have received a lot of requests from various States for construction of Road-over-bridges and Road-under-bridges. I am making a provision of  Rs. 1,785 crore for Road-under-bridges and Road-over-bridges in this Budget. I would request the concerned State Governments to expedite their proposals and pass on their share of the cost. I have decided to introduce a system of speedy clearances based on first-come-first serve basis. We intend to standardize designs and make these available online. Delegation of powers shall be done so that power of sanctioning is decentralized.
Elimination of Unmanned Level Crossings Indian Railways have 30348 Level Crossings, out of which 11563 are unmanned. Each unmanned level crossing is being examined in detail and depending on the site condition, action will be taken to eliminate it by suitable modality.
Indian Railways propose to use modern Vehicle Borne Ultrasonic Flaw Detection System to detect rail and weld fractures. In addition Ultrasonic Broken Rail Detection System (UBRD) will also be tried at two locations as a Pilot Project.
In order to improve the safety of travelling passengers, I propose to bring in technology for automatic closing of doors before start of train, both in main line and in sub-urban coaches. A pilot project for limited number of trains will be taken up.
IX.    SECURITY In order to strengthen security in trains and at Stations, 17000 RPF constables have been recruited and shall be shortly available for deployment. We also propose to recruit 4000 women RPF constables.
 
In order to ensure security of ladies travelling alone, special instructions are being issued for their safety in each class of travel. With the induction of women RPF constables, coaches meant for ladies will be escorted.
 
RPF escorting teams in trains will be provided mobile phones so that passengers can contact them when in distress. Security helpline will be augmented.
We will explore the possibility of building of boundary walls around the stations through PPP mode.
 
X.     RAIL TOURISM Madam Speaker, I foresee a huge untapped potential in the field of domestic tourism in our country. We plan to take up Eco-Tourism and Education Tourism in North Eastern States.
Special Pilgrim Circuits like Devi Circuit, Jyotirling Circuit, Jain Circuit, Christian Circuit, Sufi Circuit, Sikh Circuit, Buddhist Circuit and Famous Temple Circuit have been identified. I propose to introduce specially packaged trains for these circuits. Private participation in this area will also be encouraged.
One Tourist Train will run from Gadag to Pandarpur via Bagalkot, Bijapur and Solapur covering the pilgrim and tourist places of Karnataka and Maharashtra. Another such train will start from Rameshwaram covering pilgrim and tourist places like Bengaluru, Chennai, Ayodhya, Varanasi and Haridwar. I also plan to run a special train featuring life and work of Swami Vivekananda to inculcate good moral values and propagate the teachings of Swami Vivekananda.
XI.    REVAMPING RAILWAY RESERVATION SYSTEM Madam Speaker, Railway Reservation System will be revamped into Next Generation e-Ticketing System. Ticket booking through mobile phones and through Post Offices will be popularized.
We will improve the system capabilities in e-ticketing to support 7200 tickets per minute as against 2000 tickets per minute and allow 1,20,000 simultaneous users at any point in time.
Facility of Coin Operated Automatic Ticket Vending Machines will be experimented.
Efforts  will also  be made to  provide  facility  of  buying Platform Tickets and unreserved tickets over internet.
Parking-cum-Platform Combo Tickets will be launched to facilitate the passengers and to save their time. XII. STRUCTURAL REFORMS                                                                                                        Hon.  Speaker, at this moment, the Railway Board, due to overlapping roles of policy formulation and implementation, has become unwieldy. Therefore, I propose  to  separate these  two functions by restructuring the Ministry.
XIII.  STAFF WELFARE - CARE OF OUR RAILWAY FAMILY Indian Railways  has 13.1 lakh staff most of whom  work  on the cutting edge level of providing rail services. It is my duty  that they are taken care by providing adequate facilities.  In this  direction,  I am initiating the following:
i)      Presently   an  amount  of  ` 500 per  capita   is   contributed towards Staff Benefit Fund. I propose to increase this amount to ` 800 per capita.
ii)     I propose to announce a special scheme for the meritorious wards of Railway persons for their outstanding performance in academics and sports.
iii)      The Hospital Management Information system will be used to integrate all health units, Divisional hospitals and Central Hospitals as also our empanelled hospitals.
iv)     Examine   feasibility   of  providing  air-conditioning  in  loco cabins and provide ACs in running rooms.

 XIV.  SKILL DEVELOPMENT OF STAFF I am contemplating on setting up of a Railway University for both technical and non-technical subjects.

We will tie up with technical  institutions  for  introducing railway oriented subject for graduation and skill development.

In the meantime, staff at the ground  level  will be sent for  short duration courses of technical  and non-technical  nature, involving locally available technical institutions. The exposure for specialized areas like high-speed, heavy haul operations, etc. will be undertaken for all level of staff and officers at appropriate institutes in India and abroad. XV.    SPEED OF TRAINS It is the wish and dream of every citizen that India runs a bullet train as early as possible. Hon.  Speaker, Indian Railways is on its way to fulfil that long  cherished  dream. I propose bullet trains  by starting off with an already identified Mumbai-Ahmedabad sector, where a number of studies have been done.

  Hon.    Speaker,    it  was   the   vision    of   our   great   leader, Shri Atal Behari Vajpayee ji,    that     gave    India    the     Golden Quadrilateral   Road  Network.   Today,  under   the  leadership   of Shri Narendra Modiji,  hon. Prime Minister, we are embarking  on an ambitious  plan  to have a Diamond Quadrilateral Network  of High Speed Rail, connecting   major  Metros  and  growth   centers  of  the  country. A provision  of ` 100 crore has been made in this  Budget for high Speed  project to RVNL  / HSRC  (High Speed  Rail  Corridor) for taking further steps.

Hon.  Speaker, while bullet trains would require completely new infrastructure, higher speed for existing trains will be achieved by upgrading the present network.  Hence, an effort  will be made to increase the speed of trains to 160-200 kmph in select sectors so as to significantly reduce travel time between major cities.

 The identified sectors are:

i)        Delhi-Agra  

ii)       Delhi-Chandigarh   

iii)       Delhi-Kanpur  

iv)       Nagpur-Bilaspur  

v)           Mysore-Bengaluru-Chennai   

vi)          Goa- Mumbai  

vii)      Mumbai-Ahmedabad  

viii)     Chennai-Hyderabad and   

ix)       Nagpur-Secunderabad.  

   

XVI.     I.T. INITIATIVES  

  Hon.  Speaker,  as you know,  the I.T. revolution  has permeated into all spheres of human life. It has not only made life comfortable, but also made the service delivery efficient and the onus now is on us      to   make   governance  transparent   and   accountable   using I.T. solutions.  

Though Indian Railways  has taken up computerization  in a large way, all the efforts have not been in synergized. Hence, the desired results are not achieved.  Need of the hour  is  to bring in a total change in the work  culture  and delivery  of Railway Services  by going  in for large  scale  integrated  computerization  of major functions of Indian Railways.

Hon.   Speaker,  Indian  Railways  is  also  going  for  a computer assisted  Enterprise  Resource Planning  Solution,  so that synergy is brought in. To begin with, following initiatives will be taken up:

i)        Moving  towards  paperless          offices   in        Indian   Railways in 5 years;  

ii)       Next Generation Ticket Reservation System;  

iii)       Wi-fi Services in all A1 and A category stations and in select trains;  

iv)       Real-time tracking of trains and rolling stock;  

v)       Mobile based Wakeup Call System for passengers;  

vi)       Mobile based Destination Arrival Alert;  

vii)      Station Navigation Information System;  

 viii)    Extension  of Dual Display  Fare Repeaters at all  the Ticket  

Counters through PPP;  

ix)       Digital reservation charts at Stations (Bengaluru model);  

x)       Extension of Computerized Parcel Management System;  

xi)    Extension of  logistics support  to  various e-commerce Companies by providing designated pick-up centres at identified Stations;  

xii)      Providing education  to children  of Railway  staff at remote  

locations through Railtel OFC (optical fibre cable) network.  

Digitization of GIS mapping of land assets of Indian Railways:  

           Indian Railways  hold vast land assets the records of which need to be digitized and GIS mapped for better management and usage. This would help Railways in protecting the lands as well as leveraging it for raising resources. The  resource mobilization  using  land  assets will be explored through private participation in setting up railway related business on railway lands as well as for commercial development XVII. INNOVATIONS INCUBATION CENTER          Hon.  Speaker, in an effort to keep pace with developments of the modern   world,   Railways   have  to   adopt   and   reinvent   itself constantly. Challenges  of tomorrow  cannot be met by the tools  of yesterday. In this direction, I propose to set up an Innovations Incubation  Center. This  Center will harness the ideas  generated from  the staff of Indian Railways  and convert them into practical solutions  to  increase  efficiency  of  the  system. Such  innovations which result  in cost saving  as well  as revenue generation  will be suitably rewarded in the form of incentive.

     As part of this exercise, I also propose to set up summer internships for  under-graduates of engineering  and management studies. The students   can  intern   at  any  of  the  various   units   of  Railways i.e. Divisions, PSUs and Production Units.

XVIII.  GATHERING MORE RESOURCES         With a large backlog of sanctioned projects, funding continues to be the biggest challenge for the Railways. While private investment and customer funding for some port connectivity projects and few other Power Sector  Projects has started, much more needs to happen if infrastructure  creation  has to  keep  pace with  the  requirement. We will interact  with Industry  and  take further  steps to  attract investment under PPP through BOT and Annuity route. About 8 to 10 capacity augmentation projects on congested routes will be identified for this purpose. Zonal Railways will be suitably empowered to finalize and execute such projects.

        Hon.  Speaker, Indian Railways has taken up port connectivity on a priority through PPP mode of funding in tandem with Sagar Mala Project of Port Development. Railways will facilitate connectivity to the new and upcoming ports through private participation. So far, in principle approval has been granted for building rail connectivity to the  Ports  of  Jaigarh,  Dighi,  Rewas, Hazira,  Tuna,  Dholera  and Astranga under Participative Model Policy of Indian Railways, amounting to a total of over ` 4,000 crore.

Coal Connectivity         Railways  will speed up  construction  of  critical coal  connectivity lines in Tori-Shivpur-Kathautia Area, Jharsuguda-Barpalli-Sardega and  Bhupdeopur  –Raigarh-  Mand  Area.  This  will  bring nearly.

 

100 Million Tonnes of incremental traffic to railways and will also facilitate faster transportation of coal to Power Houses.

Total Station Development          Hon.  Speaker, we will take up development of identified stations to international standards with modern facilities and passenger amenities   on  the  lines   of  newly   developed   airports   through PPP mode.  Initially,   Indian  Railways   would   develop   at  least 10 major  stations  of  metro  cities  and  important  junctions  with state-of-the-art  facilities,  leveraging  land  and  air  space in  and around the stations.

   

Private Investment in Railway Logistics          Hon.  Speaker, Indian Railways propose to modernize logistics operations  by  setting  up  Logistic  Parks that  provide  for warehousing,  packaging,  labeling,  distribution,  door-to-door delivery and consignment tracking. In order to achieve better efficiency, mechanization of loading and unloading will be given top priority.

       In the existing pattern of traffic movement of Indian Railways, more than 33% of freight trains over the system run empty since return traffic at existing freight rates is not forthcoming. In order to garner additional revenue,  I propose to launch a pilot project whereby automatic rebate from the computerized FOIS system will be made available to customers offering returning traffic. This would help reduce the empty flows on the Indian Railway System apart from garnering additional revenue.

Parcel traffic:

        While there has been an incremental growth in our parcel earning, I see a huge untapped potential in this segment which needs to be trapped by the Indian Railways. At present, the parcel business is hindering  the movement of passengers  on platforms. It is, therefore, necessary that parcel traffic is segregated to separate terminals  where requisite  facilities  for storage and handling of parcels are made available to the customers and parcel consignments move in dedicated parcel trains running on fixed time table. Accordingly, a scheme of private  participation  in  parcel  movement  will be launched  shortly  whereby  procurement  of  parcel rakes by private parties will be facilitated.
      A new design of parcel vans with better tare to pay load is being finalized.  It is expected that by putting these measures in place, we would be able  to substantially  improve  our earnings  from  the parcel segment.
Private Freight Terminals (PFT)           To develop  network  of freight  terminals,  policy of Private  Freight Terminals on PPP model is being further refined.
Movement of Agri-Products         I propose to give a boost to rail movement of fruits and vegetables in partnership with the Central Railside Warehousing Corporation (CRWC) by providing requisite facilities of temperature controlled storages at 10 locations viz Vatva, Vishakhapatna, Badagara, Cheriyanad, Bhivandi Road, Azara, Navlur, Kalamboli and Sanand on Indian Railways in the first phase. The aggregation and distribution from Railway terminal points shall be organized by the CRWC. I hope, this would, apart from  avoiding national wastage of these products, help producers of fruits and vegetable in different  parts  of  the  country  in  getting  better  prices  for  their produce.
     Hon.   Speaker,  Indian  Railways  propose  to  facilitate transportation of milk through rail by providing special milk tanker trains  in association  with National Dairy Development  Board and Amul.
XIX.   ENERGY CONSERVATION       Hon. Speaker, it is proposed to harness solar energy by utilizing roof top spaces of  Railway  Stations,  other  Railway  buildings  and  land, including through the PPP mode apart from our own resources.   
      Indian Railways will start using Bio-Diesel up to 5% of the total fuel consumption in diesel locomotives. This will save precious foreign exchange substantially.
XX.    PROJECT COORDINATION & MANAGEMENT GROUP Railways have been suffering heavily because of time overrun and cost overrun due to poor project management. In order to overcome delays in the project execution, I propose to set up Project Formulation and Management Group at the level of Railway Board consisting of professionals. Similarly, to expedite the projects at the ground level, a Project Monitoring & Coordination Group consisting of officials of State Government, Railways and professionals will be set up.
 
XXI.   TRANSPARENCY IN RAILWAY FUNCTIONING           Simplification of procedures and easy access to information bring transparency and trust in public. Transparency in administration, execution of projects and procurement will be given top priority.
          Strategic Procurement Policies will be adopted to make the procurement process transparent and most efficient. E-procurement will be made compulsory   for procurements  worth  25  lakhs and above.
          For the convenience of the State Governments and other stakeholders, the status of ongoing projects will be made available online.
 
XXII. CONNECTIVITY TO REMOTE AREAS           Expansion of railways in Hilly States & Northeast regions:
 
Madam  Speaker,  I am happy  to inform the House that there are 23 projects underway  in the Northeast, of which 11 are National Projects. I propose to allocate  substantially  higher  funds for these projects  compared  to  previous  years. In  2014-15, an  outlay  of Rs. 5,116 crore  is   earmarked  for   projects  of  North-East.  This   is 54% jump   over  allocations   in  the  previous   year.  With  higher allocations and by close monitoring of works in this region, I hope that Dudhnoi-Mendipathar New Line; Lumding-Badarpur-Silchar Gauge Conversion; Harmuti-Murkongselek and Balipara- Bhalukpong sections will soon get commissioned. These measures will also give a boost to the State capital connectivity projects in the region.
 
Madam Speaker, this august House is already aware that the Udhampur-Katra  Rail link has recently been dedicated to Nation by hon. Prime Minister, Shri Narendra Modi, fulfilling  the  long  cherished  dream  of  Shri Atal Bihari Vajpayee and millions  of pilgrims across the country. … (Interruptions)
… (Interruptions)
SHRI D.V. SADANANDA GOWDA: You hear the next sentence.  … (Interruptions)
HON. SPEAKER: Yes, Mr. Minister.
… (Interruptions)
SHRI D.V. SADANANDA GOWDA:  We have also tied up with Government of J&K for bridging Udhampur-Banihal portion by bus so that passengers can reach Srinagar with one single ticket from origin to destination.
          Now,  Railways  will focus on the completion  of  missing  link of Banihal to Katra.
   
XXIII. RAILWAY PROJECTS IN THE STATES OF ANDHRA  PRADESH and TELANGANA              There are 29 projects running in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana at an estimated  cost of  Rs. 20,680 crore. I intend  to hold coordination meetings with the officials of the newly created States and consider their requests so as to give necessary economic boost.
 
         On the issues  concerning  Railways  in the twin states of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, a committee has already been set up of the Railways  and  State  Government  officials.  Further  action  will be taken after receipt of the Report of the Committee.
 
XXIV.GIVING BOOST TO SUBURBAN TRAFFIC    Urban Transport   With  the  challenges   posed  by   the  steadily   increasing   urban population  concentration  in  metros  and  in  million  plus  cities, a holistic  approach to urban transport  is  required.  A  smooth and seamless inter-modal access is essential to improve urban mobility and, therefore, a Passenger centric focus will be given to urban transport infrastructure creation. We will coordinate with other transport Ministries and urban bodies to develop optimal systems of integration of Railways with other transport modes.
 
Mumbai  city  will get 864 additional  state-of-the-art EMUs  over a period of two years. With completion of the conversion of traction from 1500 Volts DC to 25 KV AC in Mumbai Suburban Railways, the efficiency  of  operations  would  improve  besides  reducing  cost of operations.
   
 Madam  Speaker,   as  you  are  aware,  Bengaluru   with  bustling business  activity  attracts large  commuters from  surrounding  rural areas and towns necessitating better connectivity of Bengaluru City with its suburban areas and hinterland. A study to Explore Possibility of enhancing the existing IR network of Bengaluru for meeting the above need will be taken up immediately.
 
In addition, to cater to the demand of Passenger Traffic in Bengaluru area, Byyappanahalli will be developed as a coaching terminal.
 
13.00 hrs   XXV. FREIGHT BUSINESS   Online Wagon Demand registration:
 
Online registration of demand for wagons will be launched in the next two months. This will facilitate online payment of Wagon Registration fee as well as registering demand for wagons. Further a process for ERR (Electronic Railway Receipt) will also be initiated during the year.
 
Indian Railways  propose to introduce  corrosion-free  wagons with low tare weight for movement of salt.   … (Interruptions)
 
PROF. SAUGATA ROY (DUM DUM): What about Kolkata Metro? … (Interruptions)
SHRI KALYAN BANERJEE (SREERAMPUR): What about Kolkata Metro? … (Interruptions) You are doing only for Bengaluru and Maharashtra. … (Interruptions)
SHRI D.V. SADANANDA GOWDA: I am coming … (Interruptions) I have not completed. … (Interruptions)  You hear me.  I am reading. I have not yet completed. … (Interruptions)
 
           Dedicated Freight Corridor Project Implementation of Eastern and Western DFCs, a critical infrastructure project, will be closely monitored.       The      World      Bank      loan       agreement     for Kanpur-Mughalsarai   section   of   Eastern  corridor  of   Dedicated Freight    Corridor  will   be   signed    in   the   current   year. During 2014-15, award of nearly 1000 kms of civil construction contracts is targeted.
   
XXVI. TRAIN STOPPAGES   Ever since assuming office, I have received innumerable requests for continuance  of experimental  stoppages from  Hon’ble  Members of Parliament and various public representatives. I understand that large  number  of stoppages have been provided  on experimental basis over a period of time. While I appreciate the wish of everyone wanting a stoppage close to their place of work or residence, there is a cost to the system for each stoppage. Also  too many stoppages result in slowing down of trains and increase the travel time particularly  for  long  distance  passengers.  If  this  trend  continues, most of our express trains will become passenger trains.
   
I would like to inform this House that I have allowed continuation of these experimental stoppages for a further period of 3 months, that is up to 30th of September 2014. Then, these stoppages will be reviewed solely on the basis of operational feasibility and commercial justification. Demand for  new stoppages hereinafter will also be considered  on the same criteria.  We will try  to provide  alternate train connectivity to meet genuine demands of the public.
   
XXVII.        SURVEYS   Besides expansion and capacity augmentation projects, assessment of future  needs and requirements in the form  of providing connectivity to hitherto unconnected regions, requirement of movement of goods from  new production/consumption  centre needs to  be assessed  on  a  continuous  basis.  I  have  also  been receiving  requests for  projects from  the Hon’ble  Members, State governments and other public representatives. To honour their requests, I  propose to undertake  18 Surveys  for  New  Lines  and 10 Surveys  for  Doubling,  3rd   &  4th   line  and  Gauge Conversion Projects in 2014-15. The following is the list of such surveys.
   
A)     NEW LINES:  

i)      Kanhangad-Panathur-Kaniyuru  

ii)           Mughalsarai - Bhabua vai Naughar   

iii)          Hoshiarpur – Amb - Andaura  

iv)     Aurangabad - Chalisgaon  

v)      Singrauli - Ghorawal Lusa   

vi)     Gabbur – Bellary  

vii)    Shimoga – Sringeri - Mangalore  

viii)     Badovan – Jhargram via Chandil   

ix)       Talguppa-Siddapur  

x)           Bhabua-Mundeshwari  

xi)       Jind - Hissar  

xii)    Gadag- Harphanhalli (Updating)  

xiii)   Una-Hamirpur  

xiv)   Ujjain-Jhalawar-Agar-Susner-Soyath (Updating)  

xv)     Hissar-Narwana  

xvi)   Solapur-Tuljapur (Updating)  

xvii)  Rail connectivity to Char-Dham, Kedarnath, Badrinath, etc.  

xviii) Rail connectivity to Iron ore mines between Nayagarh-Banspani  

   

… (Interruptions)  

   

B)       DOUBLING, 3rd and 4th LINES and GAUGE CONVERSION:-  

i)       Doubling of Jaipur - Kota  

ii)      Doubling of Chandna-Fort – Nagbhir  

iii)    Doubling of Mangalore-Ullal - Surathkal  

iv)    Doubling of Rewari-Mahendergarh  

v)      Bhusawal- Badnera- Wardha 3rd line  

vi)     Kasara- Igatpuri 4th line   

vii)  Karjat-Lonavala 4th line       

viii)        Itarsi-Bhusawal 3rd line  

ix)     Gauge Conversion  of Meter Gauge line  in Ahmedabad area upto  

         Mahesana.  

x)           Gauge Conversion of Pilibhit-Shahjahanpur (Updating)  

   

          Surveys  for  Sagar-Chatarpur-Khujraho-Bhopal  and  Jabalpur- Udaipura-Sagar  New  line  have been completed.  I  will get them examined expeditiously. Survey  for Indore-Jabalpur  New line  will be expedited.
   
           I am happy to announce that the survey for Mysore-Kushalnagar portion of Mysore-Kushalnagar-Medekere New line has been completed  and State  Government has agreed to share cost of the project. This will provide Rail connectivity to important tourist destinations in Kodagu (Coorg) district. I propose to pursue this project for obtaining requisite approvals after completion of remaining survey up to Madikere.
   
         A  survey for  new line  between Tarighat  and Ghazipur  has been completed. However, the same needs to be examined by extending survey  up  to Mau  so as to connect the line  to the rail  network further. It will be undertaken expeditiously.
   
XXVIII.       NEW TRAINS:
 
   I would  like to inform this august House that while I have received innumerable requests from various quarters for running new train services,  resource constraints  preclude  me from  meeting  many of them. Nonetheless, to meet the critical demands of the un-reserved and reserved segments, I have decided to run Jansadharan group of trains and a Premium group of trains respectively, including those announced in the interim Railway Budget  2014-15. These services  would   be meeting  the  demand surges which  manifest  themselves  on  special  occasions.  Special trains would continue to run to meet the holiday and festival rush including services for Melmaruvathur, Velankanni, Jhalawar etc. for which I have received special requests from  the public representatives.
 
I also propose to introduce 5 Jansadharan Trains, 5 Premium Trains,  6  AC   Express  Trains,   27 Express  Trains,   8 Passenger Trains, 2 MEMU  services and 5 DEMU services. Besides, I also propose to extend  the  run  of  11 existing  trains.  The following is the list.
 
A)      Jansadharan Trains  

i)        Ahmedabad – Darbhanga Jansadharan Express via Surat   

ii)       Jaynagar – Mumbai Jansadharan Express  

iii)       Mumbai – Gorakhpur Jansadharan Express  

iv)       Saharasa – Anand Vihar Jansadharan Express via Motihari   

v)       Saharasa – Amritsar Jansadharan Express  

   

   

B)      Premium Trains  

i)        Mumbai Central – New Delhi Premium AC Express   

ii)       Shalimar – Chennai Premium AC Express  

iii)       Secunderabad- Hazrat Nizamuddin Premium AC Express   

iv)       Jaipur – Madurai Premium Express  

v)       Kamakhya – Bengaluru Premium Express  

   

   

C)      AC Express Trains  

i)        Vijayawada-New Delhi AP Express (Daily)   

ii)       Lokmanya Tilak (T) – Lucknow (Weekly)   

iii)       Nagpur – Pune (Weekly)  

iv)       Nagpur – Amritsar (Weekly)  

v)       Naharlagun – New Delhi (Weekly)  

vi)       Nizamuddin – Pune (Weekly)  

   

… (Interruptions)  

PROF. SAUGATA ROY (DUM DUM): West Bengal has been totally deprived. … (Interruptions)
 
13.08 hrs At this stage, Shri Kalyan Banerjee and some other hon. Members came and stood on the floor  near the Table.
 
D)      Express Trains  

i)         Ahmedabad – Patna Express (Weekly) via Varanasi  

ii)         Ahmedabad - Chennai Express (Bi-weekly) via Vasai Road   

iii)        Bengaluru – Mangalore Express (Daily)  

iv)        Bengaluru – Shimoga Express (Bi-weekly)  

v)            Bandra (T) – Jaipur Express (Weekly) Via Nagda, Kota   

vi)           Bidar – Mumbai Express (Weekly)  

vii)      Chhapra  –  Lucknow  Express (Tri-weekly)  via  Ballia,  Ghazipur, Varanasi  

viii)     Ferozpur – Chandigarh Express (6 days a week)  

ix)       Guwahati – Naharlagun Intercity Express (Daily)  

x)       Guwahati – Murkongselek Intercity Express (Daily)  

xi)       Gorakhpur – Anand Vihar Express (Weekly)  

xii)      Hapa – Bilaspur Express (Weekly) via Nagpur   

xiii)     Hazur Saheb Nanded – Bikaner Express (Weekly)   

xiv)     Indore – Jammu Tawi Express (Weekly)  

xv)      Kamakhya – Katra Express (Weekly) via Darbhanga  

xvi)     Kanpur – Jammu Tawi Express (Bi-weekly)  

xvii)       Lokmanya Tilak (T) – Azamgarh Express (Weekly)   

xviii)      Mumbai _ Kazipeth Express (Weekly) via Balharshah   

xix)        Mumbai – Palitana Express (Weekly)  

xx)      New Delhi - Bhatinda Shatabdi Express (Bi-weekly)  

xxi)     New Delhi – Varanasi Express (Daily)  

xxii)     Paradeep – Howrah Express (Weekly)  

xxiii)   Paradeep – Visakhapatnam Express (Weekly)  

xxiv)   Rajkot – Rewa Express (Weekly)  

xxv)     Ramnagar – Agra Express (Weekly)  

xxvi)   Tatanagar – Baiyyappanahali (Bengaluru) Express (Weekly)  

xxvii) Visakhapatnam – Chennai Express (Weekly)  

   

   

E)     Passenger Trains  

i)        Bikaner – Rewari Passenger (Daily)  

ii)       Dharwad – Dandeli Passenger (Daily) via Alnavar   

iii)       Gorakhpur – Nautanwa Passenger (Daily)  

iv)       Guwahati – Mendipathar Passenger (Daily)  

v)       Hatia – Rourkela Passenger  

vi)       Byndoor – Kasaragod Passenger (Daily)  

vii)      Rangapara North – Rangiya Passenger (Daily)  

viii)     Yesvantpur – Tumkur Passenger (Daily)  

   

   

F)     MEMU  services  

i)        Bengaluru – Ramanagaram 6 days a week (3 Pairs)  

ii)       Palwal – Delhi – Aligarh  

   

   

G)     DEMU services  

i)        Bengaluru – Neelmangala (Daily)  

ii)       Chhapra – Manduadih (6 days a week) via Ballia   

iii)       Baramula – Banihal (Daily)  

iv)       Sambalpur – Rourkela (6 days a week)  

v)       Yesvantpur- Hosur (6 days a week)  

   

   

H)    Extension of run of existing Trains  

i)      22409/22410 Anand Vihar – Sasaram Garib Rath Express to Gaya  

ii)      12455/12456 Delhi Sarai Rohilla – Sriganganagar Express to Bikaner   

(iii)    15231/15232 Gondia – Muzaffarpur  Express to Barauni  

   

   

(iv)    12001/12002 New Delhi – Bhopal Shatabdi Express to Habibganj   

(v)    54602 Ludhiana – Hissar Passenger to Sadulpur  

  (vi)   55007/55008 Sonpur – Kaptanganj Passenger to Gorakhpur   

  (vii)  55072/55073 Gorakhpur – Thawe Passenger to Siwan  

(viii) 63237/63238 Buxar – Mughalsarai MEMU to Varanasi  

(ix)  63208/63211 Jhajha – Patna MEMU to Jasidih  

(x)    64221/64222 Lucknow – Hardoi MEMU to Shahjahanpur  

(xi)   68002/68007 Howrah – Belda MEMU to Jaleswar  

   

   

Madam Speaker, I am aware that I would receive both praise and criticism alike.
   

Lastly, I would like to recall a popular verse of Shri D.V. Gundappa, a famous  poet, philosopher  and  writer  of  Kannada, who  wrote under the penname – Mankutimma, which translates as under:

 
“It is not that after reading this book, there will be no more doubts.
It is not that what we believe today will hold up forever.
If someone points at some shortcoming, I have an open mind to correct.
But for now, I believe this is right.”   . With these words, Madam Speaker, I commend the Railway Budget for 2014-15 to the august House.
 
     [Placed in Library. See No. LT 28/16/14]