Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

2.2 Defendant no.1 M/s VPN Infosolution Pvt. Ltd. is a private limited company. Mr. Vishal Gaurav and Ms. Arti Anupriyaare, are directors of defendant no.1 company. They were introduced to plaintiff by defendant no.2 Mr. Abhishek Anand, Chief Manager of Punjab National Bank, who was having friendly relations with plaintiff as he was having current account in Punjab National Bank at Delhi. Defendant no.2 is an acquaintance of directors of defendant no.1.

3.7 Defendant further contends that to help the plaintiff, Mr. Vishal Gaurav, director of defendant no.1 gave friendly loan of Raj Rs.3,60,000/- which he is liable to return to it. Denying other averments Kumar Tripathi and assertions of the plaint, defendant no.1 prayed to dismiss the suit with by Raj Kumar exemplary costs.

10.3 He has proved the invoices for supply of goods as Ex.PW1/1 (colly.). He also proved the e-way bills as Ex.PW1/2 (colly.). The delivery notes duly acknowledged by DPS Junior have been proved as Ex.1/9 (colly.).

10.5 In support of his case, plaintiff also examined his son Mr. Mandeep Singh as PW2. PW2 filed his evidence by way of affidavit, Ex.PW2/A, wherein, he has supported the plaintiff's case as set out in the plaint. PW2 in his cross-examination admitted that there was no written agreement relating to supply of goods and rates on which goods were to be supplied. He stated that all the specifications for supply of goods to defendant were mentioned in the order book after the order for supply of goods was given by defendant. He further deposed that DW1 had provided phone number of a person as well as the place where goods were to be delivered, and accordingly, plaintiff delivered the goods to the person concerned. As per PW2, in 2022, some of the goods were also delivered at the residence of DW1. He stated that the goods were supplied to the authorized representative of defendants as per instructions of defendant Raj Kumar no.1. He further stated that defendant no.1 introduced him (PW2) to Mr. Tripathi Prem Prakash Vidhyarthi as the Production Manager of plaintiff's firm. He was also told by defendant no.1 that Mr. Vidhyarthi is the Chairman of DPS Junior School. He further stated that it was mentioned that the said stationary (notebooks and books) was marked to M/s VPN Infosolutions Pvt. Ltd. and manufactured by M/s CTC Book World. Thus, the testimony of PW2 could not be assailed and impeached by defendants despite his lengthy cross-examination.