Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

A FEW UNDISPUTED FACTS.

21. It would be apt to mention a few facts which are not in dispute. As per para 13 of the charge sheet, the names and particulars of Chairpersons and members of the District Level Selection Committees are as under: 

Sr.  Name                    Designation                  Chairpersons/  Accused
No.                                                       members
I. AMBALA
1      Smt. Prem Bahl        District           Primary  Chair Person         A­6

    CBI Vs Vidya Dhar etc.                                 Judgment dt. 16.01.2013


                             Education        Officer, 
                             Ambala
2      Smt.          Shashi  Principal, Govt. Sr. Sec.  Member           A­7
       Malhotra              School, Ambala
3      Smt. Krishna          Ex   -   Block   Education  Member          A­8
                             Officer, Ambala­II, 
II. BHIWANI
4      Brahma Nand           District         Primary  Chairman          A­9
                             Education         Officer, 
                             Bhiwani
5      Ms. Vinod Kumari Principal, Govt. Sr. Sec.  Member                A­10
                        School, Bhiwani
6      Sawan Lal             Block Education Officer, Member             A­12
7      Maman                 Block Education Officer,  Member            A­11
                             Bhiwani­II
III. FARIDABAD
8      Ram            Saran  District         Primary  Chairman   Sh.  A­17
       Kukreja               Education         Officer,  R.S.   Kukreja 
                             Faridabad                   was   DPEO   till 
                                                         02.12.1999 
                                                         after which Sh. 
                                                         Harbans   Lal 
                                                         took   over   the 
                                                         charge.
9      Harbans Lal           DPEO,   (02.12.1999   till  Chairman        A­16
                             31.01.2002)
10     Udal         Prasad  Dy.   District   Education  Member           A­18

 CBI Vs Vidya Dhar etc.                               Judgment dt. 16.01.2013


     Sharma               Officer, Faridabad
11   Brij Mohan           Block          Education  Member          A­19
                          Officers, Palwal­II
IV. FATEHABAD
12   Smt.          Kanta  District        Primary  Chairperson      A­13
     Sharma               Education        Officer, 
                          Fatehabad
13   Prabhu Dayal         Principal, Khabra Kala   Member           A­14 
                                                                    (since 
                                                                    expired)
14   Smt.          Phool  Block Education Officer,  Member          A­15
     Khurana              Bhuna
V. GURGAON
15     Chand   Singh  District            Primary  Chairman         A­20
     Verma            Education            Officer, 
                      Gurgaon
16   Smt.   Abhilash  Block Education Officer,  Member              A­22
     Kaur             Gurgaon
17   Yogesh   Kumar  The   then   Dy.   District  Member            A­21
     Sharma          Education   Officer, 
                     Gurgaon
VI. JHAJJAR
18   Sher Singh           District        Primary  Chairman         A­23
                          Education        Officer, 
                          Jhajjar
19   Anar Singh           Dy.   Distt.   Education  Member          A­24

  CBI Vs Vidya Dhar etc.                                     Judgment dt. 16.01.2013


                              Officer, Jhajjar
20   Smt.           Kailash  Sr.   Block   Education  Member               A­25
     Kaushik                 Officer, Jhajjar
VII. JIND
21   Ajit               Singh  District        Primary  Chairman           A­26
     Sangwan                   Education Officer, Jind
22   Ram Kaur                 Dy.   District   Education  Member           A­27
                              Officer, Jind
23   Mahavir Singh            Block Education Officer,  Member             A­28
                              Jind
VIII. KARNAL
24   Narain             Singh  District          Primary  Chairman         A­29
     Ruhil                     Education          Officer, 
                               Karnal
25   Krishan              Lal  Dy.   District   Education  Member          A­30
     Narang                    Officer, Karnal
26   Smt. Usha Rani           Block Education Officer,  Member             A­31
                              Karnal
IX. KURUKSHETRA
27   Madan Lal Kalra          District           Primary  Chairman         A­32
                              Education           Officer, 
                              Kurukshetra
28   Veerbhan Mehta           Dy.   Distt.   Education  Member             A­33
                              Officer, Kurukshetra
29   Shashi Bhushan           Block Education Officer,  Member             A­34
                              Kurukshetra

  CBI Vs Vidya Dhar etc.                                   Judgment dt. 16.01.2013


X. KAITHAL
30    Dilbag Singh          District        Primary  Chairman            A­35
                            Education Officer, Distt. 
                            Kaithal
31   Ram Kumar              Block Education Officer,  Member             A­36
                            Kalayat, Distt. Kaithal
32   Megh              Nath  Dy.   Distt.   Education  Member   (But  Not 
     Sharma                  Officer, Kaithal          did not sign.) accused


XI. MAHENDERGARH
33   Pushkar            Mal  District     Primary  Chairman              A­37
     Verma                   Education   Officer, 
                             Mahendergarh
34   Durga             Dutt  Principal,   Govt.   Girls,  Member         A­38
     Pradhan                 Sr. Sec. School
35   Bani Singh             Block Education Officer,  Member             A­39
                            Mahendergarh
XII. PANCHKULA
36    Sheesh Pal Singh District              Primary  Chairman           A­43
                       Education              Officer, 
                       Panchkula
37   Smt.             Rekha  Block Education Officer,  Member            A­44
     Sharma                  Ramgarh, Panchkula
38   Smt.         Raksha  Ex­Principal   Govt.   Sr.  Member             A­45
     Jindal               Sec. School, Panchkula
XIII. PANIPAT

 CBI Vs Vidya Dhar etc.                                Judgment dt. 16.01.2013


39   Smt. Daya Saini      Assistant   Director,  Chairperson         A­40
                          Primary   Education, 
                          Haryana, Chandigarh
40    Ram Singh           Dy.   Distt.   Education  Member           A­41
                          Officer, Panipat
41   Puran                Block Education Officer,  Member           A­42
     Chand(expired        Panipat
     during trial)
XIV. ROHTAK
42       Jeet   Ram  District            Primary  Chairman           A­46
     Khokhar         Education            Officer, 
                     Rohtak
43   Amar Singh           Block Education Officer,  Member           A­48
                          Narnaul
44   Nirmal Devi          Dy.   Distt.   Education  Member           A­47
                          Officer, Rohtak
XV. REWARI
45   Smt.   Sudha  District              Primary  Chairman           A­49
     Sachdeva      Education              Officer, 
                   Rewari
46   Darshan   Dayal  District           Primary  Chairman           A­50
     Verma            Education           Officer, 
                      Rewari
47   Smt.          Saroj  Dry.   Distt.   Education  Member          A­51
     Sharma               Officer, Rewari
48   Tulsi          Ram  Block Education Officer,  Member            A­52
     Bihagra             Bawal­II Distt. Rewari

 CBI Vs Vidya Dhar etc.                                 Judgment dt. 16.01.2013


XVI. SIRSA
49   Nathu Ram            District        Primary  Chairman           A­53
                          Education Officer, Sirsa (expired 
                                                   during trial)
50   Ram          Saran  The   then   District  Chairman              A­17
     Kukreja  same   as  Primary   Edu.   Officer, 
     at Sr. No. 8        Faridabad,   (Only   till 
                         02.12.1999) and DPEO, 
                         Sirsa thereafter
51   Om           Prakash  Distt. Education Officer,  Member          A­54
     Tiwari                Sirsa
52   Bihari Lal           Block Education Officer,  Member            A­55
                          Kalanwali, Sirsa
XVII. SONEPAT
53   Rajinder   Singh  District            Primary  Chairman          A­56
     Dahiya            Education            Officer, 
                       Sonepat
54   Dalip Singh          Dy.   Distt.   Education  Member            A­57
                          Officer, Sonepat
55   Smt. Kamla Devi Block Education Officer,  Member                 A­58 
                     Sonepat­II
XVIII. YAMUNA NAGAR
56   Rajinder          Pal  District     Primary  Chairman            A­59
     Singh                  Education   Officer, 
                            Yamuna Nagar
57   Sarwan   Kumar  Dy.   Distt.   Education  Member                 A­60
     Chawla          Officer, Yamuna Nagar

  CBI Vs Vidya Dhar etc.                                     Judgment dt. 16.01.2013


58     Joginder Lal         Block Education Officer,  Member               A­62
                            Yamuna Nagar
59     Smt.         Urmil  Block Education Officer,  Member                A­61
       Sharma              Yamuna Nagar

Regarding Rohtak lists

36. Sanjiv Kumar (A3) has drawn my attention to the columns of interview marks and grand total in the Supreme Court list (D­30) of District Rohtak, which is Ex.PW43/D. It is submitted that both the columns are blank and do not contain any marks. Had it been in original list, these columns must have been filled up. It is argued that at the instance of Om Prakash Chautala, the bureaucratic and political henchmen executed the entire work of creating fake lists in most crude manner and got the signatures of chair person and members of Rohtak Selection Committee with a view to fill the marks later on as per their convenience. In this haste they forgot to fill up the marks. It is argued that this is the reason that this list does not contain the interview marks and the grand total. On the other hand, D­12 is the Directorate List of District Rohtak, which is exhibited as Ex.PW15/K. It is argued that in this list interview marks and grand total are duly filled up which shows that this is the genuine list. Regarding Sonepat lists

37. The Supreme Court List of District Sonepat (D­26) is Ext.PW43/C. CBI Vs Vidya Dhar etc. Judgment dt. 16.01.2013 The Directorate List of this district (D­8) is Ext.PW15/G. Rajender Singh Dahiya (A­56) was the Chairman of this District Level Selection Committee and Dalip Singh (A­57) was its member. Another member namely Kamla Devi (A­58) had expired before filing the charge sheet. A­56 & A­57 in their statements u/s 313 CrPC admit their signatures on both the lists. Sanjiv Kumar has drawn my attention to the Directorate List which is properly typed in respect of all the columns except interview marks and the grand total. However, it is argued by him that the typing of particulars of the candidates in Supreme Court List would show that this is a carbon copy of the typed document. It is argued that why would the selectors use a carbon copy of the sheets containing particulars of the candidates for putting the interview marks on it. It is argued that had it been a genuine list, the interview marks should have been given on the original typed copy and not on its carbon copy. It is argued by Sanjiv Kumar that the second list was prepared in a great hurry and when they found the carbon copy of the particulars of the candidates, the fake list was prepared by putting the interview marks and grand total on the same. It was done with a view to effect the scheme of creating new set of lists expeditiously. It is, therefore, argued that Supreme Court List of District Sonepat is a fake list and the Directorate List of this district is a genuine list.

(XI) Sonepat Lal Singh (PW44), a clerk from the office of DPEO Sonepat, identified the signatures of Rajender Singh (A56) (the Chairman/DPEO) and its members namely Dalip Kumar (A57) and Smt. Kamla Devi (A58 since expired) on both the lists.

(XII) Mahendergarh/Narnaul Om Prakash Sharma (PW48), a clerk in the office of DPEO Narnaul, testified that Pushkar Mal Verma (A37) was the Chairman of the District Level Selection Committee of this district. He could not tell as to whether Durga Dutt Pradhan (A38) and Bani Singh (A39) were its members. He also could not identify their signatures on any of the lists. Therefore the prosecution is relying upon the report of the hand writing expert (PW64) to prove their signatures on the two sets of lists. Remaining Districts The prosecution is relying upon the evidence of PW64 M. C. Joshi, the hand writing expert, for proving that the Directorate lists and Supreme Court lists were signed by the respective Chairpersons and the members of the said districts, who have been impleaded as accused persons herein.