Document Fragment View

Matching Fragments

17. We have carefully analyzed the facts of the case and arguments made by the Ld. Counsel for the assessee as well as counter arguments made by the Ld. Departmental Representative. The undisputed facts before us are that none of the customers have purchased only machine or only software. There was no customer who purchased only software. Ld. Counsel for the assessee drew our attention on various pages of the paper book to establish that the machine sold by the assessee could not be made operational or functional in the absence of operating software along with the application software. These facts were not controverted by the Ld. Departmental Representative during the course of hearing in response to a specific query put to him by the Bench. It is noted that complete details have been given by the assessee in the paper book at Page-222 and 224. Our attention was also drawn on certificate from the assessee enclosed at Page-225 of the paper book certifying that software supplied by the assessee to end user was for integration with the machine supplied by the assessee and that this software had no other independent use as such, except to enable such machine to function. We have also gone through the End User License Agreement (EULA) entered into by the assessee with the customers wherein there are various clauses which indicate that the software supplied by the assessee was meant only and exclusively for the purpose of making the said machine functional. Clause 2.1 of the agreement provides that customer is granted non-exclusive, non-transferable limited license to use the software and related knowhow on the machine for the sole purpose of scanning the internal / external feature of rough diamond and creating a three dimensional image of these features of rough diamond. Clause 2.2 of the agreement puts certain restrictions upon the customers for any other use of the software in any other machine. This clause restrains the customer from duplicating the software or making any copies, modifications, isolating the software and making it available as a standalone data base or product, removing any product identification, copyright or other proprietary notice from the software or decompiling, disassembling, reverse engineering, or making any other attempt to reconstruct or discover the source code, etc. This clause clearly lays down that customer shall not reproduce the software or any of the documentation provided in connection with the software or related knowhow. It is further noted that clause 6.2 of the said M/s. Galatea Ltd.