Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

Neutral Citation No.: 2023:PHHC: 072859 CRA-S-1906-SB-2007 (O&M), CRA-S-2009-2007 (O&M) 21 CRA-S-2020-SB-2010 (O&M), CRR-2255-2007 (O&M), & CRR-3182-2010 xxx... by Sh. Ranjit Singh and Sh. Shingara Singh, Advocates.

I do not remember the time as to when I gave my opinion Ex. PI/1. I have not brought the register containing the relevant entry. Self-stated the same was not requisitioned from me. Wound was already stitched when I examined the patient, radiologically. In case of stitched wound it cannot be ascertained whether the injury was incised wound or was caused by blunt weapon. I have stated incised wound on the basis of MLR and MLX film. It is wrong to suggest that there was no fracture in the injury and that I have given a wrong opinion regarding the said injury."

14(iv). Dr. Ashok Gupta, radiologically examined the complainant/injured

- Balkar Singh, in the General Hospital, Sirsa, and appeared as PW-12, in Sessions Case titled 'State v. Gurdev Singh etc.', and as PW-8, in Sessions Case titled 'State v. Rinku etc.', and deposed as under on 27.11.2006 and Neutral Citation No.: 2023:PHHC: 072859 CRA-S-1906-SB-2007 (O&M), CRA-S-2009-2007 (O&M) 22 CRA-S-2020-SB-2010 (O&M), CRR-2255-2007 (O&M), & CRR-3182-2010 06.11.2009, respectively:-

Deposition of Dr. Ashok Gupta (PW-12), dated 27.11.2006:

" On 5.11.2002 I radiologically examined Balkar Singh son of Makhan Singh, r/o Seeto Road, Abohar and found fracture nasal bone. My report in this regard is Ex. PK and x-ray film is Ex. PK/1.

xxx....by Sh. Ranjit Singh and Sh. Shingara Singh, Advocates.

Deposition of Dr. Ashok Gupta (PW-8), dated 06.11.2009:

" On 5.11.2002 I was posted as Medical Officer, in General Hospital, Sirsa. On that day, I radiologically examined Balkar Singh son of Makahn Singh resident of Seeta Road, Abohar and found fracture nasal bone. My report in this regard is Ex. P23 and X-ray film is Ex. P24.