Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

3. It is further averred that the petitioner is a medical Physiotherapist and was working under Central Government Health Scheme, New Delhi. He retired from the said services in September, 2005 and started his private practice from October, 2005 in shop No. 3 in the aforesaid property No. G­16, Hauz Khas Enclave, New Delhi. It is further stated that Dr. Alok Bhatnagar who is son of the petitioner has completed his BDS in 2005 and now he is going to complete his MDS in July, 2010 and intends to start his practice as a dental surgeon. The son of the petitioner is also going to be married to a lady who is also BDS and the petitioner as well as his son and would be daughter­ in­law intend to start their own clinic and for this purpose all the shops situated on the ground floor of the aforesaid property including the shop in question is required by the petitioner bonafide for his own benefits and requirements along with his family members for running the clinic. The petitioner has also stated that he and his dependent family members do not have any other alternative accommodation to establish a clinic to earn their livelihood and the need of the petitioner is bonafide. Therefore, present petition has been filed seeking eviction of the respondents from the suit premises.

5. It is also averred by the respondent no. 1 that the petitioner has not given the complete details of existing construction at G­16, Hauz Khas, New Delhi. It is further stated that the petitioner has not filed any certificate to show that he is a physiotherapist and further has not filed any document to show that Dr. Alok Bhatnagar is his son and he has completed his BDS in 2005. It is also stated that the petitioner has not given the name of the lady to whom Dr. Alok Bhatnagar is going to get married. It is further averred that the petitioner has not given the details of what are the properties available to him.

6. The respondent no. 1 has further contended that the petitioner is having sufficient accommodation at ground floor of the aforesaid property i.e. a shop which is being referred as shop No. 3 and there is another shop adjoining the said shop which has been shown as shop in between the staircase. Apart from this, there is one another shop which has been shown as a covered courtyard in the site plan. As such, even as per the site plan filed by the petitioner, he is having 3 shops and toilet on the ground floor and the complete area of these 3 shops and toilet would be more than 700 sq. ft which is sufficient for the need of the petitioner and his family. It is further stated that the petitioner is also having mezzanine floor over the shop No. 2, 3 and stairs and the covered area of mezzanine floor would be more than 400 sq. feet and this premises is approved for commercial use and the petitioner can use the same for physiotherapist or BDS clinic.

23. The respondent no. 1 has also contended that the petitioner has not filed any certificate to show that he is a physiotherapist and has not filed any document to show that Dr. Alok Bhatnagar is his son and said Dr. Alok Bhatnagar has completed his BDS in 2005. It is also contended that the petitioner has not given the name of the lady to whom Dr. Alok Bhagnagar is going to get married.

24. The aforesaid pleas of the respondent no. 1 are self contradictory because in the latter part of her leave to defend application, the respondent no. 1 herself has conceded that in the year 2007 the petitioner started a multi­ facility clinic in the name of 'Ansh' where the petitioner used to provide the service of himself as consultant physiotherapist, service of Dr. Alok Bhatnagar as dental surgeon and of Dr. Nidhi Bhatnagar as Audiologist and speech language pathologist. Moreover, the petitioner has placed on record photocopy of Certificate of Registration issued by The Delhi Council for Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy (Statutory Body under Ministry of Health, Govt. Of NCT, Delhi) to the effect that he has been duly registered as Physiotherapist in the register of Physiotherapy Practitioners under the Delhi Council for Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy Act 1997. The petitioner has also placed on record the photocopy of certificate issued by Delhi Dental Council to the effect that Dr. Alok Bhatnagar is duly registered as Dental Surgeon under the provision of the Dentists Act, 1948 showing his qualification as BDS in 2005 and MDS in 2010.