Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

Ext.P2 order passed by the Registrar of Firms declining registration of a partnership firm constituted by the petitioner is under challenge in this Writ Petition. The reason stated in Ext.P2 is that a LLP cannot be a partner of a firm.

2. Petitioner claims to be the designated partner of Sleeplock LLP which is a limited liability partnership registered under the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008 (for short "LLP Act"). The Sleeplock LLP formed a partnership firm along with one Gourav Raj in the name and style of M/s.Morning Owl Sleep Solutions. A partnership deed was executed accordingly on 18.09.2020. The said deed

3. Petitioner claims that a partnership along with an LLP is not prohibited under the Partnership Act and that LLP is a legal entity, as defined under the LLP Act and it is separate from its partners. It has perpetual succession and is having a common seal. Under Section 14 it is capable of suing and being sued, on its registration. It is also capable of acquiring, developing or disposing of movable or immovable properties. Therefore, petitioner claims that the LLP is liable to be treated as a person and there cannot be any objection for registering a partnership with an LLP which is a person. It is stated that the said LLP has been given Ext.P4 Certificate of Incorporation.

4. The respondent has filed a statement reiterating his stand in the impugned order. It is stated that some of the provisions of the Limited Liability Partnership Act 2008 are inconsistent with that of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, pertaining to the liability. According to the respondent, Section 25, 26 and 49 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932 makes the partners to be jointly and severally liable with all the other partners and also severally liable for the acts of the firm, of which such person is a partner. At the same time it is stated that under Section 28 of the LLP Act, 2008 the provisions regarding the liability of the partnership firm is restricted to the contents to the LLP agreement ie. under the LLP Act, the liability of the partner is restricted only to the extent provided in the agreement; such a provision runs contrary to Section 25 and 49 of the Indian Partnership Act. It is also pointed out that under LLP foreign investment is permissible whereas it is not permissible under the Partnership Act.

xxxxxxx

12. A partnership can be entered into between two persons. Such persons can be an incorporated body of individuals. LLP is a body corporate. It can be said to be a person, as defined in Section 3(42) of the General Clauses Act, 1897 in case there is no repugnancy in the subject or context. In order to examine the same it is necessary to have a look at some more provisions in both the Acts viz Partnership Act and LLP Act.